Loading...
CC SR 20210216 03 - Citizen Satisfaction Survey CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: 02/16/2021 AGENDA REPORT AGENDA HEADING: Regular Business AGENDA TITLE: Consideration and possible action to review results of the RPV Citizen Satisfaction Survey. RECOMMENDED COUNCIL ACTION: (1) Receive and file a summary of the results of the RPV Citizen Satisfaction Survey . FISCAL IMPACT: None Amount Budgeted: N/A Additional Appropriation: N/A Account Number(s): N/A ORIGINATED BY: Megan Barnes, Senior Administrative Analyst Jesse Villalpando, Senior Administrative Analyst REVIEWED BY: Karina Bañales, Deputy City Manager APPROVED BY: Ara Mihranian, AICP, City Manager ATTACHED SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS: A. November 17, 2020 staff report B. Data summary (page B-1) C. Public comments (page C-1) BACKGROUND: On November 17, 2020, the City Council approved a final list of questions for a citizen satisfaction survey in support of City Council Goal No. 66. For background, see the November 17 staff report (Attachment A). The RPV Citizen Satisfaction Survey went live on SurveyMonkey.com on December 21 and was mailed to 15,332 residential addresses in Rancho Palos Verdes in early January 2021. In addition to a social media and email listserv campaign, the survey was promoted in the media via a press release, on RPVtv and with banners hung at major City intersections for several weeks. 1 By the January 25 deadline, the City received 1,504 (2,882 received minus 1,378 invalid responses = 1,504) responses online and another approximately 1,500 in the mail. More than 20 staff members from the City Manager’s Office and the Recreation and Parks Department manually entered the print responses into SurveyMonkey so they could be analyzed with the online responses. Because an RPV address was required, for the analysis, Staff excluded respondents who did not provide an RPV address, bringing the total to 2,341 survey responses. Each Thursday in January, Staff conducted a raffle prize drawing to select 10 random gift card winners. Due to the very high volume of surveys the City received in the mail just before the January 25 deadline, Staff decided to conduct an additional raffle drawing, bringing the total number of winners to 50. Staff continues to contact winners to verify residency and, as of the writing of this report, has distributed 30 $25 gift cards to RPV restaurants and personal care services businesses impacted by COVID-19-related closures. Tonight’s report includes a summary of highlights from the survey results. A more detailed summary is included as Attachment B, excluding responses to open-ended questions. An online version of the detailed summary, including responses to open- ended questions, can be accessed at the following link: https://www.surveymonkey.com/results/SM-957TZS7K9/ The City Council can use the data collected through the Citizen Satisfaction Survey when setting goals at the upcoming City Council Goals Workshop on February 22 and to help guide future policymaking. The data has also been shared with department heads and City Staff. In addition to collecting feedback on customer service and policy issues, the survey provided an avenue for residents who might not otherwise contact the City to ask questions and share specific concerns with Staff. Staff is following up with these inquiries. Supplemental public comments regarding the survey are included in this report as Attachment C. DISCUSSION: Print vs. Online Responses Of the 2,341 survey respondents, 58.9% took the survey in print and 41.1% took the survey online. Print respondents tended to be older than those who took the survey online, with half, age 71 and older, compared to 16% of online respondents. The highest represented age group for online respondents was 51-60 at 29.8%. Print respondents tended to have lived in RPV longer than those who took the survey online, with more than half having lived in the City for more than 30 years, compared to 27% of online respondents. Slightly more men took the survey online than women, while slightly more 2 women took the survey in print than men. Racial data was largely consistent among both print and online respondents. General Questions The overwhelming majority of respondents (95%) rated the overall quality of life in Rancho Palos Verdes as “good” or “excellent,” with 63.9% reporting quality of life in the City “stayed about the same” in the past few years. Almost 60% of respondents rated the overall condition of the City’s public infrastructure as “good.” The top five most serious concerns respondents said they would like to see the City do something about were: 1. Crime 2. Wildfire prevention/emergency preparedness 3. COVID-19 pandemic 4. Conservation/open space preservation 5. Impacts to neighborhoods of visitors to parks and trails Q2 1: How would you rate the overall quality of life in Rancho Palos Verdes? Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Very Poor 0.17% 4 Poor 0.34% 8 Fair 4.44% 103 Good 45.63% 1,059 Excellent 49.42% 1,147 TOTAL 2,321 Q3 2: In the last few years, do you think the quality of life in Rancho Palos Verdes has gotten better, gotten worse, or stayed about the same? 3 Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Far Worse 1.73% 40 Worse 18.51% 429 Stayed About the Same 63.93% 1,482 Better 14.02% 325 Far Better 1.81% 42 TOTAL 2,318 Q4 3: Please rate the overall condition of the City’s public infrastructure (streets, sidewalks, medians, traffic signs and signals, etc.): 4 Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Very Poor 0.99% 23 Poor 4.09% 95 Fair 22.14% 514 Good 59.56% 1,383 Excellent 13.22% 307 TOTAL 2,322 Customer Service at City Hall About 40% of respondents reported having interacted with City Staff in the past year. The percentage of respondents who rated Staff’s service as “good” or “excellent” across the following categories was: Courteousness: 83.51% Timeliness: 69.52% Knowledge: 77.16% Helpfulness: 71.94% Overall, 44.15% of respondents said they were “very satisfied” interacting with City Staff, followed by “somewhat satisfied” at 27.65%. Q7 2: If you answered “yes” to the previous question, please rate the following aspects of the service provided by City staff you have dealt with: 5 Courteousness Answer Choices: Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent Total Percentage 0.95% 2.85% 12.68% 37.42% 46.09% Number of responses 9 27 120 354 436 946 Timeliness Answer Choices: Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent Total Percentage 4.49% 6.74% 19.25% 36.04% 33.48% Number of responses 42 63 180 337 313 935 Knowledge Answer Choices: Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent Total Percentage 1.81% 5.34% 15.69% 40.66% 36.50% Number of responses 17 50 147 381 342 937 Helpfulness Answer Choices: Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent Total Percentage 4.99% 6.59% 16.47% 34.43% 37.51% Number of responses 47 62 155 324 353 941 City Government The top five issues respondents said they would like to see the City Council pay more attention to were: 1. Crime 2. Trails and open space 3. Traffic safety 4. Senior services 5. Environment/sustainability The top three primary sources of information from which respondents said they find out about what’s happening in the City were: 1. Local news media 2. Word of mouth in the community 3. Social media 6 The top three methods of communication respondents said they preferred when receiving information from the City were: 1. Email 2. Print publications 3. Text message Half of survey respondents said they “agree” or “strongly agree” that the City keeps them informed on what’s happening in RPV and their city government, while 37.11% said they “neither agree nor disagree,” and 12.48% said they “disagree” or “strongly disagree.” Q9 1: What kinds of issues would you like to see the City Council give more attention to? (check all that apply) 7 ANSWER CHOICES Percentage Number of Responses Crime 41.57% 930 Trails and open space 38.49% 861 Traffic safety 31.34% 701 Senior services 28.39% 635 Environment/sustainability 26.73% 598 Beautification 23.42% 524 Housing/zoning/development laws 21.81% 488 Other (please specify) 20.38% 456 Education 19.40% 434 Public health/mental health 15.56% 348 Portuguese Bend Landslide 15.24% 341 Youth services 14.98% 335 Economic development 13.05% 292 Economic development 11.85% 265 Social justice/inequity issues 10.51% 235 Housing affordability 10.06% 225 Pension reform 9.92% 222 Total 2,237 8 Q10 1: What are your primary sources of information to find out what’s happening in the City? (check all that apply) Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Local news media 44.29% 1,004 Word of mouth in the community 41.60% 943 Social media 41.42% 939 City website 32.25% 731 Other (please specify) 21.79% 494 City listservs 14.25% 323 City Council, commission or committee meetings 6.93% 157 RPVtv programming 5.96% 135 City Manager’s Weekly Administrative Report 5.82% 132 TOTAL 2,299 9 Q13 4: Do you feel that the City keeps you informed on what’s happening in RPV and your city government Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Strongly Disagree 1.98% 45 Disagree 10.50% 239 Neither Agree nor Disagree 37.11% 845 Agree 44.75% 1,019 Strongly Disagree 1.98% 45 Disagree 10.50% 239 Strongly Agree 5.67% 129 TOTAL 2,277 Trails and Open Space The percentage of respondents who said they use City trails was 74.59%, and 63.89% said they find information on which City trails to use from living or having grown up in the City, or word of mouth. 10 Q19 4: How do you find information on which City trails to use? Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Social media 8.06% 165 Lists of top hiking spots on the internet 9.53% 195 Word of mouth 25.42% 520 City website 10.31% 211 I grew up here/live here 38.47% 787 Other (please specify) 8.21% 168 TOTAL 2,046 Sustainability and Conservation The top three general environmental concerns among respondents were: 1. Air pollution 2. Water pollution 3. Extreme weather The top three local environmental concerns among respondents were: 1. Ocean/beach pollution 2. Impacts of chemical dumping off the coast 3. Wildfire hazard 11 The percentage of respondents who said they feel the City is doing enough to promote sustainability was 69.34%, and 56.92% said they were “interested” or “very interested” in having more of the electricity that powers their homes come from renewable sources. Q27 6: Are you interested in having more of the electricity that powers your home come from renewable sources, such as wind and solar? Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Interested 30.18% 676 Very Interested 26.74% 599 Neither Interested nor Disinterested 19.87% 445 Not at all Interested 8.21% 184 I have a home solar system 8.13% 182 Not at all Interested 6.88% 154 TOTAL 2,240 12 Civic Center Planning More than half of survey respondents said they were “not at all familiar” with the current Civic Center Mast Plan project, and 57.97% said they “neither oppose nor favor” redevelopment of the Civic Center site. Twice as many respondents said they “favor” or “strongly favor” redevelopment of the Civic Center site than those who said they “oppose” or “strongly oppose” redevelopment. The top five amenities respondents said were likely to cause them to visit the Civic Center were: 1. Special event (such as Fourth of July) 2. Public performances at a small amphitheater 3. Hiking 4. Restaurant 5. City services (e.g. permits) Q29 2: Do you favor or oppose the redevelopment of the Civic Center site? Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Strongly Oppose 4.67% 101 Oppose 9.19% 199 Neither Oppose nor Favor 57.97% 1,255 Favor 23.14% 501 13 Strongly Favor 5.03% 109 TOTAL 9.19% 2,165 Q30 3: Please select the following the amenities that would likely cause you to visit the Civic Center. (check all that apply) Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Special Event (such as Fourth of July) 52.66% 1,130 Public Performances at Small Amphitheater 50.19% 1,077 Hiking 49.77% 1,068 Restaurant 47.20% 1,013 City Services (e.g. permits) 41.80% 897 Art, Educational or Historical Exhibit Space 36.30% 779 Sheriff’s Department Substation 30.20% 648 Public Meeting 28.38% 609 Emergency Operations Center 25.12% 539 Dog Park 24.09% 517 City Hall (specify) 22.41% 481 Playground 20.41% 438 Meet with City Staff 19.48% 418 14 Fire Department Station 18.27% 392 Meet with City Council Member 13.14% 282 Other (please specify) 4.19% 90 Total 2,146 Emergency Preparedness In the Emergency Preparedness category, 82.85% of respondents said they did not have trouble obtaining or maintaining fire insurance in the past three years, and 16.68% said their home fire insurance rate increased by more than 7% in a one-year period. The percentage of respondents who reported having conducted personal and family preparedness activities and taken steps to reduce their risk of wildfire varied across the various activities and actions. However, across the actions taken to reduce wildfire risk, a higher percentage of respondents selected “have done.” Q31 1: In the past THREE years, have you had difficulty in obtaining and/or maintaining home FIRE insurance? Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Yes 4.95% 112 No 82.85% 1,875 N/A 12.20% 276 Total: 2,263 15 Q32 2: In the past THREE years, has your home FIRE insurance rate increased more than 7% in a one-year period? Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Yes 16.68% 354 No 60.56% 1,285 N/A 22.76% 483 Total: 2,122 Public Safety Slightly more than half of survey respondents said they were “likely” or “very likely” to pay a portion of a cost with a neighborhood or homeowners association to purchase one or more neighborhood security cameras. Regarding services provided by the Lomita Sheriff’s Station, 34.99% of respondents said they were “somewhat satisfied” and 29.76% said they were “very satisfied.” One quarter of respondents said they were “neither satisfied nor dissatisfied.” The top three public safety concerns of respondents were: 1. Residential burglaries 2. Vehicle burglaries/thefts 3. Wildfire hazard 16 Q37 3: How satisfied are you with the services provided by the Lomita Sheriff’s Station? ADA/Accessibility The overwhelming majority of respondents (97%) said they were not aware o f any specific concerns, complaints or problems regarding access for persons with disabilities to any of the programs, services and activities provided by the City. Common open- ended responses for a question about what the City’s highest priority to improve accessibility for persons with disabilities should be included access to facilities, sidewalks, and transportation/help for seniors. Q45 1: Are you aware of any specific concerns, complaints or problems regarding access for persons with disabilities to any of the programs, services and activities provided by the City? 17 Answer Choices Percentage Number of Responses Yes 97.01% 2,145 No 2.99% 66 Total: 2,211 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: Staff purchased a one-year subscription Team Premier Plan subscription to SurveyMonkey for the purpose of conducting the Citizen Satisfaction Survey. If the City Council wishes to conduct additional follow-up surveys that are more topic specific, the subscription is active through November 2021. CONCLUSION: Staff recommends the City Council receive and file the summary of survey results contained in this report. The City Council can then use this information when crafting goals during the City Council Goals Workshop on February 22. 18 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 1 / 62 0.17%4 0.34%8 4.44%103 45.63%1,059 49.42%1,147 Q2 1. How would you rate the overall quality of life in Rancho Palos Verdes? Answered: 2,321 Skipped: 20 TOTAL 2,321 Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent B-1 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 2 / 62 1.73%40 18.51%429 63.93%1,482 14.02%325 1.81%42 Q3 2. In the last few years, do you think the quality of life in Rancho Palos Verdes has gotten better, gotten worse, or stayed about the same? Answered: 2,318 Skipped: 23 TOTAL 2,318 Far Worse Worse Stayed About the Same Better Far Better 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Far Worse Worse Stayed About the Same Better Far Better B-2 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 3 / 62 0.99%23 4.09%95 22.14%514 59.56%1,383 13.22%307 Q4 3. Please rate the overall condition of the City’s public infrastructure (streets, sidewalks, medians, traffic signs and signals, etc.): Answered: 2,322 Skipped: 19 TOTAL 2,322 Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent B-3 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 4 / 62 Q5 4. What do you think are the most serious issues facing the residents of Rancho Palos Verdes that you would like to see the City do something about? (check all that apply) Answered: 2,299 Skipped: 42 Crime Wildfire prevention/... COVID-19 pandemic Conservation/op en space... Impacts to neighborhood... Coyotes Overhead power lines Traffic safety Other (please specify) Housing/zoning/ development... Environment/sus tainability Portuguese Bend Landslide Street beautification Quality of life Economic development Lack of affordable... Dissemination of informati... Pension liability 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-4 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 5 / 62 40.02%920 39.76%914 39.71%913 32.88%756 31.01%713 29.58%680 29.40%676 27.75%638 22.27%512 20.70%476 19.44%447 16.62%382 16.53%380 14.79%340 11.44%263 10.40%239 8.87%204 8.35%192 Total Respondents: 2,299 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Crime Wildfire prevention/ emergency preparedness COVID-19 pandemic Conservation/open space preservation Impacts to neighborhoods of visitors to parks and trails Coyotes Overhead power lines Traffic safety Other (please specify) Housing/zoning/development laws Environment/sustainability Portuguese Bend Landslide Street beautification Quality of life Economic development Lack of affordable housing Dissemination of information (communications) Pension liability B-5 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 6 / 62 40.15%923 59.85%1,376 Q6 1. In the past year, have you interacted with City staff? Answered: 2,299 Skipped: 42 TOTAL 2,299 Yes No 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No B-6 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 7 / 62 Q7 2. If you answered “yes” to the previous question, please rate the following aspects of the service provided by City staff you have dealt with: Answered: 957 Skipped: 1,384 B-7 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 8 / 62 Very Poor Poor Fair Good Excellent Courteousness Timeliness Knowledge Helpfulness 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-8 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 9 / 62 0.95% 9 2.85% 27 12.68% 120 37.42% 354 46.09% 436 946 4.49% 42 6.74% 63 19.25% 180 36.04% 337 33.48% 313 935 1.81% 17 5.34% 50 15.69% 147 40.66% 381 36.50% 342 937 4.99% 47 6.59% 62 16.47% 155 34.43% 324 37.51% 353 941 VERY POOR POOR FAIR GOOD EXCELLENT TOTAL Courteousness Timeliness Knowledge Helpfulness B-9 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 10 / 62 5.81%63 8.20%89 14.19%154 27.65%300 44.15%479 Q8 3. Overall, how satisfied were you interacting with City staff? Answered: 1,085 Skipped: 1,256 TOTAL 1,085 Very Dissatisfied Somewhat Dissatisfied Neither Satisfied no... Somewhat Satisfied Very Satisfied 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Dissatisfied Somewhat Dissatisfied Neither Satisfied nor Dissatisfied Somewhat Satisfied Very Satisfied B-10 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 11 / 62 Q9 1. What kinds of issues would you like to see the City Council give more attention to? (check all that apply) Answered: 2,237 Skipped: 104 B-11 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 12 / 62 Crime Trails and open space Traffic safety Senior services Environment/sus tainability Beautification Housing/zoning/ development... Other (please specify) Education Public health/menta... Portuguese Bend Landslide Youth services Economic development Economic development Social justice/ineq... Housing affordability Pension reform Communications Police reform 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-12 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 13 / 62 41.57%930 38.49%861 31.34%701 28.39%635 26.73%598 23.42%524 21.81%488 20.38%456 19.40%434 15.56%348 15.24%341 14.98%335 13.05%292 11.85%265 10.51%235 10.06%225 9.92%222 8.76%196 7.33%164 Total Respondents: 2,237 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Crime Trails and open space Traffic safety Senior services Environment/sustainability Beautification Housing/zoning/development laws Other (please specify) Education Public health/mental health Portuguese Bend Landslide Youth services Economic development Economic development Social justice/inequity issues Housing affordability Pension reform Communications Police reform B-13 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 14 / 62 44.29%1,004 41.60%943 41.42%939 32.25%731 21.79%494 14.25%323 6.93%157 5.96%135 5.82%132 Q10 1. What are your primary sources of information to find out what’s happening in the City? (check all that apply) Answered: 2,267 Skipped: 74 Total Respondents: 2,267 Local news media Word of mouth in the... Social media City website Other (please specify) City listservs City Council, commission o... RPVtv programming City Manager’s Weekly... 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Local news media Word of mouth in the community Social media City website Other (please specify) City listservs City Council, commission or committee meetings RPVtv programming City Manager’s Weekly Administrative Report B-14 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 15 / 62 Q11 2. In order of preference, with 1 being the most preferred, please rank your preferred methods of communication when receiving information from the City. Answered: 2,266 Skipped: 75 66.77% 1,296 20.04% 389 8.24% 160 3.09% 60 1.44% 28 0.36% 7 0.05% 1 1,941 6.46 25.76% 477 21.00% 389 18.03% 334 12.58% 233 8.91% 165 6.32% 117 7.40% 137 1,852 4.94 11.84% 165 35.65% 497 17.72% 247 12.91% 180 9.61% 134 8.61% 120 3.66% 51 1,394 4.87 7.46% 114 20.35% 311 24.80% 379 21.86% 334 17.08% 261 7.13% 109 1.31% 20 1,528 4.53 9.77% 129 16.96% 224 20.29% 268 19.15% 253 11.96% 158 11.05% 146 10.83% 143 1,321 4.17 4.52% 58 6.54% 84 14.64% 188 10.59% 136 14.41% 185 20.72% 266 28.58% 367 1,284 3.00 1.42% 17 3.44% 41 5.87% 70 8.38% 100 18.11% 216 29.51% 352 33.28% 397 1,193 2.40 Email Print publications Text message City website Social media Phone call RPVtv programming 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 TOTAL SCORE Email Print publications Text message City website Social media Phone call RPVtv programming B-15 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 16 / 62 0.62%14 5.87%133 33.20%752 25.03%567 7.68%174 27.59%625 Q12 3. How easy or difficult have you found the City website to use? Answered: 2,265 Skipped: 76 TOTAL 2,265 Very Difficult Difficult Neither Easy nor Difficult Easy Very Easy N/A 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Difficult Difficult Neither Easy nor Difficult Easy Very Easy N/A B-16 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 17 / 62 1.98%45 10.50%239 37.11%845 44.75%1,019 5.67%129 Q13 4. Do you feel that the City keeps you informed on what’s happening in RPV and your city government? Answered: 2,277 Skipped: 64 TOTAL 2,277 Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither Agree nor Disagree Agree Strongly Agree 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither Agree nor Disagree Agree Strongly Agree B-17 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 18 / 62 Q14 5. What kinds of information would you like to receive from the City? (check all that apply) Answered: 2,286 Skipped: 55 City events (Whale of a... Peninsula-wide community... Public Works events... Recreational programs Public safety alerts/traff... Emergency preparedness... Sustainability tips and... Business resources Utilities Trails Senior resources Youth resources Resources for persons with... Volunteer opportunities Activities of the City... New laws and policies Other (please specify) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-18 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 19 / 62 69.69% 1,593 66.23% 1,514 75.63% 1,729 43.61%997 74.19% 1,696 53.54% 1,224 25.11%574 14.30%327 31.93%730 44.18% 1,010 40.55%927 18.50%423 11.72%268 31.54%721 34.43%787 64.13% 1,466 4.64%106 Total Respondents: 2,286 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES City events (Whale of a Day, Fourth of July, Los Serenos nature walks, etc.) Peninsula-wide community events Public Works events (shredding/e-waste/excess brush collection) Recreational programs Public safety alerts/traffic alerts Emergency preparedness tips and resources Sustainability tips and resources Business resources Utilities Trails Senior resources Youth resources Resources for persons with disabilities Volunteer opportunities Activities of the City Council, City commissions or committees New laws and policies Other (please specify) B-19 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 20 / 62 58.43%1,338 36.42%834 0.61%14 4.54%104 Q15 6. Do you prefer receiving information about community projects electronically, by mail, or in person at workshops? Answered: 2,290 Skipped: 51 TOTAL 2,290 Electronically By Mail In Person at Workshops No Preference 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Electronically By Mail In Person at Workshops No Preference B-20 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 21 / 62 74.59%1,720 25.41%586 Q16 1. Do you use City trails? Answered: 2,306 Skipped: 35 TOTAL 2,306 Yes No 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No B-21 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 22 / 62 38.62%825 61.38%1,311 Q17 2. Do you think the City needs more trails? Answered: 2,136 Skipped: 205 TOTAL 2,136 Yes No 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No B-22 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 23 / 62 1.82%40 7.34%161 37.21%816 47.15%1,034 6.48%142 Q18 3. Do you feel that City trails are adequately maintained? Answered: 2,193 Skipped: 148 TOTAL 2,193 Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither Agree nor Disagree Agree Strongly Agree 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Strongly Disagree Disagree Neither Agree nor Disagree Agree Strongly Agree B-23 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 24 / 62 8.06%165 9.53%195 25.42%520 10.31%211 38.47%787 8.21%168 Q19 4. How do you find information on which City trails to use? Answered: 2,046 Skipped: 295 TOTAL 2,046 Social media Lists of top hiking spots... Word of mouth City website I grew up here/live here Other (please specify) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Social media Lists of top hiking spots on the internet Word of mouth City website I grew up here/live here Other (please specify) B-24 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 25 / 62 Q20 1. Please rank your top general environmental concerns, with 1 being the most concerning: Answered: 2,132 Skipped: 209 44.91% 780 25.73% 447 15.72% 273 7.77% 135 4.15% 72 1.50% 26 0.23% 4 1,737 5.94 18.57% 310 40.38% 674 22.11% 369 12.28% 205 5.03% 84 1.38% 23 0.24% 4 1,669 5.50 18.99% 268 14.03% 198 15.73% 222 17.86% 252 19.28% 272 11.91% 168 2.20% 31 1,411 4.51 20.41% 301 12.95% 191 17.22% 254 14.51% 214 16.61% 245 15.73% 232 2.58% 38 1,475 4.49 16.80% 255 14.95% 227 17.79% 270 16.93% 257 14.23% 216 16.73% 254 2.57% 39 1,518 4.43 4.17% 51 5.39% 66 14.38% 176 17.16% 210 22.79% 279 30.72% 376 5.39% 66 1,224 3.37 21.97% 152 4.19% 29 4.05% 28 3.61% 25 1.73% 12 5.78% 40 58.67% 406 692 2.89 Air pollution Water pollution Extreme weather Food and water Security Natural resource... Sea level rise Other (specify in the field... 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 TOTAL SCORE Air pollution Water pollution Extreme weather Food and water Security Natural resource depletion Sea level rise Other (specify in the field below) B-25 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 26 / 62 Q21 Other concern: Answered: 306 Skipped: 2,035 B-26 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 27 / 62 Q22 2. Please rank your top local environmental concerns, with 1 being the most concerning: Answered: 2,139 Skipped: 202 Ocean/beach pollution Impacts of chemical... Wildfire hazard Health of marine life Port/refinery pollution GHG emissions from... GHG emissions from energy use Sea level rise Idle oil/gas wells Other (specify in the field... 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 B-27 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 28 / 62 35.55% 621 29.54% 516 16.43% 287 8.47% 148 4.75% 83 2.86% 50 1.32% 23 0.63% 11 0.40% 7 0.06% 1 1,747 8 19.99% 318 28.66% 456 21.24% 338 13.83% 220 7.35% 117 3.96% 63 2.33% 37 1.76% 28 0.75% 12 0.13% 2 1,591 8 39.07% 663 11.43% 194 8.90% 151 9.37% 159 6.36% 108 5.30% 90 10.14% 172 5.89% 100 3.24% 55 0.29% 5 1,697 7 7.59% 115 15.91% 241 22.38% 339 20.99% 318 10.43% 158 7.92% 120 6.34% 96 5.48% 83 2.71% 41 0.26% 4 1,515 6 14.74% 217 14.54% 214 12.91% 190 11.96% 176 9.92% 146 7.20% 106 8.36% 123 16.85% 248 2.92% 43 0.61% 9 1,472 6 6.61% 81 8.08% 99 11.51% 141 13.14% 161 21.55% 264 17.39% 213 14.61% 179 5.06% 62 2.04% 25 0.00% 0 1,225 6 1.29% 15 5.61% 65 7.85% 91 8.20% 95 12.34% 143 24.68% 286 19.50% 226 14.24% 165 5.35% 62 0.95% 11 1,159 5 2.14% 24 5.08% 57 11.78% 132 9.01% 101 12.67% 142 9.81% 110 11.33% 127 15.88% 178 19.27% 216 3.03% 34 1,121 4 0.89% 10 3.93% 44 4.38% 49 4.64% 52 6.88% 77 7.95% 89 8.66% 97 15.71% 176 44.29% 496 2.68% 30 1,120 3 9.15% 57 3.53% 22 1.28% 8 0.96% 6 1.77% 11 0.64% 4 0.80% 5 1.12% 7 4.98% 31 75.76% 472 623 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 TOTAL SCO Ocean/beach pollution Impacts of chemical dumping off the coast (eg. DDT, PCBs) Wildfire hazard Health of marine life Port/refinery pollution GHG emissions from transportation GHG emissions from energy use Sea level rise Idle oil/gas wells Other (specify in the field below) B-28 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 29 / 62 Q23 Other concern: Answered: 155 Skipped: 2,186 B-29 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 30 / 62 Q24 3. Which of the following sustainability/conservation programs interest you? (check all that apply) Answered: 2,188 Skipped: 153 Electric vehicle (EV)... Expanded public transit Expanded bicycle/pede... Energy efficiency... Sustainable/dro ught-toleran... Tree planting opportunities Greywater reuse... Home solar incentives E-waste collection... Expanded recycling... Food scraps recycling/co... Other (please specify) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-30 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 31 / 62 41.27% 903 24.73% 541 33.64% 736 46.12% 1,009 49.04% 1,073 39.95% 874 29.80% 652 41.64% 911 57.63% 1,261 51.55% 1,128 27.88% 610 4.02% 88 Total Respondents: 2,188 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Electric vehicle (EV) charging stations/parking spaces Expanded public transit Expanded bicycle/pedestrian amenities Energy efficiency incentives (appliance subsidies, waived permit fees for green building projects, etc.) Sustainable/drought-tolerant landscaping opportunities Tree planting opportunities Greywater reuse opportunities Home solar incentives E-waste collection events Expanded recycling opportunities Food scraps recycling/composting opportunities Other (please specify) B-31 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 32 / 62 69.34%1,316 30.66%582 Q25 4. Do you feel that the City is doing enough to promote sustainability? Answered: 1,898 Skipped: 443 TOTAL 1,898 Yes No 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No B-32 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 33 / 62 Q26 5. If you answered “no” to the previous question, what would you like to see the City do? Answered: 529 Skipped: 1,812 B-33 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 34 / 62 30.18%676 26.74%599 19.87%445 8.21%184 8.13%182 6.88%154 Q27 6. Are you interested in having more of the electricity that powers your home come from renewable sources, such as wind and solar? Answered: 2,240 Skipped: 101 TOTAL 2,240 Interested Very Interested Neither Interested n... Not at all Interested I have a home solar system Not Very Interested 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Interested Very Interested Neither Interested nor Disinterested Not at all Interested I have a home solar system Not Very Interested B-34 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 35 / 62 56.59%1,293 20.53%469 15.45%353 5.78%132 1.66%38 Q28 1. How familiar are you with the current Civic Center Master Plan project? Answered: 2,285 Skipped: 56 TOTAL 2,285 Not at all familiar Slightly Familiar Somewhat Familiar Moderately Familiar Very Familiar 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Not at all familiar Slightly Familiar Somewhat Familiar Moderately Familiar Very Familiar B-35 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 36 / 62 4.67%101 9.19%199 57.97%1,255 23.14%501 5.03%109 Q29 2. Do you favor or oppose the redevelopment of the Civic Center site? Answered: 2,165 Skipped: 176 TOTAL 2,165 Strongly Oppose Oppose Neither Oppose nor Favor Favor Strongly Favor 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Strongly Oppose Oppose Neither Oppose nor Favor Favor Strongly Favor B-36 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 37 / 62 Q30 3. Please select the following the amenities that would likely cause you to visit the Civic Center. (check all that apply) Answered: 2,146 Skipped: 195 Special Event (such as Fou... Public Performances... Hiking Restaurant City Services (e.g. permits) Art, Educational ... Sheriff’s Department... Public Meeting Emergency Operations... Dog Park City Hall (specify) Playground Meet with City Staff Fire Department... Meet with City Council Member Other (please specify) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-37 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 38 / 62 52.66%1,130 50.19%1,077 49.77%1,068 47.20%1,013 41.80%897 36.30%779 30.20%648 28.38%609 25.12%539 24.09%517 22.41%481 20.41%438 19.48%418 18.27%392 13.14%282 4.19%90 Total Respondents: 2,146 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Special Event (such as Fourth of July) Public Performances at Small Amphitheater Hiking Restaurant City Services (e.g. permits) Art, Educational or Historical Exhibit Space Sheriff’s Department Substation Public Meeting Emergency Operations Center Dog Park City Hall (specify) Playground Meet with City Staff Fire Department Station Meet with City Council Member Other (please specify) B-38 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 39 / 62 4.95%112 82.85%1,875 12.20%276 Q31 1. In the past THREE years, have you had difficulty in obtaining and/or maintaining home FIRE insurance? Answered: 2,263 Skipped: 78 TOTAL 2,263 Yes No N/A 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No N/A B-39 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 40 / 62 16.68%354 60.56%1,285 22.76%483 Q32 2. In the past THREE years, has your home FIRE insurance rate increased more than 7% in a one-year period? Answered: 2,122 Skipped: 219 TOTAL 2,122 Yes No N/A 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No N/A B-40 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 41 / 62 Q33 3. Please select the following personal and family preparedness activities that you have done, plan to do in the near future, have not done, or are unable to do. Answered: 2,279 Skipped: 62 B-41 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 42 / 62 Have Done Planning to Do Not Done Not Able to Do Prepared a disaster sup... Developed a household/fa... Saved copies of important... Attended meetings or... Identified neighbors in... 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-42 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 43 / 62 58.66% 1,321 20.34% 458 20.47% 461 0.53% 12 2,252 42.03% 936 26.99% 601 29.95% 667 1.03% 23 2,227 32.43% 718 23.40% 518 40.29% 892 3.88% 86 2,214 35.16% 777 9.10% 201 52.85% 1,168 2.90% 64 2,210 36.08% 796 9.79% 216 50.54% 1,115 3.58% 79 2,206 HAVE DONE PLANNING TO DO NOT DONE NOT ABLE TO DO TOTAL Prepared a disaster supply kit (extra food, water, batteries, cash in small denominations) sufficien Developed a household/family emergency plan? Saved copies of important documents using a “cloud” online storage system? Attended meetings or received information on emergency preparedness? Identified neighbors in your community who may need additional assistance following a disaster? B-43 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 44 / 62 Q34 4. Please select the following actions you have taken in terms of wildfire risk reduction: Answered: 2,185 Skipped: 156 B-44 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 45 / 62 Have Done Planning to Do Not Done Not Able to Do Removed combustible... Removed flammable... Covered vent openings wit... Created a firebreak fo... Replaced wood mulch within... 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% B-45 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 46 / 62 77.21% 1,657 6.62% 142 11.56% 248 4.61% 99 2,146 63.88% 1,335 6.03% 126 19.04% 398 11.05% 231 2,090 54.12% 1,122 10.23% 212 29.09% 603 6.56% 136 2,073 48.91% 1,007 8.21% 169 22.49% 463 20.40% 420 2,059 50.81% 1,030 7.10% 144 31.03% 629 11.05% 224 2,027 HAVE DONE PLANNING TO DO NOT DONE NOT ABLE TO DO TOTAL Removed combustible materials from roof, gutters, decks, base of walls, decks? Removed flammable vegetation or mowed to stubble height of 3 inches for 30 feet around any structure? Covered vent openings with 1/16 to 1/8 inch noncombustible metal mesh screens? Created a firebreak for 100 feet around any structure by clearing, cutting thinning, removing flammable and dead vegetation? Replaced wood mulch within five feet of structures with stone or gravel? B-46 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 47 / 62 39.78%903 60.22%1,367 Q35 1. Do you know about the City’s Neighborhood Security Camera Program? Answered: 2,270 Skipped: 71 TOTAL 2,270 Yes No 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No B-47 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 48 / 62 9.90%222 12.35%277 25.41%570 35.67%800 16.67%374 Q36 2. How likely are you to pay a portion of a cost with your neighborhood/HOA to purchase one or more neighborhood security cameras? Answered: 2,243 Skipped: 98 TOTAL 2,243 Very unlikely Unlikely Neither likely nor unlikely Likely Very likely 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very unlikely Unlikely Neither likely nor unlikely Likely Very likely B-48 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 49 / 62 34.99%789 29.76%671 25.72%580 6.52%147 3.02%68 Q37 3. How satisfied are you with the services provided by the Lomita Sheriff’s Station? Answered: 2,255 Skipped: 86 TOTAL 2,255 Somewhat Satisfied Very Satisfied Neither Satisfied no... Somewhat Dissatisfied Very Dissatisfied 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Somewhat Satisfied Very Satisfied Neither Satisfied nor Dissatisfied Somewhat Dissatisfied Very Dissatisfied B-49 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 50 / 62 Q38 4. With 1 being the most important, please rank the following public safety concerns in order of importance to you: Answered: 2,237 Skipped: 104 61.60% 1,288 22.91% 479 8.03% 168 5.12% 107 2.30% 48 0.05% 1 2,091 5.36 8.33% 163 47.37% 927 23.10% 452 12.06% 236 8.43% 165 0.72% 14 1,957 4.33 23.37% 456 15.79% 308 30.14% 588 14.15% 276 15.43% 301 1.13% 22 1,951 4.14 9.66% 174 11.83% 213 27.76% 500 37.15% 669 12.77% 230 0.83% 15 1,801 3.66 5.89% 98 9.61% 160 13.39% 223 22.52% 375 45.05% 750 3.54% 59 1,665 2.98 8.46% 52 2.60% 16 2.93% 18 5.69% 35 6.50% 40 73.82% 454 615 1.79 Residential Burglaries Vehicle Burglaries/T... Wildfire Hazard Traffic Safety Pedestrian/Bicy cle Safety Other (specify in the field... 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 1 2 3 4 5 6 TOTAL SCORE Residential Burglaries Vehicle Burglaries/Thefts Wildfire Hazard Traffic Safety Pedestrian/Bicycle Safety Other (specify in the field below) B-50 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 51 / 62 Q39 Other concern: Answered: 243 Skipped: 2,098 B-51 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 52 / 62 0.48%11 1.62%37 5.70%130 47.24%1,078 44.96%1,026 Q40 How safe do you feel in your neighborhood during the day? Answered: 2,282 Skipped: 59 TOTAL 2,282 Very Unsafe Unsafe Neither Safe nor Unsafe Safe Very Safe 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Unsafe Unsafe Neither Safe nor Unsafe Safe Very Safe B-52 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 53 / 62 0.92%21 6.54%149 16.23%370 53.99%1,231 22.32%509 Q41 How safe do you feel in your neighborhood during the evening/when it is dark? Answered: 2,280 Skipped: 61 TOTAL 2,280 Very Unsafe Unsafe Neither Safe nor Unsafe Safe Very Safe 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Unsafe Unsafe Neither Safe nor Unsafe Safe Very Safe B-53 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 54 / 62 11.02%249 49.27%1,113 24.79%560 10.40%235 4.52%102 Q42 How safe do you feel your home is when you are out of town? Answered: 2,259 Skipped: 82 TOTAL 2,259 Very Safe Safe Neither Safe nor Unsafe Unsafe Very Unsafe 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Very Safe Safe Neither Safe nor Unsafe Unsafe Very Unsafe B-54 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 55 / 62 8 15,381 2,015 9 17,581 1,987 8 15,471 1,880 7 11,736 1,614 Q43 6. On a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the highest, how would you rate the following public safety services in RPV? Answered: 2,067 Skipped: 274 Total Respondents: 2,067 Law enforcement... Fire services Ambulance/emerg ency medical... RPV Emergency Preparedness 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ANSWER CHOICES AVERAGE NUMBER TOTAL NUMBER RESPONSES Law enforcement services Fire services Ambulance/emergency medical services RPV Emergency Preparedness B-55 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 56 / 62 48.28%1,083 42.35%950 9.36%210 Q44 7. Do you participate in a Neighborhood Watch program? Answered: 2,243 Skipped: 98 TOTAL 2,243 Yes No N/A 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Yes No N/A B-56 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 57 / 62 97.01%2,145 2.99%66 Q45 1. Are you aware of any specific concerns, complaints or problems regarding access for persons with disabilities to any of the programs, services and activities provided by the City? Answered: 2,211 Skipped: 130 TOTAL 2,211 No Yes (please describe) 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES No Yes (please describe) B-57 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 58 / 62 Q46 2. What do you feel is the City’s highest priority to improve accessibility for persons with disabilities? (access to facilities, sidewalks, programs, etc.) Answered: 797 Skipped: 1,544 B-58 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 59 / 62 22.58%481 22.35%476 21.97%468 14.41%307 12.54%267 4.32%92 1.83%39 Q49 Please select your age group: Answered: 2,130 Skipped: 211 TOTAL 2,130 51-60 61-70 71-80 81 and over 41-50 31-40 18-30 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES 51-60 61-70 71-80 81 and over 41-50 31-40 18-30 B-59 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 60 / 62 51.24%1,093 48.01%1,024 0.75%16 Q50 Please select your gender: Answered: 2,133 Skipped: 208 TOTAL 2,133 Female Male Other: 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Female Male Other: B-60 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 61 / 62 19.72%414 1.19%25 62.41%1,310 3.62%76 0.57%12 0.52%11 8.29%174 3.67%77 Q51 Please select your race/ethnicity: Answered: 2,099 Skipped: 242 TOTAL 2,099 Asian Black/African Caucasian Hispanic/Latinx Native American Pacific Islander Prefer not to answer Other: 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Asian Black/African Caucasian Hispanic/Latinx Native American Pacific Islander Prefer not to answer Other: B-61 Rancho Palos Verdes Citizen Satisfaction Survey 62 / 62 18.41%404 17.95%394 20.87%458 14.72%323 16.49%362 11.57%254 Q52 Please indicate how many years you have lived in Rancho Palos Verdes? Answered: 2,195 Skipped: 146 TOTAL 2,195 0-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50 51+ 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES 0-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50 51+ B-62 1 Megan Barnes From:SUNSHINE <sunshinerpv@aol.com> Sent:Monday, January 4, 2021 12:27 PM To:Teresa Takaoka; Jesse Villalpando Cc:CC; imac; EPC Subject:A more specific response to the Satisfaction Survey Hello Jesse and Teri, This is another opportunity to submit suggestions, constructive criticism and to express my dissatisfaction with the quality of the management of the City of Rancho Palos Verdes. Since I have chosen to spend my discretionary time lobbying in favor of preserving and enhancing the semi-rural "quality of life" as described in the City's General Plan, I am sorry to have to report that the quality of the service which City Staff provides has deteriorated and is trending toward getting worse. The most noticeable drop in quality has been in Staff's communications with the public. Staff's statements and reports produce a lot of questions. In of itself, that is a poor business practice. The high Staff turnover is something of an excuse. What is so disconcerting is that Staff does not provide timely and accurate answers. The most common question has become… Who should I ask who will both understand the context of the question and is authorized to provide a clear and factual answer? Even upper Management doesn't seem to know which of their co-workers might have the answers. The new protocol is that Council and Staff no longer ask the people for input before some "deal" has been made. City Planners and City Engineers are not in a position to negotiate what is "appropriate" in any given situation because they are not familiar with how they are each supposed to support the other in order to produce ideal outcomes. A "workshop" when the schematics and/or the draft text has been completed is too late to fix the errors and omissions in an RFP, Grant Application or "Complete" Development Application. That leaves the search for improved day-to-day communications. The City's web site search engine is terrible. The Notify Me program is not maintained nor utilized when appropriate. Staff doesn't even have a template for how to compose a consistently complete "out of office automatic reply email". So, you two are the ones who have been designated to receive this information. RPV has become known as the "Black Hole City Hall" and Ara became known as the "man who speaks with a forked tongue" long before he became our City Manager. I know all this is not your fault. Please do what you may to help your coworkers learn to solicit info from the public in a timely fashion and apply it, so that we all can work together to maintain the expected Paradise level quality of life around here. People, including the City Council, ask questions when they have been "blind-sided". The reason why the people incorporated this City and hired a staff was so that our health, safety and welfare would be provided for within a very strictly defined scope of what is "appropriate development" as opposed to what the County had in mind. It has become very clear that the hired help has taken on a different "vision". At the Federal level that situation is now referred to as the Dark State. At the State of California level, what we have is called a Mommy State billed as saving us from the dastardly mandates of the Dark State. Both RPV and the County are getting stuck with more State mandates to address a variety of "crises" like homelessness. C-1 2 Using the Trails Network Plan as an example, it is still unclear as to whether Staff is not implementing it because Staff is conscientiously and surreptitiously supporting the goals of the Dark State and the Mommy State or that you people are incompetent in the general business side of each of your specific professions. Each of you have been asked specific questions which include… Since your job appears to be only to provide certain information to other Staff Members, the Council and Citizen Advisory Committees, who is the Staff Member who is actually working on presenting recommendations based on said information? I want to know: 1. Who is working with the Fire Department to establish their CRITERIA for fire roads and other disaster mitigation circulation corridors in relation to proposed infrastructure work on both private and City owned property? (Council Action Item.) 2. Who is working with the Public Works Department to assure that the on-going maintenance of existing trails and unpaved roadsides are funded and not deferred? (Public Records Request.) "I'll get back to you" and "Your comment has been included in late correspondence" both mean that the issue is not going to be addressed. I am considering taking the time to put together a log similar to the one which appears in the Weekly Administrative Report which tracks Public Records Requests. Mine will track when Staff tells the Council… "I'll get back to you." "I'll look into it." And, "It will be done by…" Council Goals are a joke. Unless Staff gets directed to spend your time communicating via something besides more "isolated Plans", my log will be an equal exercise in futility. That is my response to the Satisfaction Survey. I would really rather that the money was spent on training Staff about how to write complete notices and keeping records up to date. Oh dear. That is micro-managing and Council has no say in that. I thank you both for trying to respond. If the answers to my two questions are "nobody" at least everybody, including the City Council will know why our City's Budget is balanced on deferred maintenance. May 2021 be a whole lot different than 2000 through 2020 despite the virus crisis. …S C-2 1 Megan Barnes From:Jesse Villalpando Sent:Tuesday, February 9, 2021 11:26 PM To:Megan Barnes Subject:Fwd: survey ended Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Aislin Ard <aislin@gmail.com> Date: January 26, 2021 at 8:23:24 PM PST To: Jesse Villalpando <jvillalpando@rpvca.gov> Subject: survey ended Hi There, The survey ended yesterday! Darn. The only thing I wanted to say was that I wish RPV would move all power lines underground. As we have seen with other communities in California, a hot season plus a sparky or downed powerline can cause a devastating outcome. My street looked into doing this on its own years ago but the power company said it would need more area for it to be "worth it" and our neighborhood couldn't "rally" the hillside. Considering many seniors are far from wanting to take on extra charges it leaves the hill at risk. I believe this should be a top priority for our community's safety. Fires season is only going to become worse unfortunately - any and all things we can do to prevent devastation should be done. Could you forward this note to the appropriate party? Thank you so much, Aislin Ard 3549 Bendigo Drive Rancho Palos Verdes C-3 C-4City of Rancho Palos Verdes 30940 Hawthorne Blvd. RPV, CA 9027 4 27046 Shorewood Rd. Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275 January 20, 2021 Attn: Mr. Jesse Vallalpando Subject: Citizen Satisfaction Survey Dear Sir: I have mailed my survey to the City a while back, but I would offer a supplement if that is allowed? Perhaps my doing the survey in a quiet evening was my mistake, but I did omit my no. 2 problem (and not far behind no. 1 ), which is the infernal everyday noise from home gardeners. In my neighborhood, Silver Spur, everyone has a service gardener, myself included. The noise pollution created travels blocks, so as a result you will hear this noise about 99& 44/1 OOo/o of the time. The machinery, everything gasoline powered, is incessant noise, 6 days a week, 8 to 5 and sometimes later! I live only 11 houses off Hawthorne Blvd, but this noise is 20 decibels worse than traffic! As we move towards a new normal with so many more working at home, we badly need some real noise abatement rules-and then enforcement. Regards. (4J (.._.L Robert Cash