Loading...
CC SR 20230418 02 - Annual Maintenance Report PUBLIC HEARING Date: April 18, 2023 Subject: Consideration and possible action to conduct the 2022 annual review of Trump National Golf Club’s compliance with its maintenance obligations relating to trails and open space (Case No. PLMH2023-0001). Recommendation: Receive and file the 2022 annual review of Trump National Golf Club’s compliance with its maintenance obligations relating to trails and open space pursuant to the 2018 City Council- approved Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions. 1. Report of Notice Given: City Clerk 2. Declare Public Hearing Open: Mayor Ferraro 3. Request for Staff Report: Mayor Ferraro 4. Staff Report & Recommendation: Amy Seeraty, Senior Planner 5. Council Questions of Staff (factual and without bias): 6. Public Testimony: Principal Parties 10 Minutes Each. The appellant or their representative speaks first and will generally be allowed ten minutes. If the applicant is different from the appellant, the applicant or their representative will speak following the appellant and will also be allowed ten minutes to make a presentation. Applicant: Trump National Representative Mayor Ferraro invites the Applicant to speak. (10 mins.) A. Testimony from members of the public: The normal time limit for each speaker is three (3) minutes. The Presiding Officer may grant additional time to a representative speaking for an entire group. The Mayor also may adjust the time limit for individual speakers depending upon the number of speakers who intend to speak. 7. Rebuttal: Mayor Ferraro invites brief rebuttals by Appellant and Applicant. (3 mins) Normally, the applicants and appellants will be limited to a three (3) minute rebuttal, if requested after all other interested persons have spoken. 8. Council Questions of Applicant (factual and without bias): 9. Declare Hearing Closed/or Continue the Public Hearing to a later date: Mayor Ferraro 10. Council Deliberation: The Council may ask staff to address questions raised by the testimony, or to clarify matters. Staff and/or Council may also answer questions posed by speakers during their testimony. The Council will then debate and/or make motions on the matter. 11. Council Action: The Council may: vote on the item; offer amendments or substitute motions to decide the matter; reopen the hearing for additi onal testimony; continue the matter to a later date for a decision. RANCHO PALOS VERDES CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: 04/18/2023 AGENDA REPORT AGENDA HEADING: Public Hearing AGENDA TITLE: Consideration and possible action to conduct the 2022 annual review of Trump National Golf Club’s compliance with its maintenance obligations relating to trails and open space (Case No. PLMH2023-0001). RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: (1)Receive and file the 2022 annual review of Trump National Golf Club’s compliance with its maintenance obligations relating to trails and open space pursuant to the 2018 City Council-approved Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions. FISCAL IMPACT: None. A miscellaneous Hearing Fee of $3,076 was submitted by the Applicant. Amount Budgeted: N/A Additional Appropriation: N/A Account Number(s): N/A ORIGINATED BY: Amy Seeraty, Senior Planner REVIEWED BY: Octavio Silva, Interim Director of Community Development APPROVED BY: Ara Mihranian, AICP, City Manager ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS: A.Maintenance Matrix, updated as of April 7, 2023 (page A-1) B.City Council-approved Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions recorded November 27, 2018 C.Public correspondence (page C-1) D.April 5, 2022 City Council Staff Report E.Lot D Approved Plans-2019 and 2021 (page E-1) BACKGROUND: The Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions for Trump National Golf Club, among other things, requires an annual review of Trump National Golf Club’s (“Applicant’s”) compliance with trail maintenance obligations (Attachment B). Specifically, Condition No. 7 of the Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions states the following: 1 RANCHO PALOS VERDES 7. Review and Monitoring For Compliance. The City and Owners [Trump National Golf Club] shall review the Owners' compliance with its Maintenance Obligations and compliance with the terms and conditions under this Declaration at least once every twelve (12) months based on a tracking system and protocols implemented by City for monitoring compliance. Owners shall implement and/or perform all reasonably practical recommendations or requirements of City following such annual review. Pursuant to this Condition, Community Development and Recreation and Parks (“City Staff”) worked together to create a maintenance spreadsheet. In early 2019, Staff, in collaboration with the Applicant’s staff, created a tracking system for trail and open space complaints and the Applicant’s responses. The resulting document was a maintenance matrix that was first presented to the City Council on February 4, 2020, and most recently on April 5, 2022 (Attachment D). This item was not presented to the City Council for review in 2021 due to a significant backlog of work and limited resources for both the City and the Applicant. City Staff continues to maintain the matrix (Attachment A) for presentation to the City Council on an annual basis. The purpose of this report is to conduct the 2022 annual review of the overall effectiveness of the Applicant’s compliance with maintenance obligations for the trails, open space, and public amenities, using the maintenance matrix developed pursuant to Condition No. 7. The focus of this review will be on the application of the maintenance matrix and a discussion of the most common and recurring maintenance issues. DISCUSSION: The Applicant is required to maintain, manage, improve, and enhance, to the City’s reasonable satisfaction, various portions of the Trump National Golf Course property, which includes the open space, various public amenities such as picnic tables and benches, and trails. Common and recurring maintenance issues include trail erosion, spur trails, vandalism, litter, and sign deterioration. The maintenance matrix is used to log the issues and provide a method by which Staff can track and objectively measure the completeness and timeliness of the Applicant’s compliance with their maintenance obligations. The maintenance issues are grouped by trail or open space area, with a color code (green for complete, black for confirmation of work pending, and red for not complete), which allows the user to quickly assess the status of reported issues. Typically, when a report of a trail issue is either identified by the City Staff or received from the public. City Staff logs the reported issue on the maintenance matrix and reports the concern directly to the Applicant. Additionally, to improve the data and locations of reported issues, photos and map coordinates may be included, which reduces confusion regarding the location or nature of the issues. Eventually, City Staff anticipates moving to the CityWorks automated platform in the fall, which is the system that the Public Works Department currently uses for maintenance requests. There are 224 items listed in the current maintenance matrix. Currently, approximately 96 items are complete (green); 90 issues were responded to by the Applicant but not 2 confirmed complete by Staff (black); and 38 items not complete (red). The large number of issues responded to but not confirmed (black) is a result of the Applicant providing maintenance updates in the days leading up to the preparation of this report , which precluded Staff from inspecting the work. To summarize, 83% of the current reported or observed issues have been addressed. Staff continues to work with the Applicant to review its progress and ensure completion of items that are still pending. City Staff believes the Applicant, despite the challenges of the past several years, continues to make significant progress to address and keep up with the ongoing maintenance of the trails, open space and amenities. Additionally, since the April 2022 City Council meeting, five informal meetings between City Staff and the Applicant have been completed in order stay up to date with the current status of the trails. Due of the large size of the Ocean Trails Reserve and the Trump National Golf Course, the frequent usage by the public, and most recently, large amount of rain th at the area has received, topics discussed at these meetings include trail erosion, spur trails, deterioration of signage, and vandalism and litter. These topics are further discussed below: Trail Erosion As a result of erosion, trails and amenities need continuous and recurring maintenance. While various large-scale trail construction repairs were completed in October and November 2021, during 2022, the Applicant worked on smaller projects including repairing trail washouts and adding new posts and cables along the sides of existing trails. Erosion and resultant slope failures also caused the closure of the Catalina Trail bridge and the Coastal Switchback Trail landslide. Staff is working with the Applicant on possible solutions to remedy these two significant trail issues. Thus far, City Staff has held one meeting with the City’s Geologist, the California Coastal Commission, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to discuss possible solutions. City Staff is also coordinating a site visit to these two impacted trail sites, which will take place before this summer. Spur Trails One of the main issues that remains is the creation of spur trails, which are unauthorized new trails through existing habitat by hikers that must be removed. Since the last update to the City Council, the Applicant has continued to work on solutions to permanently close these unauthorized areas, including, but not limited to, installation of “Area Closed” signage, adding branches and planting cacti, as well as additional posts and cables to block off these areas. Deterioration of Signage Sign maintenance due to vandalism and exposure to the elements is another constant and recurring issue for the Applicant. In the time period tracked in the maintenance matrix, the Applicant has replaced a significant number of signs including trail name signs and other wayfinding and informational signage. Given that signs are critical for the identification of the trails, as well as advising the public of the Preserve and beach rules, 3 City Staff will continue working with the Applicant to reduce the current volume of the sign issues. Additionally, the Applicant is working on an updated version of the original signage plan for the development. The property was still named “Ocean Trails” at the time that the original signage plan was approved in October 1999, and there have been various name changes and new trails added to the signage plan since it was first created . Additionally, there have been some interim signage plans, such as a 2013 Interim Ani mal Signage Plan and the City Council-approved 2018 Amenities Plan that the Applicant is currently working to consolidate into one updated Signage Plan. Furthermore, the Open Space Management Staff has provided the Applicant with additional surplus signage , as well as direction regarding the correct type of posts to install. Additional updates will be provided as more information becomes available regarding signage proposals. Vandalism and Litter The Applicant has also informed City Staff regarding ongoing issues with vandalism in the public restroom near the La Rotonda Drive parking lot. The Applicant has placed security personnel by the restrooms to deter this activity; however, each act of vandalism requires the closure of the restrooms for deep cleaning. In an effort to further deter this type of activity, Park Rangers will continue to frequent the La Rotonda Drive parking lot and adjacent trails in this eastern section of the Reserve several times a week to watch for any vandalism in the area. Additionally, the Applicant sends an employee to walk all the trails every Friday for litter and graffiti detail. It is evident that the Applicant strives to keep up with the recurring maintenance issues, based on continually improving communication between the Applicant and City Staff, among other things. Staff will continue to work with the Applicant to facilitate and ensure that recurring maintenance of the trails, open space and amenities will be in compliance with their obligations under the Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: Infrastructure Management Advisory Committee (IMAC) Trails Subcommittee Open Space Management Staff (a division of the Recreation and Parks Department) has been in regular communication with the IMAC Trails Subcommittee regarding two closed trails in the Trump National Golf Course property. Specifically, the trails include the Coastal Switchback Trail, which is closed due to landslide movement, and the bridge closure due to erosion on the Catalina Trail. As previously noted, the trails cannot simply be repaired and likely may need to be rerouted through dedicated habitat and Preserve areas. However, the IMAC is aware that these repair projects will require coordination with various stakeholders and agencies, which will take some time. Public Correspondence On March 30, 2023, a public notice was mailed to all property owners within a 500-foot radius of the project site and published in the Palos Verdes Peninsula News. In response to the public notice, Staff received public correspondence (Attachment C) from two 4 residents of the adjacent neighborhood to the west of the project site, with one resident representing the Portuguese Bend Club community. The residents expressed concerns regarding the approved plantings for Lot D (City-owned lot), which were originally approved by the California Coastal Commission in 2019, and most recently updated in 2021. This lot is located at the western boundary of the Trump National Golf Club property, immediately to the east of the Portuguese Bend Club community. The residents expressed concerns that the plantings on Lot D were overgrown and have become a fire hazard. Furthermore, the residents stated that a fire protection plan should be drafted for Lot D, as the planted native foliage is thriving and is growing up to the shared property with adjacent residences. Based on Staff’s analysis, the planting plan for Lot D was approved in consultation with the City of Rancho Palos Verdes, the Bureau of Land Management, the California Coastal Commission, and the Los Angeles County Fire Department, and was originally labeled as a fire break area. Based on the approved design of the plan, Lot D was to include foliage to be planted in the proximity of shared property lines with several types of existing foliage along the shared property line fence or wall to be protected in place, and simply trimmed to be closer to the wall on a regular basis. CONCLUSION: Staff recommends the City Council Receive and file this annual review report regarding Trump National Golf Club’s compliance with its maintenance obligations relating to trails and open space pursuant to the 2018 City Council -approved Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions. ALTERNATIVES: In addition to the Staff recommendation, the following alternative actions are available for the City Council’s consideration: 1. Identify areas of concern regarding the Applicant’s compliance with the maintenance obligations and direct Staff to address these concerns at a future meeting. 2. Take other action, as deemed appropriate. 5 Status Box Key: -Black text shows TN (Trump National) response -Green text shows Open Space Management confirmation that TN accomplished the repairs -Red text shows potential differences in viewpoint as to whether a problem was addressed fully or not -A blank column shows no response to the reported problem as of yet. Ref. #Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 40 8/1/2022 TRAIL BED - On trail between East Portal Trail and Gnatcatcher Trail, ruts formed along middle of trail and eyebrows along inland side. 9/13/2022 Repair as needed.Repairs were made October 2022 however, winter rain may have washed out again 39 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite at trailhead (along Twin Harbors Drive) is missing the no-bike decal. 9/13/2022 Repair as needed.Stickers continue to be replaced - Ongoing issues with people removing stickers 10/22 Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests EAST PORTAL TRAIL A-1 38 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite at trailhead (along Palos Verdes Drive South) is missing the no-bike decal. 9/13/2022 Repair as needed.Stickers continue to be replaced - Ongoing issues with people removing stickers 10/2022 37 7/21/2022 VEGETATION - Lemonadeberry has overgrown along trail making it narrow. 7/21/2022 Trim back overgrowth as needed. Area trimmed and completed by 8/19/2022. Delays due to short staffing. 10/22 A-2 36 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - "22" etched into carsonite.2/14/2022 Repair as needed.Painted over etchings to minimize issue - March 2022 35 2/3/2022 GRAFFITI- Graffiti and unauthorized decals on pipe above drainage area adjacent to trail Location: 113°S 33°43'32"N 118°20'18"W 250ft elevation 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti and decals. COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, graffiti and stickers have been removed. A-3 34 2/3/2022 GRAFFITI - "22" painted on back of "Preserve Rules" Regulatory sign. On front of sign, illegible text is etched on the metal. 2/14/2022 Repair / remove as needed. COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, sign has been repainted. 33 1/10/2022 IRRIGATION- Water leak from a broken sprinkler from property on Twin Harbor View resulting in flooding to East Portal Trail. 1/10/2022 Information / notification only. CalWater had been called by the public to shut off water. Park Rangers assessed trail conditions and confirmed minimal damage. Irrigation / sprinkler was confirmed to be in private property. No trail closures took place. A-4 32 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI- Graffiti on electrical box EMPTY POST-Unoccupied post can be used for a "Dogs on Leash" sign for enforcement purposes Location: 160°S 33°43'32"N 118°20'7"W 360ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti and install a "Dogs on leash" sign for enforcement purposes COMPLETE - Date unk. Graffiti has been removed. Post was removed, and sign for "Dogs on Leash" placed approx 100 ft closer to the trailhead. 31 1/19/2021 GRAFFITI- blue graffiti on wooden post Location: 160°S 33°43'32"N 118°20'7"W 360ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 A-5 30 1/19/2021 GRAFFITI- yellow graffiti on wooden post Location: 138° SE 33°43'31"N 118°20'12"W 340ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 29 1/19/2021 GRAFFITI- blue graffiti on wooden post Location: 174° S 33°43'31"N 118°20'12"W 350ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 A-6 28 1/19/2021 GRAFFITI- white graffiti on wooden post Location: 87° E 33°43'31"N 118°20'14"W 360ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 27 1/19/2021 GRAFFITI- green graffiti on wooden post Location: 142° SE 33°43'31"N 118°20'15"W 320ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 A-7 26 1/19/2021 GRAFFITI -- Etching and stickers on the Preserve Rules sign at lower, southern end of trail Location: 139° SE 33°43'30"N 118°20'18"W 250ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove stickers and fix etch marks COMPLETE -Stickers removed. Unable to fix etch markings. Sign to be replaced Summer 2022. 25 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI- Graffiti on pipe above drainage area adjacent to trail Location: 113°S 33°43'32"N 118°20'18"W 250ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti COMPLETE - Date unknown. Confirmed on 3/10/2022. A-8 24 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI- Graffiti on bunker lid adjacent to trail and behind the fencing Location: 159°S 33°43'31"N 118°20'15"W 320ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 23 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI- Graffiti on fencing post Location: 186°S 33°43'31"N 118°20'15"W 360ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed - April 2021 A-9 22 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI -- Etching on the Preserve Rules sign Location: 177°S 33°43'36"N 118°20'2"W 380ft elevation 3/17/2021 Restore preserve rules sign INCOMPLETE - Confirmed as of 3/10/2022, etching still visible on sign. This is not significant enough to warrant replacement. 21 1/19/2021 FENCING/SPUR TRAIL/SIGNAGE -- low cable fencing and rotting wooden posts make the spur trail behind the fence more accessible. An Area Closed RPVMC 12.16.090 sign can also be added to the wooden posts Location: 177° S 33°43'31"N 118°20'15"W 320ft elevation 3/17/2021 Fix fencing; close spur trail; install an Area Closed RPVMC 12.16.090 sign Ongoing. Cables have been tightened. Signage will be installed by Summer 2022. A-10 p1ant , · oc:1<s, an cling any plants or animal • Qefacing or removing sig1Js_2!J?arriers • Reckless use of trails that endangers people or animals 20 1/19/2021 TRAIL BED/GRAFFITI -- loose, uncovered wooden step with exposed rebar is not secure to walk on; orange graffiti on the wooden step Location: 245° SW 33°43'30"N 118°20'16"W 340ft elevation 3/17/2021 Repair step and remove graffiti All steps have been removed April 2021 19 1/19/2021 TRAIL BED/GRAFFITI -- loose, uncovered wooden step with exposed rebar is not secure to walk on Location: 246° SW 33°43'31"N 118°20'16"W 300ft elevation 3/17/2021 All steps have been removed April 2021 A-11 18 1/19/2021 SIGNAGE/EMPTY POST- empty post can be used for a DOGS ON LEASH or a NO ANIMALS ON THE BEACH sign Location: 339° N 33°43'28"N 118°20'16"W 3/17/2021 Install a DOGS ON LEASH or a NO ANIMALS ON THE BEACH sign Post removed - no need for sign in this habitat area 17 1/19/2021 SIGNAGE/EMPTY POST- Gnatcatcher trail marker sign is faded and unreadable; Catalina Trail marker sign is broken and needs to be replaced; empty post can be used for a DOGS 3/17/2021 Replace faded trail marker decals on Gnatcatcher trail carsonite sign; Stickers have been updated April 2021 16 1/19/2021 REMOVAL -- Black irrigation line exposed in trail along where trail cuts down toward Gnatcatcher Tr. 3/17/2021 Resolve for safety and function.*exposed in another area 10 1/19/2021 FENCING -- Stake & cable down in multiple spots along lower portion of trail by Catalina Tr. junction 3/17/2021 Repair fencing.Cables have been tightened - this is an ongoing issue from trail users leaning or resting on cables A-12 9 1/19/2021 TRAIL BED -- Wooden steps difficult to use along lower portion of trail 3/17/2021 Repair steps. 3/10/21 Steps not repaired - Steps have been removed as of April 2021 4 3/10/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail marker at PV Drive South 8/28/2019; 3/17/2021 Install carsonite trail marker with appropriate decals. COMPLETE - Trail marker has been installed. 2 1/19/2021 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized path begins downhill where trail cuts down toward Gnatcatcher Tr. 3/17/2021 Close spur trail ONGOING - Spur trail closed. Signage to be installed Summer 2022. A-13 . A-14 L_J Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 17 3/11/2021 SIGNAGE- Animals must be on leash sign has been removed and was found on the ground 3/17/2021 Reinstall sign COMPLETE - New Post and sign installed. 16 3/11/2021 TRASH- scattered in the parking lot 3/17/2021 Remove litter COMPLETE - Date unknown. 9 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE -- Sensitive Habitat sign is bent at junction of Lake View Trail and Catalina Trail 3/17/2021 Replace sign Completed - Sign installed, date unknown 8 7/11/2019 SIGNAGE -- No Dogs on Beach sign is bent at junction of Lake View Trail and Catalina Trail 7/24/2019 Restore or replace sign.COMPLETE - New post and signage installed. 7 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE -- Warning sign is bent at junction of Lake View Trail and Catalina Trail 3/17/2021 Replace sign COMPLETE - new closure sign, date unknown. Confirmed as of 3/10/2022. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance RequestsLA ROTONDA DRIVE PARKING LOT -- LAKE VIEW TRAIL A-15 5 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE -- Trail marker decals are faded at junction of Lake View Trail and Catalina Trail 3/17/2021 Replace decals INCOMPLETE - decals were faded, and should be replaced on both sides. Confirmed on 3/10/2022. 4 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE -- 1 Habitat sign is faded along Lake View Trail 3/17/2021 Replace sign ONGOING - Sign will be installed by April 2022. 3 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE -- 1 Keep Park a Nice Place sign is faded and downed along Lake View Trail 3/17/2021 Replace sign ONGOING - Sign will be installed by April 2022. A-16 Ref. # Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 10 2/8/2022 IRRIGATION - PVC pipe is broken, with a sharp, jagged edge. The irrigation is part of a new line installed in Lot "D" (Tract 5066), outside of Reserve boundary. 2/8/2022 Repair pipe, as needed to remove hazard. 2022 - All irrigation work has been completed for this tract and hazards removed 9 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE -- blank sign with no information 115º SE 33º43'51"N 118º21'11"W 170ft elevation 3/17/2021 Replace blank sign with new signage, eg. "Closed Area" sign for enforcement purposes 2022 - New signs have been installed along W. Portal trail by RPV and Trump Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests WEST PORTAL TRAIL A-17 8 3/13/2021 SPUR TRAIL- Unauthorized trail leading from West Bluff trail down to a cliff where many hikers and paragliders are not allowed to be for safety reasons and habitat restoration 115º SE 33º43'51"N 118º21'11"W 170ft elevation 3/17/2021 Close spur trail.ONGOING - Added branches to area. Area Closed signage will be placed Summer 2022. As of 04/2023 foliage has filled this area A-18 7 3/1/2021 SIGNAGE -- Trail marker decals inaccurate the bike decal should be removed and blank sign with no information 3/17/2021 Restore proper trail marker decals & include directional arrow. Replace blank sign INCOMPLETE - decals still faded, confirmed as of 3/7/2022. City installed "Notice" signs (white / blue background with black text) on 10/18/2021; and replaced these with permanent signs on 3/2022 (brown background with white text) to be consistent with other Preserve regulatory signage. Update 4/7/23 Trail decals are ledgable and do not need to be replaced. RPV install new large sign at trail head. 5 3/13/2021 AMMENITIES -- Trash can needed at trailhead (northwest end of trail). 3/17/2021 Install trash with lid & maintain service. COMPLETE - Installed @ trail head 4 6/4/2019 TRAIL BED -- shallow erosion gully 20 yards long at trailhead (northwest end of trail). 6/17/2019 Resolve trail condition.COMPLETE - trail was repaired as Trump National redesigned pathways related to the construction on the adjacent lot. 3 3/13/2021 FENCING -- Cyclone fence bent, no top rail, old, unsightly at trailhead (northwest end of trail). 3/17/2021 Fix or replace fence.New fencing has been istalled along entire area - 2022 A-19 1 6/4/2019 SIGNAGE -- faded sign in habitat at trailhead (northwest end of trail). 6/17/2019 Restore signage.Unknown where this is??? Most likely it has been replaced as the signs all seem correct on this trail A-20 I I I I LJ Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 15 9/12/2022 FENCING - The cable broken off, resulting in a sharp, jagged edge. Caution tape placed in the interim. 9/12/2022 Repair cable.COMPLETE - As of 10/14/2022, the cable was fixed. 14 3/13/2021 SPUR TRAIL- Unauthorized trail leading from West Bluff trail down to a cliff where many hikers and paragliders are not allowed to be for safety reasons and habitat restoration 234º SW 33º43'51"N 118º21'11"W 160ft elevation 3/17/2021 Close spur trail Ongoing - City Staff coordinated: Installed at least 3 "Area Closed" signs on fence post, as well as added vegetation to block off spur. 13 3/13/2021 TRAIL BED -- Black plastic tube exposed on trail 8º N 33º44'55"N 118º21'11"W 170ft elevation 3/17/2021 Cover or remove tube COMPLETE - Plastic tubing has been removed. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests WEST BLUFF TRAIL A-21 12 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE -- Trail marker decals inaccurate the bike decal should be removed 208º SW 33º44'0"N 118º21'12"W 190ft elevation 3/17/2021 Restore proper trail marker decals & include directional arrow. COMPLETE - Trail sign has been relocated to its appropriate location. Stickers corrected. 11 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE- Faded "Habitat Area" sign 208º SW 33º44'0"N 118º21'12"W 190ft elevation 3/17/2021 Replace sign Complete - RPV installed new large sign at trail head - 2022 10 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE-There is an empty post that can be used for a "Dogs on Leash" sign or other signage 94º E 33º43'56"N 118º21'12"W 180ft elevation 3/17/2021 Install signage to assist with enforcement Completed - Random posts were removed when new fence installed - 2022 A-22 9 3/31/2020 SPUR TRAIL- Unauthorized trail leading from West Bluff trail down to a cliff where many hikers and paragliders are not allowed to be for safety reasons and habitat restoration Exact date unknown. TN indicated they have contacted the public since 2006 regarding paragliding and vandalism in this area. Close spur trail ONGOING - City Staff has monitored trail use for enforcement purposes and secured the area with vegetation, and installation of "Area Closed" signs. A trail camera was installed on 11/3/2021, and TN notified, with signage installed in adjacent locations to inform the public. As noted in the West Portal Trailhead, the Notice sign was installed on 10/2021 (white / blue background with black text) and then replaced with permanent signage (brown background with white text) to be consistent with other regulatory signage. 8 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE -- Missing trail marker at junction of West Bluff & West Portal Trails 3/17/2021 Install trail marker with appropriate decals. Completed - April 2021 7 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE -- Faded sign in habitat near the end of trail at junction with West Portal Trail. 3/17/2021 Replace sign 2022 - New "habitat" sign installed at junction 4 3/13/2021 SUPPLIES -- Mutt mitt dispenser missing 3/17/2021 Install dispenser and restock supplies COMPLETE - Installed at trailhead. 3 6/4/2019 SIGNAGE -- faded decals on the carsonite trail marker at trailhead. 6/17/2019 Attach new decals. COMPLETE - Trail markers installed at trailhead. Stickers replaced. 1 6/4/2019 SIGNAGE -- decals on trail marker confusing at west exit of clubhouse western parking lot, leading people on path towards Founder's Park. Should read West Bluff Tr . rather than West Portal Tr . and bike decal gives wrong information. 6/17/2019 Attach directional arrow decal steering people toward trailhead, remove bike COMPLETE - Trail markers installed at trailhead. Stickers replaced. A-23 Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 13 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI- Black and blue graffiti on empty post EMPTY POST- Post with no signage that can be used for the installation of a "No animals on the beach" sign at the top of Coastal switchback trail 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti and install a "No animals on the beach" sign for enforcement purposes Graffiti removed. Trail currently closed. 12 2/28/2021 COMMON VANDALISM- "22" stickers, graffiti, and etchings found along the trail and on posts, rocks, enforcement signs, and other trail areas. 243° SW 33°43'32"N 118°20'28"W 90ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove sticker and notify Rangers about the group of people or person associated with "22" logo if you receive more information about it 11 1/21/2020 TRASH -- Broken, unused PVC pipe along fence on ocean side just a few yards from the Catalina Tr. junction 3/17/2021 Remove pipe 10 1/21/2020 TRAIL BED -- Exposed plastic material near bottom of trail 3/17/2021 Remove exposed plastic 8 8/13/2019 FENCING -- Post & cable leaning over along lower end, cable needs replacing near the top end and there are around 8 broken posts along the trail 8/28/2019 Repair fence.Replaced all posts and most of cable replaced on Switchback trail 7 8/13/2019 TRAIL BED -- Rut below 2nd switchback, missing side support boards most of the length of the trail and an unstable section with the trail bed eroding below a large 8/28/2019 Restore trail bed.Removed board and rebuilt retaining wall. 5 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- Missing No Animals on Beach sign at the top of the trail for enforcement purposes 3/17/2021 Install "No animals on the beach sign" for enforcement purposes Sign will be installed when trial reopenes. 4 8/13/2019 VEGETATION -- Overgrowth along most of the trail 8/28/2019 Trim back to width of the trail bed. All of trail has been trimmed. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests COASTAL SWITCHBACK TRAIL - Trail Closed as of 5/2021 Eric: special instructions: please note which of these items are not longer relevant because they have been destroyed in landslide. A-24 p thell'l on leash > afterthern 1 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- Trail markers inadequate or missing on both ends of trail. 3/17/2021 Install trail marker signs with appropriate decals at the top and bottom of the trail Trail markers have been installed. A-25 11 I I I LJ Ref. # Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 18 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - Several instances of graffiti on the rock wall and wooden bench at the bottom of the trail. 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti.ONGOING - Graffiti removed on a routine basis. This particular graffiti has been removed. 17 2/7/2022 TRAIL BED - Steep drop-off below bottom step on the upper section of trail. (This is the 10th step on the first timber box steps installed from Catalina Trail) 2/14/2022 Repair as needed.COMPLETED - 3/3/2022, soil added to bottom of step. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests SOUTHSHORE COASTAL TRAIL A-26 16 2/7/2022 SPUR TRAIL - Unauthorized trail that is visible above rock wall near the bottom of the trail. 2/14/2022 Close spur trail. 15 2/7/2022 TRAIL BED - Loose rocks / shale along trail, likely due to poor water drainage during periods of rain. 2/14/2022 Repair as needed.ONGOING - The steep incline and small rocks on the trail is due to the terrain and a normal feature on this trail. A-27 I I I I I 7 ' I I l J I _J 14 2/15/2021 GRAFFITI- On the cement block at the top of the trail near the picnic bench 3/17/2021 Clean graffiti COMPLETE - Date unknown. Confirmed on 3/10/2022. 13 2/15/2021 SPUR- an unauthorized trail near the beginning of the trail that leads to the edge of the cliff and is very unsafe 187ºS 33º43'24"N 118º20'9"W 80FT elevation 3/17/2021 Close or cordone off unauthorized trail INCOMPLETE - Spur trail still visible as of 3/10/2022. Have not found a sustainable… Update - Plan to add posts/cable barrier 12 2/15/2021 SPUR- an unauthorized trail near the beginning of the trail that leads to the edge of the cliff and is very unsafe 239ºSW 33º43'24"N 118º20'9"W 70FT elevation 3/17/2021 Close or cordone off unauthorized trail INCOMPLETE - Spur trail still visible as of 3/10/2022. 2023 Update - Plan to add posts/cable barrier A-28 11 2/15/2021 SPUR- an unauthorized trail near the beginning of the trail that leads to the edge of the cliff and is very unsafe 243ºSW 33º43'24"N 118º20'10"W 60FT elevation 3/17/2021 Close or cordone off unauthorized trail INCOMPLETE - Spur trail still visible as of 3/10/2022. 2023 Update - Plan to add posts/cable barrier 10 2/15/2021 GRAFFITI- On the rocks along the top and middle of the trail 3/17/2021 Clean graffiti COMPLETE - Date unknown. Confirmed as of 3/10/2022. A-29 9 2/22/2021 GRAFFITI-- At bottom of trail at the beach, several instances of graffiti on rocks. 328ºNW 33º43'24"N 118º20'9"W 40FT elevation. 3/17/2021; 2/7/2022 Clean graffiti.Ongoing - Several instances of graffiti reported on the same location. Exact dates of removal unknown. Previously confirmed removal as of 3/10/2022. 8 2/15/2021 GRAFFITI-- On picnic benches at Southshore Coastal Trail. 3/17/2021 Clean graffiti Ongoing. Graffiti has been removed several instances. Picnic benches remain in poor condition due to vandalism. 7 2/15/2021; 2/7/2022 TRAIL BED -- Steep trail needs more steps, also an erosion gap, both at the upper and lower portion of trail 3/17/2021; 2/14/2022 Restore trail bed.PARTIALLY INCOMPLETE - the lower portion of the trail requires additional work, reported again on 2/14/2022. The upper section of the trail bed was restored in October 2021, when Bellfree Contractors completed trail repairs on the upper and mid sections of the trail. 5 2/15/2021 TRAIL BED -- Missing or collapsed section at the middle portion of trail 3/17/2021 Restore trail bed.COMPLETE - The trail bed was restroed in October 2021, when Bellfree Contractors completed trail repairs on the upper and middle sections of the trail. A-30 3 2/15/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail markers at top or bottom of trail 3/17/2021 Install carsonite markers with appropriate decals. INCOMPLETE - No trail markers are visible at the top or bottom of the trail, confirmed on 3/10/2022. 1 8/19/2019 VEGETATION -- Overgrowth near the bottom of the trail 8/28/2019 Trim back to a 3 foot width. COMPLETE - Date unknown. Confirmed as of 3/10/2022. A-31 Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 11 8/23/2021 SIGNAGE - "No Animals" sign at the trailhead. 8/23/2021 Install a "no animals on the beach" sign at the top of the trailhead. COMPLETE 1/20/22 - Sign installed by 10/18/21 by TN. However, the code was incorrect. Requested code corection. Should read "6.04.050". City Staff observed on 1/19/21 the codes were still incorrect and sent a reminder. On 1/20/21, TN corrected codes. 10 3/15/2021 SIGNAGE- Vandalized "No animals" sign near the top of Sunset trail. (This is the second location from the top, just before the first switchback). 3/17/2021; 8/23/2021 Replace with new "No animals on the beach sign. COMPLETED - 2/2/2022. Sign installed by City. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests SUNSET TRAIL A-32 8 8/14/2019 FENCING -- Fence cable frayed near upper part of trail 8/28/2019 Replace cable.COMPLETED - Date unknown. Confirmed 3/7/2022. 7 8/14/2019 FENCING -- Post & cable down at top and bottom of trail 8/28/2019 Repair.COMPLETED - Date unknown. Confirmed 3/7/2022. 6 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- No Animals on Beach signs at the bottom of the trail 3/17/2021; 8/23/2021 Install a "no animals on the beach" sign at the bottom of Sunset trail COMPLETED 1/20/22 - Sign installed by 10/18/21 by TN. Code correction required. On 1/20/21, TN corrected codes. City staff installed signs on 2/2/2022 with larger signs, consistent with other Coastal locations within the Preserve, and to be more visible to the public. A-33 5 3/15/2021 SIGNAGE -- Faded decals on trail marker sign at top of the trail and missing trail marker sign at the bottom of Sunset trail 315º NW 33º43'43"N 118º21'4"W 160ft elevation 3/17/2021 Replace faded decals on trail marker sign at the top of the trail and install trail marker sign at the bottom of Sunset trail PARTIALLY INCOMPLETE - As of 1/19/2022, new decals at the top of the trail were observed. However, no carsonite on the bottom trailhead. 2/2022 - Installed newe Carsonite trail sign and stickers at bottom of trail. 4 8/14/2019 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized side path near top of trail 8/28/2019 Close spur trail.INCOMPLETE - As of 3/10/2022, spur trail is still visible. Due to the increase in trail usage spur trails are becoming more frequent. We will continue to add foliage to these areas A-34 LJ Ref. #Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump National Action Requested Status 10 8/14/2022 SPUR TRAIL - On Catalina View Trail, two unauthorized trails are evident that lead to the ocean. 9/13/2022 Cover up spur trails.COMPLETE - On 10/14/2022, spur trail was covered with brush barrier. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests Founders Park A-35 9 8/23/2021 SIGNAGE- All Pets Must Be Restrained On a Leash post is damaged and not secured. Located on the walkway closest to the blue Preserve Rules sign. 3/17/2021 Recemented or replaced.PARTIALLY INCOMPLETE - Sign was no longer present. No Replacement sign as of 3/14/2022. 8 2/28/2021 GRAFFITI- Graffiti on sign 324º NW 33º43'44"N 118º21'1"W 190ft elevation 3/17/2021 COMPLETED - Date unknown. Graffitti Removed. A-36 7 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE- Faded sign that can be replaced with a "Dogs on leash" sign for enforcement purposes 274º W 33º43'45"N 118º20'59"W 180ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove faded sign and install a "Dogs on leash" sign for enforcement purposes 6 3/15/2021 SIGNAGE- New "No animals on beach" sign has not been installed near the entrance of Founder's park 3/17/2021 Replace old sign with new one INCOMPLETE - Old sign is present and has not been replaced with the new sign. Code is covered with the bolt. A-37 5 3/15/2021 SIGNAGE- Pets on leash sign is bent and scratched near the pinic table at the southeast corner of Founder's park leading to Catalina trail and Sunrise trail 3/17/2021 Repair of replace sign INCOMPLETE - Sign not repaired as of 3/14/2022. 4 3/15/2021 SIGNAGE- No designated trail marker sign for Catalina trail (Carsonite with trail name and trail users allowed) near the southeast corner of Founder's park and the bike rack area. 3/17/2021 Install trail marker sign INCOMPLETE - No designated trail marker as of 3/7/2022. 4/2022 Carsonite Sign and stickers added at the beginging of trail A-38 3 11/19/2019 LIGHTING -- Landscape lighting post has loose top at the far end of the last sidewalk loop from the clubhouse 11/26/2019 Repair or replace.COMPLETE - Several caps and wires exposed and reported. It is unknown how many were initially observed / reported in 2019. 2 11/19/2019 AMENITIES -- Table pad has a border strip loose and poking up at the second picnic table west of the Catalina Trailhead 11/26/2019 Replace.COMPLETE - date unknown. 1 11/19/2019 AMENITIES -- Picnic table has slat broken off at the table nearest the Catalina Trailhead 11/26/2019 Repair.COMPLETE - date unknown. A-39 Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 12 8/14/2022 FENCING - Fallen post and cable barrier. The barrier had blocked an unauthorized spur trail 9/13/2022 Repair or reset post.COMPLETE - As of 9/29/2022, post was reset. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests SUNRISE TRAIL A-40 11 8/14/2022 TRAIL BED - Broken irrigation pipe has been uncovered and is protruding above the trail bed near the bottom of Sunrise Trail 9/13/2022 Repair or remove pipe.COMPLETE - As of 10/14/2022, pipe was removed. 10 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- Empty post at the bottom of the trail that needs a "No animals on the beach" sign which was previously vandalized and then removed . 1/23/2020; 3/17/2021; 1/20/2022 Reinstall a "no animals on the beach" to assist with enforcement COMPLETE - Sign reinstalled by TN on 1/20/2022. Sign was previously installed by TN on January 2022, however, the sign was seen on the ground days later. However, the code was incorrect. Requested code corection. Should read "6.04.050". City Staff observed on 1/19/21 the codes were still incorrect and sent a reminder. On 1/20/21, TN corrected codes. A-41 5 3/1/2021; 8/30/2022 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized paths all along the trail leading to the cliff edge making it very unsafe 3/17/2021; 9/13/2022 Close spur trails with fencing and the installation of "Closed Area" signs for enforcement purposes COMPLETE- On 12/21/2022, TN installed new posts and cables to close access to the spur trail. Signage to be installed shortly. A-42 3 3/13/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail markers at top or bottom of trail 3/17/2021 Install trail marker signs with appropriate decals INCOMPLETE. No trail marker signs as of 1/19/2022. A-43 2 3/1/2021 SIGNAGE -- No Animals on Beach sign broken at bottom of trail at overlook 1/23/2020; 3/17/2021 Install "No animals on beach" sign using an empty post or fencing post along the trail for enforcement purposes COMPLETE - Unknown if previous signs had been installed between the initial report (3/2021 to 1/2022). The sign was not visible on 1/19/2022. As of 1/20/2022, City staff observed sign was installed at one of the posts. On 1/29/22, City staff found the sign off the post. This was the result of improper screws used when mounting onto the post. On 2/2022, City Staff installed new signage on the bottom of the overlook and secured with proper screws. A-44 2 12/18/2020 SIGNAGE- New "No animals on beach" sign has not been installed near beginning of Sunrise trail 3/17/2021 Replace with new sign for more visibility COMPLETED - 2/2/2022 by City Staff. The current sign had been installed and moved to its current location for improved visibility. Height was also increased. A-45 Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 10 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE -- Trail marker sign at bottom of trail is missing authorized decals and is covered with graffiti 3/17/2021 Apply appropriate decals and remove graffiti INCOMPLETE - Confirmed as of 3/7/2022. UPDATE 4/22 new carsonite post and stickers installed 9 9/10/2019 SIGNAGE -- Bent No Animals on Beach sign at top of trail 3/17/2021 Repair or replace sign.INCOMPLETE - Sign is still bent, and graffiti is now visible on the back of the sign as of 3/7/2022. UPDATE 4/22 New sign installed 7 8/19/2019 TRAIL BED -- Railroad tie difficult to step over near top of trail 8/28/2019 Restore to a usuable condition. INCOMPLETE - Confirmed as of 3/7/2022. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests DUDLEYA TRAIL A-46 6 8/19/2019 GRAFFITI -- On rocks (2) near the bottom of the trail and on the trail marker at the bottom 8/28/2019; 3/17/2021 Clean graffiti.INCOMPLETE - Additional graffiti has been added since the item was reported. Confirmed as of 3/7/2022. UPDATE 4/22 Graffiti removed 5 8/19/2019 SIGNAGE -- Trail marker missing decals at bottom of the trail 8/28/2019 Apply appropriate decals.4/22 Trail signs installed again - Sign was installed over a year ago but someone removed. 4 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail marker at the top of the trail 3/17/2021 Install carsonite trail marker with appropriate decals. 4/22 Trail signs installed 1 6/4/2019 SIGNAGE -- Trail marker decals faded at trailhead. 6/17/2019 Attach new decals.4/22 Trail signs installed A-47 Ref. # Date Maintenanc e Issue Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump National Action Requested Status 27 8/30/2022 SPUR TRAIL - Unauthorized paths on Shoreline Park Trail connecting to East Boundary Trail 9/13/2022 Close spur trail.ONGOING - TN Closed spur trail on 9/29/2022. UPDATE 4/2022 Foliage has covered this spur trail. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests SHORELINE PARK TRAIL A-48 26 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - Bike decal on the carsonite at the bottom of the trail at Sagebrush Walk Trail has been scratched out. // Etched with 22 at the top of the carsonite 9/13/2022 Replace decal.10/2023 - Multiple bike decals have been (unauthorized) removed by someone. Trump replaced several stickers. UPDATE 03/2022 Again stickers removed by someone and replaced by Trump 25 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - Bike decal on the carsonite at Shoreline Park Trail near East Boundary Trail has been scratched out 9/13/2022 Replace decal.10/2023 - Multiple bike decals have been (unauthorized) removed by someone. Trump replaced several stickers. UPDATE 03/2022 Again stickers removed by someone and replaced by Trump A-49 24 8/1/2022 SPUR TRAIL - Unauthorized paths on uphillside of trail between Gnatcatcher and East Boundary Trail junction. 9/13/2022 Close spur trail. ONGOING- TN continues to place brush barriers to deter visibility and access. 23 2/7/2022 TRAILBED - Rut in the middle of trail bed, on several sections of upper portion of trail; likely caused by recent rain events. 2/14/2022 Repair as needed.ONGOING- On 3/3/2022, TN will continue to monitor ruts, and make repairs after rainy season. UPDATE 4/2022 Repairs made to trail A-50 ~ 22 2/7/2022; SIGNAGE - Carsonite Missing / Needed at Sagebrush Walk and Shoreline Park Trail junction. 2/14/2022 Install carsonite with appropriate decals. COMPLETE - 3/3/2022, carsonite sign installed at location. 21 2/7/2022; 8/1/2022 GRAFFITI - On Shoreline Park Trail and Gnatcatcher Trail junction, the no-bike decal has been scratched out on carsonite. 2/14/2022; 9/13/2022 Replace decal.Ongoing - City confirmed 2/18/22 bikes are permitted on Gnatcatcher Trail and Shoreline Park Trail. TN removed stickers to correct permitted user groups. UPDATE 10/2022 stickers replaced A-51 20 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - white (faded) graffiti on wooden post on the upper section near Gnatcatcher Trail junction. 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti.COMPLETE - 3/3/2022 Graffiti removed. A-52 19 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - on two orange traffic cones located approximately halfway down the middle of the trail. 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti or cone, if no longer needed. COMPLETE - 3/3/2022 Cones have been removed. A-53 18 2/1/2022 FENCING - the post to the right of the sign on the junction of East Boundary and Shoreline Park is broken. 2/1/2022 Repair or replace.New post has been installed. 17 1/6/2020 GRAFFITI -- Stickers on All Pets Must… sign & graffiti on the mutt mitt dispenser at the East Boundary Tr. junction; and just a few yards west on the bluff fence, there is graffiti on the Dangerous Conditions sign. 1/23/2020 Remove stickers Stickers have been removed multiple times since reported in 2020. As of 4/2023 no graffiti or stickers observed. 15 8/19/2019 TRASH -- Litter scattered all along the trail 8/28/2019 Remove litter.COMPLETE-- 9/25/19. Ongoing issue. litter along the trail observed various times, and collected. 14 2/28/2021 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized path from the upper portion of the trail connecting Gnatcatcher Trail and Shoreline Park Trail. Trail forks in two directions, but no clear signage to indicate which one is the authorized trail. 3/17/2021; 2/14/2022; 9/13/2022 Close spur trail.INCOMPLETE - Spur trail has been closed. Signage will be installed in Spring 2022. As of Spring 2022, spur trail was heavily used and visible. A-54 13 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail marker at junction with East Boundary Trail. 3/17/2021 Install trail marker sign with appropriate decals. INCOMPLETE - No trail marker as of 3/10/2022. UPDATE 04/2022 carsonite sign and stickers installed 11 3/26/2019 TRAIL BED -- Shallow gully starts in trail at about 32 yards north/east (uphill) from the Gnatcatcher Trail junction and continues for about 20 yards. 4/18/2019 Repair trail.COMPLETE - Trail has been repaired. 10 2/15/2021 VEGETATION -- Overgrowing trail intermittently from the Gnatcatcher Trail junction to the junction with East Boundary Trail 3/17/2021 Trim back to a 3 ft. width. COMPLETE - Trail has been repaired. 9 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail marker at either junction with Sagebrush Walk Trail. 3/17/2021 Install carsonite trail marker with appropriate decals. COMPLETE - Carsonite post and trail stickers have been installed. 8 3/26/2019 TRAIL BED -- Gullies 2 ft. deep start in trail at about 430 yards south of the Gnatcatcher Trail junction and picks up again at 470 yards. 4/18/2019 Repair trail.COMPLETE - Trail has been repaired. 6 3/26/2019 TRAIL BED -- Deep gully starts in trail at about 200 yards south of the Gnatcatcher Trail junction and picks up again at about 270, 290 & 330 yards south. 4/18/2019 Repair trail.COMPLETE - Trail has been repaired. 5 3/26/2019 TRAIL BED -- Shallow gully starts in trail at about 155 yards south of the Gnatcatcher Trail junction and continues for about 12 yards. 4/18/2019 Repair trail.COMPLETE - Trail has been repaired. 4 3/26/2019 TRAIL BED -- Shallow gully starts in trail at about 65 yards south of the Gnatcatcher Trail junction. 4/18/2019 Repair trail.COMPLETE - Trail has been repaired. 3 2/15/2021 TRAIL BED -- Steep drop off at edge of trail at 5 yards south of Gnatcatcher Trail junction 3/17/2021 Stabilize trail bed.Trail is in acceptable condition A-55 2 3/26/2019 DEBRIS -- Unsightly old post / cable fence and broken, unused white PVC pipes in the large erosion gully 5 yards south of the Gnatcatcher Trail junction just off the trail. 4/18/2019 Remove old fence & pipes. Broken PVC pipes have been removed. Plan to assess all unused irrigation pipe in 2022 and remove as needed. A-56 Ref. #Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 12 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - 11 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - Yellow graffiti on back of "Dangerous Condition" sign located at the junction of East Boundary Trail and Sagebrush Walk Trail near the "Preserve Rules" sign. 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti.COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022 Graffiti has been removed. 10 2/5/2022 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized path from the middle section near Delicia access towards the bottom (Southern) section of trail as it meets Sagebrush Walk Trail junction 2/14/2022 Close spur trail.INCOMPLETE - Spur trail remains visible and accessible. May be blocked by new spring growth, limiting use year-round, however, there is no signage, or barriers to prevent additional damage. UPDATE 3/2023 Foliage has grown and thus spur trail not visible. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests EAST BOUNDARY TRAIL A-57 9 2/1/2022 FENCING -- The fence post to the right of a "Dangerous Condition" sign has damage, likely from termites. It is broken off at ground level. 2/1/2022 Replace wooden post and reinstall. 4/2022 Post Replaced 8 3/1/2021 SIGNAGE -- City logo sign on sign board & Preserve Rules sign both scratched at junction with Shoreline Park Tr. Nearby at the border fence with the mobile home park, there is a Revegetation sign on a post that is just leaning against the cyclone fence 265º W 33º43'20"N 118º19'58"W 150ft elevation 3/17/2021; 2/7/2022 Repair or replace or reset in place. COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022 removed as able. Sign has not been compromised to ap point of replacement. All Preserve regulation signs will be replaced in Summer 2022. Revegetation sign repaired. A-58 6 3/1/2021 SIGNAGE -- No trail marker available at the top or bottom of East boundary trail, including at the San Pedro/RPV border 3/17/2021 Install East Boundary trail marker sign No trail marker sign 3/1/2021. East Boundary Trail is not on the original trail map. New stickers will be ordered March 2022. 5 8/13/2019 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized path near the top (north) end of the trail. 3/17/2021 Close spur trail Spur trail closed on BOTH sides. Signage will be placed Summer 2022. 3 8/13/2019 VEGETATION -- Overgrowth on upper switchbacks near the top (north) end of trail 8/28/2019 Trim back to width of trail bed. COMPLETE. A-59 Ref. # Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump National Action Requested Status 24 8/1/2022 FENCING- on Gnatcatcher and Catalina Trail junction, wooden fence post is down. 9/13/2022 Repair / Replace posts as needed. GNATCATCHER TRAILOcean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests A-60 23 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - On Gnatcatcher carsonite at the Catalina Trail junction, the no bike decal has been scratched out; the order of decals should be: trail name, level of difficulty, hiker, and biker / no biker 9/13/2022 Replace as needed. A-61 22 2/7/2022; 8/1/2022 GRAFFITI - On Gnatcatcher and Shoreline Park Trail, no bike decal has been scratched out on carsonite. 2/14/2022; 5/5/2022; 9/13/2022 Replace as needed.Ongoing - City confirmed 2/18/22 bikes are permitted on Gnatcatcher Trail. Decal replaced as of 3/3/2022.Reported scratched again on / before May and in August 2022. 21 2/14/2022 DECAL- No bike decal vandalized on carsonite at Catalina Trail and Gnatcatcher Trail. Decal was scratched out. 2/14/2022 Replace as needed. A-62 20 2/14/2022 POST - Two wooden posts are down, located within 10 feet of one another. Damage is likely caused by termite damage at the base. 2/14/2022 Repair / Replace posts as needed. COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, post was fixed. Additionally, 10-15 posts were repaired during this period that needed to be secured. 19 12/8/2021 POST - Wooden Post is down and broken at the Palos Verdes Drive South intersection. 12/8/2021 Replace or remove.COMPLETE - As of 2/2022, Post is still down. Post was fixed in March of 2021 and again in March 2022 -- Fixed as of 3/2022. A-63 18 3/15/2021 SIGNAGE- Old sign with incorrect municipal code at the top of Gnatcatcher trail where it meets Palos Verdes Drive South road 3/17/2021 Replace old sign with a new "Dogs on leash sign INCOMPLETE - Sign and post removed. New "Dogs" sign installed. UPDATE 3/2022 New signs installed 17 2/8/2021 GRAFFITI - On back of metal sign, located on Shoreline Park Trail Junction. The graffiti is the same as that found on Catalina Trail "Varrio Slauson Avenue 19" 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti.Graffiti has been removed. 16 10/28/2019 SIGNAGE -- Faded decals on trail marker at junction with Sagebrush Walk Trail. [Also has graffiti on it] 11/5/2019 Attach appropriate decals. New post and sign installed. A-64 15 1/21/2020 GRAFFITI -- Tagging on a big, low, steel trail support midway along the trail 1/23/2020; 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti.Graffiti has been removed. 14 10/28/2019 SIGNAGE -- Faded decals on trail marker at junction with Catalina Tr. [Also has graffiti on it]. 11/5/2019; 3/17/2021 Attach appropriate decals. New post and sign installed. 13 10/22/2019 GRAFFITI -- Tagging on a large, steel post sticking uprright in the trail about halfway along 11/5/2019; 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti.Graffiti removed. 10 3/11/2019 TRASH -- Litter on left side of trail about 20 yards west of trail junction with Shoreline Park Trail. 4/18/2019 Remove litter. Completed - 7/7/2019. 9 3/11/2019 SIGNAGE -- No trail marker at junction with Shoreline Park Trail. 4/18/2019; 3/17/2021 Install carsonite trail marker with appropriate decals at this trailhead. Trail sign has been installed. A-65 Ref. # Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 70 8/14/2022 SPUR TRAIL - Spur trail on ocean side east of Dudleya Trail junction. 9/13/2022 Cover up spur trail. 69 8/1/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite at the bottom of inclined section (near Sagebrush Walk Trail) needs to be corrected to Catalina Trail 9/13/2022 Replace decal. 68 8/1/2022 GRAFFITI - Black text graffiti on wooden post on inclined section of Sagebrush Walk Trail towards Catalina Trail. 9/13/2022 Remove graffiti.COMPLETE - As of 10/14/2022, graffiti removed; post repainted. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests CATALINA TRAIL A-66 67 /1/2022; 8/30/202 SIGNAGE - Carsonite at the top of inclined section (near Gnatcatcher Trail) is down. 9/13/2022 Repair carsonite, as needed. COMPLETE - As of 9/29/2022, Carsonite sign was replaced. 66 5/5/2022 SIGNAGE - On top of steps, trail name on decal is incorrect. It is currently marked as "Sagebrush Walk Trail," but should be "Catalina Trail" 5/13/2022 Replace decal. A-67 65 5/5/2022 SIGNAGE - On top of steps, decal no bike decal on carsonite is scratched out. 5/13/2022 Replace decal. 64 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - faded red text on back of "Dangerous Condition" sign located at the start of Catalina Trail, just west of picnic area on Sagebrush Walk Trail. 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti.COMPLETE - 3/3/2022 Graffiti removed. 63 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - "22" etched on back of "Dangerous Condition" sign located at the start of Catalina Trail, west of picnic area on Sagebrush Walk Trail. 2/14/2022 Repair as needed.COMPLETE - 3/3/2022 Graffiti removed. A-68 62 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - red text on back of "Dangerous Condition" sign located at the base of the inclined section, near Sagebrush Walk Trail junction. / 3 decals were also reported on the front of the sign by Volunteers, but were easily removable. Black text graffiti on front of sign reported in August, in addition to graffiti on wooden post. Remove graffiti. 61 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - yellow text on wooden post located on uphill side of trail, west of Gnatcatcher Trail junction. Remove graffiti. A-69 60 2/7/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite located west of Gnatcatcher Trail (near the large boulders), has bike decal scratched out. 2/14/2022; 9/13/2022 Replace decal.COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, carsonite sign straighened. 59 2/7/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite located west of Gnatcatcher Trail (near the large boulders), is leaning. 2/14/2022 Repair carsonite, as needed. COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, carsonite sign repaired. A-70 58 2/7/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite at top of inclined section (close to of trail has no bike decal missing as it scratched out. 2/14/2022 Replace decal.COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, decal replaced. 57 2/7/2022 SIGNAGE - Carsonite at top of inclined section of trail has incorrect name as "Sagebrush Walk Trail" but should be "Catalina Trail". 2/14/2022; 5/5/2022 Replace decal.COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, decal replaced. A-71 56 2/7/2022 FENCING - Cable sagging frayed / broken at the bottom of the inclined section near Southshore Coastal Trail junction 2/14/2022 Repair as needed.COMPLETE - Work delayed due to supply procurement. Exact date of completion unknown, but was completed in Spring 2022. 55 2/7/2022; 8/1/2022 TRAIL BED- Wooden railroad-tie step is not level on lower portion of inclined section of Catalina Trail. There is a hole at the bottom of the trail. On upper section (going North), several steps have steep drop-offs and /or are not level. Hikers are going into habitat to get around, causing damage. 2/14/2022; 05/5/2022; 9/13/2022 Repair steps as needed to address grade, and deter damage to habitat. ONGOING - Extensive work done by outside contractor in october 2021. Additional repairs will be completed after the end of rainy season, and will continue to be monitored. A-72 54 2/3/2023 SIGNAGE / FENCING--Secure temporary closure on Catalina Trail near East Portal junction. 2/3/2022 Install another post to secure the netting or barrier to deter access into the closed section. ONGOING On 2/3/2022- TN confirmed work can be completed as new signs to educate public on temporary closure were already ordered / arrived. New signs installed at this location, and a new post on 2/11/2022. A-frame was provided by City, and orange netting continued to be replaced by TN and City to maintain temporary closure. 53 5/13/2021 BRIDGE - Unstable footing on the third and eastern most footbridge (from Lakeview Trail facing the Ocean, turn left). 3/17/2021 Inspect bridge for safety concerns and coordinate closures, as needed. ONGOING 5/13/2021 - City Staff and PVPLC reported fissures along the footbridge. City staff notified Trump to begin coordination. On 5/14/2021, City staff closed the bridge. A- frames were placed on the bridge to close it. On 5/20/2021, Trump National Staff responded that they would provide additional closure to close off the bridge with plywood and additional signage. A-frames with Trail Closed language were placed at both access points and adjacent junctions. On 5/28/2021, Trump National Staff responded they would install plywood across both entrances of bridge. The following week, they would install a cable across the trail. City and TN continued to patrol and monitor closures, with several iterations to reinforce the signage. TN installed barriers with plywood attached to both ends of the bridge. As of 3/10/2022, "Do Not Enter" sign missing on the Western section. 52 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE- Stickers on enforcement sign 178º S 33º43'40"N 118º20'51"W 140ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove stickers A-73 50 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE- Graffiti on enforcement sign 39º NE 33º43'38"N 118º20'44"W 170ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti INCOMPLETE - Graffiti still visible on sign. 50 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE- Blank sign with no information that can be replaced with a new sign "Dogs on leash" or "No animals on the beach" 222º SW 33º43'35"N 118º20'30"W 150ft elevation 3/17/2021 Replace blank sign with a new sign "Dogs on leash" or "No animals on the beach" for enforcement 4/2021 Old sign replaced with new sign 50 2/28/2021 FENCING- Loose posts no longer cemented to the ground and stray pieces of cement on the vegetation 5º N 33º43'34"N 118º20'29"W 170ft elevation 3/17/2021 Recement loose posts on Catalina trail and remove unused cement blocks Post has been reinstalled. Cement removed. A-74 49 2/28/2021 FENCING/ TRASH CAN- Blue container being used as a makeshift trash can. Fencing has frayed cables that can cut trail users. 330º NW 33º43'30"N 118º20'25"W 170ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove blue container if not an authorized and regularly emptied trash can. Fix frayed cable fencing to make it safer Removed trash can. Cables will be assessed Spring 2022. 48 2/15/2021 SIGNAGE- Enforcement signs (Animals on the beach, Animals on leash) are heavily vandalised (etchings) and have stickers 172º S 33º43'24"N 118º20'9"W 260ft elevation 3/17/2021 Remove sticker and vandalism marks, if necessary replace signs INCOMPLETE - sign is still vandalized as of 3/14/2022. 47 2/15/2021 TRASH CANS- missing lids 3/17/2021 Replace lids INCOMPLETE - Trash lids missing as of 3/14/2022. UPDATE 4/2022 New trash cans installed A-75 46 3/8/2021; 8/26/2022 SIGNAGE- Carsonite missing decals located about 50 yards south of Dudleya Tr. junction. POSSIBLE SPUR- trail leads up through scrub to golf cart road and raised golf feature Trail is not in the Preserve, but is part of the Ocean Trails Amenities Plan, known as Flying Golf Ball Trail 3/17/2021; 9/13/2022 Replace decals and close spur if it is not part of the official trail COMPLETE - TN removed carsonite in Spring 2022. Signage being reassessed. Cholla planted on spur trail. City was able to confirm this trail is authorized, known as Flying Golf Ball Trail and any barriers placed should be removed. All barriers were removed by 12/23/2022 45 3/1/2021 FENCING-Two poles down located south of bridge 3/17/2021 Fix fencing posts Posts fixed. 44 3/1/2021 GRAFFITI/STICKERS- On caution sign on first footbridge (when heading south from golf course). Sign is on northbound entrance. 3/17/2021 Remove stickers and graffiti Sign removed as it is not part of Ocean Trails Signage Plan. 43 3/1/2021 GRAFFITI- On fencepost, about 150ft south of Coastal Switchback trail 3/17/2021 Remove graffiti Graffiti removed. A-76 42 2/22/2021 SIGNAGE - At Lakeview Tr. junction, sign 3/17/2021 Fix sign COMPLETE - Date unknown. Sign is no longer present at the location. 40 2/8/2021 GRAFFITI - White and black graffiti below railling on bridge over creek. "Varrio Slauson - Ave. 19" (Location: The bridge is larger of the 2 bridges on this trail. It is the last one to the east, naer junction with path leading to Lakeview Trail). 3/17/2021 Clean Graffiti.COMPLETE - Date unknown. Graffiti is no longer on the bridge. Entire bridge repainted. 38 11/30/2020 GRAFFITI - 1 instance of graffiti on sign after footbridge. Clean graffiti.Graffiti removed. A-77 37 11/30/2020 GRAFFITI - 2 instances of graffiti on posts lining trail, near footbridge. Clean graffiti.Graffiti removed. 36 11/22/2020 GRAFFITI - 1 instance of graffiti on trash can lid at Lakeview and Catalina Clean Graffiti.INCOMPLETE - Lid was thrown down the hill. Could not confirm if the lid had graffiti. 35 11/30/2020 BROKEN POST - near second fotobridge.Replace post. All broken posts have been replaced 34 11/30/2020 GRAFFITI - 1 instance of graffiti at view point 50 yards south of second footbridge on Catalina Trail, 2 more instances of Clean graffiti. Graffiti removed. 33 1/22/2022 SIGNAGE - No trail marker at western trailhead by Founders Park. 3/17/2021 Install marker with appropriate decals. UPDATE 4/2021 Carsonite Sign and stickers installed at trail head 32 1/22/2020 GRAFFITI - On back of sign board at east end of the trail. 1/23/2020 Install marker with appropriate decals.Graffiti removed. 31 1/22/2020 TRAIL BED - Hikers icon sign on post unneeded next to the sign board at the east end of the trail 1/23/2020 Remove sign and post. Following up on location 30 1/9/2020 TRAIL BED - Erosion gully has developed along trail between the East Portal and Coastal Switchback Trail 1/23/2020 Remove sign and post. Trail fixed 29 1/9/2020 TRAIL BED - Erosion gully has developed on the east end of the trail. 1/23/2020 Restore trail bed. Trail fixed 28 1/9/2020 SIGNAGE - Dangerous conditions signs hangs loose on the bluff fence at the east end of the trail 1/23/2020 Secure sign. Sign tightened 27 1/9/2020 Trail Bed - Exposed drain pipe 30 feet east of the junction with Coastal Switchback 1/23/2020 Bury. All broken pipe removed 26 1/9/2020 SPUR TRAIL - Spur trail on ocean side a few yards east of Catalina Trail junction 1/23/2020 Block spur trail access. Location being clarified. 25 1/9/2020 TRASH - In the habitat near the bluff west of the junction with Southshore Coastal Trail 1/23/2020 Remove trash. Removed A-78 24 1/9/2020 TRAIL BED - Ruts 2-6" deep on the sloped trail east of the junction with Coastal Switchback Trail 1/23/2020 Remove trash. 23 1/9/2020 TRAIL BED - Torn sandbags near the junction with Coastal Switchback Trail. 1/23/2020 Replace or remove. Sandbags removed 22 1/9/2020 TRAIL BED - Exposed tubing or pipe on the sloped trail east of the junction with Coastal Switchback Tr. 1/23/2020 Bury or remove. All broken pipe removed 21 1/9/2020 FENCING - Cable sagging near junction with Coastal Switchback Trail 1/23/2020 Replace cable or tighten.Trail section currently closed 20 12/10/2019 TRASH - Dog waste bags scattered left along trail. 12/11/2019 Remove bags. Trash cleaned every Friday 19 10/28/2019 GRAFFITI - on metallic support for a wooden fence post along trail. 11/5/2019 Clean graffiti. Graffiti removed. 18 3/1/2021 FENCING -- Cable rusted & splintered at various points along the trail 3/17/2021 Replace cable.PARTIALLY INCOMPLETE - Parts of the cable are still rusted and frayed as of 3/7/2022. Some cable not replaced 1/10/20 (8/11/2020 Cable rusted and splintered.) 17 10/28/2019 GRAFFITI -- on metallic support for a wooden fence post along trail 11/5/2019 Clean graffiti.Graffiti removed. 16 9/5/2019 GRAFFITI -- on Environmentally Sensitive Area sign along trail 9/11/2019 Clean graffiti.Graffiti removed. 14 9/5/2019 HABITAT -- Irrigation line exposed, looping up in the air west of the Gnatcatcher Tr. junction 9/11/2019 Secure the line down on the ground. Irrigation line removed 12 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- Eastern end has no trail marker, the marker near the eastern end sign board needs decals, the trail marker at the East Portal Tr. junction needs decals on both sides (has graffiti also); and on the eastern portion of the trail there are damaged signs that are unreadable (3) and there are missing Preserve signs (3) 3/17/2021 Install trail marker signs with appropriate decals and restore all signs to guide trail users at the junction of multiple trails COMPLETE - Signs installed as of 5/17/2021. A-79 11 2/28/2021 SPUR TRAIL -- Unauthorized paths extend into the habitat from around the rim of Founders Park on the west end of Catalina Tr. 3/17/2021 Close spur trails using branches or vegetation to discourage hikers from entering the habitat Still open 2/28/2021. Signage will be installed in Spring 2022. UPDATE 4/22 branches added to area closing spur trail 5 7/29/2019 FENCING -- Mutiple downed or leaning wooden fence posts & cable at several locations (including posts lying on top of the vegetation) 3/17/2021 Repair.Post fixed. 4 6/4/2019 FENCING -- bollard missing (with former concrete base protruding in the path) at the junction with the path down from La Rotonda parking lot 6/17/2019 Restore bollard.Post has been reinstalled. A-80 1 2/22/2021 TRAIL BED -- Wooden steps have severe erosion around them and are unusable causing patrons to go off trail into habitat all along the steep eastern part of the trail. 119° SE 33°43'25"N 118°20'11"W 110ft elevation 6/17/2019; 3/17/2021 Restore trail to usable condition. Wooden stairs were replaced and/or removed by Bellfree 10/2021 A-81 Ref. # Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump Action Requested Status 19 8/1/2022 GRAFFITI - Black text graffiti on wooden post on inclined section of Sagebrush Walk Trail towards Catalina Trail. 9/13/2022 Remove graffiti.COMPLETE - As of 10/14/2022, graffiti removed; post repainted. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests SAGEBRUSH WALK TRAIL A-82 18 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI - Yellow text graffiti on wooden post on coastal side of trail. (Post is next to a castor bean plant, just before reaching the picnic area. 2/14/2022 Remove graffiti.COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, graffiti removed. 17 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI-- Decal on "Dangerous Condition" sign on coastal side of trail near East Boundary junction was observed and removed by Volunteers. 2/14/2022 Information / notification only. COMPLETE A-83 16 2/7/2022 TRAIL BED - On coastal side of trail, erosion of edge is visible. May pose issue for stability of post in the future. Reoccuring issue after winter rains due to poor water drainage. 2/14/2022 Fill in hole, and assess water drainage. COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, hole was backfilled. A-84 15 2/7/2022; 8/1/2022 SPUR TRAIL - Spur trail seen on ocean side of trail, leading to cliff edge. Located past the junction of Shoreline Park Trail towards Southshore Coastal Trail. 2/14/2022; 9/13/2022 Cover up spur.ONGOING - As of 3/3/2022, spur trail was closed. However, it has been uncovered and is visible. UPDATE 3/22 Trump crew continues to add branches etc. to this area. New CLOSED signs ordered on 4/7 A-85 14 2/7/2022 TRAILBED - On coastal side of trail, a large hole is visible. 2/14/2022 Fill in hole.COMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, hole was filled in with soil. 13 2/7/2022 TRAIL AMMENITITES - Picnic Table has burn mark on the center. 2/14/2022 Replace or repair as needed. COMPLETE 2/18/22 - Picnic table repaired to smoothen out top and repainted. A-86 12 2/7/2022 SIGNAGE - "22" is etched on "Tidepool Collecting" sign at the junction of Sagebrush Walk Trail and Catalina Trail. 2/14/2022 Repair, as able.INCOMPLETE - As of 3/3/2022, repaired as able. Recommend RPV replace the sign. 11 7/30/2021 TRASH - At least 3 trash cans are visible on the hillside below Sagebrush Walk Trail.7/30/2021 Retrieve trash cans, and other debris along hillside. Replace, as needed. COMPLETE- 9/2021. New trash can was installed at Shoreline Park. A-87 10 8/19/2019; 2/7/2022 GRAFFITI-- Numerous spots of tagging on posts, signs, trash can, benches, bag dispenser & etc. all along trail 8/28/2019; 2/14/2022; 8/19/2022; 8/24/2022 Clean graffiti.ONGOING - Graffiti continously removed and repainted as needed. UPDATE 4/23 graffiti continues to be removed. A-88 9 8/19/2019;TRAIL BED -- Railroad ties used as steps are unstable and the ground is severly eroded around them (20) on the steep, western portion of the trail 8/28/2019 Restore trail bed.COMPLETE - Bellfree completed trail restoration 10/2021 Work was contracted through Bellfree to restore trail bed and repair steps in October 2021. The work was anticipated to begin on March, however, due to bird nesting season, it was postponed to Fall 2021. 8 8/19/2019 TRAIL BED -- Long erosion gully in eastern portion of the trail and a couple of ruts/holes in the western postion 8/28/2019 Restore trail bed.COMPLETE - Bellfree completed trail restoration 10/2021 7 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- No Animals on the Beach sign is scratched up at the junction with Southshore Coastal Tr. 3/17/2021 Replace sign INCOMPLETE - Going to install new post and sign A-89 3 2/28/2021 SIGNAGE -- Missing decals on trail marker in middle of trail 3/17/2021 Install trail marker sign with appropriate decals New stickers installed on top and bottom of the trail. A-90 I I Ref. #Date Maintenance Issue Found Issue Type -- Specific Problem Date Reported to Trump National Action Requested Status 1 12/18/2020 New "no animals on the beach" sign is not installed 3/17/2021 Replace old sign with new one New post and sign installed by TN - Fixed Summer 2021, and installed new green and white sign Spring 2022. Ocean Trails Preserve / Adjacent Areas -- OSM Maintenance Requests PARKING LOT OFF TRUMP NATIONAL DRIVE A-91 From:Kelvin Vanderlip To:Amy Seeraty Subject:Fwd: Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 18th City Council meeting - brush clearance on Lot D adjoining Tract 16540 Date:Tuesday, April 11, 2023 1:13:58 PM Attachments:image009.png image010.png image011.png image012.png image013.png image014.png image016.png EXTERNAL EMAIL: Do not click links or open any attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe!!!. Hi Amy, Not sure why this email missed you, and I apologize for the added confusion. Anyway, here's what I sent you the other day. David Gakenheimer read it after it was sent, and added a lot of information which he thinks will help out. Thank you again for your help with the the 3 drinking fountains on/near the Trump area which were repaired last year and are still in tip top condition. With bext regards, Kel -------- Forwarded Message -------- Subject:Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 18th City Council meeting - brush clearance on Lot D adjoining Tract 16540 Date:Wed, 5 Apr 2023 16:05:35 -0700 From:Kelvin Vanderlip <kelvin@vanderlip.org> To:AmyS@rpvca.govCC:octavios@rpvca.gov, David Gakenheimer <dgakenheimer@gmail.com>, Steve Stewart <sr.stew@verizon.net>, Robert Voll <rvoll@cox.net>, Rob Hamilton <robertlhamilton@hotmail.com> Dear Amy, Last year about this time we discussed the planting on the City's Lot D, Tract 50666, which adjoins our Tract 16540. The Lot D planting is now complete and has grown up thick and deep. The residents of our Tract 16540 recently received their 2023 L.A. County Fire Department instructions on brush clearance requirements. Our residents will comply with these detailed instructions and create a safe fire landscape. However, this might not be possible if flamable vegetation within a home's brush clearance zone is on City property. For residents on the eastern edge of our Tract, the planting on Lot D is within the 50 foot "Zone 1 Lean, Clean and Green Zone" surrounding their homes. Therefore, these residents cannot clear their brush clearance Zone 1 of all flammable vegetation - some of that vegetation may be on the City's Lot D. Here is an extract of our emails back in May 2022. I wrote: 3. As you know, there was a fire last week near the bridge to the Club House, fortunately quickly extinguished, but the fire treat from the habitat shrubs to my tract is real. There is new landscaping adjoining my tract which might be dangerous if not maintained properly. This new landscaping to the west of the driving range, on Tract 50666 Lot D, has been planted, irrigated, and is growing vigorously in most places. This landscaping covered what was a vacant dirt lot which was formerly a fuel load control area. The former bare dirt lot gave my tract (16540) some protection from possible fires in the habitat area to the south of the driving range. Several years ago my tract’s HOA met with the former planning director, the L.A. County fire department and a representative of the Golf Club and we all agreed that the planting to the west of the driving range was to be maintained “in park-like condition”, which meant watered and maintained in such a way that it would not carry a fire across Lot D into our tract. I do not see anything about this planting in the Maintenance Matrix, and I am hoping this would be a great time to get it onto the Maintenance Matrix schedule. You replied: I know that irrigation was installed for the plantings on Lot D. Please see the sentence that starts with: “The Maintenance Obligations and the area…” towards the bottom of page 5, as that mentions the maintenance of the landscaping. I will review the project documentation to find additional information regarding the maintenance of Lot D and will get back to you. I hope you have had a chance to review the project documentation. Could you please let us know if Lot D flammable vegetation will be cleared back from our homes in accordance with the County brush clearance requirements? If not, can you suggest how we can preserve the safety of our Tract over the hot, drying summer and fall? The Lot D planting is well watered today but could easily become dried out and flammable in a few months. It all depends on how it is maintained by the Trump National Golf Club. It would be great to get full year irrigation and brush clearance into the agreed Lot D maintenance schedule. Please let us know what the City will request from the Trump Golf Course in this regard. Thank you for your help with this public safety issue. With best regards, Kel Vanderlip -------- Forwarded Message --------Subject:Fw: Questions regarding Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 5th City Council meeting Date:Tue, 3 May 2022 19:58:19 +0000 From:Kelvin Vanderlip <kelvinvanderlip@outlook.com> To:kelvin@vanderlip.org <kelvin@vanderlip.org> FYI From: Amy Seeraty <AmyS@rpvca.gov> Sent: Tuesday, April 5, 2022 17:46 To: 'Kelvin Vanderlp' <kelvinvanderlip@outlook.com> Subject: RE: Questions regarding Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 5th City Council meeting Hello Kelvin- So sorry for the delay, been out with a sick child. I’ll be at the meeting tonight though. I wanted to get you an answer about the water fountains at least before the meeting. Rec and Parks staff will be adding the water fountains to the maintenance matrix, and I’ll mention those to the Trump staff as well. I haven’t been able to locate information about the maintenance of Lot D yet, but I would imagine that if there are issues beyond the normal growth of native plants, I could always reach out to the Trump folks. Thank you and please let me know if you have any additional questions. Sincerely, Amy SeeratySenior Planneramys@rpvca.gov Phone - (310) 544-5231 C-1 City of Rancho Palos Verdes30940 Hawthorne Blvd.Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275Website: www.rpvca.gov This e-mail message contains information belonging to the City of Rancho Palos Verdes, which may be privileged, confidential and/or protected from disclosure. The information is intended only for use of the individual or entity named. Unauthorized dissemination, distribution,or copying is strictly prohibited. If you received this email in error, or are not an intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately. Thank you for your assistance and cooperation. Due to the current surge of the COVID-19 Omicron Variant, Rancho Palos Verdes City Hall will be closed to walk-in visitors through February 28, 2022, unless further notification is provided. Several members of the City’s workforce are being asked to work remotely during this time. Inquiries will continue to be reviewed on a daily basis. Please be patient with us as there may be delays or minor inconveniences in responding to your inquiry. From: Amy Seeraty Sent: Thursday, March 31, 2022 4:13 PM To: 'Kelvin Vanderlp' <kelvinvanderlip@outlook.com> Subject: RE: Questions regarding Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 5th City Council meeting Thank you for your kind words Kelvin. I’m glad I could help clarify. I’ll be in touch and should have additional information for you by Monday. Thank you. Sincerely, Amy SeeratySenior Planneramys@rpvca.gov Phone - (310) 544-5231 City of Rancho Palos Verdes30940 Hawthorne Blvd.Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275Website: www.rpvca.gov This e-mail message contains information belonging to the City of Rancho Palos Verdes, which may be privileged, confidential and/or protected from disclosure. The information is intended only for use of the individual or entity named. Unauthorized dissemination, distribution,or copying is strictly prohibited. If you received this email in error, or are not an intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately. Thank you for your assistance and cooperation. Due to the current surge of the COVID-19 Omicron Variant, Rancho Palos Verdes City Hall will be closed to walk-in visitors through February 28, 2022, unless further notification is provided. Several members of the City’s workforce are being asked to work remotely during this time. Inquiries will continue to be reviewed on a daily basis. Please be patient with us as there may be delays or minor inconveniences in responding to your inquiry. From: Kelvin Vanderlp <kelvinvanderlip@outlook.com> Sent: Thursday, March 31, 2022 4:02 PM To: Amy Seeraty <AmyS@rpvca.gov> Subject: Re: Questions regarding Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 5th City Council meeting CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of Rancho Palos Verdes. Dear Amy, Your email was greatly appreciated! Your reply was clear, complete, concise, and helped me understand the state of things. The City is lucky to have you. With thanks and best regards, Kel On 3/31/22 15:28, Amy Seeraty wrote: Hello Kelvin- Thank you for your email. Please see your questions with my answers following each below: 1. The “Attached Supporting Documents, item B., City Council-approved Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions recorded November 27, 2018” on the 2nd page of the agenda item’s PDF is missing from the PDF file. If I click on this item as a URL I get to a user/password protected page at Microsoft.online. This means I cannot read this document, which is key to understanding everyone’s obligations to review and comply (and I hope this is not leading to me to ask questions which might be irrelevant below.) I’m so sorry about that Kelvin, I’m not sure what occurred with the link, but please see what should be a working link below: 2018-1187784 REC ALL (Restated Maintenance Agrmt) .pdf 2. There are 2 drinking fountains in Marylin Ryan Sunset Point Park. One is completely dead, the other has had its drain blocked for several years, making its drinking bowl foul. A 3rd drinking fountain on the north side of P.V. Dr. South near the intersection with P.V. Dr. East is also dead, without water. I walk by these drinking fountains all the time and the lack of maintenance has driven me crazy. Should these public drinking fountains be maintained by the Golf Club? I searched the Maintenance Matrix for anything about these drinking fountains and came up with nothing. I cannot tell if the Golf Club is required to maintain these drinking fountains, in part because of item 1), but mostly because there are so many other documents which ran through the City to get Tract 50666 recorded that it is not possible for an outsider to know where to look. Would you please let me know if the Golf Club has any responsibility to maintain the 3 drinking fountains noted above, and whether this is the right time to get the required maintenance onto the Maintenance Matrix? I believe the Golf Club is supposed to maintain all amenities in the parks, open spaces, trails etc. However, I will verify with the Recreation, Parks, and Open Space Staff and get back to you. If the Golf Club is supposed to maintain these, I’ll make sure they get added to the matrix, or addressed in some way, shape, or form. 3. As you know, there was a fire last week near the bridge to the Club House, fortunately quickly extinguished, but the fire treat from the habitat shrubs to my tract is real. There is new landscaping adjoining my tract which might be dangerous if not maintained properly. This new landscaping to the west of the driving range, on Tract 50666 Lot D, has been planted, irrigated, and is growing vigorously in most places. This landscaping covered what was a vacant dirt lot which was formerly a fuel load control area. The former bare dirt lot gave my tract (16540) some protection from possible fires in the habitat area to the south of the driving range. Several years ago my tract’s HOA met with the former planning director, the L.A. County fire department and a representative of the Golf Club and we all agreed that the planting to the west of the driving range was to be maintained “in park-like condition”, which meant watered and maintained in such a way that it would not carry a fire across Lot D into our tract. I do not see anything about this planting in the Maintenance Matrix, and I am hoping this would be a great time to get it onto the Maintenance Matrix schedule. I know that irrigation was installed for the plantings on Lot D. Please see the sentence that starts with: “The Maintenance Obligations and the area…” towards the bottom of page 5, as that mentions the maintenance of the landscaping. I will review the project documentation to find additional information regarding the C-2 DOWNLOAD r-111.fi ';) PV rwii-Eii; DOWNLOAD 111.fj ';) PV @,, __________ _ maintenance of Lot D and will get back to you. 4. The “Fencing /Wall Plan for Tract 50666” calls for the construction of a 30” slumpstone wall on the west side of the entrance to Costa de las Islas. This was included to reduce noise and light from cars entering and leaving Costa de las Islas which would otherwise bother my tract neighbors (see the plan’s Fencing and Construction Notes, item 5). There is no sign of this wall yet. Is the construction of this wall part of the Golf Club’s compliance with the plans? If not, can you let me know when this wall was removed from the list of things the Golf Club was going to do? Thank you for the reminder but please note I am aware and have reminded the Trump Contractor in writing that this wall is still required. I will be working with them on a specific location, as the approved fencing plan included only a general location and dimensions. I will also be working with them on a possible material change, to make the wall more aesthetically pleasing than the currently required “slumpstone”. This change, as well as others that have been requested and/or implemented, will be shown on an updated fencing plan that the Trump contractor is currently working on, and will be documented as a minor change to the existing conditions of approval for the project. These changes will include other revisions to the approved fencing plan, and will be either presented or provided to the City Council along with a few other (relatively) minor project changes, which include a change to the storm drain plan for Tract No. 50666. Staff is currently working on the prerequisites to the storm drain revisions, which include updates to the City’s NCCP and an addendum to the MND for the storm drain project. I hope I am not being too much of a pain in the neck here as you are probably pretty busy, but I am hopeful these points can be considered as part of the City’s compliance review. Its very easy for things to fall between the cracks. Thank you for considering my comments and requests. No problem at all! Please always feel free to reach out to me with any questions. I can add these items to my presentation to the Council on Tuesday. Please also note that I am working on numerous other items with the Trump Golf Club staff to ensure they are meeting the conditions of approval as well as mitigation measures for the new development, including the trimming of foliage that has extended above the southern berm, review of the irrigation plans with the City Geologist, following up on their compliance with the water quality inspections, etc. Thank you, Amy SeeratySenior Planneramys@rpvca.gov Phone - (310) 544-5231 City of Rancho Palos Verdes30940 Hawthorne Blvd.Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275Website: www.rpvca.gov This e-mail message contains information belonging to the City of Rancho Palos Verdes, which may be privileged, confidential and/or protected from disclosure. The information is intended only for use of the individual or entity named. Unauthorizeddissemination, distribution, or copying is strictly prohibited. If you received this email in error, or are not an intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately. Thank you for your assistance and cooperation. Due to the current surge of the COVID-19 Omicron Variant, Rancho Palos Verdes City Hall will be closed to walk-in visitors through February 28, 2022, unless further notification is provided. Several members of the City’s workforce are being asked to work remotely during this time. Inquiries will continue to be reviewed on a daily basis. Please be patient with us as there may be delays or minor inconveniences in responding to your inquiry. From: Kelvin Vanderlip <kelvinvanderlip@outlook.com> Sent: Thursday, March 31, 2022 1:51 PM To: Amy Seeraty <AmyS@rpvca.gov> Cc: Ara Mihranian <AraM@rpvca.gov>; Ken Rukavina <krukavina@rpvca.gov> Subject: Questions regarding Trump National Golf Club’s compliance for the April 5th City Council meeting CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the City of Rancho Palos Verdes. Dear Amy, I have read the agenda from the City web site for the April 5th City Council review of the Trump National Golf Club’s compliance with the 11/27/2018 recorded restrictions. I have some comments and questions: 1. The “Attached Supporting Documents, item B., City Council-approved Amended and Restated Declaration of Restrictions recorded November 27, 2018” on the 2nd page of the agenda item’s PDF is missing from the PDF file. If I click on this item as a URL I get to a user/password protected page at Microsoft.online. This means I cannot read this document, which is key to understanding everyone’s obligations to review and comply (and I hope this is not leading to me to ask questions which might be irrelevant below.) 2. There are 2 drinking fountains in Marylin Ryan Sunset Point Park. One is completely dead, the other has had its drain blocked for several years, making its drinking bowl foul. A 3rd drinking fountain on the north side of P.V. Dr. South near the intersection with P.V. Dr. East is also dead, without water. I walk by these drinking fountains all the time and the lack of maintenance has driven me crazy. Should these public drinking fountains be maintained by the Golf Club? I searched the Maintenance Matrix for anything about these drinking fountains and came up with nothing. I cannot tell if the Golf Club is required to maintain these drinking fountains, in part because of item 1), but mostly because there are so many other documents which ran through the City to get Tract 50666 recorded that it is not possible for an outsider to know where to look. Would you please let me know if the Golf Club has any responsibility to maintain the 3 drinking fountains noted above, and whether this is the right time to get the required maintenance onto the Maintenance Matrix? 3. As you know, there was a fire last week near the bridge to the Club House, fortunately quickly extinguished, but the fire treat from the habitat shrubs to my tract is real. There is new landscaping adjoining my tract which might be dangerous if not maintained properly. This new landscaping to the west of the driving range, on Tract 50666 Lot D, has been planted, irrigated, and is growing vigorously in most places. This landscaping covered what was a vacant dirt lot which was formerly a fuel load control area. The former bare dirt lot gave my tract (16540) some protection from possible fires in the habitat area to the south of the driving range. Several years ago my tract’s HOA met with the former planning director, the L.A. County fire department and a representative of the Golf Club and we all agreed that the planting to the west of the driving range was to be maintained “in park-like condition”, which meant watered and maintained in such a way that it would not carry a fire across Lot D into our tract. I do not see anything about this planting in the Maintenance Matrix, and I am hoping this would be a great time to get it onto the Maintenance Matrix schedule. 4. The “Fencing /Wall Plan for Tract 50666” calls for the construction of a 30” slumpstone wall on the west side of the entrance to Costa de las Islas. This was included to reduce noise and light from cars entering and leaving Costa de las Islas which would otherwise bother my tract neighbors (see the plan’s Fencing and Construction Notes, item 5). There is no sign of this wall yet. Is the construction of this wall part of the Golf Club’s compliance with the plans? If not, can you let me know when this wall was removed from the list of things the Golf Club was going to do? I hope I am not being too much of a pain in the neck here as you are probably pretty busy, but I am hopeful these points can be considered as part of the City’s compliance review. Its very easy for things to fall between the cracks. Thank you for considering my comments and requests. With thanks and best regards, Kelvin Vanderlip 4105 Sea Horse Lane, R.P.V. (424) 241-0609 C-3 DOWNLOAD ?tt_'<r '")']JV From:David Gakenheimer To:Amy Seeraty Cc:Ara Mihranian; Robert Voll; Steven Stewart; Kelvin Vanderlip; Rob Hamilton Subject:Concerns for Trump Maintenance Review April 18 Date:Thursday, April 6, 2023 8:26:57 AM Attachments:Tract 16540 Trump Lot D Fire Buffer Zone Issues - 2023.pdf EXTERNAL EMAIL: Do not click links or open any attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe!!!. To: Amy Seeraty, RPV Planning Division, I am following up Kelvin Vanderlip's letter to you since I have been actively involved with the City and the Fire Department on the plantings for Lot D and the need to protect our homes from brush fires. Tract 16540 has major concerns with the plans (or lack thereof) for fire protection along our property line with the Trump Golf Course. We would like to see more detailed plans given that the area is newly planted and is growing very robustly. The plantings already exceed the Fire Department's recommended size and density for a safe fire protection zone. As time goes on towards the hot summer months it will be even more dense and risky for our homes. I have attached some pictures of the property line today showing our homes and the plantings coming up to our homes within 10 ft or less (first three slides in attached PowerPoint). Since our homeowners do not have access to Lot D any longer per City orders, they cannot do the maintenance themselves and Trump must do it. I have also attached the results of a meeting we had with the City (hosted by Ara Mihranian and So Kim), the Fire Department, the LA County Agricultural Commission and the Trump organization concerning this problem in January 2019 (same attachment below) during the planting planning phase for Lot D. I have never seen a detailed fire protection plan from that meeting following the Fire Department recommendations. I strongly recommend you have one developed ASAP as the area is growing very rapidly and the problem will be upon us soon. Trump staff have informally said they will create a park-like environment on Lot D. It is not clear what that means and so far nothing like a park has been created. They have not built the fire break zones like the Fire Department recommends. As you can see from the recent pictures (April 2023) and the original plans (Jan 2019) it is all very densely planted growing up to the fences with our homes (typically 10 feet or less from the houses themselves). I would be happy to meet with you to discuss this subject further prior to the review meeting. Sincerely yours, David -- Dr. David C. Gakenheimer Tract 16540 Board Member/CFO C-4 dgakenheimer@gmail.com 310-913-3703 C-5 Submission for the Public Hearing on April 18, 2023 Trump National Golf Club Monitoring and Maintenance Review (Case No. PLMH2023-001) From: Community Association for Tract 16540 4100 Palos Verdes Drive South, RPV, 90275 Contact: David Gakenheimer, CFO Tel: 310-913-3703 Email: dgakenheimer@gmail.com C-6 Lot D Plantings Today (April 2023) Tract 16540 homes C-7 C-8 C-9 C-10 Gmail David Gakenheimer <dgakenheimer@gmail.com> RE: Minutes from January 14, 2019, Meeting on Trump Lot D 1 message Jill Martin <jmartin@trumpnational.com> Wed , Jan 30 , 2019 at 3:59 PM To : David Gakenheimer <dgakenheimer@gmail.com>, Ara Mihranian <aram@rpvca.gov>, "So Kim (SOK@RPVCA.GOV)" <sok@rpvca .gov>, Chief J Lopez <J.Lopez@fire.lacounty.gov>, "Zach .Rehm@coastal.ca.gov" <Zach.Rehm@coastal.ca .gov>, "cchiew@acwm.lacounty.gov" <cchiew@acwm .lacounty.gov> Cc : Kelvin Vanderlip <kelvin@vandertip .org> Thank you for sharing your notes of the meeting David . While we appreciate that you would like to use these as a record of the meeting for your own purposes , please be aware that as this your personal summary and not an actual transcript, we do not agree that this document may be relied upon or used as a "record of the meeting " for any official purpose. Best regards , Vice President & Asst. Gen. Counsel The Trump Organization c/o Trump National Golf Club Los Angeles One Trump Na t ional Dr. Rancho Palos Verdes , CA 90275 Tel: 310-303-3225 C-11 From: David Gakenheimer <dgakenheimer@gmail .com > Sent: Monday, January 28, 2019 4 :54 PM To: Ara Mihranian <aram@rpvca .gov>; So Kim (SOK@RPVCA.GOV) <sok@rpvca .gov>; Chief J Lopez <J.Lopez@fire.lacounty.gov >; Jill Martin <jmartin@trumpnational.com>; Zach .Rehm@coastal.ca .gov; cchiew@acwm .lacounty.gov Cc: Kelvin Vanderlip <kelv in@vanderlip.org > Subject: Minutes from January 14 , 2019 , Meeting on Trump Lot D To attendees: Kelvin Vanderlip and I wish to thank everyone for attending this meeting. The potential fire risks of the future landscaping of Lot D are very important to the residents of Tract 16540 of the Portuguese Bend Club. Attached are our slides and minutes from the meeting which we ask you to save w ith your records for Lot D. We are in agreement with the plan to maintain the area like a park (with watering to maintain a safe plant moisture level and pruning out of dead wood) to meet the LA County Agricultural Commissioner Weights and Measures Office weed abatement and brush clearance requirements . Since the latest landscape plans (Version 6 dated 9/3/18) themselves do not have the Iona term maintenance requirements spelled out, we wish a record of this meetin~ be availa?le to all ~uture parties in the City, Golf Course owner/developer's office, and Coastal Commission that may be involved with Lot D in the future . David Dr. David C. Gakenheimer Tract 16540 Portuguese Bend Club, CFO dgakenheimer@gmail.com 310-913-3703 Agenda Lot D Technical Interchange Meeting January 14, 2019 •Introduction –So Kim •Tract 16540 Technical Concerns –David Gakenheimer •Overview Lot D Landscaping Plans –Jill Martin •Los Angeles County Fire Department Fire Protection Approach –Chief J. Lopez •Los Angeles County Agricultural Commission Weed and Brush Clearance Requirements •Action Items C-12 Trump Lot D Fire Buffer Zone Technical Issues January 14, 2019 Dr. David Gakenheimer, Board Member/CFO Kelvin Vanderlip, Board Member/Secretary Tract 16540 HOA Portuguese Bend Club C-13 Why is this meeting important? Remember the Woolsey Fire C-14 t~ 1J WATCH LIVE menu ic:JJ D SHARE CJ TWEET Bl SHARE 1::1 EMAIL -. . I By Ei leen Frere and ABC7.co m staff Tuesday , November 13 , 2018 CALABASAS , Calif. (KABC) --Alarming video shows home after home full y engulfed in flames b y the massiv e \i\Toolsey Fire in a Calabasas neighborhood. Mel anie Turquand on Monday 1:eturned vvith a neighbor to Parkmor Road, where her hus band Tyler s tay ed behind to b y t o s av e t heir place. He des c1ibed the apocalyptic scene as the Woolsey Fire roared t hrough h is street. "It ,,vas a bridge of flame from ov er t here to this house, and I was literally putting o u t fire on m y roof, m y gutters m plant s " Tyler s aid. "There w a s a fil'eman o ver here, shooting on that hous e then turning around and shooting on m y hou se and directing me where t o put out fire ." PBC houses on property line Lot D landscaping area Hiking & Biking Trails Lot D Trails and Landscape Area Adjacent to Tract 16540 PBC Tract 16540 (42 homes) Trump Golf Course Driving Range Scale: trials and bike path 50 to 100 ft from Tract 16540 property line. Homes within 10 ft of property line. C-15 -. I--~• -. -'f -, 'l j v--------:. ~✓•-,,(( ' I ' /' ---\ \--~-~ .. --:. . -:=~~ :1 --..,,-;:---~ j :==:::::za -- ~ -- ~-=--= -- ---4 - 'l TTIC 00D _FENCt • ~✓ { u15 ~ . ...,.,,._,.,.,,_,a.,,,_,, ,_-.....,,,,r-....._, ........ _,,_·,rr EIK£\ii ) 0 L //v ~~~~~,.___.., ) ~--./ . ( .... -· ., TRAI ~ ~ Lot D is in Cal Fire VHFHSZ C-16 ·1 ,•"' r••" \ .... ,. ! I , ....... __ .... Rancho Palos Verdes Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones in LRA As Recommended b CAL FIRE Unique updraft wind conditions along Lot D allow paragliders to takeoff from standstill –could drive fire storm towards and across Tract 16540 C-17 Good Intention but Wrong Design C-18 TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF CLUB L OT 'D' FIRE BUFF R ""JU1 l 11r.al l ~1 1 llru ....... , .. , ....... , ··~- •l•l ,H,I !'•l• •• • I :1~11:. ""',::, ·~ 111 t I.._ lrd11 ••It, 11, 1!'1fr>f.MI• 11-a I, Y• ,-N, I DA TE : 7 /20/18 DESIGNED BY: __ DRAWN BY: __ s_w_ CHECKED BY:~ SC AL E: 1' Ge SIDI.Lio" STE PHEN WOOD LANDSCAPE ARC HI TECT 4120 RO SE AV:E. LONG BEA CH ., CA 90807 RLA 6244 REVI SIONS J/18 Clti 5U8 Ml f1'AL PL L0.00 vm OOWt.tON MA I. IHU WA'JE~UH [.1.00 PL I\N"TT , PL1\N 1,1.01 PI .I\NTI G PI.I\N IIJIIH I.UPINB I OAL O :WI" 0,0, ._,II HYLOW 1.1.02 Pl .,\NTl c; D RTl\11.'i 1.2.00 IJ \RI Gl\"11ON PI_I\N Zone A: 20 ft from structure Plant “lean” Small herbaceous or succulent plants less than 2 to 3 ft tall Co-locate hardscape like large rocks Zone B: 20 to 100 ft from structure Planted slightly higher density than Zone A Hedging discouraged because it promotes dead wood inside Zone C: 100 to 200 ft from structure Avoid landscaping as dense as native vegetation Good rule follow guidelines for Zone B with slight increase in density Access road required 20 ft wide LAFD Fire Buffer Zones (aka Fuel Modification Zones) Requirements for New Construction & Subdivision Developments C-19 uel od Zone C A Clearance recommended up to 200 ft from neighboring structures Lot D C-20 CJ ·-·.··I...,·--..., . • ~ -. . . . ·t--~~ ~ ... ~ -.. ~ 1· ~ C' -;·,,,.......... .::~ ~• •'••' • :..~ .,. -,.::y,. ·-~~~~-~-._ ------ et M..-~ ..... 'I ...... __._,, ....... ~ • • . . .. _._.,... ......... - - - -Property Li ne County of Los Angeles Department of Agricultural Commissioner/Weights and Measures IMPORTANT! Clearance req uireme nts appl y to you r property even if the structu re being protected is no t on you r property I W eed and Brush CLEARANCE REQUIREMENTS IMPORTANT! Thin ning or re mo va l of vegetation an ad diti onal 70 to 130 feet (100 to 200 fe et total) from structu re s may be re qui re d I Please contact your Zone Inspector ! (626) 575 -5484 http ://acwm.laco un ty.gov Grass and other vegetation located more than 30 feet from structure s and les s th an 18 inches in he ight may be maintained where necessar/ to sta bil ize soi l and prevent erosion. (County Code sec . 325 .2.1 EXCEPTIO NS (3)) Space trees and shru bs a min im um of 15 feet or th ree ti mes th ei r diameter from other shru bs. T re es shou ld be spa ce d to all ow a minimum of 30 feet between ca no p ie s at ma turi ~/. For tre es tal ler tha n 18 feet , prun e lower bran che s with in 6 feet of the ground. For trees and shrubs le ss th an 18 fe et , pru n e lower branches to 113 of the ir he ight. Choose land sc aping plants th at are fire res ista nt an d ma in tain all pla nts re gul arly remov in g dead branches , leaves , etc. (Go lo http ://fi re .l acounty gov/FromChief asp and scro ll dawn lhe page and cli ck on the lin k on the left entitled 'Ready! Set! Go! Wildfire Action Plan~.) Okay to have orname ntal plants and trees if ind iv idua lly planted , spaced an d main ta in ed so th ey do not fo rm a means of trans mitting fire from native gro wth to th e structure. No po rtion of a tree may extend withi n 10 feet of the ouflet of a ch imney and it mu st b e fre e of de ad wood . (County Code sec . 325.2.1 EXCEPTIONS (1 )I Roadwa~, cl earance , min imum of 10 fe et d eara nce fo r all fiammable vegetation or ot her combustible growth (County Code sec 325 .10 ) Remove/c lear away all fi amma ble veg etat ion or combustib le growth for a distance of not less th an 30 fe et fro m any CL Co Depart CJO 0 Los ngeles a cu ra ~ e1g urns e d a nd Br s I PORT NT 1 Cl req uire ents ap I pro ert y e if stru ct ure bei n pr no 0 yo r rap aran ce ·o you r ct dis I s Planting pattern proposed for Lot D (Part 1) Densely planted up to property line Scale: Distance between Tract 16540 property line and walking/bike trails is 50 to 100 ft (all within LAFD Zones A and B and LA County Agriculture Commission weed and brush clearance area) C-21 EX I 1'1.1.MV LLL n, :wovra M6U. BCfllJI IK/IN /IND V.[ 05 Typical planting pattern proposed for Lot D (Part 2) Densely planted up to property line Scale: Distance between Tract 16540 property line and walking/bike trails is 50 to 100 ft (all within LAFD Zones A and B and LA County Agriculture Commission weed and brush clearance area) C-22 ::-/'' ' ---,, ' -----; _ ... r ----..,/ /~-:-- ING ?t~ ' -----· -- Proposed plants all on LAFD list of Fuel Modification Plants with one exception (Ash Buckwheat) C-23 Pl 1lJR!E sv · BOL E COMMON AME S,IIZE W TERUSE LUPI NUS LO GI RORUS BUS HI ILUP IINE 5 AL 3 ,Q.C. VERY LOW LUPINUS SUCCULENliUS A ROYO LUPI .· 5 ,GAL ER IOGONU . CINEREU '. I AS 1H BUCKWHEAT 5GAL 36 ,O.C. E NCEL I\A CALIFORNI CA BUSH SU F L OWER 5 GAL@ 418 O .C .. ILOW IMULUS ILO NGIFILORUS 'ONKEY !FLOWER Vl=iRY LOW' SISY I CH 1u · BEULU , -BlUE EYED GRASS , 5G L 48 ,o.C. lO □ I□ □I Details on proposed planting: 1.Within 10 ft or less of structures 2.3 to 4 ft plant spacing 3.Up to 5 ft plant height 4.Much more dense than LAFD & LA AgComBC recommendations Tract 16540 house Tract 16540 house C-24 Native habitat area adjacent/east of Lot D •Very dense •No pruning •Dried out in summer For Lot D •Plant density similar •Long term watering schedule unknown •Pruning plan unknown C-25 Summary of Technical Issues with Lot D Plans •Trump name of landscape plan “Fire Buffer Area” misleading –but good intention! •Plan DOES NOT follow LAFD guidelines for fire buffers (also known as fuel mod zones and defensible spaces) •Plan DOES NOT follow LA County Agriculture Commissioner Weed and Brush Clearance Requirements •Plan DOES use recommended fire resistant plants BUT DOES NOT employ plant spacing and height for fuel mod zones (A, B and C) as LAFD recommends for new construction/subdivisions NOR weed and brush clearance requirements required by LA County Agriculture Commission •Proposed plant densities are representative of a hedge which LAFD recommends against •Public trails along edge of golf course and Lot D present fire hazard from careless visitors (e.g., tossing cigarette butts, etc.). Trails are within 50 to 100 feet of homes. •Prevailing winds and occasional strong gusts could spread fire rapidly to our homes (Lot D is in Cal Fire Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone) [Note paragliders use cliffs adjacent to Lot D for take off.] •Area not readily accessible by fire trucks •A detailed Lot D plant watering schedule and plant maintenance plan (pruning and removing of dead wood) are not known. Other native plant areas of Trump Golf Course are not regularly watered or maintained and dry out during hot summers. •Lot D does not employ open spaces or hardscape (e.g., large rocks) that could reduce amount of fire fuel and inhibit fire spreading •Fire storm could impact up to 42 Tract 16540 PBC closely spaced homes (seven are on property line within 10 feet of proposed plantings with no other hardscape except varying types of low fencing made of stucco, wood and chain link) [Note: this is 100 million dollar liability] C-26 Alternatives to consider •Smaller patterns of herbaceous plants trimmed to 2 to 3 ft height •Fill in with patterns of succulent plants (cactus with thorns) •Add large rugged rock (boulder) gardens C-27 E-1TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF CLUB WATER CONSERVATION STATEMENT WATER CONSERVATION STATEMENT \ ' ' ,. ' .l I l 1 t11• ' . , ••• ,., t '•t "• I 11 -I , AUDIT SCHEDULE !.; _1.._..1,.,-::.... ,','.LU' .•.1,.• t ... I l. _ ' '• I .I • I' •• • o-~ -1! ·l PROJECT SITE: PROJECT LOCATION: LANDSCAPE J\RCHITECT/JRRJGATION DESIGNER: -~.;:: j WATER USE CALCULATIONS RYDROZONE AREA A I .. L ,:-~ t ... ' -" -_,--MAXIMUM APPLIED NATER ALLOWANCE (MANA) It ~ 1' I "I 'I I .. 0 • I l ~-~~ , r =r-~r r :-,, --.:-T-~ IT J ~•I. I;.~ I L' t:"t •r -.-• :r•fl rr---T n·~-J ---L--·Ll r L • •;, ESTIMATED TOTAL WATER OSE (ETWIJ) -n-~ -t~ 1-·-:1-l(i-1'1:.1~-.2· I•~~ l.•1£ l~--:.T, --of.::-fSF'I·-::-C:\:.J\,T"-:._l~.~-1!•;-··•: ,1•:.-:...::-· . F -J :.\J-F.;-T.~-;1_;_"" u::--·;: ):c: ;._:,,=_:.. «::.·:.:..:>E :-:c:-1 • (. -,:,:_IJ; ~ ~: L '! -:.: '-'"' 1=---·-:r-;:..-r:·i -:-:::-·,:·-:-.::, :-_:..1: !-:_ r_:._::....:: :r:,.:-,:::0: ::::-11 l -1 ► • _ ~ BYDROZONE 1 HYDROZONE 2 , ........ Tl . · , ... ,. ~ t 1,. I" ' LOT 'D' FIRE BUFFER AREA RANCHO PALOS VERDES PLANTING LEGEND SYMBOL BOTANICAL NAME COMMON NAME SIZE LUPINUS LONGIFLORUS BUSH LUPINE 5 GAL@ 36" O.C LUPINUS SUCCULENTUS ARROYO LUPINE 5 GAL @48" O.C ERIOGONUM CINEREUM ASH BlJCt<WHEAT 5 GAL @ 36" O.C ~ ENCELIA CAUFORNICA BUSH SUNFLOWER 5 GAL@48" OC MIMULUS LONGIFLORUS MONKEY FLOWER 5GAL@48"OC SISYRINCHIUM BELLUM BLUE EYED GRASS 5 GAL@.ffl"O C, l; , ) • )In \/. ,,!) C, · ?, -1 , , )'-:,, Lll"tt~ :.,s , I 11 f /\: ., ;,-1 ,· WATER USE VERY LOIN VERY LOW VERY LOW LOW VERY LOV-.' LOW SHEET INDEX LO.DO Ll.Oll L1 .01 Ll.02 L2.00 L2.01 L2.02 COVERSHEET PL\NTING PL\N PL\KTIKG PLAN PLr\l\:TIKG DETAILS IRRIGATION PL\N IRRIG,-\TION PL-\N IRRIGATION DETAILS KEY MAP SITE CD N< rn ( I SCALE *i'Joi vi :iu L:111;:;;ss ecc:..o,n1xmie::.J bv a completed Cleu.rance Forrri REVISl81\S Lf•I!:. ' ' . / ,--( :t<)Ved for I o u lu n [:'; .\sion Pbn L,h ~ I ,.:•~Jr.Jved f r i uilding r\H 1rnt ______ .......,_.__ TRL:MF f\J .:'I TOI\IAL G:J~;:-C ... US '...OT 'D' F RE BUFc""E~ £\REA. CO\E~ SC1EET LC.OC E-2~---------' ,, ' ' ' ' ' / r=' I ' -' ' ' ~EHEDE.AA.tFECIE'!:l VINES "~O Of!AOl"L.\J.JlW.ll:fll.U ll-lCSOVTH 10 ~SIOEOFT)IEC~~NUNJlf_a;tE 'Yfrtt1N IHE AACA lt«lte6TED Hi R'fC.Ef\'C N!::W >\.ANT MATli:'™1. Allt! IR_!t!GI-T _I_-_,_ EXISTING HIBISCUS ANO ALONG 6 FOOT Pl.ASTER WALL TO REMAIN PROTECT IN PLACE SHEAR TO BRING IN CLOSER TO WALL ON A REGULAR BASIS REMOVE CASTOR BEAN PLANTS WEEDS AND OTHER DEAD FOLIAGE APPROXIMATE LOCATtoN OF EXISTING CHAIN LINK FENCE .... LUPINUS SUCCULENTUS ARROYO LUPINE 5GAL@48"0C ERIOi[",;l)NU CIMi:RI"U I ASlfL£Afl BUCt:Wt-EAT ::GAL@ 36"0.C EXISTING BOUGAINVILLEA ALONG ,.. CHAIN LINK FENCE TO REMAIN PROTECT IN PLACE. SHEAR TO BRING IN CLOSER TO WALL ON A REGULAR BASIS '-8' WIDE BIKE PATH J WIDE PLANTING AREA 4' WIDE PEDESTRIAN PATH 5' WIOE PEDESTRIAN PATH ,,-~ PLANT BOTANICAl NAME () OfTAll--------...__ __t_?\ HEMEROCAI.LIS HVBRIO REFERENCE l ~ j OAYLILY SIZE & SPACING ~~✓ S GALAT 24" O.C. /,-PAGF --/ 20 REOUIR·E~D~TH~l~S~S-H=EE=T~~ NUMBER '-----QUANTITY PER SHEET PLANTING NOTES ,. 2. 3. 4. 8. 9. PLANT MATERIAL SYMBOLS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS ARE TYPICAL THROUGHOUT DRAWING SET. EACH SHEET CONTAINS A PLANT CALLOUT TO THE SPECIFIC PLANT SYMBOL. QUANTITIES GIVEN FOR PLANT MATERIALS SPECIFIED FOR "ON CENTER" SPACING ARE SHOWN FOR CONVENIENCE ONLY AND ARE SUBORDINATE TO THE SPACING GIVEN, CHECK ANO SUPPLY SUFFICIENT NUMBER OF PLANTS TO FULFILL SPACING REQUIREMENTS ALL PLANT MATERIAL TO BE INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS ANO CONSTRUCTION DETAILS. IN SOME CASES, PLANTING SYMBOLS MAY BE SHOWN IN AREAS WHERE ABOVE GRADE UTILITIES INTERFERE OR ALTER THE DESIRED SPACING AND/OR PATTERN, CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW AREAS WITH LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT PRIOR TO PLANTING MATERIAL. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT SHALL REVIEW ARRANGEMENT AND LAYOUT OF MATERIAL IN FIELD PRIOR TO PLANTING. TOPDRESS ALL AREA WITHIN THE LIMIT OF WORKLINE (EXCLUDING PATH)WITH A 3" LAYER OF j• -2" MATURE, COMPOSTED MULCH. SUBMIT SAMPLES FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL. REMOVE ALL WEED GROWTH AND DEAD PLANT MATERIAL FROM LOT 'D' AND DISPOSE OF OFF SITE. REMOVE SQUASH PLANTS, ALL HEDERA SPECIES (ENGLISH IVY). BOSTON IVY ANO CASTOR BEAN FROM LOT 'O' AND ALONG THE STACKED STONE RETAINING WALL. LANDSCAPING WITHIN ALL COMMON AREAS SHALL BE PLANTED IN SUCH A MANNER SO THAT VIEWS FROM ADJACENT PROPERTIES AND ANY PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY ARE NOT AFFECTED AND SO THAT SOLAR ACCESS TO ALL DWELLING UNITS IS PROTECTED, WHILE SOME EXISTING VEGETATION AROUND THE PERIMETER WILL BE RETAINED, NATIVE VEGETATION WILL BE PLANTED TO PROVIDE A CONTINUOUS PLANTING AREA WITH NO GAPS OR LARGE VOID AREAS WHEN GROWN IN •. E.UC.F-_1 IA-AUF(\~Nl(;A llUS11 SUNFLOWER ~GAL@~poc LJ.8.1017 _. J).QOOL ~'.YI'.-'.': ;::; F--1 .. \~ ~C~~~ -:tJ ·:·,iVi\J(J [),\/l ·;;~Ja-J ~P.LOS VL:, t~ :·· ,j ____ As Sub11iiL,.:.·..-. Co11d1c1ons 1 ro tcrHl!Or 1s 01, lr1 ·-; : • :1 um 1.I i8 Plc:1, 1ninr; Ui'· ·,Ji_ , urik,ss otherwise sµ0~1i1s;,ct c",ccr'1n1)&nied bv a completed Clearance Form ,j for su!rrit.t-1! to u1IJing on F-'18.n for i TRL.;~F I\JAT!JNAL GOLF CLUB LOT 'D' F,RE BLl""E~ ARE.LI. PLANTING PLAN u cc S 1[[0 __ 2 __ C.F E-3===:::J EXISTING BOUGAINVILLEA ALONG 5-fj' SLUMP STONE WALL TO REMAIN PROTECT IN PLACE SHEAR TO BRING IN -CLOSER TO WALL ON A REGULAR BASIS REMOVE BOSTON IVY LC::::1.:_: ,t_L Cr __ I 1--A,,<\,'!~ --: (: :: \' El' ISTitl:G f"L !.!!.400, BOUGAl~'"I~ -"To 1:1r ~Cl.toJr.D RE"l.!f'l\lli m (itHER EXISTING SINGLE PLUMBAGO ALONG 6' WOOD FENCE TO REMA.IN PROTECT IN PLACE THERE IS NO EXISTING ON GRADE PLANT MATERIAL THIS PORTION OF 6 WOOD FENCE. CLOUDS REPRESENT EXISTING TREE CANOPY GROWING SJ.\AU.SCAU!l.fi'LA lt;CLUOINOCASTEJ, BEAN AND WEEDS TO BE REMOVED EXISTING RHUS INTEGRIFOLIA TO REMAIN PROTECT IN PLACE SELECTIVELY PRUNE DOWN TO 60" MAINTAIN BELOW60" AT ALL TIMES ,/ ~ / /' / ✓-...JY'~e@! -LllP1~ .. tJ5~.11:::nuwnus ARROYO LUPINE FROM PRIVATE RESIDENCE SIDE OF~ FENCE '\.. 5 GAL @ 4a' o_c ERIOGONUM CINEREUM --ASHLEAF BUCKWHEAT 5GAL@ J6"0C 8' WIDE BIKE PATH :l' WIDE PLANTING AREA 4' WIDE PEDESTRIAN PATH -:~;~~, , .. t,. .. "'I' • (" ~Z' ~\ ;;,;;..::.J...-'.:11 ~ * t ,~1• ~ t1 t,i,.\\,"-< I II i '-I~~ 1~,_:':iL ~\L L-=:i\J.:~ EE >1 ~' ~_C,._; -:;: t ,~,2-+4 ~----EXISTING METROSIDEROS PART OF DRIVING RANGE EXISTING DRY STACK STONE WALL ALONG WEST SIDE OF DRIVING RANGE METROSIDEROS I TO REMAIN PART OF DRIVING RANGE I Ll•lt. RE•!ISIONS h.t:.1//d-cv: s,_,Gw,.-..'.IL ·,11RY1~-~: ~'-11.:",I: I \L ~~ l"'V T-.l,, / / ' / / / / -$0'?' / ~o<c / ,· / l<-o-+-/ ~q PROPOSED FUTURE IMPROVEMENTS ' It p I ir DETAIL --..-... HEMEROCl\l.LIS HYBRID REFERENCE ~ IJ:AYLll y =~--PLANT BOTANICAL NAME SIZE & SPACING ~ g;_~_l,,_Af i4• o=.c~. ___ _ PAGE---20 REQUIRED THIS SHEET QUANTITY PER SHEET NUMBER PLANTING NOTES 1. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7 8. 9. PLANT MATERIAL SYMBOLS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS ARE TYPICAL THROUGHOUT DRAWING SET. EACH SHEET CONTAINS A PLANT CALLOUT TO THE SPECIFIC PLANT SYMBOL QUANTITIES GIVEN FOR PLANT MATERIALS SPECIFIED FOR "ON CENTER" SPACING ARE SHOWN FOR CONVENIENCE ONLY AND ARE SUBORDINATE TO THE SPACING GIVEN. CHECK AND SUPPLY SUFFICIENT NUMBER OF PLANTS TO FULFILL SPACIN REQUIREMENTS ALL PLANT MATERIAL TO BE INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS MD CONSTRUCTION DETAILS, IN SOME CASES, PLANTING SYMBOLS MAY BE SHOWN IN AREAS WHERE ABOVE GRADE UTILITIES INTERFERE OR ALTER THE DESIRED SPACING AND/OR PATTERN, CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW AREAS WITH LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT PRIOR TO PLANTI G MATERIAL. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT SHALL REVIEW ARRANGEMENT AND LAYOUT OF MATERl/1 IN FIELD PRIOR TO PLANTING. TOPDRESS ALL AREA WITHIN THE LIMIT OF WORKLINE (EXCLUDING PATH) WITH A 3 LAYER OF j" • 2" MATURE, COMPOSTED MULCH. SUBMIT SAMPLES FOR REVIEW AN APPROVAL. REMOVE ALL WEED GROWTH AND DEAD PLANT MATERIAL FROM LOT 'D' AND DISPOSE OF OFF SITE. REMOVE SQUASH PLANTS, ALL HEDERA SPECIES (ENGLISH IVY), BOSTON IVY AND CASTOR BEAN FROM LOT 'D' AND ALONG THE STACKED STONE RETAINING WALL. LANDSCAPING WITHIN ALL COMMON AREAS SHALL BE PLANTED IN SUCH A MANNE SO THAT VIEWS FROM ADJACENT PROPERTIES AND ANY PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY A E NOT AFFECTED AND SO THAT SOLAR ACCESS TO ALL DWELLING UNITS IS PROTECTED. WHILE SOME EXISTING VEGETATION AROUND THE PERIMETER WILL BE RETAINED, NATIVE VEGETATION WILL BE PLANTED TO PROVIDE A CONTINUOUS PLANTING AR A WITH NO GAPS OR LARGE VOID AREAS WHEN GROWN IN .. SU.8.?-Df1 -O ODO GOLF CLUB BUFFE~ .ARC::.A TRUMF "-IAT!JNAL LOT 'O' FiRE L 1.C1 PLAI\JTING ~ l[[T __ 3 __ E-4~ " ~ r .. ,, .-' "a\""' . ::~ (\\1 ,-:.1 -i!'#-11-·• ri ... ~u REVISIOl\cS f--;lJ/,\~V~ G,•/1 t:L PLANTER BEDS TO BE 0 r BELOW WALK FINISH SURFACE EO ''• • • • ro. • • • / PLANT LOCATIONS • • • • •-PS O.C. DIMENSION l DISTANCE THE SAME --------------~-PAVING BUILDING WALL CURBING __/ OR OTHER AREA lllr.41TS NOTE: SEE PLANTING PLANS FOR ON-CENTER SPACING DISTANCE GROUNDCOVER SPACING DETAIL 1----------':'-'g"-~'-=~=-~-L-E__, 3 18'-1 ·::0•1'.o, ~·,Jnu:1 .J,·1s of 1-,p;.JrC\!-i · ' ,-,-. \ . ' , . , ·-•.,..i'V ~)ul,it1:1 __ 1 c,n r rL~t) 0~1l1l._ urnee,;s olherwise Sf.iec:,1-.oc ,J ur:iass accornµaniccl l1y r! completed Clearance Form f'·:oroved for Dhiision Pl2;n /\}proved for Perrnit a .,j issue.nee 0 g 1 il2TIMESWIDTH 0, R-i'.JCl'TeAU 0 0 0 ROOTBALL PLANT FERTILIZER TABLETS SEE SPECIFICATIONS BACKFILL MIX: 2i3 SITE SOIL 1/J ORGANIC AMENDMENTS SEE SPECIFICATIONS WATERING BASIN FINISH GRADE SITE SOIL NOTE: KEEP TOP OF ROOTBALL ANO TOP OF FINISH GRADE AT SAME LEVEL SHRUB PLANTING DETAIL SCALE , = 1' • ON CENTER 9!',-t.JU(: H[ fl\.ANTitJO PLJ\N ' ' ....,::;;;,.:;;;,.,~,-. __ ;7 / -;/ , ~ i' -----'T I /40, I.e. -/ f ,, , ·b: ·. /. -,.---(i • -.,,-.., ,#_ ._,U/,(, .;;.-:,,_: ~ ,,__.. I . ll>Tll.lES\"ld OF ROOTBALL 8 ROOTBALL CD FINISH GRADE 0 BACKFILL MIX (CONTINUOUS BElWEEN ® SITE SOIL ROOTBALLS) 2/J SITE SOIL 1/3 ORGANIC AMENDMENT 0 WATERING BASIN 8 PLANT FERTILIZER TABLETS SEE SPECIFICATIONS NOTE: KEEP TOP OF ROOTBALL AT FINISH GRADE OR 112" ABOVE SHRUB MASS PLANTING DETAIL SCALE ,. = 1·-D' 1 2 TRUMF NATiONAL GOLF C __ UB c.OT 'O' FIRE BLJeTE~ .ARE.A ~1.02 FL.~NTl~G CETAILS 1[[T __ 4 __ E-5/ L 1:..:::1e:: \l:..l t: , \\ t -I I I--A .• ~,.j, ~ \ =--::1 -iiMJ-:1~ • ,.~11 -r ,., ,. l,, "' ·l ~l Xref I:\ TruMo\New fololer\0000 PROJECT F□LDER\Bo.se\col-irrioo.tion bo.se DRIP.olwo () APPROX. LIMIT OF WORK PROPER1Y LINE _ ~~~~~a~~~t~--~r.~ --_o~ __:,.__; /-.. • • ..---"-----,..~----''-'---'----'-----'-'"---'. • ,II \ I \ '■ • • • IRRIGATION NOTES 1 INSTALL ALL PRESSURE ANO NON-PRESSURE LINES AND ANY EQUIPMENT INSIDE PLANTING AREAS WHEREVER POSSIBLE (ITEMS SHOWN OUTSIDE SUCH AREAS FOR PURPOSE OF CLARITY ONLY) 2, ALL EQUIPMENT SHALL BE SELECTED AND INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS AND CONSTRUCTION DETAILS SEE SHEET NO. l2.02 3 FOR SYMBOL DESIGNATIONS SEE LEGEND ON SHEET NO L2,01 4 ALL PIPE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN A SCH, 40 SLEEVE TWICE THE DIAMETER OF THE PIPE CARRIED All WIRE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN SCH 40 SLEEVE THE SIZE REQUIRED TO EASILY PULL WIRE THROUGH ALL SLEEVES TO BE INSTALLED WITH A MINIMUM DEPTH AS SHOWN ON THE SLEEVING DETAIL SLEEVES TO EXTENO AT LEAST 12" PAST THE EDGE OF PAVING, 5 ALL SPRAY HEADS ARE TO BE INSTALLED WITH THE NOULE SCREEN AND ARCS SHOWN ON THE PLANS ALL HEADS ARE TO BE ADJUSTED TO PREVENT OVERSPRAY ONTO BUILDING WALLS FENCES ANO HARDSCAPE THIS INCLUDES BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO ADJUSTMENT OF DIFFUSER PIN OR ADJUSTMENT SCREVV, REPLACEMENT OF PRESSURE COMPENSATING SCREENS, REPLACEMENT OF NOULES WITH MORE APPROPRIATE RADIUS UNITS ANO THE REPLACEMENT OF NOZZLES WITH ADJUSTABLE ARC UNITS 6 AREAS THAT NEED TO BE DEFINED IN ORDER TO DETERMINE EXACT LOCATION OF SPRINKLER HEADS ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR TO SEE THAT THEY ARE DEFINED PRIOR TO INSTALLATION 7 AS-BUILT DRAWINGS AND SPECIFICATIONS SHALL BE MAINTAINED ON SITE AT ALL TIMES As-BUILT DRAWINGS SHALL BE UPDATED IMMEDIATELY AS REQUIRED NO SITE REVIEWS ARE TO BE CONDUCTED WITHOUT THESE DRAWINGS 6 AREAS RECEIVING AN IRRIGATION SYSTEM SHALL DE REVIEWED AND VERIFIED BY THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR FOR ACCURACY OF SIZE AND CONFIGURATION IF DISCREPANCIES ARE FOUND THAT WOULD PROVE DETRIMENTAL TO FINAL COVERAGE THIS SHALL BE BROUGHT TO THE OWNER'S ATTENTION BEFORE INSTALlATION BY FAILING TO DO SO THE CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY ADJUSTMENTS REQUIRED 9 IRRIGATION CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW PROJECT LIMIT OF WORK PRIOR TO START OF CONSTRUCTION IN THE EVENT THAT ANY OVERLAP OCCURS IE EQUIPMENT FROM AN EXISTING IRRIGATION SYSTEM DESIGNATED TO REMAIN CROSSES OVER INTO AN AREA OF NEW IRRIGATION; CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CLJTTING ANO CAPPING EXISTING SYSTEM AS REQUIRED. FURTHERMORE, CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR RELOCATING OR REPAIRING ANY EQUIPMENT THAT WOULD BE DISPLACED BY THE NEW CONSTRUCTION THAT IS REQUIRED TO KEEP EXISTING IRRIGATION OUTSIDE THE LIMIT OF WORK IN OPERATION PIPE SIZING NOTES SIZING CHART 1 2 3 4 REFER TO IRRIGATION HEAD LEGEND ON SHEET L2 01 FOR GPM OF HEADS CONTRACTOR TO DETERMINE PIPE SIZING WHERE SYMBOLS ARE NOT SHOWN SEE ADJACENT SIZING CHART ALL LATERAL LINE PIPE DOWNSTREAM OF A 314" SIZED PIPE IS ALSO 314" ALL UNSIZED RUNS OF LATERAL LINE PIPE SERVING THREE OR FEWER SPRAY HEADS SHALL BE SIZED 3/4" PVC SYMBOL GPM 3'4" --,--'---:,,i 0-8 1' ~ 8-13 1114" "• 13-23 1112· 23-32 ,~~ ,. ~ 32-53 2 1/2" ~-SJ-74 3' ----e:::-= 7-4-116 :-:,J .. ' r~·\," "hc.....U::.3 \: ,,-__ .. ' ) ______ t,;;; suuin,._, ------=----~-.,JJ)I? , ,ir s.ltr;rations on ,. ' ·-; I I .n 11 rr ,,D ~,;Ur i8 , frcw·1 t:,o ~•ic.-u 1ni,i 1 1 ilS ()~ ,~,pp! JVC~! u, ,;ess accornpanied by a curnpleted Cl83rance Form ,;s, unl0ss otherwise Sf)l,u, 1 !·oved for subn iittal to Bui I L _,,· .. ,~-,0·,·1 F'l·-1r·1 Ch0°K' -! \ I~. '-'· I .vv -----------h:::J: oved for 1ssucJ ice of Building ~'drn1t GOl_r=-cu~ BU~TER !:\RE A nuv'F ~.AT,ONAL lOT 'o' F:RE IRRIGA ~ION PLAf~ L2.0C 5 E-6• I / c: F= l CONSTRUCTION NOTES 0 POINT OF CONNECTION TO EXISTING 4" IRRIGATION METER. VERIFY LOCATION IN FIELD. ADD A 2" FEBCO B25YA BACK FLOW TO MAINLINE AND TEE OFF FOR IRRIGATION WATER TO LOT D. CONTRACTOR TO LOCATE WITHIN ADJACENT PLANTED AREAS WHERE POSSIBLE ADD NORMALLY CLOSED MASTER VALVE AND CONNECT TO NEW CONTROLLER 0 CONNECT NEW VALVES TO NEW SOLAR CONTROLLER, 0 CONTRACTOR TO LAYOUT ALL PLANT MATERIAL IN TliE AREAS SHOWN AND AT THE SPACING SHOWN. THEN LAYOUT THE IRRIGATION ZONES. PVC LATERALS AND DRIP EMITTERS IN THE AREAS SHOWN 0 LOCATION OF MAINLINE AND VALVES ARE SHOWN DIAGRAMMATICALLY FOR CLARITY. INSTALL ALONG WEST SIDE OF PEDESTRIAN PATH FOR EASE OF ACCESS . r ,.,--..,.-t~~;...-_.... .,("'::_ ~ ... r--,..,;..._,,vr, -·::--Er,-;:•·~ 1 : /.-'o !1 ... , ,:,,;.. .!" PIPE SIZING NOTES 1 REFER TO IRRIGATION HEAD LEGEND ON SHEET L2 01 FOR GPM OF HEADS 2 CONTRACTOR TO DETERMINE PIPE SIZING WHERE SYMBOLS ARE NOT SHOWN SEE ADJACENT SIZING CHART J All LATERAL LINE PIPE DOWNSTREAM OF A 314" SIZED PIPE IS ALSO 31-4• -4 ALL UNSIZED RUNS OF LATERAL LINE PIPE SERVING THREE OR FEWER SPRAY HEADS SHALL BE SIZED J/4" ./ SIZING CHART PVC SYMBOL J/4" 1" 111.;-11/2" 2" 2 1/2" 3" ., .. .u,,• ---1~1 -• GPIA 0-<l 8-13 13--23 23-32 32-53 53-7-4 74-116 ' SYMBOL ------------@E -@ ct ~ ~ IRRIGATION NOTES 1 INSTALL All PRESSURE AND NON-PRESSURE LINES AND ANY EQUIPMENT INSIDE PLANTING AREAS WHEREVER POSSIBLE. !ITEMS SHOWN OUTSIDE SUCH AREAS FOR PURPOSE OF CLARITY ONLY) 2 ALL EQUIPMENT SHALL BE SELECTED AND INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS AND CONSTRUCTION DETAILS. SEE SHEET NO_ L2.02 3 FOR SYMBOL DESIGNATIONS SEE LEGEND ON SHEET NO L2 01 4 All PIPE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN A SCH 40 SLEEVE TWICE THE DIAMETER OF THE PIPE CARRIED All WIRE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN SCH 40 SLEEVE THE SIZE REQUIRED TO EASILY PULL WIRE THROUGH ALL SLEEVES TO BE INSTALLED WITH A MINIMUM DEPTH AS SHOWN ON THE SLEEVING DETAIL SLEEVES TO EXTEND AT LEAST 12· PAST THE EDGE OF PAVING 5 ALL SPRAY HEADS ARE TO BE INSTALLED WITH THE NOZZLE, SCREEN AND ARCS SHOWN ON THE PLANS ALL HEADS ARE TO BE ADJUSTED TO PREVENT OVERSPRAY ONTO BUILDING WALLS FENCES AND HARDSCAPE THIS INCLUDES BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO ADJUSTMENT OF DIFFUSER PIN OR ADJUSTMENT SCREW REPLACEMENT OF PRESSURE COMPENSATING SCREENS REPLACEMENT OF NOZZLES WITH MORE APPROPRIATE RADIUS UNITS ANO THE REPLACEMENT OF NOULES WITH ADJUSTABLE ARC UNITS 6 AREAS THAT NEED TO BE DEFINED IN ORDER TO DETERMINE EXACT LOCATION OF SPRINKLER HEADS ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR TO SEE THAT THEY ARE DEFINED PRIOR TO INSTALLATION 7 AS-BUILT DRAWINGS AND SPECIFICATIONS SHALL BE MAINTAINED ON SITE AT ALL TIMES. AS-BUILT DRAWINGS SHALL BE UPDATED IMMEDIATELY AS REQUIRED NO SITE REVIEWS ARE TO BE CONDUCTED WITHOUT THESE DRAWINGS 8 AREAS RECEIVING AN IRRIGATION SYSTEM SHALL BE REVIEWED AND VERIFIED BY THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR FOR ACCURACY OF SIZE AND CONFIGURATION. IF DISCREPANCIES ARE FOUND THAT WOULD PROVE DETRIMENTAL TO FINAL COVERAGE THIS SHALL BE BROUGHT TO THE OWNER'S ATTENTION BEFORE INSTALLATION BY FAILING TO DO SO, THE CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY ADJUSTMENTS REQUIRED 9 IRRIGATION CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW PROJECT LIMIT OF WORK PRIOR TO START OF CONSTRUCTION IN THE EVENT THAT ANY OVERLAP OCCURS, IE, EQUIPMENT FROM AN EXISTING IRRIGATION SYSTEM DESIGNATED TO REMAIN CROSSES OVER INTO AN AREA OF NEW IRRIGATION: CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CUTTING AND CAPPING EXISTING SYSTEM AS REQUIRED. FURTHERMORE CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR RELOCATING OR REPAIRING ANY EQUIPMENT THAT WOULD BE DISPLACED BY THE NEW CONSTRUCTION THAT IS REQUIRED TO KEEP EXISTING IRRIGATION OUTSIDE THE LIMITOF WORK IN OPERATION GENERAL LEGEND DESCRIPTION MANOFAC1URER & PARl NUM.BER REFERENCE PRESSURE SUPPLY LINES & SIZE SCHEDULE 40 P.V.C SPECIFICATIONS (1 112" AND SMALLER) PRESSURE SUPPLY LINES & SIZE CLASS 315 PVC SPECIFICATIONS (2" AND LARGER) NON-PRESSURE LATERAL LINE & SIZE SCHEDULE -40 PVC SPECIFICATIONS SLEEVE & SIZE (2" AND LARGER) CL.ASS 200 P .V C, DET 2 SHT_ L2.02 1-CONTROLLER SEQUENCE -GALLONS PER MINUTE (GPM) -REMOTE CONTROL VALVE SIZE REMOTE CONTROL VALVE (1" 1 r~· & 2·J RAINBIRD PEB SERIES DRIP ASSEMBLY VALVE DET 1 SHT L2 02 QUICK COUPLING VALVE RAINBIRD 33 DRC DET 6 SHT. L2 02 BALL VALVES/GATE VALVES (LINE SIZE) HAMMOND 8901 BRASS SERIES DET 5, SHT L2 02 NORMALLY CLOSED MASTER VALVE 2· GRISWOLD OR EQUAL (RAIN BIRD) DRIP EMITTER LEGEND DESCRIPTION PSI GPH MFG. BODY REMARKS DETAIL ~X-~_2_0_~_-1_0_32_R_E_D_2_0_G_P_H_(_Y_~_~_J~1-~_00~--1~R_A_IN_B_IR_D~-F-LE_X_R_IS_E_R_~s-H_R_u_as __ ~_DIT_6_S_HT_~_o_2_SU.~J?-o o~, E-70 0 0 0 0 0 0 AMBIENT LIGHT POWERED CONTROLLER TERMINAL STRIP 12 OR 14 GUAGE WIRE PROGRAMMING KEY 35" STEEL MOUNTING COLUMN FINISH GRADE ---0 CD POURED CONCRETE BASE/FOOTING 1-112 CU.FT DIRECT BURIAL CONTROL WIRES TO SPLICE BOX (2) DRY SPLICE CONNECTORS. IRRIGATION JUNCTION BOX 0 ~~~~g:iit~~~:t fe~ER 8 FINISH G~ADE ',) PVC MALE ADA0TOR 8 BALLVALVE l .. i') J/4-PEA Gf..AVEL (MIN 5· DEPTH) :" i..2,) PVC SUPPLY Llt.:E NOTE~: 1 BALL V>.LVE SHALL BE INSTALLED IN SH~UB AREAS UNLESS OTHERWISE APPROVED 2 SET VALVE BOX FLUSH WITH FINISH GRADE II\ TURF AREAS SET 2" ABOVE FINISH GRADE II\ GROUNDCOVER AREAS LEIT SOLOR CONTROLLER 7 BALL VALVE ASSEMBLY SCALE 5 * SPACING PER PLANTING PLAN ~v;__ . C'\"' I . ,7 '1 y .6 I( ) I --_,_ _,' --,,,.-0~ I . ~~ I il+--',1--....... -:---~; -G) EDGE OF HAROSCAPE/ PLANTER BOUNDARY @ PLANT ROOTIW.I. (CAN SIZE) @ © PLANT GROWIH O APROX. J YEARS J/4" SCHEDUL£ 40 PVC lATERAI. LINE CLOSED LOOP: NIN. PRESSURE EACH VN..VE IS 15 PSI, SIZE PER PLAN @ ~B~ttENOTE CONTROL DRIP VN..VE @ RAINBlflD 12• POLYFL.£X RlSER er;°~ ft:_!'~J J~:-FRA} EMITI!R ASSEl,IBLY (X8-20PC-10J2) 0 MAINLINE: SIZE PER PlAN ® ® FACE OF BUILDING OR OTHER S'TRUCTIJRE (~. __.J , ~K j __JR ~ ~-_ __, --------i~---~L@ @ 0 I POINT SOURCE DRIP EMITTERS SCALE ,/. REVISIO"-:S 6 l·d:.1/,\f.<V: L·t_:::1i'~ \t.T t: · ; h,,,, I C ( ., \' _ _ l~'~'':,L.. /-\ L __ ,~r-, -, EE· -t-i ;:_ :_ ,~,L44 . ' ... 11·11 ,.. 0 ROUND PLASTIC BOX & COVER WI LOCK TOP MARKED: 0 C 0 QUICK COUPLER VALVE LOCATE TOP OF VALVE 2· BELOW TOP OF BOX COVER 0 FINISH GRADE 0 J'4" PEA GRAVEL (MIN 6" DEPTH) 0 PVC SUPPLY LINE 0 24" MIN LENGTH NO 4 REBAR ATTACH W.' 2 STAINLESS STEEL BANDS 0 e..~S."l~Hf.U 0 BRASS NIPPLE (6" MIN l 0 PVC SCH 40 TEE OR ELL ir---~~-(i -,-J __,____,. -~11-----.o~NO:• @ BRASS NIPPLE LENGTH AS REQUIRED 1 SET VALVE BOX FLUSH WITH FINISH GRADE !.i,>------7:J G: 0 :~ ~¼~u~~~~~E~E~2~:ovE FINISH GRADE QUICK COUPLER VALVE t--S....,,CA.,....LE_, ([) PLANT (PER CAN SIZE) © FINISH GRADE 3 @ ~,iiw_ ~L: ~ LOOP: MIN. PRESSURE E'ACH VN...VE. IS 15 PSI © THREADED TEE ®-® ® 0 I l f~I~~ ~f EXPANSION LOOP fSR!~~d1~· ~'WEJ.sw&>s~~~RE FINISH GRADE COMMON WIRE CONTROL WIRE 0 @ ® @ I I I © j l ® J/4" PRESSURE REGULATING V/ll.VE PVC MAINLINE 3/4" PEA GRAVEL (MIN, 6" DEPTH) 1" X 3/4" SCH 40 RED BUSHING TxT (jJ) 5\fi~}lJE~&TEJ8~0L @ 3/4" DISC FILTER REMOTE CONTROL DRIP VALVE 0 SLEEVING SEE SPECIFICATIONS --0 -, 1 ® ® R>lNBIRD XERl BUG EMITTER ASSENB~ 0 0 0 0 © CONTROL WIRES Lim:-ir~J~2l» EMITTER IS 15 PSI. 0 BACKFILL MIX PER SPECIFICI.TIONS ® ffi * OISTANCE VNIIES BY CAN SIZE PLACE lATERN.. LINE AT EDGE OF CAN LOCATION, PARAU..El. W/ PLANTING lAYOUT DRIP EMITTERS SCALE NTS 0 PRESSURE SUPPLY LINE NON-PRESSURE SUPPLY LINE CONCRETE/AC. PAVING COMPACTED SUBGRADE CLEAN COMPACTED BACKFILL SEE SPECIFICATIONS. ~ UB..:W/7--' DD{X)} ~--+""'""4"""':L-_J --tt+::.,) I 10 ;~ l\L r ~ v'ili1 vUilUiL!O,:S ____ ,:,, ::> ~miLtcx.i /-/£ -,.,)./J/1 <-~ i:"' IOI' {)I r I om the Plannin Div,•, ,Jr' "; •r n~n rjc1v 2 ,-g,.LMFoN mon ,, .. is fl:_ t1 ·n lJRe ~JffER AREA <3:1 L2.C2 ·.';~, )rovE$~ ffQO ·" :q~:n<te [9 ®g ~ i[[T __ " v rn it 1*$563&4&,7<68%0,77$/,62&20$0(1=,(6,,&2$67$/*2/'(1%86+/27866&23$5,86'((5:(('%$&&+$5,63,/8/$5,6 3,*(2132,17 &2<27(%86+E-8LOT 'D' FIRE BUFFER AREA WATER CONSERVATION STATEMENT WATER CONSERVATION STATEMENT The Landscape and irrigation system for Trump National Golf Course 1 Acre Preservation Area has been designed with significant emphasis on water conservation. Plant species have been selected to adhere to a low water/drought tolerant palette consistent with a native plant community. The irrigation system is fully automatic and connected to an existing mainline and controller. Planting areas are designed to minimize overwatering, or other similar conditions where water flows onto adjacent areas not part of the irrigated area, such as adjacent property, walks, roadways, or structures. The irrigation system has been divided into hydrozones, so that plants with similar water requirements have been valved together. AUDIT SCHEDULE An Irrigation Audit for this project shall occur every five years. Audit to be performed by State of California Certified Water Auditor To be hired by the property owner. PROJECT SITE: Trump National Golf Course LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT/IRRIGATION DESIGNER: Stephen Wood Landscape Architect, RLA 6244 4120 Rose Ave. Long Beach, Ca 90807 (310)387-6729 PROJECT LOCATION: County of Los Angeles,California WATER USE CALCULATIONS HYDROZONE AREA A HYDRO ZONE HYDROZONE 1 HYDROZONE 2 HA 5,422 SQ. FT. 30,952 SQ. FT. IRRIGATION VALVES A-3, A-7 PLANT TYPE SHRUBS SHRUBS PLANT FACTOR 0.3 A-1, A-2, A-4-6, A-8 ITOTAL LANDSCAPE AREA: 30,952 SQ. FT. MAXIMUM APPLIED WATER ALLOWANCE (MAWA) MAWA ~ (ETo) (0.8) (LA) (0.62) MAWA ~ MAXIMUM APPLIED WATER ALLOWANCE (GALLON PER YEAR) ETo ~ REFERENCE EVAPOTRANSPIRATION (INCHES PER YEAR) 0.8 ~ ET ADJUSTMENT FACTOR LA= LANDSCAPE AREA (SQUARE FEET) 0.62 ~ CONVERSION FACTOR (TO GALLONS PER SQUARE FEET) MAWA 146.30) (0.8) (30,952) (0.62) IMAwA 710,807 GALLONS/ YEAR ESTIMATED TOTAL WATER USE (ETWU) ETWU (HYDROZONE) ~ [ (ETo) (PF) (HA) (D. 62)] /IE ETWU ~ ESTIMATED TOTAL WATER USE (GALLONS PER YEAR) ETo ~ REFERENCE EVAPOTRANSPIRATION (INCHES PER YEAR) PF~ PLANT FACTOR HA~ HYDROZONE AREA (SQUARE FEET) 0.62 ~ CONVERSION FACTOR IE~ IRRIGATION EFFICIENCY RANCHO PALOS VERDES ETo ~ 46.30 LANDSCAPE AREA~ 30,952 SQ. FT. HYDROZONE 1 ETWU ~ [(46.30) (0.3) (5,422) (0.62)]/0.85 ETWU ~ 54,933 GALLONS PER YEAR HYDROZONE 2 ETWU ~ [(46.30) (0.2) (25,530) (0.62)]/0.85 ETWU = 172,439 GALLONS PER YEAR ESTIMATED TOTAL WATER USE 227,372 GALLONS/YEAR DA TE -~/_/ __ DESIGNED BY: __ _ DRAWN BY: SW CHECKED BY: SW SCALE: 1" = 20' -0" 0.2 05-05-RENEWAL DATE 07-20-18 DATE RANCHO PALOS VERDES STEPHEN WOOD LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 4120 ROSE AVE. LONG BEACH, CA 90807 RLA 6244 NO. BY 2 3 4 5 6 REVISIONS DATE REMARKS 7 /23/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/02/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/12/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/21 /18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/25/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 9/03/18 CITY SUBMITTAL PLANTING LEGEND SYMBOL BOTANICAL NAME COMMON NAME ENCELIA CALIFORNICA BUSH SUNFLOWER MIMULUS LONGIFLORUS MONKEY FLOWER SISYRINCHIUM BELLUM BLUE EYED GRASS DD□ SIZE WATER USE GAL@ 36" O.C. VERY LOW GAL @ 48" O.C. VERY LOW GAL@ 36"" O.C. VERY LOW GAL @ 48" O.C. LOW GAL @ 48" O.C. VERY LOW GAL @ 48" O.C. LOW SHEET INDEX L0.00 COVERSHEET Ll.00 PLANTING PLAN Ll.01 PLANTING PLAN Ll.02 PLANTING DETAILS L2.00 IRRIGATION PLAN L2.01 IRRIGATION PLAN L2.02 IRRIGATION DETAILS I<EYMAP SITE CD NOTTO SCALE TRUMP LOT NATIONAL GOLF 'D' FIRE BUFFER TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF CLUB CLUB AREA COVER SHEET DRAWING L0.00 SHEET __ 1 __ OF 7 /27866&23$5,86'((5:(('%$&&+$5,63,/8/$5,6 3,*(2132,17 &2<27(%586+,62&20$0(1=,(6,,*2/'(1%86+$&,7<68%0,77$/E-9/ / / / / / ' ' ' < > / \ ' , ' ' ' ' \. ' \. ' ' z ' ' ' ' / / ' ' ' > / ' ' ' ' ' ' / / / / /_ / / ---A / --; ' / -;_ V ---, /---.._ - - - - - - - - -.i .,.... ____ --' -_., ---------· ---·-------· --' ---· -XISTINGV TAIION-0N'IHESQ!!Ili---· ----. --· -SI i'\REA !!,IDICAf'EO'"FOR NE -' ----~ ~PLArwi,JG-IS IU k1:~RGTECT"'~ -· -----· ,-----_,,__ ' . . -. -· RE1ii10VE HEDERl\"SP'ECIES V111158-,!,ND ~--. -. . ---8EA[Jf'LAfilJ,,1ME4THESO D . ' . --· --.NORIH SiLJE Of ..J:WE-eHA UN_KEENCE IN . ' _.....- . -. . ~ AREA INDl91]"ED--fe-RECEIVE. N _ . -MALeRb'IL' 11ND1~0r.-:--_ -· . ------. ' -----· ------· --------' . --. --. --. --_;..._ -----· -· ' -.--------· _ _, -¥! ---' --------------~ -----. --. . ----t""._/ '-----· ---. --. --_....,..--'. --------. --. -----------''---. --. --. -----·--' -~---------· -· _ __, '.-· --------· ''---. -----. _ _,, ~-· ----· ~-. -~·J---,--J ~,,.,,__-~ --'r ~'.J....------' ... -11-;;;;:;c-:::..,.,--x ,·_ ,.,.r-i_,,-\, ' I < 7 /20/18 DATE \. ~ :\~?~EN Hfio '11' '<., s Z) C1 Lie. No. DESIGNED BY: 6244 0 10 20 40 80 l~I SW DRAWN BY: I 05-05-19 RENEWAL DATE CHECKED BY: SW 07-20-18 DATE SCALE: 1 " 20'-o" SCALE: 1" = 20' -0" EXISTING HIBISCUS AND ALONG 6 FOOT PLASTER WALL TO REMAIN. PROTECT IN PLACE. SHEAR TO BRING IN CLOSER TO WALL ON A REGULAR BASIS\ REMOVE CASTOR BEAN PLANTS, WEEDS AND OTHER DEAD FOLIAGE @36"0:e. APPROXIMATE LOCATION OF EXISTING CHAIN LINK FENCE STEPHEN WOOD LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 4120 ROSE AVE. LONG BEACH, CA 90807 RLA 6244 GAL @ 48" O.C. \ ---1.', ,, _I_,_ --. . . \(--/~> <> \'1 2!__ --\ I --' EXISTING VEGETATION PROTECT IN PLACE NO. BY 2 3 4 5 6 -DATE 7 /23/18 8/02/18 8/12/18 8/21 /18 8/25/18 9/03/18 s ,... REVISIONS REMARKS CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL I I I \ \\ \ \ \~ "' GAL @ 36" O.C. I I f I \ \ \ \ ,I \ \ \ \ \ \ \ ' APPROX. LIMIT OF WORK I L \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ EXISTING BOUGAINVILLEA ALONG 4' CHAIN LINK FENCE TO REMAIN. PROTECT IN PLACE. SHEAR TO BRING IN CLOSER TO WALL ON A REGULAR BASIS EXISTING BOUGAINVILLE AND, VITUS VINES ALONG 6' CHAIN LINK FENCE TO REMAIN. PROTECT IN PLACE. SHEAR TO BRING IN CLOSER TO WALL ON A REGULAR BASIS 8' WIDE BIKE PATH 3' WIDE PLANTING AREA 4'WIDE PEDESTRIAN PATH 5' WIDE PEDESTRIAN PATH I { ' . l., ( ;-. / () ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ --■ ■ ■ DETAIL--REFERENCE ~ PAGE--~ NUMBER _....,,-PLANT BOTANICAL NAME W HEMEROCALLIS HYBRID / ~ DAYLILY _....,,-SIZE & SPACING ~5~G~A=L~-A~T~2~4~"~O~.C~-~---~/ _20_R_EQ_U_IR_E_D_T_H_IS_S_H_E_ET _____ QUANTTTYPERSHEET PLANTING NOTES 1. PLANT MATERIAL SYMBOLS SHOWN ON THESE PLANS ARE TYPICAL THROUGHOUT DRAWING SET. EACH SHEET CONTAINS A PLANT CALLOUT TO THE SPECIFIC PLANT SYMBOL. 2. QUANTITIES GIVEN FOR PLANT MATERIALS SPECIFIED FOR "ON CENTER" SPACING ARE SHOWN FOR CONVENIENCE ONLY AND ARE SUBORDINATE TO THE SPACING GIVEN. CHECK AND SUPPLY SUFFICIENT NUMBER OF PLANTS TO FULFILL SPACING REQUIREMENTS. 3. ALL PLANT MATERIAL TO BE INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS AND CONSTRUCTION DETAILS. 4. 7. IN SOME CASES, PLANTING SYMBOLS MAY BE SHOWN IN AREAS WHERE ABOVE GRADE UTILITIES INTERFERE OR ALTER THE DESIRED SPACING AND/OR PATTERN. CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW AREAS WITH LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT PRIOR TO PLANTING MATERIAL. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT SHALL REVIEW ARRANGEMENT AND LAYOUT OF MATERIAL IN FIELD PRIOR TO PLANTING. TOPDRESS ALL AREA WITHIN THE LIMIT OF WORKLINE (EXCLUDING PATH) WITH A 3" LAYER OF~" -2" MATURE, COMPOSTED MULCH. SUBMIT SAMPLES FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL. REMOVE ALL WEED GROWTH AND DEAD PLANT MATERIAL FROM LOT 'D' AND DISPOSE OF OFF SITE. REMOVE SQUASH PLANTS, ALL HEDERA SPECIES (ENGLISH IW), BOSTON IW AND CASTOR BEAN FROM LOT 'D' AND ALONG THE STACKED STONE RETAINING WALL. ■ 8. -----■ --■ LANDSCAPING WITHIN ALL COMMON AREAS SHALL BE PLANTED IN SUCH A MANNER SO THAT VIEWS FROM ADJACENT PROPERTIES AND ANY PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY ARE NOT AFFECTED AND SO THAT SOLAR ACCESS TO ALL DWELLING UNITS IS PROTECTED. I \ \ I I I ■ ■ ■ 9. ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■;; ■...: ■ -' ■ ti:i -~ ■(/) -~ ■ -' ■:i::: -~ ■ <( ■:::!? ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ l) WHILE SOME EXISTING VEGETATION AROUND THE PERIMETER WILL BE RETAINED, NATIVE VEGETATION WILL BE PLANTED TO PROVIDE A CONTINUOUS PLANTING AREA WITH NO GAPS OR LARGE VOID AREAS WHEN GROWN IN .. r77""7rl ENCELIA CALIFORNICA BUSH SUNFLOWER GAL @ 48" O.C. TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF LOT , D, FIRE BUFFER CLUB AREA PLANTING PLAN DRAWING L 1.00 SHEET 2 OF 7 7 7 70'7 77 -3:>7I7 345*>7I"##5A##"I%-III3 II #B*79*2%I7*2%-#I4->1%3I-32%IIA33"I$#2 #I83I5#1*2I4539# 9I)2I4/ #I:&#5#I*7I23I#B)7:*2%I32I%5"#I4.29I1<#5).I9&*7I4359*32I3$IIA33"I$#2 #I /3>"7I5#45#7#2:I#B)79)2%I:5##I 234CI%53A*2%I$531I45)?8#I5#7)"#2 #I7)"#I3$I$#2 #I#B)78*2%I3>%)2?*--#I-32%II7->14I7932#IA--I83I5#1*2I453:# 9I*2I4- #I7&#5I93I5)2%I*2I -37#5I93IA-.I32II5#%>05I7)7I  '5*7I4*->-5*7I4*%#32I43*2:F GI 3C3:#I>7' 5#13?#I37;32I*?CI I%-I I3 ?-/,8 E'$*"   +IIA)"#I*,#I49(IIA)"#I4.29*2%I5#IIA*"#I4#"#7:5)2I49(I#2 #-)I -)$352) I>7&I7>2$.3A#5III%-III3 I  #B*79*2%I4->1%3I3>%)2@--#I:3I#I5#13?#"I 5#13?#I--I3=#5I71--I7 5>I4-2:7I)2 ->"*2%I!79#5I#2I2"IA##"7I:3I#I5#13?#"IDI#B)7:*2%I5&>7I)2:#%5)$3-*I93I5#1*2I453:# 9I*2I4- #I7#.# :)?#/CI45>2#I"3A2I93II1*29*2I#-3AII :I--I9*1#7I>>E>E>E7*7I-># %-E->4*2>7I-32%*$-35>7I>7'I->4)2#III%.II3 H #B*78)2%I1#8537*"#537I 7 7%7 67177  70$ )7 57.4)7 57047!&7 57040'7 7 7 7  7                  01,!)7 4++7')0,7.!$117 7 .+07 37 '+) 7 "7 7  7I.'7  7459I3$I"5)?)2%I52%#I#B*79)2%I"5CI79 ,I7:32#IA--I-32%IA#79I7*"#I3$I"5)?)2%I52%#I1#9537*"#537I:3I5#1*2I459I3$I"5*?)2%I52%#I-2#/#*(/7                                         463437#"I$>8>5#I)1453?#1#297I  " " " "" "!*/,''#1E!9/#E@E9'$(9E!   :; ;;'; E;2<;;E,; ;; E AE:B/;.C;$/;;;3;!;#1B1;!;;3E====:E ""      EEEEE-'+3E*2/$'E19*,'1E1!,7+E,+E2!1E-'+1E/E29-#'E2!/, !,2E/7$+ E13 E!E1!3E,+4$+1EE-'+3E)',3E2,E2!E1-$$E-'+3E19*,'E.+2#2$1E #6+E,/E-'+3E*2/$'1E1-##E,/E,+E+2/E1-$+ E/E1!,7+E,/E,+6+#+E,+'9E+E/E1,/#+2E3,E2!E1-#+ E $6+E !&E+E1--'9E1#$+3E+*/E,E-'+31E3,E'#''E1-$+E/.$/*+21 E''E-'+2E*3/#'E2,EE#+12''E#+E,/+E7$3!E1-##3$,+1EE,+12/3$,+E3$'1 E$+E1,*E11E-'+2$+ E19*,'1E*9EE1!,7+E#+E/1E7!/E,6E 0E2#'#2$1E$+3//E,/E'3/E2!E1#/E1-#+ E+,/E-42/+ E,+2/2,/E3,E/6$7E/1E7#2!E'+1-E/!#32E-/$,/E3,E-'+3$E E*3/$'E'+1-E/!$32E1!''E/6$7E//+ *+2E+E'9,3E,E*2/#E$+E$'E-/#,/E2,E-'+2#+ E3,-/11E''E/E7#2!$+E3!E'#*$3E,E7,/&'$+E8'#+ E-2!E7#2!EEE'9/E,DE E*2/E,*-,12E*5'!E 1*#2E1*-'1E,/E/6$7E+E--/,6'E/*,6E)'E7E /,72!E+EE-'+2E*4/$'E/,*E',3EE+E$1-,1E,E,E1#2E/*,6E1.1!E-'+31 E''E!/E1-#1E+ '#1!E$69 E,12,+E#69E+E13,/E+E/,*E',2EE+E',+ E3!E12&E13,+E/2#+#+ E7''E'+1-#+ E7$3!$+E''E,**,+E/1E1!''EE-'+3E#+E1!EE*++E1,E2!2E6$71E/,*E%+2E-/,-/2#1E+E+9E-'#E/$ !3 , 79EEE+,2E3E+E1,E2!3E1,'/E11E2,E''E7''#+ E+$31E#1E-/,23 E7!#'E1,*E8$12#+ E6 32$,+E/,+E3!E-/#*3/E7#''EE/3$+E+2#6E6 23#,+E7#''EE-'+2E3,E-/,6$EE,+2#+,1E-'+2$+ E/E E7#2!E+,E -1E,/E'/ E6,#E/1E7!+E /,7+E$+E E.4$) 7              0!17+7&,7<68%0,77$/1E-10I -I< It t~ •• . ·-----1,2,3 L1.02 -----. . /! I /1 7 'it I &,7<68%0,77$/E-117 /20/18 DATE \. ~ :\~?~EN Hfio '11' NO. BY '<., s Z) C1 Lie. No. DESIGNED BY: 6244 l~I 2 SW STEPHEN WOOD 3 DRAWN BY: 05-05-19 RENEWAL DATE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 4 CHECKED BY: SW 07-20-18 4120 ROSE AVE. DATE 5 LONG BEACH, CA 90807 6 AS SHOWN SCALE: RLA 6244 REVISIONS DATE REMARKS 7 /23/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/02/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/12/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/21 /18 CITY SUBMITTAL 8/25/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 9/03/18 CITY SUBMITTAL EQ. • • • PLANTER BEDS TO BE 9 • • 2" BELOW WALK FINISH ------SURFACE --------------PAVING, BUILDING WALL, CURBING --~ OR OTHER AREA LIMITS. • • • • DISTANCE THE SAME AS O.C. DIMENSION NOTE: SEE PLANTING PLANS FOR ON-CENTER SPACING DISTANCE. GROUNDCOVER SPACING DETAIL SCALE NO SCALE 3 ON-CENTER SPACING SEE PLANTING PLAN 1 1/2 TIMES WIDTH OF ROOTBALL 0 ROOTBALL 0 PLANT FERTILIZER TABLETS SEE SPECIFICATIONS 0 BACKFILL MIX: 2/3 SITE SOIL 1/3 0 FINISH GRADE ORGANIC AMENDMENTS SEE SPECIFICATIONS 0 WATERING BASIN © SITE SOIL NOTE: KEEP TOP OF ROOTBALL AND TOP OF FINISH GRADE AT SAME LEVEL. SHRUB PLANTING DETAIL SCALE 1" = 1'-0" 1 ON CENTER SPACING SEE PLANTING PLAN <? 1 1/2 TIMES WIDTH OF ROOTBALL 0 ROOTBALL 0 FINISH GRADE 0 BACKFILL MIX (CONTINUOUS BETWEEN © SITE SOIL ROOTBALLS) 2/3 SITE SOIL 1/3 ORGANIC AMENDMENT 0 WATERING BASIN 0 PLANT FERTILIZER TABLETS SEE SPECIFICATIONS NOTE: KEEP TOP OF ROOTBALLAT FINISH GRADE OR 1/2" ABOVE. SHRUB MASS PLANTING DETAIL SCALE 1" = 1'-0" 2 DRAWING TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF CLUB , D, LOT FIRE BUFFER AREA L 1. 02 PLANTING DETAILS SHEET __ 4 __ OF 7 &,7<68%0,77$/E-12" \_\ ' / \" ' \\ \ \ \ 'f \ \. ' / ' r / / / /, / / / / ' / / ' / /~~ ' ' < ' / ' / ' ( / ' / ' / ' 1i ( ' /' ' ' ' ' ' / ( ' / ' ' / / " ' ' ' / / /, " ' / ' / / ;;' ' ' / / / ~-' / ' / z / / " / / 7 /20/18 DATE \. ~ :\~?~EN Hfio '11' '<., s Z) C1 Lie. No. DESIGNED BY: 6244 0 10 20 40 80 l~I SW DRAWN BY: STEPHEN WOOD I 05-05-19 RENEWAL DATE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT CHECKED BY: SW 07-20-18 4120 ROSE AVE. DATE SCALE: 1 ,, 20'-o" LONG BEACH, CA 90807 SCALE: 1" = 20' -0" RLA 6244 I r I I I I I I I I I L \ I I \ \~ I I I \\, I ~ I I \\ I I I \:\ L 1 \ r\ I \ ti I / .,. Lti I / \ \ I I I c I APPROX. LIM IT OF WORK APPROX. LIMIT OF WORK REVISIONS NO. BY DATE REMARKS 7 /23/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 2 8/02/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 3 8/12/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 4 8/21 /18 CITY SUBMITTAL 5 8/25/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 6 9/03/18 CITY SUBMITTAL 1 I I I I I I I '\ ;' I I \\ 'l I \\1 \ ' I \\ \ 1 PROPERTY LINE I 1 • () • ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ . ■ ■ --■ ■ ■ <■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ~ 0 ■"' ■ -' ■ tii ■ ~ ■ (/) ■ ~ ■ -' ■ 13 ■ ~ ■ ~ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ t) IRRIGATION NOTES 1. INSTALL ALL PRESSURE AND NON-PRESSURE LINES AND ANY EQUIPMENT INSIDE PLANTING AREAS WHEREVER POSSIBLE. (ITEMS SHOWN OUTSIDE SUCH AREAS FOR PURPOSE OF CLARITY ONLY.) 2. ALL EQUIPMENT SHALL BE SELECTED AND INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS AND CONSTRUCTION DETAILS. SEE SHEET NO. L2.02 3. FOR SYMBOL DESIGNATIONS, SEE LEGEND ON SHEET NO. L2.01 4. ALL PIPE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN A SCH. 40 SLEEVE TWICE THE DIAMETER OF THE PIPE CARRIED. ALL WIRE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN SCH. 40 SLEEVE THE SIZE REQUIRED TO EASILY PULL WIRE THROUGH. ALL SLEEVES TO BE INSTALLED WITH A MINIMUM DEPTH AS SHOWN ON THE SLEEVING DETAIL. SLEEVES TO EXTEND AT LEAST 12" PAST THE EDGE OF PAVING. 5. ALL SPRAY HEADS ARE TO BE INSTALLED WITH THE NOZZLE, SCREEN AND ARCS SHOWN ON THE PLANS. ALL HEADS ARE TO BE ADJUSTED TO PREVENT OVERSPRAY ONTO BUILDING, WALLS, FENCES AND HARDSCAPE. THIS INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, ADJUSTMENT OF DIFFUSER PIN OR ADJUSTMENT SCREW, REPLACEMENT OF PRESSURE COMPENSATING SCREENS, REPLACEMENT OF NOZZLES WITH MORE APPROPRIATE RADIUS UNITS AND THE REPLACEMENT OF NOZZLES WITH ADJUSTABLE ARC UNITS. 6. AREAS THAT NEED TO BE DEFINED IN ORDER TO DETERMINE EXACT LOCATION OF SPRINKLER HEADS ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR TO SEE THAT THEY ARE DEFINED PRIOR TO INSTALLATION. 7. AS-BUILT DRAWINGS AND SPECIFICATIONS SHALL BE MAINTAINED ON SITE AT ALL TIMES. AS-BUILT DRAWINGS SHALL BE UPDATED IMMEDIATELY AS REQUIRED. NO SITE REVIEWS ARE TO BE CONDUCTED WITHOUT THESE DRAWINGS. 8. AREAS RECEIVING AN IRRIGATION SYSTEM SHALL BE REVIEWED AND VERIFIED BY THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR FOR ACCURACY OF SIZE AND CONFIGURATION. IF DISCREPANCIES ARE FOUND THAT WOULD PROVE DETRIMENTAL TO FINAL COVERAGE, THIS SHALL BE BROUGHT TO THE OWNER'S ATTENTION BEFORE INSTALLATION. BY FAILING TO DO SO, THE CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY ADJUSTMENTS REQUIRED. 9. IRRIGATION CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW PROJECT LIMIT OF WORK PRIOR TO START OF CONSTRUCTION. IN THE EVENT THAT ANY OVERLAP OCCURS, IE. EQUIPMENT FROM AN EXISTING IRRIGATION SYSTEM DESIGNATED TO REMAIN CROSSES OVER INTO AN AREA OF NEW IRRIGATION; CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CUTTING AND CAPPING EXISTING SYSTEM AS REQUIRED. FURTHERMORE, CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR RELOCATING OR REPAIRING ANY EQUIPMENT THAT WOULD BE DISPLACED BY THE NEW CONSTRUCTION THAT IS REQUIRED TO KEEP EXISTING IRRIGATION OUTSIDE THE LIMIT OF WORK IN OPERATION. PIPE SIZING NOTES SIZING CHART 1. REFER TO IRRIGATION HEAD LEGEND ON SHEET L2.01 FOR GPM OF HEADS. 2. CONTRACTOR TO DETERMINE PIPE SIZING WHERE SYMBOLS ARE NOT SHOWN. SEE ADJACENT SIZING CHART 3. ALL LATERAL LINE PIPE DOWNSTREAM OF A 3/4" SIZED PIPE IS ALSO 3/4". 4. ALL UNSIZED RUNS OF LATERAL LINE PIPE SERVING THREE OR FEWER SPRAY HEADS SHALL BE SIZED 3/4". PVC 3/4" 1" 1 1/4" 1 1/2" 2" 2 1/2" 3" TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF LOT , D, FIRE BUFFER SYMBOL GPM 0-8 .......... ;y4 ......._ 1 " 8-13 e:::: 11/, 13-23 e:::: w;· 23-32 e:::: 2" 32-53 E':::: 2Yi 53-74 Et::3" 74-116 CLUB AREA IRRIGATION PLAN DRAWING L2.OO SHEET 5 OF 7 &,7<68%0,77$/E-13f ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ L f I I I f ~ \ \ l I l \ 1 / I I V ' ' ' / :,--.J,,-y-V--V'v-v''C'\CY-v:,Cl::Y::Yct.:::V:::::::0 PROPERTY LINE ■ ,:_;;.~~~~n::s:::ct~-s..o..c....c...~""i--1-~}J(_;( ,._,.__ ._,,.,_____ __ "( ■ g ■ / '/', _/ y ;f"?' / //,/\'// . // ,,,,,1,7 ~ ■, ,,-,, '///-V /~,/ ~,,,/,/ , ,/ t-■/' /-.,, / ,' / ./\'/ /, / /-, /~_/,. t w · · / ·/ / /'' · , I w ■,~ , ~1✓()'..-//,/ / ~-· < /.S',:/,, . II I ■ . -~•-··7·;,•--'V-",-;.::'r-,r-'-,-c F-,•,J"',c· ~-:" (/) ■ ~1 . y /. /,,,-/ / _{',_// / ,' ,' !"//'~•'· ~--·-.·-. w , , / 7-"2''/,/ >-',: ,', / (,' , / I!· .. ·-. .;.,,~. z .,, /·/ _/y /// ,>/, ·. /2".// //'/','' ~~' ---'■/ /, /_/ 7_,,/,'✓ /. / __ /, . ,' ,' ),, "'"'-). ' I ,-~~...,../ i/·y /, ' / / / ' ( ' ' ' ' ' ' ' \ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' \ ' \ ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o■ , ~ =.· ~;d~::C:JDLJJ[!«:~1'~:-:r::t·~:i:::~j:i'O~_l~L~~!!:n~:-I1:A"'Ll:-"~7f!7~£zo~~-=2~~-=-=:/~2,'~===·=/~=-==~~-==/==-====•=7::·:·::~:~::~~:zo~~LOZQ'~~JJZ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~;~~!s:~~~ -c ---■ -----------------■ APPROX. LI K >--"-_1--,U'--"-__,,, ■ ■-­■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ i I I I I , l \ I I I I I ' '-0 ' I I \ I 10 \ \ ) I / 20 SCALE: 1 ,, \ I I ' I I \ ' \ I \ \ I I I \ CONSTRUCTION NOTES 0 0 0 0 POINT OF CONNECTION TO EXISTING 4" IRRIGATION METER. VERIFY LOCATION IN FIELD. ADD A 2" FEBCO 825YA BACKFLOW TO MAINLINE AND TEE OFF FOR IRRIGATION WATER TO LOT D. CONTRACTOR TO LOCATE WITHIN ADJACENT PLANTED AREAS WHERE POSSIBLE. ADD NORMALLY CLOSED MASTER VALVE AND CONNECT TO NEW CONTROLLER. CONNECT NEW VALVES TO NEW SOLAR CONTROLLER. CONTRACTOR TO LAYOUT ALL PLANT MATERIAL IN THE AREAS SHOWN AND AT THE SPACING SHOWN. THEN LAYOUT THE IRRIGATION ZONES, PVC LATERALS AND DRIP EMITTERS IN THE AREAS SHOWN. LOCATION OF MAINLINE AND VALVES ARE SHOWN DIAGRAMMATICALLY FOR CLARITY. INSTALL ALONG WEST SIDE OF PEDESTRIAN PATH FOR EASE OF ACCESS. 7 /20/18 DATE \, ~ :\~?~EN Hfio '11' '<., s Z) C1 Lie. No. DESIGNED BY: 6244 \ I \ / I PIPE SIZING NOTES 1. REFER TO IRRIGATION HEAD LEGEND ON SHEET L2.01 FOR GPM OF HEADS. 2. CONTRACTOR TO DETERMINE PIPE SIZING WHERE SYMBOLS ARE NOT SHOWN. SEE ADJACENT SIZING CHART 3. ALL LATERAL LINE PIPE DOWNSTREAM OF A 3/4" SIZED PIPE IS ALSO 314". 4. ALL UNSIZED RUNS OF LATERAL LINE PIPE SERVING THREE OR FEWER SPRAY HEADS SHALL BE SIZED 314". NO. BY DATE 7 /23/18 40 80 l~I 2 8/02/18 SW 8/12/18 STEPHEN WOOD DRAWN BY: 3 I 05-05-19 RENEWAL DATE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 4 8/21 /18 CHECKED BY: SW 07-20-18 4120 ROSE AVE. DATE 5 8/25/18 20'-o" LONG BEACH, CA 90807 SCALE: 1" = 20' -0" RLA 6244 6 9/03/18 ' SIZING CHART PVC 314" SYMBOL GPM 1" 1 114" 1 112" 2" 2 112" 3" REVISIONS REMARKS CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL 1 " 2" 0-8 8-13 13-23 23-32 32-53 53-74 3" 74-116 < SYMBOL 2" ------------/A1\ \ 1 :l_o::',{ @ () ~ ~ IRRIGATION NOTES 1. INSTALL ALL PRESSURE AND NON-PRESSURE LINES AND ANY EQUIPMENT INSIDE PLANTING AREAS WHEREVER POSSIBLE (ITEMS SHOWN OUTSIDE SUCH AREAS FOR PURPOSE OF CLARITY ONLY.) 2. ALL EQUIPMENT SHALL BE SELECTED AND INSTALLED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SPECIFICATIONS AND CONSTRUCTION DETAILS. SEE SHEET NO. L2.02 3. FOR SYMBOL DESIGNATIONS, SEE LEGEND ON SHEET NO. L2.01 4. ALL PIPE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN A SCH. 40 SLEEVE TWICE THE DIAMETER OF THE PIPE CARRIED. ALL WIRE UNDER PAVED AREAS TO BE INSTALLED IN SCH. 40 SLEEVE THE SIZE REQUIRED TO EASILY PULL WIRE THROUGH. ALL SLEEVES TO BE INSTALLED WITH A MINIMUM DEPTH AS SHOWN ON THE SLEEVING DETAIL. SLEEVES TO EXTEND AT LEAST 12" PAST THE EDGE OF PAVING. 5. ALL SPRAY HEADS ARE TO BE INSTALLED WITH THE NOZZLE, SCREEN AND ARCS SHOWN ON THE PLANS. ALL HEADS ARE TO BE ADJUSTED TO PREVENT OVERSPRAY ONTO BUILDING, WALLS, FENCES AND HARDSCAPE. THIS INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO, ADJUSTMENT OF DIFFUSER PIN OR ADJUSTMENT SCREW, REPLACEMENT OF PRESSURE COMPENSATING SCREENS, REPLACEMENT OF NOZZLES WITH MORE APPROPRIATE RADIUS UNITS AND THE REPLACEMENT OF NOZZLES WITH ADJUSTABLE ARC UNITS. 6. AREAS THAT NEED TO BE DEFINED IN ORDER TO DETERMINE EXACT LOCATION OF SPRINKLER HEADS ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR TO SEE THAT THEY ARE DEFINED PRIOR TO INSTALLATION. 7. AS-BUILT DRAWINGS AND SPECIFICATIONS SHALL BE MAINTAINED ON SITE AT ALL TIMES. AS-BUILT DRAWINGS SHALL BE UPDATED IMMEDIATELY AS REQUIRED. NO SITE REVIEWS ARE TO BE CONDUCTED WITHOUT THESE DRAWINGS. 8, AREAS RECEIVING AN IRRIGATION SYSTEM SHALL BE REVIEWED AND VERIFIED BY THE INSTALLING CONTRACTOR FOR ACCURACY OF SIZE AND CONFIGURATION. IF DISCREPANCIES ARE FOUND THAT WOULD PROVE DETRIMENTAL TO FINAL COVERAGE, THIS SHALL BE BROUGHT TO THE OWNER'S ATTENTION BEFORE INSTALLATION. BY FAILING TO DO SO, THE CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY ADJUSTMENTS REQUIRED. 9, IRRIGATION CONTRACTOR TO REVIEW PROJECT LIMIT OF WORK PRIOR TO START OF CONSTRUCTION. IN THE EVENT THAT ANY OVERLAP OCCURS, IE. EQUIPMENT FROM AN EXISTING IRRIGATION SYSTEM DESIGNATED TO REMAIN CROSSES OVER INTO AN AREA OF NEW IRRIGATION; CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR CUTTING AND CAPPING EXISTING SYSTEM AS REQUIRED. FURTHERMORE, CONTRACTOR MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR RELOCATING OR REPAIRING ANY EQUIPMENT THAT WOULD BE DISPLACED BY THE NEW CONSTRUCTION THAT IS REQUIRED TO KEEP EXISTING IRRIGATION OUTSIDE THE LIMIT OF WORK IN OPERATION. GENERAL LEGEND DESCRIPTION MANUFACTURER & PART NUMBER REFERENCE PRESSURE SUPPLY LINES & SIZE SCHEDULE 40 PVC. SPECIFICATIONS (1 1/2" AND SMALLER) PRESSURE SUPPLY LINES & SIZE CLASS 315 P.V.C. SPECIFICATIONS (2" AND LARGER) NON-PRESSURE LATERAL LINE & SIZE SCHEDULE 40 PVC. SPECIFICATIONS SLEEVE & SIZE (2" AND LARGER) CLASS 200 P.V.C. DET 2, SHT L2.02 CONTROLLER SEQUENCE GALLONS PER MINUTE (GPM) REMOTE CONTROL VALVE SIZE REMOTE CONTROL VALVE (1", 1 ½" & 2") RAINBIRD PEB SERIES DRIP ASSEMBLY VALVE DET 1, SHT L2.02 QUICK COUPLING VALVE RAINBIRD 33 DRC DET 6, SHT L2.02 BALL VALVES/GATE VALVES (LINE SIZE) HAMMOND 8901 BRASS SERIES DET 5, SHT L2.02 NORMALLY CLOSED MASTER VALVE 2" GRISWOLD OR EQUAL (RAIN BIRD) DRIP EMITTER LEGEND DESCRIPTION PSI GPH MFG. BODY REMARKS DETAIL XB-20-C-1032: RED, 2.0 GPH (Y.561/h) 15-50 2 RAINBIRD FLEX RISER SHRUBS DET. 6, SHT. L2.02 TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF CLUB LOT , D, FIRE BUFFER AREA IRRIGATION PLAN DRAWING L2.O1 SHEET 6 OF 7 &,7<68%0,77$/E-140 0 0 0 0 0 @ LEIT 4000E ® ,m COMMON AMBIENT LIGHT POWERED CONTROLLER TERMINAL STRIP 12 OR 14 GUAGE WIRE PROGRAMMING KEY 35" STEEL MOUNTING COLUMN FINISH GRADE H>99ERIE8 Acm.J.1,TOR TOESERIBS ACTUATOR -II 0 0 0 @ -sLOPI:. POURED CONCRETE BASE/FOOTING 1-1/2 CU.FT. DIRECT BURIAL CONTROL WIRES TO SPLICE BOX (2) DRY SPLICE CONNECTORS. IRRIGATION JUNCTION BOX LEIT SOLOR CONTROLLER SCALE NTS 7 6 )--I-'---3 4 1 2 MAX. 12" 0 ROUND PLASTIC BOX & COVER W/ LOCK TOP MARKED: B.V. 0 FINISH GRADE 0 PVC MALE ADAPTOR 0 BALL VALVE 0 3/4" PEA GRAVEL (MIN. 6" DEPTH) © PVC SUPPLY LINE NOTES: 1. BALL VALVE SHALL BE INSTALLED IN SHRUB AREAS UNLESS OTHERWISE APPROVED. 2. SET VALVE BOX FLUSH WITH FINISH GRADE IN TURF AREAS. SET 2"" ABOVE FINISH GRADE IN GROUNDCOVER AREAS. BALL VALVE ASSEMBLY SCALE NTS 5 * SPACING PER PLANTlNG PLAN 3 2 1 (-.", _/_,_...-~ /" ------.. ..... \ . ' ( ' ! ' I I ' ' ' ! ' ~ // \'-../ \ / . / ~ • ~--a. * Cl z ~ /.-... ,\ /.-.", / .. -."\ ( I a. .IJ '1 l ' ' " ' '•, ' ffi \. ! ' I "•·/ a. ii-./ "-•/ Cl z ~ Ill * /-'\ / ... -"' /-"' f \ I \ * I I I I ' ; ' \ / \ / ! \ J . / .• / "• ~----IJ _/--~ /.-.", / _ _,,....-----~ I ( ' \ I ' ' ' ' \ . ' • \ ' ' ; "•/ "-•/ I "•/ DATE 7/20/18 DESIGNED BY: __ _ DRAWN BY: SW CHECKED BY: SW SCALE: 1 'A5= S'.l'WWN0" * It. ---. . (/4 • 05-05-19 RENEWAL DATE 07-20-18 DATE _Q /_...------."' • • i t ~/ ~ \ '-.. Q ~-4 9 I -<H I -I _J f 0 ® @ © EDGE OF HARDSCAPE/ PLANTER BOUNDARY PLANT ROOTBALL (CAN SIZE) PLANT GROWTH O APROX. 3 YEARS 3/4" SCHEDULE 40 PVC LAlERAL LINE ClosED LOOP: MIN. PRESSURE EACH VM..Vf. IS 15 PSI, SIZE PER PLAN RAINBIRD REMOTE CONlROL DRIP VM..Vf. PER PLAN RAINBIRD 12" POLYFLEX RISER AND ADAPTER ASSEMBLY (PRF-FRA) W/ RAINBIRD XERI-BUG DRIP EMITTER ASSEMBLY (XB-2OPC-1D32) MAINLINE: SIZE PER PLAN FACE OF BUILDING OR OTHER STRUCl\JRE RAINBIRD AIR_YACUUM RELIEF VM..Vf. KIT (AR VAi.VE KIT) INSTALL IN LINE .SC BELOW GRADE POINT SOURCE DRIP EMITTERS SCALE NTS 6 STEPHEN WOOD LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT 4120 ROSE AVE. LONG BEACH, CA 90807 RLA 6244 NO. BY 2 3 4 5 6 DATE 7 /23/18 8/02/18 8/12/18 8/21 /18 8/25/18 9/03/18 REVISIONS REMARKS CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL CITY SUBMITTAL 3 6 )----------,,-i 7 8 7 0 ROUND PLASTIC BOX & COVER W/ LOCK TOP MARKED: Q.C. 0 QUICK COUPLER VALVE LOCATE TOP OF VALVE 2" BELOW TOP OF BOX COVER 0 FINISH GRADE 0 3/4"" PEA GRAVEL (MIN. 6"" DEPTH) 0 PVC SUPPLY LINE 0 24" MIN. LENGTH NO. 4 REBAR ATTACH W/ 2 STAINLESS STEEL BANDS. 0 BRASS STREET ELL 0 BRASS NIPPLE (6" MIN.) ---+-,9 0 PVC SCH. 40 TEE OR ELL ® BRASS NIPPLE. LENGTH AS REQUIRED. NOTES: 1. SET VALVE BOX FLUSH WITH FINISH GRADE IN TURF AREAS. SET 2" ABOVE FINISH GRADE IN GROUNDCOVERAREAS. QUICK COUPLER VALVE SCALE NTS 3 It. * G) ® @ 0 PLANT (PER CAN SIZE) FINISH GRADE 3/4" SCHEDULE 40 PVC LATERM.. LINE -CLOSED LOOP: MIN. PRESSURE EACH VM..Vf. IS 15 PSI THREADED TEE 12" POLY F"LEX( RISER .SC ADAPTER ASSEMBLY PFR-FRA) RAINBIRD XERI BUG EMITTER ASSEMBL: (XB-20PC-1032) MIN. PRESSURE D EMITTER IS 15 PSI. BACKFILL MIX PER SPECIFICATIONS * DISTANCE VARIES BY CAN SIZE PLACE LAlERAL LINE AT EDGE OF CAN LOCATION, PARALLEL W/ PLANTlNG LAYOUT ORI P EMITTERS SCALE NTS 4 2 3 I 4 CD 12• X 18" PLASTIC BOX &: COVER 0 3/4• PRESSURE REGULATING VIJ...VE W6: LOCK TOP MARKED: R.C.V. B X TO BE PLACED AT RIGHT ® PVC MAINLINE ANGLE TO HARDSCAPE EDGE. ® 3/4" PEA GRAVEL (MIN. 6" DEPTH) ® 8URL r◄_ef EXPANSION LOOP MIN. 24 @ CHRISlY'S ID. TAGJSTND.) SECURE @ 1" X 3/4" SCH 40 TO SOLENOID WIR . SEE SPECS. RED BUSHING TxT © FINISH GRADE (jj) ELECTRIC REMOTE CONTROL ® DRIP VALVE PER LEGEND COMMON WIRE @ ® CONTROL WIRE 3/4• DISC FILTER REMOTE CONTROL DRIP VALVE SCALE NTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 SLEEVING. SEE SPECIFICATIONS CONTROL WIRES PRESSURE SUPPLY LINE NON-PRESSURE SUPPLY LINE CONCRETE/A.C. PAVING COMPACTED SUBGRADE CLEAN COMPACTED BACKFILL SEE SPECIFICATIONS. TRENCHING AND SLEEVING DETAIL ,___s~~~~tE___, DRAWING 1 2 TRUMP NATIONAL GOLF CLUB LOT 'D' FIRE BUFFER AREA L2.02 IRRIGATION DETAILS SHEET __ ? __ OF 7