20110329 Late CorrespondenceDec. 21, 2010 RPV City Council mtg.
Councilman Stern moved, seconded by Mayor Long,
to adopt the staff recommendation of Alternate No. 1
to: Temporarily suspend the City's
entitlement process for the proposed Annenberg
Project at Lower Point O/icente for the purpose of
directing Staff to work with the Annenberg
Foundation to submit a formal application to the
National lurk Service (NPS) and the State Office
of Grants and Local Services (OGALS)
in order to obtain their approval of the proposed
Annenberg Foundation project for Lower Point
Vicente.
v
Meet the Goats
City Manager Speaking Points
On Saturday, April 9, the City will hold a fun new recreational activity
at the Point Vicente Interpretive Center: "Meet the Goats"!
The City is currently undergoing its annual fuel modification program
to reduce the risk of wildfires by removing brush and growth in City -
owned open space areas.
A less expensive and more environmentally friendly method of
removing the brush is to use grazing animals, such as goats, to graze
in the open space areas.
On Saturday, April 9, the public will have the opportunity to meet
these hard working goats at the Point Vicente Interpretive Center
from 11 am — 1 pm.
The City consultant and owner of the goats will be present to share
information on the benefits of using goats to clear open space areas.
They will also give a demonstration on how their herding dogs are
used to move the goats.
Finally, participants will get to feed and pet the hard-working goats.
This event is free, and parking will be available at the Point Vicente
Interpretive Center. For more information, please visit the city's
website (www.palosverdes.com/rpv) or call the Recreation and Parks
Department at 310-544-5260.
Bob Golacello on Wallis Annenberg I Style j Vanity Fair Page l of'4
40N n_ ht6-'r16: 71 —,Al- ._Sr PAU.,'1ES SVNHE ,'Y .,ii,? _ ��iP!.i.ES Mt F. vE .. L,.. ..,
CONTINUED PAGE 3 OF 3)
GUARANTEED
G
a �$4
VM ITY FA R
LOW RATE
ONLY
err r
itiStik
IA Give a Gift
Renew
i Questions
40N n_ ht6-'r16: 71 —,Al- ._Sr PAU.,'1ES SVNHE ,'Y .,ii,? _ ��iP!.i.ES Mt F. vE .. L,.. ..,
CONTINUED PAGE 3 OF 3)
Wallis with her sans, Charles, 6regofy,
itl> her children grown and living on their and Rogf.r, at a ..a,arity herrefit at the
Beverly Wilshire i-bi el, t_os Angeles,
own, Wallis decided to give tip her Bevvrly 1984, !D QF_renages 'Vw tesy of Cary L,
Hills mansion --it would eventually be bought by pudnea.
Brad Pitt and JenniferAniston. "I found this
wonderful gated. community, and I love it," she says, sitting in the library of icer two-story
villa in Century Woods, an exelasivecondominium development adjacent to Century City.
"I can walls to Work. I can walk my dogs in the morning in my bathrobe and leave my doter
unlocked. Howmany people can live like this without being stuck in the desert or at some
resort?"
The house is elegant but comfortable, with a mix of English, Art Deco, and modern
furniture and an impressive collection of photographs—l-lehuut Newton, Philippe
11alsmmn, Jacques I-l.enr'i I,artigue, Bruce, Weber, Peter Beard, Irving Penn. She especially
lovas Berenice .Abbott s picture of a newsstand in 1935. "It reminds me of my grandfather.,"
she says. "You can see the Daily Racing Form —10 cents," David Fahey, the leading Los
Angeles photography dealer, says, "She goes for the powerful images. A lot of collectors
stay in one particular niche or genre, but she likes phot6ourrtalism, she likes fashion, she
likes young contemporary photographers and classic loth -century images."
wal@I6with one of her three. lu?altfse to lrc rt. 7f a 2007,"Work fieaturlog the actress Monica Belloca by
photographer Berdoar Rheims. Photgpar,ii hy,lonathx, C>ecke;.
RECEIVED PROM
As Wallis and I talk, California attorney general Jerry Brown, the ons£ and possibly future AND MADE A PART OF TH C RD AT
Democratic governor of the state, arrives for. a quick drink on his way to dinner. He COUNCIL MEETING OFi�%
explains that the Annenberg Foundation is supporting a public charter school for the arts OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
in Oakland, which he started when he was mayor of that city. "Wallis gave a very CARLA MORREALE, CITY CLERK
substantial donation to move it into a restored 1928 movie palace this year. And we didn't FghlC CVW4
11ttp://www.vanityfair.cotnlstvlolfeaturegl?OOQI'If1/cx"all;C,—n"+-1,---. nnnlnn-- - .,., —
G
J
Wallis with her sans, Charles, 6regofy,
itl> her children grown and living on their and Rogf.r, at a ..a,arity herrefit at the
Beverly Wilshire i-bi el, t_os Angeles,
own, Wallis decided to give tip her Bevvrly 1984, !D QF_renages 'Vw tesy of Cary L,
Hills mansion --it would eventually be bought by pudnea.
Brad Pitt and JenniferAniston. "I found this
wonderful gated. community, and I love it," she says, sitting in the library of icer two-story
villa in Century Woods, an exelasivecondominium development adjacent to Century City.
"I can walls to Work. I can walk my dogs in the morning in my bathrobe and leave my doter
unlocked. Howmany people can live like this without being stuck in the desert or at some
resort?"
The house is elegant but comfortable, with a mix of English, Art Deco, and modern
furniture and an impressive collection of photographs—l-lehuut Newton, Philippe
11alsmmn, Jacques I-l.enr'i I,artigue, Bruce, Weber, Peter Beard, Irving Penn. She especially
lovas Berenice .Abbott s picture of a newsstand in 1935. "It reminds me of my grandfather.,"
she says. "You can see the Daily Racing Form —10 cents," David Fahey, the leading Los
Angeles photography dealer, says, "She goes for the powerful images. A lot of collectors
stay in one particular niche or genre, but she likes phot6ourrtalism, she likes fashion, she
likes young contemporary photographers and classic loth -century images."
wal@I6with one of her three. lu?altfse to lrc rt. 7f a 2007,"Work fieaturlog the actress Monica Belloca by
photographer Berdoar Rheims. Photgpar,ii hy,lonathx, C>ecke;.
RECEIVED PROM
As Wallis and I talk, California attorney general Jerry Brown, the ons£ and possibly future AND MADE A PART OF TH C RD AT
Democratic governor of the state, arrives for. a quick drink on his way to dinner. He COUNCIL MEETING OFi�%
explains that the Annenberg Foundation is supporting a public charter school for the arts OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
in Oakland, which he started when he was mayor of that city. "Wallis gave a very CARLA MORREALE, CITY CLERK
substantial donation to move it into a restored 1928 movie palace this year. And we didn't FghlC CVW4
11ttp://www.vanityfair.cotnlstvlolfeaturegl?OOQI'If1/cx"all;C,—n"+-1,---. nnnlnn-- - .,., —
Bob Colacello on Wallis Annenberg I Style I Vanity Fair
. ��
"She's open to evelything."
have to go through a lot of
paperwork, which was great.
Based on this experience, I
would say the creativity of the
school was matched by the
creativity of the donor."
Our next stop is dinner at
Spago with Betsy
Bloomingdale's son Robert and
his wife, Justine. The
Annenberg Foundation
supports an organization that
Justine is deeply committed to,
the Ojai Foundation's Council
project, which works, to turn
around the lives of Timer -city
kids. "Wallis spends her entire
day giving money to things that
you wouldn't expect her to,"
says Robert Bloomingdale.
I"nard Aube, the executive director of the Annenberg roundation, sitting in its sleek, art -
filled headquarters on a high floor of a Ck-ntmy City tower, says, "Wallies approach to
philanthropy is to look for vision -driven leaders. If you're doing something in the
community; and you're exceptional, like Geoffrey Canada, with the Harlem Children's
?,one, she's going to support you. If you're a world-class marine biologist, Eke Dr. Roger
Payne, who discovered that humpback whales sing, and you want to save an 1863 Paint
factory in Gloucester, Massachusetts, so you can move the Ocean Alliance headquarters
into it, she's going to support that."
"Jane Goodall, Jerry Brown, Geoff Canada, Steven Spielberg with the Sboah Foundation—
they'm the real heroes," says Wallis. "Nothing can get done without these people. And
that's what I'm supporting. their vision." Two other "visionaries" she cites are Ernest
Wilson 111, the new dean of the Annenberg School for Communication at U.S.C., and
LAc4iA director Michael Govan,The day Wilson's appointment was publicly announced,
she pledged a $i million grant from the foundation and told him, he says, "it was start-up
money to do some exciting things.' Likewise, almost immediately after Govan was hired,
in 2000, she gave the museum an exploratory giant of $2 million for his pet pixrject: the
Installation of a i 7o -foot -high Jeff Koons sculpture of a locomotive hanging from a crane
in front of the museum, which Govan sees as Los Angeles's Eiffel'lower. She has since had
second thoughts, however, and says she will leave it to other trustees to fund the $25
million project. "I personally think Los Angeles deserves a much finer icon than a train
banging fimorn a crane," says Wallis, "and when the. Vernon Collection came up, I thought,
This is where my heart is." She adds, "I think the world of Michael. Hes doing quite a job."
rVwo years before her father died, Wallis tells me, she suggested to him that they open
I an office on the West Coast. "lie thought it was a marvelous idea. It had never
occurred to him. And so it happened." She also persuaded him to include her three
children as trustees. "It was very importan t for me to bring their perspectives and interests
into the foundation. And I never wanted my children to wait for me to slip on a banana
peel" Wallis notes that in the, lbundation'-, governing documents her father specified that
in perpetuity only his direct descendants could be trustees, with the single exception of
1A*e.
Wallis's daughter, Lauren Bon, a graduate of Princeton and M.I.T. and a multi -media
artist, has initiated foundation projects that combine Earth Art with socially conscious
Page 2 of 4
http://www.vanityfair.com/stylei'features/2009/1 0/wallis-annenberg20091 O?currentPage=3 11/3/2010
t5ob colacelto on Wallis Annenberg I Style I Vanity Fair
k I I t.
environmentalism. Gregory, a painter who lives with his family in Paris, has channeled his
interest,; in the arts and "global well-being" through more traditional organizations, such
as the World Monuments Fund and the American Friends of the Paris Opera & Ballet. {Itis
mother, an Obama supporter, thought he would have made the perfect American
ambassador to France.) The youngest sibling, Charles, a filmmaker with degrees fix)m
Duke and U.S.C., has expanded the foundation's activities to Africa, Asia, and the Middle
East, supporting everything from the, Anwu School for underpri4eged children in rural
China to the Rescue Foundation for female victims of human trafficking in India.
"This generation is saying the foundation is about the power of communication," says
Leonard Aube, who was the fust employee hired by Wallis, in late 2003, "It's about getting
people together to discuss touchy issues, progressive issues—whatever it is, let's get people
together. So ifs been an amazing time, because they have had to learn, all this. Frankly, it
was a blank canvas—there wasn't any framework in plate when the ambassador passed
away. All of a sudden, Wallis was in a leadership role, without any experience of being a
leader, We had our first board meeting a month after I started. We. are incredibly
unorthodox. In most foundations, the boardroom is the hallowed place, where the trustees
convene in private. Well, in our shop theres a no -foot plate -glass window that looks into
the boardroom—it's wide open. And this is Wallis—everybody who works, at the
Annenberg Foundation attends board meetings, regardless of rank, including the
receptionist."
When I ask Wallis which of the foundation's hundreds of projects are closest to her beart,
she names the Universally -Accessible 1—mvhouse, designed to accommodate handicapped
people, in Torrance, California. "I had read that Paul Nex+man had done this at his camp
for children in Connecticut, and I said, 'We're going to do this in LA.'I think one of the
most moving days of my life was when I got to push the first child, a young man about 12
years old, in a wheelchair, up that ranip.
"I want to do the Mayo Clinic for companion animals," she continues. "The idea is to teach
mle a reverence for animals and to tie it in to the local ecology and environment. After
two years of negotiations, we have a magnificent piece of land in Rancho Palos Verdes."
,Officially called the Annenberg Project at WWel' Point Vicente, the 20 -acre oceanfront site
will include a model adoption center for cats and dogs. "I call it m-
y last hurrah, but who
knows? My father used to say that about every project he ever did. And it was never his
last hurrah."
No one believes this will be hers, either. In fact, next year the foundation will launch a
project called Alchenky, a leadership-df.-velopment-and-training; initiative for nonprofit
executives and volunteer leaders. And ground has already been broken on a visitors' center
adjacent to Sunnylands-, which will be open to the public for architectural tours and will
also serve as, a high -leve] retreat for world leaders, much as it did while Walter and Lee
Annenberg were alive. The 202 -acre, pink -walled estate evil] be administered by the
Annentwrg Trust at Sunnylau&. Wallis and her three children sit on that board along with
Lees daughters froom her first two marriages, Diane Deshong and Elizabeth Kabler, and
their children. Family friends wonder how this will work out, given that Wallis iv&s
noticeably absent at the service her stepsisters held for their mother at Sunnylands. She
told me she is also not planning on attending the special tribute to Lee at Philadelphia's
Academy of Music on September 24, which will have Prince Charles and George H. W. and
Barbara Bush as honorary co -hosts. Of her late stepmother, Wallis now says., "She lived a
wonderful rife. I wish it on all of us—to live to 91 and experience all that she did. She and
my father were a true love match. And she was a hell of a golfer."
Bob PAlacello is, a Kwiy Fah .,peuaf mie,,pondent.
keywords
SM -E, SOCIETY, BOB COLACELLO
Page 3 of 4
http://www.vanityfair.com/style/features/2009/1 O/wallis-annenberg2OO9l O?currentPage=3 11/3/2010
PRESERVING LAND AND RESTORING HABITAT FOR THE EDUCATION AND ENJOYMENT OF ALL
March 8, 2006
Mrs. Wallis Annenberg
The Annenberg Foundation
Center West, Suite 1605
10877 Wilshire Boulevard
Los Angeles, CA 90024
Dear Mrs. Annenberg,
On behalf of the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy and the City of Rancho
Palos Verdes,# am pleased to submit the attached application for grant funding to
create a Vision Plan for the coastal and Preserve areas of Rancho Palos Verdes.
This effort for which we are seeking support will be a remarkable opportunity for a
coastal city to do regional planning at a critical point in its history. The planning
effort will make a real difference to the community's future, and will provide
benefits to numerous community organizations and user groups. You will atm+
that this process will Provide the City with the o ortunit r to consider locating an Y
ianima edu atfon and rescue center on the Lower Point Vicente site.
The Land Conservancy is applying to be the recipient of the grant, but will work
very closely with the City and the community throughout the process. Melani
Smith, of Melendrez, will take the lead on the effort and will produce the resulting
plans and documents. We expect that Ron Yeo will serve as the architect for the
effort, providing advice and input as needed.
We very much appreciate your support for the creation of the Portuguese Bend
Nature Preserve. Your donation was a critical factor in the community's successful
effort to raise the funds needed to purchase the land that is at the heart of the
Portuguese Bend Nature Preserve on the south side of the Peninsula. Thanks to
your support, we are able to leave a legacy of permanent natural open space for the
people of Palos Verdes and the Los Angeles basin.
We look forward to continuing to work with you on this exciting project. Thank
you for your consideration.
:IVED FROM k—ffld C1"M !U&
MADE A PART OF THE CRD AT
NCIL MEETING OF 163
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
CARLA MORREALE, CITY CLERK
2010 -BANE PRA00040
916 SILVER SPUR ROAD #108, ROLLING HILLS ESTATES, CA 44274-3826 T 310.341.761?. F 310.541.7623 WWW.PVPLC.ORG
Compania Education Facility
Project Meeting #2
January 22, 2009 9:00 a.m.
ITEM DESCA=ON ACTION
Tricia said she doesn't believe a new project must accept offsite storm drainage like Terranea, Carry
and the large storm drain carrying offsite drainage shouldn't be an issue for this project. Ara
also stated Terranea storm drainage was intermixing with the offsite drainage and that was why
that project needed to account for the offsite drainage as well.
Patrick mentioned the Compania project could get a LEED Innovation point for cleaning the
offsite storm drainage that passed through its site, but also believed the foundation might want
to consider doing it simply because it is the right thing to do, and shows the community a
commitment to the environment.
2.13 Building Entrance
The building entrance was discussed and the Project Team should be focused toward one Carry
entrance. One of the next studies for the design team is to consider how to make the PVIC
(entrance), outdoor epic portal and Compania (entrance) work together.
A separate interior space that leads to entering the building was brought up.
The buildings need to respond together with each other to tie the entire site together.
2.14 Theatre Modification
In order to accommodate the City of Rancho Palos Verdes City Council in the auditorium, the Carry
design team needs to continue to look at ways to enlarge the theatre to take advantage of a
more appropriate size crowd (150 —175 seating capacity range).
2.15 Bereavement
Bereavement program must be immediate, dealing with problem and proximity. The Project Carry
Team needs to think about the feelings one would have in this moment and how to incorporate
this space into the design.
2.16 7rustee Facilities
Leonard ty
explained the Project Team needs to design trustee facilities (Wallis Annenberg's Car
executive suiteand a trustee meeting room) in the building and to the standards and
xpectations of Wallis and the Trustees.
2.17 Outdoor Program Infrastructure
The project should include a permanent infrastructure for other facilities (i.e., aquariums, birds, Carry
etc.) when they come to visit for daily programs. Indoor infrastructure in the theatre as well as
outdoor must be considered.
6 1 P a a e
2010 -BANE PRA02087
The Annenberg Project at Lower Point Vicente
Project Meeting #5
March 11 & 12, 2009
1NI DESCRIPTION AMON
and approaches for the multiple use conditions in order to shape the next architectural step.
2.15 Bereavement
Bereavement program must be immediate, dealing with problem and proximity. The Project Carry
Team needs to think about the feelings one would have in this moment and how to incorporate
this space into the design.
2.16 Trustee Facilities
Leonard explained the Project Team needs to design trustee facilities (Wallis Annenberg's
executive suite and a trustee meeting room) in the building and to the standards and
expectations of Wallis and the Trustees.
3/11/09: Leonard indicated the need for a catering prep area adjacent to the Trustee
Conference/Board Room.
e
Leonard also indicated a second elevator must be considered because it is unrealistic to have
catering and deliveries come up the elevator adjacent to the Theatre and through the facility t
the Trustee/Admin areas. This elevator must also be designed more than simply a service
elevator, as it would more than likely be the elevator Wallis and the trustees would use to get to
their spaces.
2.17 Outdoor Program Infrastructure
GMA
4/16/09
The project should include a permanent infrastructure for other facilities (i.e., aquariums, birds, MDRZ
etc.) when they come to visit for daily programs. Indoor infrastructure in the theatre as well as
outdoor must be considered. GMA
Outdoor,OpVhitheat "riii—gh -e—& sider seating for all types from primary school 4/16/09
child 'to Wallis and a few of her friends. Project Team needs to think about the noise to
the com I les To—c-aUff
3/11/09: With the concept that the building dissolves into the landscape, the project team
determined additional thought must be given to the current design concept surrounding the
outdoor amphitheatre (i.e. concrete seating vs. some type of landscaped terrace seating).
2.19 User Experience
Project Team to sub -divide the user experience into specific user groups and their needs. Carry
Consultecon will take the first pass and present to Leonard at the next project meeting.
9 1 Fla, a e
2010 -BANE PRA02105
The Annenberg Project at Lower Point Vicente
Project Meeting #8
June 3, 2009
'ITEM DESCRIPTION ACTION
Rancho Palos Verdes. Therefore, in regards to the lease agreement required between the City
and CompaNia, the County of Los Angeles will not be involved.
Additionally, Howard indicated he would follow up with the appropriate action to have separate
planning process language in the lease agreement since it is a partnership with RPV (similar to
the 415 project). The upcoming diner with city officials will touch on project goals and
requirements for lease discussions.
6/3109: Howard indicated a draft Memo of Understanding (MOU) is anticipated to be sent out
from the Annenberg Council any day.
e
2.3 Project Vision
Leonard explained the project vision from The Annenberg Foundation's perspective to the team. Info
The end result of this facility is expected to be the model animal care facility in the nation if not
in the world, where visitors can walk away with a compelling experience. Leonard explained the
project should establish a different paradigm for this type of complex at every conceivable level.
The value of the experience at Compahia should be different than the current model where
these types of facilities are isolated and pushed to the outer edges of society. The bar has been
set very high in order to challenge the Project Team to work toward establishing a new set of
national standards (i.e., Compahia Certification) for future duplication. Everything about this
project is to be about learning and education, making available the systems and experiences,
both indoor and outdoor. Compaflia should be a destination connecting the companion animal
experience and education with humanity.
I Leonard stressed one of the significant design challenges Will be to integrate the facility into the
community of Rancho Palos Verdes while also creating an environment where students will feel
C
motivated. Joel also pointed out the community is looking for something that doesn't
v
IOerwhelm the site or the existing PVIC.
Leonard also stressed this facility should embrace The Annenberg Foundation's Trustees' values
�onnims ) accessibility, diversity, swift responsiveness, responsibility to community, honoring
t,5e .acv a,
t e legacy and historic investments on site, attention to detail, as well as the first class gold
standard the foundation represents.
Lastly, the expectations from the Foundation are that every member of the Project Team brings
their very best to the table, to dare to imagine outside of the box and believe that nothing is
impossible.
2.4 Compahla Identity
Leonard explained Lower Point Vicente has a unique ambiance, and one of the obligations of Info
this Project Team is to design Compaiiia as a place set apart, yet connected. Although the
5 1 P aa e
2010 -BANE PRA02184
The Annenberg Project at Lower Point Vicente
Project Meeting #8
June 3, 2009
ITEM DESCRIPTION
ACTION
F p"
1. Leonard will be at the Compaffia project office on Wednesdays. Info
2. The design consultants will be meeting in the coming weeks. Location and time will be worked Info
out with the design team members.
3. Project Meeting #9 targeted for 6130/09 at the project office. Time and date will be confirmed Info
by Howard.
2.1 Team Communications Slog & FTP Site
Storyline has established the private monitored Team Communications Slog. Tim will be the SS
moderator and he will send out invitations to join. Users will simply need a Google ID to gain
access. Any other individuals which will require access (i.e. other consultants as they come on 6/30/09
board) will need to have their email address provided to Tim so he can send out an invitation.
An FTP site still needs to be setup to handle large files. If Peter with The Annenberg
Foundation doesn't establish an FTP site in the next week, Howard has given Storyline direction
to setup the FTP site.
3/12/09: Joel indicated the RPV attorney confirmed the Team Communications Slog is not
public information since it is being maintained on a private site. Therefore, the blog would not
be required to be disclosed by RPV if a request for project information was submitted by the
public.
6/3/09: Various items have been added to the blog and FTP site, including the survey and soils
report. Julie Beckman requested an invitation to the blog, and Tim to follow up.
2.2 Letter of Authorization/Notice to Proceed
Howard stated Compahia LLC will be sending out letters of authorization to direct consultants to GCC
move forward with design development, as well as authorization to submit invoices for work 6/30/09
performed.
3/12109: Patrick to follow up on 2"d Tier GMA sub -consultant letters of authorization (LOA).
Tracking the status of remaining LOA not in place will be carried in specific meeting items
below.
6/3/09: All LOA's have been issued. Now that the project is moving forward the contract process
can begin and consultant contracts should be forthcoming in June and July.
21 Page.
2010 -BANE PRA02181
The Annenberg Project at Lower Point Vicente
Project Meeting #10
August 12, 2009
MEM RESCRIPTIP& ACTION
I. INFORMA77ON ITEMS:
I. Leonard will be at the Compafila project office on Wednesdays. Info
2, Joel introduced the City of RPV Public Works senior engineer Nicole Jules to the project team. Info
3, 1313G indicated a post card mailer has been created introducing the community to the project Info
and will be mailed to 60,000 residents In Rancho Palos Verdes. Additionally BBG indicated the
City of RPV and The Annenberg Foundation websites have been updated with new material of
this planned project.
4. RPV requested the PVIC Phase 3 Improvements projects be renamed to the PVIC Parking Lot Info
Expansion Project.
5. Schematic design presentation for Leonard is scheduled from 11-2prn on 8/26/09. Info
6. Jackie requested Bills presence at the 9/9/09 meeting the foundation is holding with the Info
docents at PVIC.
11. BUSINESS / OPERATIONS:
2.1 Team Communications Slog & FTP Site
Storyllne has established the private monitored Team Communications Blog. Tim will be the Carry
moderator and he will send out invitations to join. Users will simply need a Google ID to gain
access. Any other individuals which will require access (i.e. other consultants as they come on
board) will need to have their email address provided to Tim so he can send out an invitation,
An FTP site still needs to be setup to handle large files. If Peter with The Annenberg
Foundation doesn't establish an FTP site in the next week, Howard has given Storyline direction
to setup the FTP site.
6/3/09: Various
A have been added to the blog and FTP site, including the survey and soils
report. u e eckmaWrequested an invitation to the bf99,,.and ,Tin t9_allow up
8/12/09: SS will add Nicole Jules to the Team Communications Blog. f
"A
2.2 Letter of Authorization/Notice to Proceed
1.
Howard stated Compahia LLC will be sending out letters of authorization to direct consultants to Carry
move forward with design development, as well as authorization to submit invoices for work
performed.
6/3/09. All LOA'S have been issued. Now that the project Is moving forward the contract
process can begin and consultant contracts should be forthcoming in June and July.
2 1
2010 -BANE PRA02247
FWJM,
The Annenberg Project at Lower Point Vicente
Project Meeting #5
March 11 & 12, 2009
3/12/09: Patrick is to complete the OPPI application.
4.3 Branding
ACTION
3/19/09
Leonard stated a temporary name and logo would be used at this time (The Annenberg Project AF
at Lower Point Vicente). Jackie also stated there will be continued discussions about branding
of the project, the site, and further work out into the city following an upcoming meeting with 4/16/09
the city council and staff.
5.1 Project Schedule
Patrick indicated the current preliminary schedule reflects the timeline contained within the EIR GCC
Consultant RFP as well as newly added AF facility operations activities, in addition to the
assumption the Plan Check would1run concurrently with the EIR development. 4/16/09
Further discussion with RPV indicated the planning entitlement process can run concurrent with
the EIR. Patrick also suggested the project team explore all opportunities for accelerating the
schedule. These might include accelerating the design of the 'primary application" documents.
However, the most positive opportunity to accelerate the schedule would be to have the PVIC
Phase 3 Improvements project proceed, and reduce that scope of work currently contained in
the CompaAia project.
The desire would be for the construction for the PVIC Phase 3 Improvements project to
complete and dovetail into the start of the construction for the Compaffia project.
5.2 Lease Agreement AF
Joel indicated the original lease agreement between the City of Rancho Palos Verdes and the 3/23/09
County of Los Angeles in 1977 was for 50 years. However, as a result of the lead mitigation
during the PVIC expansion the County transferred ownership of the property to the City of
Rancho Palos Verdes. Therefore, in regards to the lease agreement required between the City
and Compaffia, the County of Los Angeles will not be involved.
Additionally, Howard indicated he would follow up With the appropriate action to have separate
planning process language in the lease agreement sipae-44 a partnership with RPV (similar to
the 415 project). The upcoming diner with �f,'c2i
�!city 11 touch on project goals and
requirements for lease —diss'-
'cussion---------(-
Al
fi 919
4 1 Pa g e
E PRA02100
The Annenberg Project at Lower Point Vicente
Project Meeting #5
March 11 & 12, 2009
ITEM I&SCRIPTLON
2.6 Whale of a Day
Whale of a Day is the largest civic event in Rancho Palos Verdes and Leonard stated the info
foundation did not want this project to hold off this event more than one year. Leonard also
challenged the Project Team to consider designing an infrastructure which would help support
this event (ie., food servicelhospitality hookups for food vendors, electrical outlets for inflatable
jumpers and non-profit vendor booths, etc.). The goal is to surpass what the current
community expectation might be with the addition of Compafiia. The design development
should also include flat areas, wet areas, etc.
The event is only one day now, but it could become more of a weekend experience if the
infrastructure and design is thought out carefully.
Additionally Jackie mentioned large vehicles (i.e. fire trucks) would be on display.
2/26/09: The 2009 event is scheduled for 3/7/09. Several team members are planning to
attend and will report on their findings.
3/11/09: Stuart provided a slide show of the 2009 event. Team members that attended
indicated the event appeared to be an overall success. Those that had not attended before got
a real indication how important it is to the local community, as well as a firsthand understanding
how the Compaflia project design can enhance the experience (i.e. infrastructure, parking, etc.).
2.21 Process/Approvals
Leonard is Wallis Annenberg's proxy on regular updates and project approvals will be given Drop
directly by Leonard. Leonard will be at the project office every Wednesday so it will be a good
time to get his audience then.
Existing Farm Lease
The City of RPV is to contact the farm lease holder to discuss the project and possible next RPV
steps.
3/17/00
Additionally, Storyline indicated Japanese farming in the area is a mpel ing exhibit story's
3/12/09: Joel indicated they have not made contact but it is in the works because the project
team discussed several actions that will be occurring on site soon (i.e. soil investigation borings,
EIR Consultant RFP pre-bid meeting, survey work, etc.)
4.2 Insurance
Patrick is pursuing Owner requirements. Patrick requested design consultants forward full limits GCC
of their existing insurance if they had not done so already,
31 Page
2010 -BANE PRA02099
LI
oRk.s.- RANCHO PALOS VERDES
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: CITY CLERK
DATE: MARCH 29, 2011
SUBJECT: ADDITIONS/REVISIONS AND AMENDMENTS TO
AGENDA**
Attached are revisions/additions and/or amendments to the agenda material presented
for tonight's meeting:
Item No.
City Manager Report
2
Respectfully submitted,
I W/4 et
Carla Morreale
Description of Material
Annenberg Project Status Update from Staff
Email from: Stella and Russell La Rose
** PLEASE NOTE: Materials attached after the color page were submitted through
Monday, March 28, 2011**.
W:\AGENDA\2011 Additions Revisions to agendas\20110329 additions revisions to agenda.doc
From: Ara M [aram@rpv.com]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 10:12 AM
To: CC@rpv.com
Cc: clehr@rpv.com; 'Carolynn Petru'; 'Carol W. Lynch'; joelr@rpv.com; 'Ara M'
Subject: Annenberg Project Status Update
Dear Mayor Long and Members of the City Council,
As you know, pursuant to Council direction at the December 21, 2010 meeting, City Staff and the
Annenberg Foundation have been working on an application for the proposed Annenberg project for
submittal to OGALS. While City Staff has kept the Council Sub -committee updated on the progress of
the application preparation, City Staff would like to now update the entire Council and the public on the
application status. As such, the following message will be posted on the City's website (under the
Annenberg homepage) and will be sent out to list -serve subscribers later today. Additionally, the
message below will be announced at tonight's Council meeting under the City Manager's Report.
Ara
P.S. In order to avoid any potential Brown Act violations, please do not reply to all.
PROJECT UPDATE ON THE APPLICATION SUBMITTAL TO OGALS AND NPS
On December 21, 2010, the City Council suspended the local entitlement process and directed Staff to work with the Annenberg Foundation to submit a
formal application to the National Park Service (NPS) and the State Office of Grants and Local Services (OGALS) in order to obtain their approvals for the
proposed Annenberg Foundation project at Lower Point Vicente. Since that time, City Staff have been in contact with OGALS to be clear on the application
submittal process and have coordinated with the Annenberg Foundation on the application preparation. While City Staff has kept the Annenberg Project City
Council Sub -Committee of Councilmen Stern and Campbell updated on the status of the application, Staff recognizes that there has not been an update on
the application status to the general public or City Council in a while. Therefore, an update on the status of the application is now being provided.
Based on feedback from OGALS on the available application categories, an application is being prepared for a "Public Facility Request." This type of
application will request that OGALS and NPS approve the proposed Annenberg project as a "public facility" exception to the existing recreational open space
restrictions at Lower Point Vicente. According to OGALS, the processing steps for this type of application are as follows:
1. Informal consultation on certain components of the proposed Public Facility Request application between City Staff, the Annenberg Foundation,
OGALS and NPS;
2. Based on informal feedback from OGALS and NPS, preparation of a Draft Application by City Staff/Annenberg Foundation along with preparation
of the necessary California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and the National Environmental Protection Act (NEPA) analysis of the Draft
Application by City Staff;
3. Public comment period on the CEQA/NEPA analysis of the Draft Application;
4. Submittal of the Final Application and completed CEQA/NEPA analysis by the City to OGALS and commencement of a public comment period on
the Final Application; and,
5. Formal decision on the application by OGALS and NPS.
At this time, City Staff together with the Annenberg team are still in the informal consultation process stage noted above (step 1). Based on collective informal
feedback on the proposed application, a Draft Application will be prepared and Staff will prepare a CEQA/NEPA environmental analysis of the Draft
Application. The draft application and associated CEQA/NEPA document will be released for public comment before formal submittal to the State. As such,
the public will have an opportunity to comment on the Draft Application as part of the CEQA/NEPA review process before the Final Application is submitted to
the State. At this time, Staff expects the public CEQA/NEPA review process to take place later this Spring with submittal of the Formal Application to the
State in early summer.
Ara Michael Mihranian
Deputy Director of Community Development
City of Rancho Palos Verdes
1 0 F ;`
3/29/2011 P-0(2
30940 Hawthorne Blvd.
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275
310-544-5228 (telephone)
310-544-5293 (fax)
aram@rpv.com
www.palosverdes.com/rpv
`AW Do you really need to print this e-mail?
This e-mail message contains information belonging to the City of Rancho Palos Verdes, which may be privileged, confidential and/or protected from disclosure. The
information is intended only for use of the individual or entity named. Unauthorized dissemination, distribution, or copying is strictly prohibited. If you received this
email in error, or are not an intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately. Thank you for your assistance and cooperation.
a of a
3/29/2011
Page 1 of 1
From: Carolynn Petru [carolynn@rpv.com]
Sent: Monday, March 28, 2011 4:59 PM
To: 'Matt Waters'
Subject: FW: Shakespeare by the Sea Performances
Hi Matt —
FYI
From: Russell LaRose [mailto:russlarose@verizon.net]
Sent: Thursday, March 24, 201110:19 AM
To: cc@rpv.com
Subject: Shakespeare by the Sea Performances
As long time residents of Rancho Palos Verdes, we have always found life on the Peninsula gracious
and rewarding.
One of the rewards is annual attendance of free 'Shakespeare by the Sea' performances every year.
Appreciation of the arts is in keeping with the life-style of your constituents, and since this is a
completely non-profit organization that has given so much pleasure to so many, we hope that you can
find a small amount from the city budget —they are only asking for $500 - $1,000 per performance to
help enable them to perform at Terranea and Hesse Park.
Lately there has been so much public contentions between City Hall and local residents, this is one
thing you can do to garner some good will and be known as patrons of the arts, and enable us to take
pride in our community.
Please give the matter careful consideration. Thank you. Stella and Russell LaRose, 6111 Arrowroot
Lane, Rancho Palos Verdes
3/28/2011
�a
L 14
RANCHO PALOS VERDES
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
FROM: CITY CLERK
DATE: MARCH 28, 2011
SUBJECT: ADDITIONS/REVISIONS AND AMENDMENTS TO
AGENDA
Attached are revisions/additions and/or amendments to the agenda material received
through Monday afternoon for the Tuesday, March 29, 2011 City Council meeting:
Item No. Description of Material
2 Emails from: Sharon Yarber; Ann Shaw; Renee Cartwright;
Lynn Swank
Respectfully submitted,
Carla Morreale
W:WGENDA\2011 Additions Revisions to agendas\20110329 additions revisions to agenda through Monday afternoon.doc
From: sharon yarber [momofyago@gmail.com]
Sent: Friday, March 25, 2011 2:41 PM
To: cc@rpv.com
Cc: Carolyn Lehr
Subject: CC Mtg. 3/29/11
Gentlemen:
I am writing to evidence my support for the expenditures, subject to the terms and provisions outlined on the
agenda, for the items set forth in Agenda Items 2 (1) through (3), inclusive. I would like to know the identity of the
proposed grant recipients set forth in item 2 (4), but assume they are all worthy recipients and would likely support
the granting of up to $60,000 to them as well, consistent with past City grant practices.
Thank you,
Sharon Yarber
3/28/2011
From: ANN SHAW [anndshaw@msn.com]
Sent: Friday, March 25, 2011 3:44 PM
To: Matt Waters; RPV Council
Cc: Jarel Wheaton; Al and Kathy Edgerton; maryann Rimoin
Subject: RE: City grant requests
Thank you so much for sending the staff report regarding our grant request.
Jarel Wheaton noticed, and called to my attention, that the city is also recommending a one-time capital contribution of up to
$80,000 to the Peninsula High School Pool renovation project with the condition (among others) that the City enter into a
joint use agreement with the PVPSD to allow the City to use the pool for recreational programs. Should such an agreement
come to fruition we would strongly recommend that the City consider a water aerobics class. We would be happy to publicize
it to our membership and work with the City to make it a success.
Several years ago Peninsula Seniors participated in a water aerobics program using the pool at the Marriot in Torrance.
Unfortunately the program was terminated by the Marriot because of insurance concerns. This program was very popular
with a great number of our members and was sorely missed when it was ended. As I remember, members signed up and
paid for a six-month program which was fairly expensive. We often had a waiting list of people who wanted to participate. It
is excellent exercise for many, especially seniors, who find other forms of exercise too taxing.
I plan to be at the meeting on the 29th.
Ann
From: mattw@rpv.com
To: mayna25@msn.com; rmiller675@aol.com; jfarber@vfnet.com; blueeye@charter.net; jhessick@pvldfriends.org;
weekslh@cox.net; anndshaw@msn.com; nlmahr@verizon.net; dciminera@cox.net; keri@palosverdeschamber.com;
lisa@shakespearebythesea.org; laurie@shawlwomenshouse.org; janandjerald@cox.net; jhamiltonlee@sbclinic.org;
susan@sbchc.com; renjonl2@msn.com; jgruessing@norriscenter.com; kathy@pvpef.org; salandmar@cox.net
CC: carolynn@rpv.com
Subject: City grant requests
Date: Fri, 25 Mar 2011 11:33:23 -0700
To All City of Rancho Palos Verdes Grant Applicants:
Thank you for submitting your Grant Applications for FY 11-12 and FY 12-13. The information you have provided will be
presented to the City Council on Tuesday, March 29, 2011 starting at 7pm. The meeting will be held at Fred Hesse
Community Park, 29301 Hawthorne Boulevard, in Rancho Palos Verdes. You are invited to attend this meeting or send
someone to represent your organization, address the City Council and/or answer any questions that the City Council may
have regarding your grant request.
Attached is a copy of the City Grant Program staff report and the City Council Agenda for March 29, 2011. Due to the sheer
size of the grant attachments, they are not included in this email. They are part of the materials being presented to the City
Council.
Please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
Matt Waters
Senior Administrative Analyst
Finance & IT Department
City of Rancho Palos Verdes
310-544-5218
mattw@rpv.com
3/28/2011
From: Renee Cartwright [renjon12@msn.com]
Sent: Friday, March 25, 2011 5:58 PM
To: RPV City Council
Subject: FW: Los Serenos Grant Request 2011/2012
Attachments: RPV CC Re Grant Request 2011.doc
Sorry, forgot the attachment.
Renee
From: renjonl2@msn.com
To: cc@rpv.com
Subject: Los Serenos Grant Request 2011/2012
Date: Fri, 25 Mar 2011 17:55:57 -0700
Dear Members of the City Council,
Attached is a letter in support of Los Serenos de Point Vicente request for RPV grant funds. I know there are many worthy
organizations such as Los Serenos and realize it is sometimes tough to choose who should receive grant funds; thank you for
your consideration. I am very proud to live in a City that shares its limited resources with others.
Renee
/Of -3
a
3/28/2011
March 25, 2011
To Members of the RPV City Council,
LOS SERENOS DE POINT VICENTE
POINTVICENTE INTERPRETIVE CENTER
31501 Palos Verdes Drive West
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275
(310) 377-5370
www losserenos.or; • losserenos@rpv.com
As President of Los Serenos de Point Vicente I will begin by thanking you for your past
support of Los Serenos, it is very much appreciated.
I am writing to ask for your support of Los Serenos request for a $7,000 grant to help
fund the docents' 6th Grade Geology Program and our Jr. Docent Program.
Historically, the PTAs from individual PV schools funded the 6th Grade Geology program
and Los Serenos paid the parking fees. Over the years, one -by -one the schools
stopped participating in the program because of budget restrictions. One school,
Miraleste, continued its struggle to participate in the program, sending classes every
other year; and then finally they too had to discontinue sending children.
The 6th Grade Geology program is unique in that during the tour of Ladera Linda, the
docents actually teach based on the sixth grade curriculum requirements. With many of
the docents being former teachers, we know from experience that learning is easier in a
hands-on environment; at Ladera Linda, children can actual see the forces of nature
and have the best learning tools at their fingertips.
More importantly, the docents realize that we provide a unique opportunity to educate
while allowing every child who graduates from the Peninsula school system to
experience some of the wonders that Rancho Palos Verdes has to offer. That is one of
the reasons why the docents started to fund buses for the sixth graders with our Whale
Of A Day (WOAD) proceeds; the other reason, to be very truthful, is that when the
schools could no longer afford to come, the docents missed the children. Unfortunately,
the WOAD proceeds will not allow us to offer this program to all PV elementary schools
and to continue it year after year, even if we are successful with other cost-cutting
measures.
The Los Serenos Jr. Docent program is new. This program provides an opportunity for
senior high students to learn about the environment, marine life, and again learn about
and experience all the goodies that RPV offers such as Abalone Cove, Forrestal, and
the hiking trails. We train them to be good stewards and caretakers of the environment
with the goal that they will serve as role models, share their knowledge with their peers,
and become leading citizens in our community.
4� of 3
-2—
Los Serenos programs are educational, they are local, and they are for our children, but
they also affect the families as well. We find this especially true with the Jr. Docent
Program when parents actually participate in the docent -led hikes along with their
children, and burst at the seams on graduation day.
If you have not participated in a hike lead by one of our docents, I am extending a
personal invitation for you to do so; just let me know when and the level of hike (some
can be strenuous), and I will make the arrangements. You may be amazed at the
docent's breathe of knowledge and the positive impact they leave with the public while
representing the City of RPV.
In closing, about 150 docents and volunteers who donate over 10,000 hours to the City
of RPV each year would be eternally grateful for this exceptional support from the City.
I will personally assure you that Los Serenos will acknowledge your generous
contribution in our newsletter and in all literature that we send to the PV schools.
Thank you for your consideration and all that you do for Los Serenos.
Sincerely yours,
Renee Cartwright, President
Los Serenos de Point Vicente
343
From: Matt Waters [mattw@rpv.com]
Sent: Monday, March 28, 2011 1:43 PM
To: 'Lynn Swank'
Cc: 'Carolynn Petru; 'Carolyn Lehr'; 'Carla Morreale'; terit@rpv.com
Subject: RE: CC Meeting Grant Requests
Attachments: RPVCCA_SR_2011_03_29_02_City_Grant_Requests.pdf; 20110329 CC AGENDA.doc
Hi Lynn,
Hope all is well with you and thanks for contacting me about the City's grant program. I hope the following addresses the
issues raised in your email. Please feel free to contact me if you have any additional questions or concerns. Word of
warning when downloading: Please keep in mind that the attached staff report is several hundred pages long (15MB).
Program Protocol
• Letters to current grant recipients and recent grant applicants were sent out in mid-February. Other organizations that
contacted the City since the last budget cycle were sent applications as well. A total of 20 organizations submitted
grant applications this budget cycle. Groups that contact the City after the deadline for submission are placed on a
contact/mailing list for the next grant cycle. This same protocol for grant program outreach has been in place since at
least the late 1990s.
Non -Profit Status
• All applicants are required to provide proof of non-profit status.
Abalone Cove Improvements
City Grant program is designed to support organizations that provide civic -based services that the City itself does not
provide. The funds have not been used in the past to fund capital projects. Given these parameters, it would be
difficult for staff to recommend a City Grant to a local non-profit organization to fund park improvements on a property
the City owns and manages. However, staff would be happy to work with Save Our Coastline to see if a request can
be developed that meets all of the City's criteria for the next grant cycle.
Kiwanis Club of Rolling Hills Estates
. The following is an excerpt from the 3/29/11 City grants staff report that addresses some of your questions:
"In 2011, the Kiwanis Club of Rolling Hills Estates relocated its main charity event, the Palos Verdes Marathon, to
start and end within the City's boundaries. Prior to this time, the race began and ended in the City of Los Angeles (San
Pedro). In going through the City's permit process this year, the Kiwanis Club was required to establish a $7500 trust
deposit to cover the City's out-of-pocket expenses related to the event. The grant is being requested to off -set this
expense in FY 11-12 in order to lower the overall cost of the fundraising event, thereby allowing the Kiwanis to provide
more funding to local organizations, including athletic and educational programs, REACH, and charities that assist sick
children."
The Kiwanis Grant application states in section 4 of its application: "Impact of (City) Funding on our organization is
measured by our ability to either increase the number of participants in programs or scholarships to local students, supply
REACH programs and/or assist sick children. We facilitate additional support for the vital local charities/programs serving
our community listed above." The application does not specify what part of the $7500 is given directly to the charities. It
does note that 100% of the monies raised by their fundraisers goes to its foundation and that they have no significant
overhead (rent/payroll) because its members are volunteers.
I've attached the agenda for tomorrow night's meeting and a copy of the staff report which includes the complete
application from each group, including financial statements.
REACH
• The REACH program did not request funds this year. As a City recreation program, REACH is funded by a
combination of City funds, participant fees and grants from charitable organizations. Our records indicate that REACH
has never received funds through the City Grant program.
Sincerely,
3/28/2011
,( 0 / _�Z C_�?
Matt Waters
Senior Administrative Analyst
Finance & IT Department
City of Rancho Palos Verdes
310-544-5218
mattw@rpv.com
From: Lynn Swank [mailto:lynn.swank@cox.net]
Sent: Monday, March 28, 20117:43 AM
To: Matt Waters
Cc: Carolynn Petru
Subject: CC Meeting Grant Requests
Matt,
Thanks for returning my call last week regarding the non-profit funding requests. I have some questions regarding this.
• When was public notice given and how? (I have been out-of-town and may have missed it.) I assume these monies are
intended for bonafide 501(c)3 organizations.
• Is there an avenue for groups within RPV to request funds for specific projects which benefit RPV? I refer to the group
Save Our Shoreline, which would like to work with the City on Abalone Cove improvements. We have identified small
projects (with staff input) that could be done now so that we don't need to wait for the grants from other agencies which
may or may not be awarded to the City.
• The Kiwanis application is for $7500. Is this for the waived fees given by the City Council for the marathon this year? The
report does not show that $7500 was waived for Kiwanis this year. I think this should be noted because while Kiwanis did
not go through the City -Grant process they were given $7500 in waived fees for which other organizations should have
been allowed to compete.
• Does this Kiwanis Club request ask for the $7500 to offset the permit expense for next year?
• What part of the $7500 is given directly to the charities they have identified and what is the amount?
• I see no request from the REACH program this year. Did they not request money? If they did please let me know the page
(s) in the staff report.
Thanks Matt.
Lynn
3/28/2011 °/1 �'