Loading...
CC RES 2023-047 RESOLUTION NO. 2023-47 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES, CALIFORNIA, DECLARING THE EXISTENCE OF A LOCAL EMERGENCY IN WITHIN THE GEOGRAPHIC BOUNDARIES OF THE PORTUGUESE BEND LANDSLIDE COMPLEX WHEREAS, the City of Rancho Palos Verdes is home to three (3) active Landslide Complexes commonly known as : the Portuguese Bend Landslide (the PBL), the Abalone Cove Landslide (the ACL), and the Klondike Canyon Landslide (the KCL), also known as the Greater Portuguese Bend Landslide Complex, or Landslide Complex. The landslides have been active since the 1950s, and are depicted in Exhibit "A"; and WHEREAS, the Landslide Complex is divided into zones 1 through 8. Zones 7 and 8 are owned by the City and part of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve. Zone 6 has been sliding towards the ocean since the 1950s, some homes having moved as much as 450 feet from their original location. Zone 6 moves at a much faster rate, though not at a consistent speed throughout, with the most active part of the Zone 6 moving up to 8' a year. The landslide zones are depicted in Exhibit "B"; and WHEREAS, in the recent past, and especially since May of 2023, the land movement in the Landslide Complex has increased significantly. Specific land movement and its impacts can be found here https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=1 x7CEOgB1 hAdofi2R62KV81i137h5P4&II =33.74613292408661%2C-118.36740885&z=16; and WHEREAS, recent increased land movement has already caused 2 homes in the KCL to be "red-tagged" and the building official is closely monitoring several others. The homes are located at 4332 Dauntless and 4361 Exultant. (See Exhibit "C" photographs of the homes). In July, a dozen homes in Rolling Hills Estates were destroyed because of land movement, and experts believe the entire Palos Verdes Peninsula is an area of concern [see https.//www.youtube.com/watch?v=WA3mwOISKjY]; and WHEREAS, the KCL moved on average by 0.5" per year between 2007 and 2018; the rate of movement increased between 2018 and 2022 to 1"-2" (and as much as 4"); and in 2022-2023, the rate of movement increased dramatically by up to -30+" in some places, and more typically by -10-14" in others. See Exhibit "D"; and WHEREAS, a report from McGee Surveying Consulting dated August 6, 2023, concluded, regarding KCL and ACL, that the rate of land movement in the "2014-2018 period is generally representative of previous years back to 2007. In the last two months the movement velocities have accelerated over the previous seven-month period between October 10, 2022 to May 12, 2023. In that seven-month period the average velocities had accelerated over the previous four-year average which saw an acceleration over the previous 8 or more years. A monitoring year is 12 months beginning and ending about the beginning of the rainy season on October 1." The report includes a chart with 01203 0023/925011 5 the "measured movements for a sample of monitoring points for the indicated periods with a projection for the full year of October 10, 2022 to October 2023 based on actual measurements for the period October 10, 2022 to July 15, 2023." See Exhibit "E"; and WHEREAS, due to increased land movement, the Landslide Complex has seen an increase in water main breaks. Starting in 2016, the following water main breaks occurred and had to be fixed urgently by CalWater. The exact location varies, as the break may have occurred along different sections of the pipe, but broken down by trail name, the breaks occurred on the following dates: • Gary's Gulch Trail: August 29, 2023. • Vanderlip Trail: October 2020; November 25, 2021; April 24, 2023; April 25, 2023; June 14, 2023; September 16, 2023. • Burma Road Trail: July 2016; October 2021; March 2022; November 2022 (two separate breaks); February 2023; March 2023; August 16, 2023; August 18, 2023; September 5, 2023. • Conqueror Trail: June 2018; May 20, 2023; August 16, 2023. • Barn Owl Trail: September 5, 2023. (See Exhibit "F" of photographs of the Vanderlip Trail September 16, 2023 and Burma Road Trail August 18, 2023 breaks); and WHEREAS, the City has established, via repeated geologic studies, that a significant factor in the speed of land movement in the Districts is the amount of water in the soil. ACLAD, for example, has installed a number of dewatering wells within its boundaries to mitigate the land movement; and WHEREAS, the 2022-2023 rainy season brought exceptional amounts of rain to the region. The 2022-2023 rainy season dumped about 190% of the average annual rainfall in the region [source: https://ggweather.com/seasonal rain.html, with the region experiencing 20.9" of rain. As a result of the increased amount of rain, all the Landslide Complex in all the Districts have been subject to an alarming increase in land movement. Additionally, there is a strong likelihood that El Nino will bring another wet winter in 2023- 2024, [see https://ktla.com/weather/historically-strong-el-nino-possible-what-it-means- for-winter/; https://patch.com/california/palosverdes/wet-el-nio-ahead-brings-concerns- palos-verdes-landslide-complex?utm term=article-slot-1&utm source=newsletter- daily&utm medium=email&utm campaign=newsletter&user email=10970c30f10d3992 86140af9d05d399c34c897422c415a4087d6e1 cfd9dfl c29], thereby further destabilizing the landslide; and WHEREAS, in response to an increase in public inquiries and concerns raised at the September 19, 2013 meeting, the City has created a dedicated homepage on the City's website to the landslide, as well as an email address (landmovement@rpvca.gov). 111 01203 0023/925011 5 Resolution No 2023-47 Page 2 of 6 City Staff is forming a Working Group, to meet on a weekly basis or as needed, that will have the following representatives: • City of Rancho Palos Verdes: Ara Mihranian, City Manager; Ramzi Awwad, Director of Public Works. • Other stakeholders: Seaview HOA; Portuguese Bend Beach Club HOA; Klondike Canyon Landslide Hazard Abatement District Board; Abalone Cove Landslide Hazard Abatement District Board; Portuguese Bend HOA; Cal Water; So Cal Gas; Southern California Edison; Los Angeles County Public Works Sanitary Sewer Maintenance and Operations; Los Angeles County Sanitation District. The meetings' purposes are the following: • Prevent utility leaks from exacerbating landslide movement • Prevent utility damage from impacting the natural and built environment • Formulate and implement solutions to landslide movement • Coordinate among all stakeholders • Provide regular updates to the public; and WHEREAS, the City has been receiving a growing number of comments expressing concern regarding the accelerating land movements, from homeowners in the Landslide Complex, and from other concerned citizens; and WHEREAS, the health, safety, and welfare of the residents, visitors, and other who live, work, or play with the geographic boundaries of the or Landslide Complex are of utmost importance to the City and additional future measures may be needed to protect the same from the dangers of ongoing land subsidence within these landslides; and WHEREAS, Chapter 2.44 of the Rancho Palos Verdes Municipal Code ("RPVMC") details the powers and responsibilities of the City during emergency circumstances, which is defined in Section 2.24.020 as "the actual or threatened existence of conditions of disaster or of extreme peril to the safety of persons and property within this city caused by such conditions as air pollution, fire, flood, storm, epidemic, riot, or earthquake, or other conditions, including conditions resulting from war or imminent threat of war, but other than conditions resulting from a labor controversy which conditions are or are likely to be beyond the control of the services, personnel, equipment and facilities of this city, requiring the combined forces of other political subdivisions to combat;" and WHEREAS, RPVMC § 2.24.060(A)(1) authorizes the City Council of the City to proclaim the existence or threatened existence of a local emergency if the City Council is in session; and I 01203 0023/925011 5 Resolution No 2023-47 Page 3 of 6 WHEREAS, RPVMC § 2.24.030 creates the Disaster Council to act during the state of local emergency, which Disaster Council shall consist of the following: the mayor, who shall be chairman, and the members of the city council, the director of emergency services, the assistant director of emergency services and the chiefs of emergency services as are provided for in the emergency plan adopted under Section 2.24.080, all of whom shall be ex officio and nonvoting members of the disaster council;" and WHEREAS, RPVMC § 2.24.050 appoints the City Manager as the Director of Emergency Preparedness ("Director"), and the Director shall appoint an Assistant; and WHEREAS, after consideration of all facts reasonably available the City Council now desires to proclaim the existence of a state of local emergency within the or Landslide Complex. NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES, CALIFORNIA, HEREBY FINDS, DETERMINES, AND RESOLVES AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Recitals. The City Council hereby determines that the above recitals are true and correct and incorporates the same as the findings of the City Council. SECTION 2. Proclamation of Emergency. The City Council finds, pursuant to RPVMC Chapter 2.24 and Government Code §§ 8630 and 8680.9, there exists an actual condition of peril to the safety of persons and property exiting within the Portuguese Bend or Landslide Complex (as identified in Exhibit "A" attached hereto) and hereby proclaims that a state of local emergency now exists throughout the same. SECTION 3. Authority Granted. It is further proclaimed and ordered that during the existence of said local emergency, the powers, authority, functions and duties of the Disaster Council, Director, and the City's emergency services organizations shall be those prescribed by State Law, City ordinances, resolutions, and approved plans of the City in order to mitigate the effects of said local emergency. The City Council desires to make clear that such powers, functions, and duties of the Disaster Council include the following but may be more in the Disaster Council's judgement: (a) As necessary for the public safety, life, and property, entering into contracts to arrange for the procurement of materials, goods, and services needed to assist in containing, responding to, mitigating the effects of, and recovering from the ongoing land subsidence occurring within the geographic boundaries of the Portuguese Bend Landslide, the Abalone Cove Landslide, and the Klondike Canyon Landslide. (b) Applicable provisions of the Government Code and the Public Contract Code, including but not limited to, advertising, and competitive bidding requirements, as well as any City procurement or related policy, are suspended to the extent reasonably necessary to address the ongoing land subsidence occurring within the Portuguese Bend Landslide, the Abalone Cove Landslide, and the Klondike Canyon Landslide. 01203 0023/925011 5 Resolution No 2023-47 Page 4 of 6 (c) Furthermore, during the emergency, the Disaster Council is authorized and directed to coordinate with and provide assistance to the Abalone Cove Geologic Hazard Abatement District ("ACLAD") and the Klondike Canyon Geologic Hazard Abatement District ("KCLAD"), the boards of directors, staff, and geologists of these two (2) GHADs in performing their statutory duties under the Public Resources Code of the State of California (Public Resources Code §§ 26500-26601). SECTION 4. Immunity Invoked. To the maximum extent permitted by law, and pursuant to Government Code § 866, the City Council hereby invokes the immunity afforded to the City of Rancho Palos Verds in adopting and implementing the declaration of local emergency with the Portuguese Bend or Landslide Complex. SECTION 5. Duration. The local emergency shall be deemed to continue to exist until its termination is proclaimed by the City Council in accordance with law. SECTION 6. Continuing Declaration. Government Code § 8630 requires the City Council to review of the need for continuing the local emergency at least once every 60 days until the City Council determines the local emergency within the geographic boundaries of the Portuguese Bend Landslide, the Abalone Cove Landslide, and the Klondike Canyon Landslide has been abated or mitigated to insignificance. SECTION 7. Severability. If any subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or word of this Resolution or any application of it to any person, structure, gathering, or circumstance is held to be invalid or unconstitutional by a decision of a court of competent jurisdiction, then such decision will not affect the validity of the remaining portions or applications of this Resolution. SECTION 8. Effectiveness. This Resolution shall take effect immediately. A copy of the Proclamation and this Resolution shall be forwarded to the California Emergency Management Agency. The City Clerk shall certify to the passage and adoption of this resolution.. PASSED, APPROVEDand ADOPTED on this 3rd day of October, 2023. John ru kshank, Mayor Pro Tern ATTEST: eresa aoka, City Clerk— STATE lerkSTATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ss CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES ) 01203 0023/925011 5 Resolution No 2023-47 Page 5 of 6 I, Teresa Takaoka, City Clerk of the City of Rancho Palos Verdes, hereby certify that the above Resolution No. 2023-47 was duly and regularly passed and adopted by the said City Council at a regular meeting thereof held on October 3, 2023. eresa T. ra City Clerk 0 01203 0023/925011 5 Resolution No 2023-47 Page 6 of 6 Resolution 2023-47 Exhibit A Page 1 of 1 Legend 1:14,066 Enter Map Title Enter Map Description Notes2,344.41,172.20 © City of Rancho Palos Verdes 2,344.4 0 Feet NAD_1983_StatePlane_California_V_FIPS_0405_Feet The information on this map is for reference only and may not be up-to-date. Please contact the City for more information. Street Centerlines Private Public Palos Verdes Reservoir City Boundary Adjacent Cities Palos Verdes Estates Rolling Hills Estates Rolling Hills Other Ocean Street Centerlines (2015) Private Public Landslide Zones (2017) Portuguese Bend Active Landslide Areas Abalone Cove Landslide Flying Triangle Landslide Klondike Canyon Landslide Portuguese Bend Landslide City Boundary Parcel 2020 Aerials Red: Band_1 Green: Band_2 Blue: Band_3 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit B Page 1 of 2 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit B Page 2 of 2 EXHIBIT C Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 1 of 47 4361 EXULTANT Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 2 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 3 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 4 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 5 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 6 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 7 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 8 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 9 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 10 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 11 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 12 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 13 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 14 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 15 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 16 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 17 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 18 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 19 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 20 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 21 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 22 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 23 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 24 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 25 of 47 4332 DAUNTLESS Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 26 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 27 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 28 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 29 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 30 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 31 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 32 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 33 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 34 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 35 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 36 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 37 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 38 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 39 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 40 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 41 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 42 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 43 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 44 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 45 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 46 of 47 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit C Page 47 of 47 Avg Movement Per Year* •2007 to 2018 = 0.5” •2018 to 2022 = 1” - 2” (KC02 = 2.75”) (KC18 = 4”) •2022 to 2023 Annualized = See Map *Rate of Movement Varies Depending on Location & Year Klondike Canyon Monitoring Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit D Page 1 of 2 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit D Page 2 of 2 McGee Surveying Consulting Page 1 of 4 1 August 6, 2023 Ramzi Awwad, City Engineer City of Rancho Palos Verdes 30940 Hawthorne Blvd. Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275 Subject: Report on Rancho Palos Verdes (RPV) Portuguese Bend and Klondike Cyn Landslide Monitoring in Seaside in July and August 2023. Refer to the 2007-2023 Portuguese Bend Landslide Monitoring Reports for more details and procedures utilized in this survey. A portion of the Portuguese Bend Landslide Complex was monitored between July 12, 2023 and July 19, 2023 (average date July 15, 2023), and then again on August 2, 2023. The purpose was to monitor the movement in the Klondike Canyon Slide and specifically the recent movements at the intersection of Dauntless & Exultant Drives. Additionally, a sampling of points in the Abalone Cove Slide were observed with a single observation to make a preliminary assessment in the gated community of recent movements (listed below). The expected precision (referred to as noise) of repeat GNSS (satellite) observations based on extensive experience is generally 0.02 feet or less; however, solar disturbances occurring during the period of the July surveys resulted in a level of noise of 0.03 to 0.04 feet. To successfully measure actual movement, the measured movement (referred to as signal) must exceed the noise. Thus, the movement is effectively the signal plus or minus the noise. In Klondike Canyon (KC), five observations were made beginning July 12 over a seven day period and again 21 days after the first day. All current KC monitoring points and two new points set at Dauntless & Exultant Drives were monitored. The new points are KC19 located about 100’ westerly and KC20 located about 70’ southerly of the intersection. Along with existing points KC06 located about 200’ westerly and KC07 about 70’ east of the intersection provided adequate coverage of the area of visible movement. The daily movements in the first seven days was within the range of the measurement noise which limited the capability to estimate actual movements. The overall assessment with the exception of KC07, indicates points KC06, KC19 and KC20 moved westerly about 0.01 feet per day with no adverse changes in velocities. KC07 remained unchanged. A better assessment of the velocities was possible after a sixth observation on August 2, 2023 in which the accumulative movement sufficiently exceeded the noise to model the signal as listed in the table below. McGee Surveying Consulting Page 2 of 4 2 Point Bearing Dist. Bearing Dist. (degrees) (feet) (degrees) (feet) July 12>July 19 July 12>August 2 FT091 * * * * KC021 S 03 W 0.05 S 03 W 0.19 KC051 * * S 14 W 0.06 KC061 S 67 W 0.06 S 67 W 0.11 KC071 * * * * KC131 * * S 22 E 0.06 KC141 * * * * KC151 S 50 W 0.04 S 50 W 0.11 KC161 * * * * KC171 S 24 W 0.02 S 24 W 0.10 KC181 S 10 W 0.05 S 10 W 0.26 KC191 N 85 W 0.07 N 85 W 0.09 KC201 N 78 W 0.06 N 78 W 0.09 * No Detectable Movement Estimated Accuracy= 0.02 feet at 95% Confidence Points around the intersection of Dauntless & Exultant Drives slowed, however it appears other points in the KC Slide accelerated after the first seven days of observations. It is noted below that KC06 moved westerly 0.32 feet between the May 12 and July 15 (about 0.005’/day) and 0.33 feet in the previous seven months since October 10, 2022. Except for KC07, KC14 and KC16 all other points in the Klondike Canyon Slide have accelerated in this last year after having accelerated in the previous four years. The following table provides a general assessment of movements since 2014. The 2014-2018 period is generally representative of previous years back to 2007. In the last two months the movement velocities have accelerated over the previous seven-month period between October 10, 2022 to May 12, 2023. In that seven-month period the average velocities had accelerated over the previous four-year average which saw an acceleration over the previous 8 or more years. A monitoring year is 12 months beginning and ending about the beginning of the rainy season on October 1. Below are the measured movements for a sample of monitoring points for the indicated periods with a projection for the full year of October 10, 2022 to October 2023 based on actual measurements for the period October 10, 2022 to July 15, 2023. McGee Surveying Consulting Page 3 of 4 3 Movement Summary at Selected Points in Feet 2014-2018 2018-2022 Oct.10,2022 May 12, 2023 Oct.‘22-July‘23 to May 12,2023 to July 15, 2023 ID 4-Yr.Av./Max. 4-Yr.Av./Max. 7 Months 2 Months 1 Yr. Projection AB17 0/0 0/0 0.05 <0.04? ? AB20 0.09/0.20 0.48/0.54 0.84 0.74 2.11 AB53 0.07/0.18 0.43/0.49 0.74 0.65 1.85 AB58 0.07/0.14 0.35/0.41 0.60 0.54 1.52 AB60 0.07/0.17 0.45/0.46 0.80 0.63 1.91 AB67 0.03/0.04 0.16/0.18 0.32 0.21 0.71 AB68 0.05/0.11 0.31/0.32 0.54 0.50 1.39 AB70 0.49/0.52 0.84 0.69 2.04 AB73 *0.36/0.46 0.78 0.67 1.93 CR07 0.06/0.13 0.30/0.32 0.44 0.42 1.15 FT09 *0.02/0.03 0.04 0.03 0.09 KC02 0.05/0.11 0.22/0.30 ? 0.91/9 Mo. 1.21 KC05 0.03/0.06 0.10/0.15 ? 0.40/9 Mo. 0.53 KC06 0.04/0.09 0.16/0.22 0.33 0.32 0.87 KC07 0/0 0/0 0 0.02 ? KC13 0.04/0.07 0.08/0.15 0.19 0.15 0.45 KC14 0/0 0.03/.04 ? 0.08 0.11 KC15 0.04/0.09 0.16/0.23 ? 0.61/9 Mo. 0.81 KC16 0/0 0/0 0 0.04 ? KC17 0.04/0.09 0.14/0.19 0.31 0.28 0.79 KC18 *0.33/0.40 ? 1.28/9 Mo. 1.71 PB55 0.89/1.31 0.89/1.23 1.06 0.96 2.69 PB70 *0.53/0.82 0.82/1.15 1.14 0.79 2.56 * 3 Years As stated above, velocities were fairly stable prior to 2018. After the Fall of 2018 they increased about 3 to 5- fold at most points and remained fairly stable until the Fall 2022. Between October 10, 2022 and May 12, 2023 (seven months) the velocities accelerated, and accelerated again in the following two months as noted. The one-year Projected Movements (October 2022 to October 2023) are annualized based on the accumulated movements between October 10, 2022 and July 12, 2023. McGee Surveying Consulting Page 4 of 4 4 SURVEYOR'S STATEMENT: This report is based on record information and a portion on field surveys and was prepared by me on July 23, 2022 and revised August 6, 2023 at the request of Ramzi Awwad of the City of Rancho Palos Verdes. 1 Elena Gerli From:Ara Mihranian <AraM@rpvca.gov> Sent:Saturday, September 16, 2023 3:42 PM Cc:William Wynder; Elena Gerli; Cory Linder; Daniel Trautner; Ramzi Awwad Subject:Cal Water Pipe Break - Portuguese Bend Reserve *** EXTERNAL SENDER *** Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers, There has been another water main break in the Portuguese Bend Reserve off the Vanderlip Trail. This trail was already closed due to a previous water main break. As you can see from the photos, it was like a gushing river. We now have an 8’ to 10’ deep rut in the trail. I must admit they did respond timely to the scene. However, we plan on billing Cal Water for the repairs including staff time. Ara From: Ara Mihranian <AraM@rpvca.gov> Sent: Saturday, September 16, 2023 1:24 PM To: Ara Mihranian <AraM@rpvca.gov> Subject: Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 1 of 14 2 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 2 of 14 3 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 3 of 14 4 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 4 of 14 5 Sent from my iPhone Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 5 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 6 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 7 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 8 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 9 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 10 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 11 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 12 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 13 of 14 Resolution No. 2023-47 Exhibit F Page 14 of 14