RPVCCA_CC_SR_2011_10_18_06_Palos_Verdes_Nature_Preserve_PVPLC_Annual_Mgmt_ReportsCITY OF
MEMORANDUM
RANCHO PALOS VERDES
TO:
FROM:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
REVIEWED:
Project Manager:
HONORABLE MAYOR &CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS
JOEL ROJAS,AICP,COMMUNITY ....L..",--LOPMENT DIRECTOR
OCTOBER 18,2011
PALOS VERDES NATURE PRESERVE -PVPLC ANNUAL
MANAGEMENT REPORTS
CAROLYN LEHR,CITY MANAGER c!y-<
Ara Michael Mihranian,AICP,Deputy Community DevelopmenJ}8
Director m
RECOMMENDATION
Receive and file the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy's 2008-2009 and 2010
Annual Report on managing the City's Palos Verdes Nature Preserve.
BACKGROUND
According to the City's Natural Community Conservation Plan (NCCP),the Palos
Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy (PVPLC)serves as the City's management
agency for the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve.In this capacity,the PVPLC is required
by the NCCP to submit certain annual reports to the City and Wildlife Agencies (the
California Department of Fish and Game and the U.S.Fish and Wildlife Service).
Specifically,the PVPLC is required to submit a monitoring report on its habitat
restoration areas in the Preserve as well as a Report on its exotic plant removal efforts.
On December 20,2005,at the PVPLC's request,the City Council and the PVPLC
entered into a formal agreement authorizing the PVPLC to begin management of the
Preserve properties identified at that time in accordance with the management
responsibilities of the NCCP approved by the City in 2004.This agreement requires the
PVPLC to submit an Annual Report to the City Council summarizing the PVPLC's
management activities in the Preserve.
The PVPLC began managing the Preserve in 2006.The following is a summary of
previous PVPLC Management Reports submitted to the City Council:
6-1
CITY COUNCIL MEMO -PVPLC ANNUAL REPORT
PALOS VERDES NATURE PRESERVE
OCTOBER 18,2011
•06/07 Annual Report for the reporting period July 1,2006 to June 30,2007
•07/08 Annual Report for the reporting period July 1,2007 to June 30,2008
In accordance with the NCCP and City/PVPLC Management Agreement,the City
Council is now being presented with the following PVPLC Management Reports:
•08/09 Annual Report for the reporting period July 1,2008 to December 31,2009
•2010 Annual Report for the reporting period January 1,2010 to December 31,
2010.
As noted above,up until 2010,the annual management reports were based on a fiscal
calendar.However,at the request of the Resource Agencies (California Department of
Fish and Game and the U.S.Fish and Wildlife Service),beginning in 2010,the reporting
period was changed to a calendar year.As such,in order to accommodate this request,
the reporting period for 2008-2009 was extended and represents a year and half (July 1,
2008 to December 31,2009).The annual reports for the 2008-2009 and 2010 reporting
periods were not presented to the City Council until now since it was Staff's intent to
pair the annual reports with the final management agreement because of potential
questions that may arise with management responsibilities.The final management
agreement will be considered at the November 1,2011 City Council meeting.
The 2008-2009 and the 2010 Annual Reports were transmitted to the Council on
September 21,2011 under separate cover,but are attached for reference purposes as
well.
DISCUSSION
The Annual Report describes the PVPLC's management activities relating to habitat
enhancement and restoration,property maintenance and monitoring,vegetation and
wildlife monitoring,facility improvement projects (Le.trail improvements),volunteer
involvement,and grant opportunities referenced in the Management Agreement.The
Annual Reports include the following sub-reports:
•Habitat Restoration and Monitoring
•Trail Management,Improvements and Monitoring
•Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plans (TERPP)
•Research,Education,and Community Involvement Program for the Environment
(RECIPE)
•Education Program
•Volunteer Program
According to the attached letters from PVPLC Executive Director Andrea Vona (see
attachment),the Annual Report is consistent with the reporting requirements of the
NCCP and raises no significant issues or concerns with regards to the routine
management of the Preserve.Staff has reviewed the Annual Reports and agrees that it
is consistent with PVPLC's preserve management responsibilities as dictated by the
City Council approved 2004 NCCP and the current interim management agreement
6-2
CITY COUNCIL MEMO -PVPLC ANNUAL REPORT
PALOS VERDES NATURE PRESERVE
OCTOBER 18,2011
between the City and the PVPLC.
As part of the Annual Report,the PVPLC develops an annual list of projects to be
completed by City Staff and the PVPLC within the Preserve.The 2011 Project list
consists of trail and site improvements such as erosion repair,trail delineation,and
fence removal to name a few.The Project List currently being implemented can be
found on Page 18 of the 2010 Annual Report.City Staff and the PVPLC intend to
complete the trail projects during the coming year based on available funding
opportunities,such as grants and volunteer efforts.The majority of the work is typically
conducted outside the gnatcatcher breeding season (February 15 through August 31),
except for work that will not impact habitat.
As previously reported,the Annual Report is a requirement of the City's NCCP and the
management agreement between the City and the PVPLC.Moreover,since the
management agreement identifies the management responsibilities for each entity,
which is directly related to the annual reports,it was City and PVPLC Staff's intent to
have the final management agreement completed for Council consideration at the same
meeting the annual reports are presented to the Council in the event questions came up
regarding the management of the Preserve.The final management agreement will be
presented to the Council at the next City Council meeting on November 1,2011.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Transmittal of Annual Reports to City Council
As previously reported,the Annual Reports were transmitted to the City Council on
September 21,2011,but are attached for reference.The Annual Reports are also
available on the City's website under the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve homepage.
Public Notice
On October 5,2011,an electronic message was sent to the subscribers of the Palos
Verdes Nature Preserve list-serve (formerly known as the NCCP and PUMP list-serves)
announcing the availability of the Annual Reports and the October 18,2011 City Council
meeting.To date,no public comments were submitted to the City.In the event public
comments are submitted to the City after the transmittal of this Staff Report,Staff will
provide those comments letters to the Council at the meeting.
FISCAL IMPACT
Receiving and filing the 2008 Annual Report will not result in any costs to the City.
CONCLUSION
Pursuant to the City's NCCP and current City/PVPLC Preserve management
agreement,the PVPLC has submitted its 200-2009 and 2010 Annual Reports which
summarizes the PVPLC's management activities in the City's Palos Verdes Nature
6-3
CITY COUNCIL MEMO -PVPLC ANNUAL REPORT
PALOS VERDES NATURE PRESERVE
OCTOBER 18,2011
Preserve.Staff has reviewed the Annual Reports and agrees that it is consistent with
PVPLC's preserve management responsibilities as dictated by the City Council
approved 2004 NCCP and the current interim operating agreement between the City
and the PVPLC.Therefore,Staff recommends that the City Council receive and file the
2008-2009 and 2010 Annual Reports submitted by the PVPLC.
ATTACHMENTS
•PVPLC Letters
•2008-2009 PVPLC Annual Report
•2010 PVPLC Annual Report
6-4
PRESERVING LAND AND RESTORING HABITAT FOR THE EDUCATION AND ENJOYMENT OF ALL
October 7,20 II
Joel Rojas
Community Development Director
City of Rancho Palos Verdes
30940 Hawthorne Boulevard
Rancho Palos Verdes,CA 90275-5391
Re:Annual Report 20 I0 for the RPV Draft Natural Communities Conservation Plan and
Habitat Conservation Plan.
Dear Mr.Rojas,
This letter is to confirm that the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy submitted in May of
20 II the January-December 20 10 annual report for the RPV Draft Natural Communities
Conservation Plan (NCCP)and Habitat Conservation Plan.The draft NCCP requires reporting
with respect to habitat enhancement and restoration,management activities,volunteer
contributions,vegetation and wildlife monitoring,and efforts on targeted exotic plant removals.
This report is consistent with the submittal requirements for the Draft NCCP and Habitat
Conservation Plan.
Sincerely,
Andrea Vona
Executive Director
916 SILVER SPUR ROAD #207.ROLLING HILLS ESTATES.CA 90274-3826 T 310.541.7613 WWW.PVPLC.ORG
6-5
PRESERVING LAND AND RESTORING HABITAT FOR THE EDUCATION AND ENJOYMENT OF ALL
MARCH 10,2011
Joel Rojas
Community Development Director
City of Rancho Palos Verdes
30940 Hawthorne Boulevard
Rancho Palos Verdes,CA 90275-5391
Re:Cumulative Management and Monitoring Report 2007-2009 and Annual Report July 2008-
December 2009 for the Rancho Palos Verdes Draft Natural Communities Conservation Plan
and Habitat Conservation Plan
Dear Mr.Rojas,
This letter is to confirm that two draft copies of the Cumulative Management and Monitoring
Report 2007-2009 and Annual Report for July 2008-December 2009 for the Rancho Palos
Verdes Draft Natural Communities Conservation Plan and Habitat Conservation Plan were
delivered to Rancho Palos Verdes City Hall for your review,on March 9,20 I I.
An additional appendix needed in the Cumulative Report,which the City of Rancho Palos
Verdes can provide,is the habitat tracking matrix.Please let us know if there is any assistance
that we can offer on this.
Please contact me with any questions,and with the final number of copies that you would like
us to produce.
Thank you!
Danielle LeFer
Conservation Director
Andrea Vona
Executive Director
916 SILVER SPUR ROAD #207.ROLLING HILLS ESTATES.CA 90274-3826 T 310.541.7613 WWW.PVPLC.ORG
6-6
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
i
July 2008 to December 2009
PALOS VERDES NATURE PRESERVE REPORT
FOR THE
RANCHO PALOS VERDES
NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLAN
Prepared By
Danielle LeFer
PALOS VERDES PENINSULA LAND
CONSERVANCY
Prepared For
The City of Rancho Palos Verdes
February 2011
6-7
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................................... 1
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................... 1
Site Description ................................................................................................................................ 3
Management Plan .............................................................................................................................. 5
HABITAT RESTORATION AND MONITORING ............................................................................ 6
Habitat Restoration ......................................................................................................................... 6
Habitat Management Plan ....................................................................................................... 6
Additional Restoration .......................................................................................................... 9
Habitat Monitoring .......................................................................................................................... 12
Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants .................................................................... 12
Covered Plant Species ............................................................................................................. 12
Vegetation Mapping .................................................................................................................. 12
Brush Clearance ............................................................................................................................... 12
SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH AND WILDLIFE MONITORING ............................................................ 13
TRAIL MANAGEMENT, IMPROVEMENTS, AND MONITORING .............................................. 13
Trail Management ............................................................................................................................. 13
Trail Monitoring ................................................................................................................................ 13
Trail Markers and Decals ................................................................................................................ 14
Trail Repair ........................................................................................................................................ 14
Ranger Program ................................................................................................................................ 16
VOLUNTEER INVOLVEMENT ............................................................................................................... 16
GRANTS AND FUNDING ...................................................................................................................... 16
BOARD OF DIRECTORS ........................................................................................................................ 17
6-8
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
ii
TABLES
1. Reserve Names of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve .................................................... 3
2. Restoration Project Schedule for Alta Vicente Reserve Phases 1 and 2 ..................... 7
3. Restoration Project Schedule for Additional Restoration in Palos Verdes Nature
Preserve ...................................................................................................................................... 11
4. Number of Missing Decals for Each Decal Type 14
5. Future Trails Project List ........................................................................................................... 15
FIGURES
1. Map of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve with Associated Reserves Locations ...... 4
2. Map of Restoration Areas at Alta Vicente Reserve .......................................................... 8
3. Site map for All Restoration Projects in the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve ............. 10
APPENDICES
1. 2009 Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants
II. Volunteer Involvement
6-9
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The 2008-2009 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes Natural
Community Conservation Plan provides annual submittal requirements by the Palos Verdes
Peninsula Land PVPLC (PVPLC) on the status of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve (Preserve).
Additionally this report details stewardship activities, research, funding, and community
involvement in the Preserve during the period July 1, 2008 through December 31, 2009.
The Preserve encompasses approximately 1,200 acres and is located on the southern side of
the Palos Verdes Peninsula in the City of Rancho Palos Verdes (RPV), California. PVPLC serves
as the management agency for RPV. The Preserve was formed under a draft Natural
Community Conservation Plan (NCCP) to “maximize benefits to wildlife and vegetation
communities while accommodating appropriate economic development within the City of
Rancho Palos Verdes and region pursuant to the requirements of the NCCP Act and Section
10(a) of the ESA (URS 2004a).”
The primary focus of management for the Preserve is to maintain or restore habitat for the
covered plant and animal species listed in the draft NCCP. A Habitat Management Plan was
adopted in 2007 that outlines the restoration of 5 acres per year for a total of 15 acres over a
3-year period. This plan also outlined the methodology for removal of exotic plant species, a
predator control plan, and the monitoring of covered plant and animal species. PVPLC attempts
to seek additional funding when possible, to perform restoration on more than the minimum 5
acres per year required in the NCCP. Several opportunities of this nature occurred during the
reporting period that will enable PVPLC to conduct additional restoration over the next 3
years.
PVPLC also conducts scientific research and trail maintenance projects in the Preserve.
Volunteers make up a large component of the management strategies for the Preserve. They
assist in monitoring the properties, wildlife, and habitat as well as help restore habitat and
maintain trails. Partnering with regional high schools and colleges allows for scientific research
that expands our understanding of the Preserve. We also seek funding from a variety of sources
including private donations, federal and state grants, and foundations.
INTRODUCTION
The Palos Verdes Peninsula Land PVPLC (PVPLC) serves as the management agency for the
Palos Verdes Nature Preserve (Preserve), previously referred to as the Portuguese Bend
Nature Preserve, for the City of Rancho Palos Verdes (RPV). The Preserve was formed under a
Draft Natural Community Conservation Plan (NCCP) to “maximize benefits to wildlife and
vegetation communities while accommodating appropriate economic development within the
6-10
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
2
City of Rancho Palos Verdes and region pursuant to the requirements of the NCCP Act and
Section 10(a) of the ESA (URS 2004a).” As a primary component of the NCCP, a Preserve
design was proposed to conserve regionally important habitat areas and provide habitat linkages
in order to benefit sensitive plants and wildlife. PVPLC manages the Preserve under an
operating agreement with RPV.
The operating agreement with RPV requires that PVPLC submit an annual report to the RPV
City Council describing management activities with respect to habitat enhancement and
restoration, property maintenance and monitoring, vegetation and wildlife monitoring, and
efforts on targeted exotic plant removals. The 2009 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve Report for the
Rancho Palos Verdes Natural Community Conservation Plan (NCCP) and Habitat Conservation Plan
(HCP) provides annual submittal requirements on the status of the Preserve for the period of
July 1,2008-December 31,2009. It is accompanied by a status report for the Targeted Exotic
Removal Program for Plants (TERPP). Volunteer involvement and support and student-based
scientific research are also covered in this report.
As stated above, the NCCP Implementing Agreement has not been signed by the regulatory
agencies, and therefore, the NCCP is technically not officially executed. However, because it is
anticipated that this agreement will be signed in the near future, this annual report was
provided to satisfy the requirements of the both the Management Agreement with RPV and the
reporting requirements of the Draft NCCP. Annual reporting requirements for the Draft
NCCP are detailed below. Additionally, once every three years, a Comprehensive report is
required. This Comprehensive report is provided along with this report.
Annual submittals (included in this report)
1. A monitoring report on habitat restoration areas using standard monitoring
protocol as detailed in the Preserve Habitat Restoration Plan.
2. Report on Targeted Exotic Plant Removal Efforts.
Comprehensive Reporting Every Three Years (to be addressed in this year’s report)
A comprehensive monitoring report will be prepared every three years and will include
both a synthesis of all data collected in the preceding three years and an analysis of
overall trends in biological resources. This comprehensive report will include the
following:
1. A report that details surveys and data analysis regarding covered plants,
gnatcatchers, cactus wren, and butterflies. These surveys occur once every 3 years.
6-11
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
3
2. Updated Predator Control Plan
3. Updated Habitat Restoration Plan
4. Annual Reports during years when the Comprehensive Report is due
This 2009 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP and Habitat
Conservation Plan has been divided into 6 main topics, with subtopics embedded into each main
topic. Where applicable, subtopics have been further divided by Reserve (Reserves are
explained under the heading Site Description), to provide easier reference for a particular area
within the PVNP.
Site Description
The Preserve is located on the southern side of the Palos Verdes Peninsula in the City of
Rancho Palos Verdes, California (Figure 1). The approximately 1023-acre Preserve has been
divided into ten areas referred to as Reserves. The Public Use Master Plan Committee (PUMP
Committee), described further in the Community Involvement section of the report, submitted
recommendations for the naming of the Preserve and the 10 Reserve areas at the February 23,
2008 RPV City Council meeting. The committee made its recommendations based on
currently used names and names that conveyed the physical characteristics of each area. Table
1 reflects the Reserve names as approved by the RPV City Council. In addition, the 190-acre
Upper Filiorum Reserve, acquired in December 2009, added 190 acres to reserve, resulting in
over 900 contiguous acres of protected open space and a wildlife corridor linking Three Sisters
and Portuguese Bend Reserves (Figure 1).
Table 1: Reserve Names of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve. See Figure 1 for locations.
Abalone Cove Reserve San Ramon Reserve
Agua Amarga Reserve Three Sisters Reserve
Alta Vicente Upper Filiorum Reserve
Forrestal Reserve Vicente Bluffs Reserve
Ocean Trails Reserve Vista del Norte Reserve
Portuguese Bend Reserve
6-12
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
P
e
n
i
n
s
u
l
a
L
a
n
d
C
o
n
s
e
r
v
a
n
c
y
M
i
d
-
2
0
0
8
-
-
2
0
0
9
P
V
N
P
R
e
p
o
r
t
f
o
r
t
h
e
R
a
n
c
h
o
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
C
C
P
4
Fi
g
u
r
e
1
:
Ma
p
o
f
t
h
e
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
a
t
u
r
e
P
r
e
s
e
r
v
e
w
i
t
h
a
s
s
o
c
i
a
t
e
d
R
e
s
e
r
v
e
s
l
o
c
a
t
i
o
n
s
.
6-13
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
5
The topography of the Preserve is diverse, ranging from relatively flat lowland areas above
steep coastal bluffs in the south, to very steep slopes, ridgelines and gullies on the slopes to the
north. Elevations range from approximately sea level along the coastal edges of Vicente Bluffs,
Abalone Cove, and Ocean Trails to approximately 1,300 feet above mean sea level at the
northern most parcel, vista del Norte. Adjacent land uses include single-family residences on
most sides, open space associated with neutral lands on the Peninsula, the Pacific Ocean to the
south and west, and the Los Verdes and Trump National golf courses near the western and
eastern ends of the Preserve area.
On August 27, 2009, the Palos Verdes Fire burned approximately 165 acres of the Portuguese
Bend Reserve, affecting both native and non-native vegetation and known nesting sites of the
threatened coastal California gnatcatcher (Polioptila californica californica) and the special status
cactus wren (Campylorhynchus brunneicapillus). To address the impacts of the fire, PVPLC
created a Fire Recovery Plan in October 2009 (See Cumulative Report (2010), Section 3,
Appendix I).
Management Plan
The original document dictating management of the Preserve was the Forrestal Management
Plan. This management plan was adopted in 2001 when PVPLC became the management agency
for the RPV owned Forrestal Nature Preserve. Since that time, more open space properties
were purchased by RPV, and in February 2008, City Council adopted to name Forrestal as one
of the Reserves within the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve.
Additionally, in 2006, the Public Use Master Plan Committee (PUMP Committee) was formed
to provide recommendations for naming of the Preserve, forming a Preserve Trails Plan and
reviewing other guidelines for the public use of the Preserve. The Preserve Trails Plan was
brought before the RPV City Council over the course of several meetings in early 2008, and
was approved by the City Council in April 2008.
The current document dictating management of the PVNP is the draft NCCP/HCP, expected to
be finalized by August 2011, pending review by Wildlife Agencies.
6-14
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
6
HABITAT RESTORATION AND MONITORING
Habitat Restoration
Habitat Management Plan
The initial Preserve Habitat Management Plan (PHMP) for the Draft NCCP was created in 2007.
A component of the PHMP was the Habitat Restoration Plan for the restoration of 5 acres per
year for a total of 15 acres over the first 3-year period. This plan was completed in April 2007
and concluded that Alta Vicente Reserve in the Preserve ranked the highest in terms of site
suitability for an immediate restoration project. The Habitat Restoration Plan for Alta Vicente
Reserve outlines appropriate revegetation locations and methodology to adequately comply
with the Preserve Management requirements of the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP. The
following provides a brief description of the Habitat Restoration Plan for Alta Vicente Reserve.
The Habitat Restoration Plan for Alta Vicente Reserve provides guidelines for the establishment
of coastal sage scrub (CSS), coastal cactus scrub (CCS), and butterfly habitat on a total of 15
acres during 3 consecutive years at the Alta Vicente Reserve. However, since the fire occurred
at Portuguese Bend Reserve in August 2009, plans were adapted to focus immediate
restoration at Portuguese Bend, and only Phase 1 and 2 will be completed in the at Alta
Vicente. The proposed habitat restoration at the Alta Vicente Reserve consists of two 5-acre
phases, with one phase initiated each year. The first 5 acres of restoration (Phase 1) began with
site preparation during the fall of 2007. Phase 1 plants were installed and hydroseeded during
the winter of 2009/2010. Site preparation for Phase 2 began in fall 2008, and planting and
seeding was planned for winter 2010/2011. A Restoration plan for 15 acres at Portuguese Bend
Reserve was commissioned, and restoration was scheduled to begin in 2010.
Draft NCCP annual reporting requirements include a monitoring report on habitat restoration
areas using standard monitoring protocol for years 1, 2, 3 and 5 during the 5-year maintenance
and monitoring period that follows plant installation. Monitoring will begin in 2011, one year
after plant installation. The following provides a brief description of work done to fulfill the
NCCP during the reporting period. Table 2 provides the implementation schedule for Phase 1
and Phase 2.
6-15
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
7
Table 2: Restoration Project Schedule for Alta Vicente Reserve Phases 1 and 2. This table has
been modified from its original content in the 2007 Habitat Restoration Plan to reflect activities
only in Phase 1 and 2.
P
H
A
S
E
1
Task Date
Site clearing and soil preparation Fall 2007, Fall 2008
Installation of temporary irrigation system Fall 2008
Weed/exotic removal and grow-kill cycles Fall 2008-Spring 2009
Planting container stock Early Winter 2009/2010
Hydroseed application Winter 2009/2010 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment of site
installation
Following completion of installation and seeding
and 120 day maintenance period
5-year biological monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase one completion 2015, end of Year 5
P
H
A
S
E
2
Site clearing and soil preparation Fall 2008, Fall 2009
Installation of temporary irrigation system Fall 2008, Fall 2009
Weed/exotic removal and grow-kill cycles Fall 2008, Fall 2009,-Spring 2010
Planting container stock Winter 2010/2011
Hydroseed application Winter 2010/2011 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment of
site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding
and 120 day maintenance period
5-year biological monitoring and
maintenance
To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase two completion 2016, end of Year 5
6-16
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
8
Figure 2: Map of Restoration Areas at Alta Vicente Reserve.
6-17
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
9
Additional Restoration
PVPLC attempts to seek additional funding when possible, to perform restoration on more than
the minimum 5 acres per year required in the NCCP. Several opportunities of this nature
occurred during the reporting period.
In January 2007, Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA) provided funding to conduct twenty-one
acres of coastal sage scrub and perennial grassland restoration in the Three Sisters Reserve as
part of mitigation for the Southwest Airfield at Los Angeles International Airport. A restoration
plan was completed in 2008. In January 2009, the PVPLC began implementation of the first
season of weed control, including the use of 250 goats for grazing. Acacia trees (300) were
treated with a glyphosate herbicide, using the “drill and kill” method, and removed from the
site. Staff systematically removed weeds such as fennel, mustard and non-native annual grasses
through mechanical, hand removal, and herbicide application. An irrigation system was installed
in September 2009. In December 2009, 7,930 container plants of coastal sage scrub species
were planted, and the site was seeded with coastal sage scrub and native grass seeds from local
sources.
In June 2008, two grant agreements were signed with the State Coastal Conservancy to provide
restoration to seven acres of coastal sage scrub and riparian habitats. Four acres will be
restored in McCarrell’s Canyon, which is the western boundary of Three Sisters Reserve, and
three acres will be restored at the Fishing Access area of Vicente Bluffs Reserve. However, due
to a funding freeze, restoration was delayed until 2010. Table 3 shows the timeline for each
additional restoration project.
Figure 3 provides a site map for each restoration project, including the restoration at Alta
Vicente Reserve that fulfills the requirements of the NCCP Habitat Restoration Plan.
6-18
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
10
Figure 3- Site map for all 2008-2009 restoration projects in the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve.
6-19
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
11
Table 3: Restoration project schedule for additional restoration in Palos Verdes Nature
Preserve.
Th
r
e
e
S
i
s
t
e
r
s
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
21
A
c
r
e
s
Task Date
Seed collection Winter 2008-Spring 2009 (again in second year if
necessary)
Initial site preparation/weeding Winter 2008-Spring 2009, Fall 2009
Final site preparation(mowing/thatch
removal) Fall 2009
Seeding and container planting Fall 2009
Irrigation installation Summer 2009
Maintenance Winter 2009-Spring 2010
Remedial seeding Fall 2010 (if needed)
3-year monitoring (horticultural and
performance) Winter 2008-Spring 2011
Mc
C
a
r
r
e
l
l
’
s
C
a
n
y
o
n
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
4
A
c
r
e
s
Task
Date
Site clearing and soil preparation Winter 2008/2009-Fall 2009
Planting container stock Winter 2009/2010
Seeding application Winter 2009/2010 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment of
site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding and
120 day maintenance period.
3-year monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of restoration
work
Vi
c
e
n
t
e
B
l
u
f
f
s
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
4
A
c
r
e
s
Task
Date
Site clearing and soil preparation Winter 2009/2010
Planting container stock Winter 2010/2011
Seeding application Winter 2010/2011 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment of
site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding and
120 day maintenance period.
3-year monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of restoration
work
6-20
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
12
Habitat Monitoring
Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants
The Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants (TERPP) is an element of the Preserve
Habitat Management Plan for the Draft NCCP that requires the annual removal of exotic plant
species of twenty individual populations or five acres found in the Preserve. The TERPP
provides protocol for ranking the degree of threat to native vegetation, the feasibility of
eradication, and the invasiveness of each exotic species found in the Preserve. Populations of
exotic plant species are then targeted for removal based on the results of the ranking outcome.
The 2009 TERPP Report documents PVPLC’s effort during the reporting period to fulfill the
requirements of the TERPP plan. It details the methods of assessing the threat of individual
exotic species to native vegetation, field methods for removal, and provides site-specific
documentation related to every completed removal.
The complete 2009 TERPP Report can be found in Appendix 1 of this report.
Covered Plant Species
The draft NCCP/HCP includes a total of six covered plant species. They are aphanisma
(Aphanisma blitoides), south coast saltscale (Atriplex pacifica), Catalina crossosoma (Crossosoma
californicum), island green dudleya (Dudleya virens ssp. insularis), Santa Catalina Island desert-
thorn (Lycium brevipes var. hassei) and woolly seablite (Sueda taxifolia). Focused surveys were
conducted throughout the Preserve for each of these covered plant species. The covered plant
species report can be found in Section 2.1 of the attached cumulative report.
Vegetation Mapping
In 2009, stewardship staff mapped vegetation through a Preserve-wide Dept. of Fish and Game
Local Assistance Grant. However, the Upper Filiorum Reserve was not mapped because it was
acquired at the end of 2009. In addition, the mapping occurred prior to the August 2009 fire
that burned 165 burned acres at Portuguese Bend Reserve.
Brush Clearance
Brush clearance is the act of clearing or minimizing flammable vegetation in areas that occur
immediately adjacent to residential structures and roads. RPV is responsible for ongoing
maintenance of brush clearance within the Preserve, to provide an appropriate level of fire
protection, emphasizing the protection of life, public safety, and property values in the urban-
wildlife interface areas while minimizing environmental impacts of fire suppression and control.
A portion of the Agua Amarga Reserve is owned by PVPLC and falls under their responsibilities
to maintain brush clearance requirements. All of these requirements were met in May and June
2009. No other fuel modification areas within the Preserve fall under the responsibility of
6-21
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
13
PVPLC.
SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH AND WILDLIFE MONITORING
The Preserve is an ideal setting for an outdoor laboratory, because it provides scientists and
students with access to a variety of habitats. Results of wildlife research are in Section 2.2, 2.3
and 2.4 of the attached Cumulative Report.
TRAIL MANAGEMENT, IMPROVEMENTS AND MONITORING
Trail Management
One of the directives of the draft NCCP was to minimize the number of trails within the
Preserve, to ensure the conservation of habitat, while continuing to provide public access. In
2006, the Public Use Master Plan Committee was formed to provide recommendations for
naming of the Preserve, forming a Preserve Trails Plan and reviewing other guidelines for public
use of the Preserve. The Preserve Trails Plan was brought before the RPV City Council over
the course of several meetings during early 2008.
Prior to this, only the Forrestal Reserve had a designated trails plan. Most other Reserves
within the Preserve had a series of informal trails that had not been formally designated. In
November 2007, RPV City Council decided to restrict public access solely to fire roads in the
Portuguese Bend Reserve. The drought in 2007 had a severe impact on vegetation in all of
areas of the Preserves, and the Portuguese Bend Reserve is the most heavily used of the
Reserves. The drought, combined with an unofficial trail network and limited signage, was
sufficient cause for concern to restrict access until the Preserve Trails Plan was approved. The
Preserve Trails Plan for the Portuguese Bend Reserve was approved in February 2008 and City
Council directed the PVPLC to initiate several management tools. Among these were the
development of educational materials to alert the public to the new approved trail system and
the sensitivity of the habitat and to install signage throughout the Reserve indicating trail names
and uses.
As of the writing of this report, PVPLC staff continues to maintain trail markers, close off old
trail routes, and provide trail brochures. As requested by the City Council decision to open up
all trails in the Preserve Trails Plan on June 6, 2008, a 6-month trail monitoring report of the
Portuguese Bend Reserve was submitted to the Council in December 2008.
Trail monitoring
PVPLC stewardship staff or volunteers from the Keeping an Extra Eye on the Preserve for
Environmental Review and Stewardship (Keepers) Program conducted all trail monitoring
6-22
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
14
during the reporting period. The Keepers program is described in detail in the Volunteer
Involvement section of the report (Appendix II).
Monitoring was typically limited to overall trail conditions such as erosion, hazards, and
vegetation overgrowth. No efforts were made to improve or maintain any of the trails until the
final approval of the Preserve Trails Plan with the exception of the Forrestal Reserve, which had
designated uses, and one trail at Abalone Cove that had been badly eroded and was heavily
used by the public as beach access. Details of all trail improvements follow.
Trail Markers and Decals
From July 2008 through December 2009, 30 trail markers and 244 trail decals were replaced.
Table 4. Number of Missing Decals for Each Decal Type
Type of Decal Total # Replaced
No Bikes 56
Bikes OK 28
No Horses 4
Horses OK 46
Pedestrians OK 48
Trail Name 41
Arrows 21
Total 244
Trail Repair
The majority of trail work done in the Preserve corresponds to the outdoor volunteer
workdays. PVPLC staff or RPV Public Works department were also involved in trail
enhancement. A complete summary of the PVPLC Volunteer Trail Crew Program can be found
in the Community Involvement section of the report (Appendix II).
In 2009, PVPLC restored unauthorized dirt bike jumps in the upper Peacock Flats trail at
Portuguese Bend Reserve. The Toyon Trail Project at Portuguese Bend Reserve repaired and
restored the Toyon Trail. The Pescadero trail that leads from the Fishing Access parking lot to
the beach was repaired, through funding from a Coastal Conservancy grant. PVPLC also
enhanced trails at Portuguese Bend, Three Sisters, Abalone Cove, and Forrestal Reserves.
Table 5 lists future trail projects.
6-23
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
15
Table 5. Future Trails Project List (current as of February 2011)
Reserve Name Trail Name Project Type Completed
Forrestal
Flying Mane Fence Removal Project Y
Mariposa Bridge and trail repair
Vista Spur trail closure
Cristo Spur trail closure
Portuguese Bend
Burma at Panorama Grade trail to decrease water flow
onto Panorama
North Sandbox Trail Repair
Ishibashi Spur trail closure and trail delineation
Rim trail north of Burma Road End‐point delineation
Peppertree Trail Trail erosion repair Y
Barn owl trail Trail erosion repair
Rim trail near Paintbrush redirect away from private property
Toyon Trail Trail repair Y
Three Sisters
Sunshine Trail Repair Y
Barkentine Spur Trails Spur trail closure
Connector between Three sisters
and Upper Filiorum
Erosion Repair
Three Sisters trail at McCarrell’s
Canyon
Trail Repair Y
Fishing Access
Pescadero trail Trail Repair Y
Abalone Cove
Cave and Sacred Cove connection Erosion repair
Sacred Cove (to beach)Erosion repair
Bow and Arrow Erosion repair on eastern portion
Alta Vicente
North Spur trail Trail delineation
Prickly Pear trail Erosion repair and delineation
Agua Amarga
Lunada Canyon trail Delineation
Vista del Norte
Indian peak loop trail Delineation
6-24
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
16
Ranger Program
The City Council approved funding for a Ranger Program in June 2009. The City contracted
with the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (MRCA) to provide rangers at the
Preserve.
VOLUNTEER INVOLVEMENT
PVPLC is a non-profit organization that relies heavily on the support of community involvement
to perform many of the tasks necessary to manage the Preserve. The Volunteer Annual Report
for July 1, 2008 through December 31, 2009 is located in Appendix 1I.
GRANTS AND FUNDING
Funding to support PVPLC activities on the Preserve, such as restoration, education, and
monitoring is obtained through many sources including government agencies, foundations,
donors, and grantors. The PVPLC maintains a program-based budget and accounting system,
allowing it to allocate revenues and costs to specific projects. A list of funding awarded to
PVPLC specific to the Preserve is found below.
• The City of RPV provided $157,138.00 toward management of the Preserve, as specified in
the NCCP.
• Private donors and PVPLC members, including The Legacy Circle members, who committed
to a $5000 per year donation for three years, and Mariposa Circle members, who commit to
$1000 per year are a large component of funding sources.
• The Alcoa Foundation funded the RECIPE program, which includes science-related intern
projects and science programming in the Preserve.
• In 2009, PVPLC received a $22,944 grant from Los Angeles County Weed Management
Area (WMA) ARRA, to map and control populations of non-native carnation spurge (Euphorbia
terracina) on the Peninsula. This funding is available through December 2011.
• In 2008, REI provided $10,000 to support the development of the Trail Crew Program.
• In 2009, REI provided $15,000 to enhance the Stewardship Volunteer Program.
• In 2009, two agreements were signed with the California Department of Fish and Game to
provide restoration at Portuguese Bend Reserve. The first agreement, an NCCP Local
Assistance Grant Award, provided funding to restore coastal sage scrub and cactus scrub
habitat in the burned area of Portuguese Bend Reserve. Implementation is scheduled for 2010.
The second agreement provided funding to restore 9.5 acres of coastal sage scrub and
grassland habitat at Portuguese Bend Reserve.
6-25
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Mid-2008 --2009 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
17
2009 Officers
Henry Jurgens, President
Elizabeth Kennedy, Executive Vice President
Deena M. Sheridan, Secretary
Marc Crawford, Treasurer
Bill Ailor, President Emeritus
2009 Board of Directors
Bruce Biesman-Simons
Allen Franz
Michael J. Kilroy
Susan McKenna
Jess Morton
Joe Platnick
Jack Smith
Jim Staes
Bill Swank
Kenneth W. Swenson
Grace Wallace
2009 Staff
Executive Director Land Stewardship
Andrea Vona Lily Verdone, Conservation Director
Cristian Sarabia, Stewardship Manager
Office Administration Leslie Buena, Stewardship Associate
Hazel Martinez, Office Administrator
Christen Kitner, Administrative Assistant
Baltazar Gonzalez, Stewardship Technician
Lead
Nely Gonzalez, Nursery Technician
Humberto Calderon, Stewardship Technician
Science Program Sonia Gonzalez, Nursery Technician
Ann Dalkey, Science Director
Education Program
Kristina Ellis, Director of Education Programs
Development
Robert Ford, Director of Development
Louise Olfarnes, Manager of Marketing
Communications
Mary Lopes, Donor Relations
George F. Canyon Nature Center
Loretta Rose, Naturalist
Laurie Morgan, Assistant Naturalist
6-26
Land Conservancy Palos Verdes Peninsula
January -- December 2010 PALOS VERDES NATURE PRESERVE REPORT
FOR THE
RANCHO PALOS VERDES
NATURAL COMMUNITY CONSERVATION PLAN
May 2011
PO Box 3427
Palos Verdes Peninsula,
California 90274
T 310-541-7613
F 310-541-7623
www.pvplc.org
6-27
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
BACKGROUND INFORMATION ........................................................................................................ 1
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................... 1
Site Description ................................................................................................................................ 2
Management Plan .............................................................................................................................. 5
HABITAT RESTORATION AND MONITORING ............................................................................ 5
Habitat Restoration ......................................................................................................................... 5
Habitat Management Plan ....................................................................................................... 6
Additional Restoration .......................................................................................................... 11
Habitat Monitoring .......................................................................................................................... 15
Covered Species ....................................................................................................................... 15
Vegetation Mapping .................................................................................................................. 15
Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants .................................................................... 15
Brush Clearance ........................................................................................................................ 15
SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH AND WILDLIFE MONITORING ............................................................ 16
TRAIL MANAGEMENT, IMPROVEMENTS, AND MONITORING .............................................. 16
Trail Management ............................................................................................................................. 16
Trail Monitoring ................................................................................................................................ 17
Trail Markers and Decals ................................................................................................................ 17
Trail Repair ........................................................................................................................................ 17
Future Trail Projects ........................................................................................................................ 18
Ranger Program ................................................................................................................................ 19
VOLUNTEER INVOLVEMENT ............................................................................................................... 19
GRANTS AND FUNDING ...................................................................................................................... 20
BOARD OF DIRECTORS ........................................................................................................................ 21
6-28
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
ii
TABLES
1. Reserve Names of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve .................................................... 3
2. Restoration Project Schedule for Alta Vicente Reserve Phases 1 and 2 ..................... 7
3. Restoration Project Schedule for Portuguese Bend Reserve Phases 1-3 .................... 9
4. Restoration Project Schedule for Additional Restoration in Palos Verdes Nature
Preserve ...................................................................................................................................... 12
5. Future Trails Project List ........................................................................................................... 18
FIGURES
1. Map of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve with Associated Reserves Locations ...... 4
2. Map of Restoration Areas at Alta Vicente Reserve .......................................................... 8
3. Map of Restoration Areas at Portuguese Bend Reserve ................................................. 10
4. Site map for All Restoration Projects in the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve ............. 14
APPENDICES
I. 2010 Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants
II. Volunteer Involvement
III. Research and Monitoring
6-29
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
1
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
The 2010 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes Natural
Community Conservation Plan provides annual submittal requirements by the Palos Verdes
Peninsula Land PVPLC (PVPLC) on the status of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve (Preserve).
Additionally this report details stewardship activities, research, funding, and community
involvement in the Preserve during the period January 1, 2010 through December 31, 2010.
The Preserve encompasses approximately 1,400 acres and is located on the southern side of
the Palos Verdes Peninsula in the City of Rancho Palos Verdes (RPV), California. PVPLC serves
as the management agency for RPV. The Preserve was formed under a draft Natural
Community Conservation Plan (NCCP) to “maximize benefits to wildlife and vegetation
communities while accommodating appropriate economic development within the City of
Rancho Palos Verdes and region pursuant to the requirements of the NCCP Act and Section
10(a) of the ESA (URS 2004).”
The primary focus of management for the Preserve is to maintain or restore habitat for the
covered plant and animal species listed in the draft NCCP. A Habitat Management Plan was
adopted in 2007 that outlines the restoration of 5 acres per year for a total of 15 acres over a
3-year period. This plan also outlined the methodology for removal of exotic plant species, a
predator control plan, and the monitoring of covered plant and animal species. PVPLC attempts
to seek additional funding when possible, to perform restoration on more than the minimum 5
acres per year required in the NCCP. Several opportunities of this nature occurred during the
reporting period that will enable PVPLC to conduct additional restoration over the next 3
years.
PVPLC also conducts scientific research and trail maintenance projects in the Preserve.
Volunteers make up a large component of the management strategies for the Preserve. They
assist in monitoring the properties, wildlife, and habitat as well as help restore habitat and
maintain trails. Partnering with regional high schools and colleges allows for scientific research
that expands our understanding of the Preserve. We also seek funding from a variety of sources
including private donations, federal and state grants, and foundations.
INTRODUCTION
The Palos Verdes Peninsula Land PVPLC (PVPLC) serves as the management agency for the
Palos Verdes Nature Preserve (Preserve), previously referred to as the Portuguese Bend
Nature Preserve, for the City of Rancho Palos Verdes (RPV). The Preserve was formed under a
Draft Natural Community Conservation Plan (NCCP) to “maximize benefits to wildlife and
vegetation communities while accommodating appropriate economic development within the
6-30
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
2
City of Rancho Palos Verdes and region pursuant to the requirements of the NCCP Act and
Section 10(a) of the ESA (URS 2004a).” As a primary component of the NCCP, a Preserve
design was proposed to conserve regionally important habitat areas and provide habitat linkages
in order to benefit sensitive plants and wildlife. PVPLC manages the Preserve under an
operating agreement with RPV.
The operating agreement with RPV requires that PVPLC submit an annual report to the RPV
City Council describing management activities with respect to habitat enhancement and
restoration, property maintenance and monitoring, vegetation and wildlife monitoring, and
efforts on targeted exotic plant removals. The 2010 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve Report for the
Rancho Palos Verdes Natural Community Conservation Plan (NCCP) and Habitat Conservation Plan
(HCP) provides annual submittal requirements on the status of the Preserve for the period of
January 1, 2010-December 31,2010. It is accompanied by a status report for the Targeted
Exotic Removal Program for Plants (TERPP). Volunteer involvement and support and student-
based scientific research are also covered in this report.
As stated above, the NCCP Implementing Agreement has not been signed by the regulatory
agencies, and therefore, the NCCP is technically not officially executed. However, because it is
anticipated that this agreement will be signed in the near future, this annual report was
provided to satisfy the requirements of both the Management Agreement with RPV and the
reporting requirements of the Draft NCCP. Annual reporting requirements for the Draft
NCCP are detailed below. Additionally, once every three years, a Comprehensive report is
required. The most recent Comprehensive Report reported for 2007 through 2009.
Annual submittals (included in this report)
1. A monitoring report on habitat restoration areas using standard monitoring
protocol as detailed in the Preserve Habitat Restoration Plan.
2. Report on Targeted Exotic Plant Removal Efforts.
This 2010 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP and Habitat
Conservation Plan has been divided into 6 main topics, with subtopics embedded into each main
topic. Where applicable, subtopics have been further divided by Reserve (Reserves are
explained under the heading Site Description), to provide easier reference for a particular area
within the PVNP.
Site Description
The Preserve is located on the southern side of the Palos Verdes Peninsula in the City of
Rancho Palos Verdes, California (Figure 1). The approximately 1,400-acre Preserve has been
6-31
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
3
divided into ten areas referred to as Reserves. The Public Use Master Plan Committee (PUMP
Committee), described further in the Community Involvement section of the report, submitted
recommendations for the naming of the Preserve and the 10 Reserve areas at the February 23,
2008 RPV City Council meeting. The committee made its recommendations based on currently
used names and names that conveyed the physical characteristics of each area. Table 1 reflects
the Reserve names as approved by the RPV City Council. In addition, the 190-acre Upper
Filiorum Reserve, acquired in December 2009, added 190 acres to reserve, resulting in over
900 contiguous acres of protected open space and a wildlife corridor linking Three Sisters and
Portuguese Bend Reserves (Figure 1).
Table 1: Reserve Names of the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve. See Figure 1 for locations.
Abalone Cove Reserve San Ramon Reserve
Agua Amarga Reserve Three Sisters Reserve
Alta Vicente Upper Filiorum Reserve
Forrestal Reserve Vicente Bluffs Reserve
Ocean Trails Reserve Vista del Norte Reserve
Portuguese Bend Reserve
6-32
Pa
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
P
e
n
i
n
s
u
l
a
L
a
n
d
C
o
n
s
e
r
v
a
n
c
y
20
1
0
P
V
N
P
R
e
p
o
r
t
f
o
r
t
h
e
R
a
n
c
h
o
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
C
C
P
4
Fi
g
u
r
e
1
:
Ma
p
o
f
t
h
e
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
a
t
u
r
e
P
r
e
s
e
r
v
e
w
i
t
h
a
s
s
o
c
i
a
t
e
d
R
e
s
e
r
v
e
s
l
o
c
a
t
i
o
n
s
.
r=
J
Pa
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
Na
,
l
u
r
e
Pr
e
·
s
e
:
r
,
"
e
·
bO
U
i
n
d
a
r
i
e
s
I o
0.
5
1
I
il
e
s
2
Ma
p
ti
s
up
d
a
t
e
d
31
8
1
2
0
1
1
AB
6-33
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
5
The topography of the Preserve is diverse, ranging from relatively flat lowland areas above
steep coastal bluffs in the south, to very steep slopes, ridgelines and gullies on the slopes to the
north. Elevations range from approximately sea level along the coastal edges of Vicente Bluffs,
Abalone Cove, and Ocean Trails to approximately 1,300 feet above mean sea level at the
northern most parcel, vista del Norte. Adjacent land uses include single-family residences on
most sides, open space associated with neutral lands on the Peninsula, the Pacific Ocean to the
south and west, and the Los Verdes and Trump National golf courses near the western and
eastern ends of the Preserve area.
On August 27, 2009, the Palos Verdes Fire burned approximately 165 acres of the Portuguese
Bend Reserve, affecting both native and non-native vegetation and known nesting sites of the
threatened coastal California gnatcatcher (Polioptila californica californica) and the special status
cactus wren (Campylorhynchus brunneicapillus). To address the impacts of the fire, PVPLC
created a Fire Recovery Plan in October 2009 (PVPLC 2009).
Management Plan
The original document dictating management of the Preserve was the Forrestal Management
Plan. This management plan was adopted in 2001 when PVPLC became the management agency
for the RPV owned Forrestal Nature Preserve. Since that time, more open space properties
were purchased by RPV, and in February 2008, City Council adopted to name Forrestal as one
of the Reserves within the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve.
Additionally, in 2006, the Public Use Master Plan Committee (PUMP Committee) was formed
to provide recommendations for naming of the Preserve, forming a Preserve Trails Plan and
reviewing other guidelines for the public use of the Preserve. The Preserve Trails Plan was
brought before the RPV City Council over the course of several meetings in early 2008, and
was approved by the City Council in April 2008.
The current document dictating management of the PVNP is the draft NCCP/HCP, expected to
be finalized by August 2011, pending review by Wildlife Agencies.
HABITAT RESTORATION AND MONITORING
Habitat Restoration
Habitat Management Plan
The initial Preserve Habitat Management Plan (PHMP) for the Draft NCCP was created in 2007.
A component of the PHMP was the Habitat Restoration Plan for the restoration of 5 acres per
year for a total of 15 acres over the first 3-year period. This plan was completed in April 2007
and concluded that Alta Vicente Reserve in the Preserve ranked the highest in terms of site
6-34
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
6
suitability for an immediate restoration project. The Habitat Restoration Plan for Alta Vicente
Reserve outlines appropriate revegetation locations and methodology to adequately comply
with the Preserve Management requirements of the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP.
The Habitat Restoration Plan for Alta Vicente Reserve provides guidelines for the establishment
of coastal sage scrub (CSS), coastal cactus scrub (CCS), and butterfly habitat on a total of 15
acres during 3 consecutive years at the Alta Vicente Reserve. However, since the fire occurred
at Portuguese Bend Reserve in August 2009, plans were adapted to focus immediate
restoration at Portuguese Bend, and only Phase 1 and 2 (10 acres) will be completed at Alta
Vicente.
The following provides a brief description of work done to fulfill the NCCP during the
reporting period. Table 2 provides the implementation schedule for Phase 1 and Phase 2 at Alta
Vicente and Portuguese Bend.
Alta Vicente Reserve
The habitat restoration at the Alta Vicente Reserve consists of two 5-acre phases, with one
phase initiated each year. The first 5 acres of restoration (Phase 1) began with site preparation
during the fall of 2007. Phase 1 plants were installed and hydroseeded during the winter of
2009/2010. Site preparation for Phase 2 began in Fall 2008. In December 2010, staff removed
Acacia cyclopsis and completed planting and seeding in the Phase 2 area.
Draft NCCP annual reporting requirements include a monitoring report on habitat restoration
areas using a standard monitoring protocol for years 1, 2, 3 and 5 during the 5-year
maintenance and monitoring period that follows plant installation. Monitoring at Alta Vicente
began in 2010.
6-35
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
7
Table 2: Restoration Project Schedule for Alta Vicente Reserve Phases 1 and 2. This table has
been modified from its original content in the 2007 Habitat Restoration Plan to reflect activities
only in Phase 1 and 2.
P
H
A
S
E
1
Task Date
Site clearing and soil preparation Fall 2007, Fall 2008
Installation of temporary irrigation system Fall 2008
Weed/exotic removal and grow-kill cycles Fall 2008-Spring 2009
Planting container stock Early Winter 2009/2010
Hydroseed application Winter 2009/2010 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment of site
installation
Following completion of installation and seeding
and 120 day maintenance period
5-year biological monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase one completion 2015, end of Year 5
P
H
A
S
E
2
Site clearing and soil preparation Fall 2008, Fall 2009
Installation of temporary irrigation system Fall 2008, Fall 2009
Weed/exotic removal and grow-kill cycles Fall 2008, Fall 2009,-Spring 2010
Planting container stock Winter 2010/2011
Seed application Winter 2010/2011 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment of
site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding
and 120 day maintenance period
5-year biological monitoring and
maintenance
To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase two completion 2016, end of Year 5
6-36
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
8
Figure 2: Map of Restoration Areas at Alta Vicente Reserve. Phase 3 has been postponed to
implement burn recovery at Portuguese Bend.
6-37
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
9
Portuguese Bend Reserve
A restoration plan for 15 acres at Portuguese Bend Reserve was completed July 2010, and can
be found in the 2007-2009 Cumulative Report. Site preparation at Portuguese Bend began in
February 2010. Field staff weeded (hand/herbicide) the burn area, removed castor bean along
Rolling Hills and targeted fennel with herbicide.
Table 3: Restoration Project Schedule for Portuguese Bend Reserve Phases 1, 2 and 3, based
on the Portuguese Bend Reserve Habitat Restoration Plan.
P
H
A
S
E
1
Task Date
Site preparation, weed removal Fall 2010-Fall 2011
Final site preparation: weed and thatch
removal Fall 2011
Installation: Seeding Fall 2011-Early Winter 2012
Maintenance weeding Winter 2012-Spring 2013
Remedial seeding, as needed Fall 2012-Fall 2013
5-year biological monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase one completion 2016, end of Year 5
P
H
A
S
E
2
Site preparation, weed removal Fall 2011-Fall 2012
Final site preparation: weed and thatch
removal Fall 2012
Installation: Seeding Fall 2012-Early Winter 2013
Maintenance weeding Winter 2013-Spring 2014
Remedial seeding, as needed Fall 2013-Fall 2014
5-year biological monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase two completion 2017, end of Year 5
P
H
A
S
E
3
Site preparation, weed removal Fall 2012-Fall 2013
Final site preparation: weed and thatch
removal Fall 2013
Installation: Seeding Fall 2013-Early Winter 2014
Maintenance weeding Winter 2014-Spring 2015
Remedial seeding, as needed Fall 2014-Fall 2015
5-year biological monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of
restoration work
Phase three completion 2018, end of Year 5
6-38
Pa
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
P
e
n
i
n
s
u
l
a
L
a
n
d
C
o
n
s
e
r
v
a
n
c
y
20
1
0
P
V
N
P
R
e
p
o
r
t
f
o
r
t
h
e
R
a
n
c
h
o
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
C
C
P
10
Fi
g
u
r
e
3
.
M
a
p
o
f
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
a
r
e
a
s
a
t
P
o
r
t
u
g
u
e
s
e
B
e
n
d
R
e
s
e
r
v
e
.
75
15
0
30
0
F-
e
e
t
~l
j
<
l
l
,
l
l
>
_
~~
l
j
m
J
l
>
.
~
t
I
>
I
o
>
i
.
.
.
lj
l
>
J
>
l
"
_Q
l
o
o
I
t
o
I
I
~
l
j
m
J
b
.
_
b
~
l
;
I
_
IF
l
G
'
R
E
1
Pm
p
a
.
e
d
R.
.
-
o
1
8
i
1
o
n
H
~
~
_
Be
n
d
Pm
p
a
-
.
d
~t
o
l
'
B
d
o
n
An
l
a
Ps
I
o
s
~
.
Na
l
J
r
e
Pr
e
a
e
l
v
e
6-39
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
11
Additional Restoration
PVPLC attempts to seek additional funding when possible, to perform restoration on more than
the minimum 5 acres per year required in the NCCP. Several opportunities of this nature
occurred during the reporting period. Table 3 shows the timeline for each additional
restoration project.
Three Sisters
In January 2007, Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA) provided funding to conduct twenty-one acres of
coastal sage scrub and perennial grassland restoration in the Three Sisters Reserve as part of mitigation
for the Southwest Airfield at Los Angeles International Airport. A restoration plan was completed in
2008. In January 2009, the PVPLC began implementation of the first season of weed control, including
the use of 250 goats for grazing. Acacia trees (300) were treated with a glyphosate herbicide, using the
“drill and kill” method, and removed from the site. Staff systematically removed weeds such as fennel,
mustard and non-native annual grasses through mechanical, hand removal, and herbicide application. An
irrigation system was installed in September 2009. In December 2009, 7,930 container plants of coastal
sage scrub species were planted, and the site was seeded with coastal sage scrub and native grass seeds
from local sources. Restoration site installation was completed in January 2010. Staff is maintaining the
restoration site through active weeding, herbicide application and scheduled irrigation.
McCarrell’s Canyon
In June 2008, a grant agreement was signed with the State Coastal Conservancy to provide restoration
to seven acres of coastal sage scrub and riparian habitats at McCarrell’s Canyon, which is the western
boundary of Three Sisters Reserve. Due to a funding freeze, restoration was delayed until 2010. A final
restoration plan was submitted by Newfields for all activities performed under the grant. To
implement the restoration plan, staff contracted with Nakae & Associates to remove 5 acres of
non-native acacia trees. The project began in March. In Nov, Crew weeded the restoration
site, including Euphorbia, and hauled out debris. Staff weeded nonnative annual grasses to
prepare the site for planting in Fall 2010.
Fishing Access
In June 2008, a grant agreement was signed with the State Coastal Conservancy to provide restoration
to three acres at the Fishing Access area of Vicente Bluffs Reserve. Due to a funding freeze, restoration
was delayed until 2010. An updated habitat restoration plan for Fishing Access was completed by
restoration ecologist, Margot Griswold. Site preparation and planting began in December 2009.
Staff is maintaining and weeding the area in preparation for additional planting and seeding, in
Fall 2011.
Portuguese Bend
A Department of Fish and Game Local Assistance Grant (LAG) funds restoration in the burn
area at Portuguese Bend. The grant provides funding to restore native habitat through non-
native plant control and removal, provide supplemental native planting in areas of historic
cactus scrub, and perform post-fire monitoring for California gnatcatchers and cactus wrens.
Invasive species removal and planting began Fall 2010, and is ongoing.
6-40
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
12
In March 2010, the City of El Segundo provided funding to conduct 9.5 acres of coastal sage scrub and
perennial grassland restoration at Portuguese Bend as part of mitigation for the Plaza El Segundo
Development. The restoration site is on the upper portion of the Ishibashi Trail. staff worked with the
California Conservation Corps Weed Strike Team to clear approximately 5 acres of mustard
and fennel in the burn area. In Fall 2010, the 9.5 acre-site was seeded with native grasses and
coastal sage scrub. Staff continues to maintain and control weeds at the site.
Figure 4 provides a site map for each restoration project, including the restoration at Alta
Vicente Reserve that fulfills the requirements of the NCCP Habitat Restoration Plan
Table 4: Restoration project schedule for additional restoration in Palos Verdes Nature
Preserve.
Th
r
e
e
S
i
s
t
e
r
s
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
21
A
c
r
e
s
Task Date
Seed collection Winter 2008-Spring 2009 (again in second year if
necessary)
Initial site preparation/weeding Winter 2008-Spring 2009, Fall 2009
Final site preparation(mowing/thatch
removal) Fall 2009
Seeding and container planting Fall 2009
Irrigation installation Summer 2009
Maintenance Winter 2009-Spring 2010
Remedial seeding Fall 2010 (if needed)
3-year monitoring (horticultural and
performance) Winter 2008-Spring 2011
Mc
C
a
r
r
e
l
l
’
s
C
a
n
y
o
n
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
4
A
c
r
e
s
Task
Date
Site clearing and soil preparation Winter 2008/2009-Fall 2009
Planting container stock Winter 2009/2010
Seeding application Winter 2009/2010 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment
of site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding and
120 day maintenance period.
3-year monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of restoration
work
6-41
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
13
Vi
c
e
n
t
e
B
l
u
f
f
s
R
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
4
A
c
r
e
s
Task
Date
Site clearing and soil preparation Winter 2009/2010
Planting container stock Winter 2010/2011
Seeding application Winter 2010/2011 (following planting)
Completion of installation/assessment
of site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding and
120 day maintenance period.
3-year monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of restoration
work
Po
r
t
u
g
u
e
s
e
B
e
n
d
E
l
Se
g
u
n
d
o
G
r
a
n
t
9.
5
a
c
r
e
s
Task
Date
Site preparation and weed control Spring 2010-Fall 2010
Seeding Winter 2010/2011
Completion of installation/assessment
of site installation
Following completion of installation and seeding and
120 day maintenance period.
3-year monitoring and maintenance To begin upon successful installation of restoration
work
Po
r
t
u
g
u
e
s
e
B
e
n
d
Lo
c
a
l
A
s
s
i
s
t
a
n
c
e
Gr
a
n
t
(
L
A
G
)
Task
Date
Invasive species removal Fall 2010-Mar 2011
Native planting Fall 2010-Mar 2011
6-42
Pa
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
P
e
n
i
n
s
u
l
a
L
a
n
d
C
o
n
s
e
r
v
a
n
c
y
20
1
0
P
V
N
P
R
e
p
o
r
t
f
o
r
t
h
e
R
a
n
c
h
o
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
C
C
P
14
Fi
g
u
r
e
4
.
S
i
t
e
m
a
p
f
o
r
a
l
l
2
0
1
0
r
e
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
p
r
o
j
e
c
t
s
i
n
t
h
e
P
a
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
a
t
u
r
e
P
r
e
s
e
r
v
e
.
Vi
c
e
n
t
e
B
l
u
f
f
at
F
i
s
h
i
n
g
Ac
c
e
s
s
i
Mc
C
a
r
r
e
l
l
’
s
Ca
n
y
o
n
Re
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
Th
r
e
e
S
i
s
t
e
r
s
Re
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
Po
r
t
u
g
u
e
s
e
B
e
n
d
Re
s
t
o
r
a
t
i
o
n
~d
e
l
l
l
b
t
e
,
)
o
Pa
os
V
e
r
d
e
s
N
a
t
u
r
e
Pl
e
s
e
:
r
v
e
-
b
o
u
n
d
a
r
i
e
s
-
I o
0.
5
1
I Mi
l
e
s
2
Ma
p
la
s
t
up
d
a
t
e
d
31
8
1
2
0
1
1
AB
6-43
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
15
HABITAT MONITORING
PVPLC staff performed annual photo point monitoring. The photo point records
now document several years of changing site conditions, and public use. PVPLC’s
stewardship staff conducted a variety of surveys at the restoration sites throughout
the preserves. Vegetation transect surveys were conducted using standardized
methods that provide data on the cover of native and non-native plants in the
habitat. In 2010, monitoring transects were completed at Alta Vicente Reserve and
Three Sisters Reserve.
Covered Species
The draft NCCP/HCP includes a total of six covered plant species. They are aphanisma
(Aphanisma blitoides), south coast saltscale (Atriplex pacifica), Catalina crossosoma (Crossosoma
californicum), island green dudleya (Dudleya virens ssp. insularis), Santa Catalina Island desertthorn
(Lycium brevipes var. hassei) and woolly seablite (Sueda taxifolia). In 2010, surveys were
conducted for special status plants in the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve. Surveys were
conducted for the El Segundo blue butterfly at Vicente Bluffs and Abalone Cove Reserves.
Surveys for California gnatcatcher and coastal cactus wren were conducted at Portuguese Bend
Reserve.
Vegetation Mapping
The Stewardship team completed the vegetation mapping project for the Preserve-wide Dept.
of Fish and Game Local Assistance Grant.
Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants
The Targeted Exotic Removal Program for Plants (TERPP) is an element of the Preserve
Habitat Management Plan for the Draft NCCP that requires the annual removal of exotic plant
species of twenty individual populations or five acres found in the Preserve. The TERPP
provides protocol for ranking the degree of threat to native vegetation, the feasibility of
eradication, and the invasiveness of each exotic species found in the Preserve. Populations of
exotic plant species are then targeted for removal based on the results of the ranking outcome.
The 2010 TERPP Report documents PVPLC’s effort during the reporting period to fulfill the
requirements of the TERPP plan. It details the methods of assessing the threat of individual
exotic species to native vegetation, field methods for removal, and provides site-specific
documentation related to every completed removal. The complete 2010 TERPP Report can be
found in Appendix I of this report.
6-44
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
16
Brush Clearance
Brush clearance is the clearing or minimizing of flammable vegetation in areas that occur
immediately adjacent to residential structures and roads. RPV is responsible for ongoing
maintenance of brush clearance within the Preserve, to provide an appropriate level of fire
protection, emphasizing the protection of life, public safety, and property values in the urban-
wildlife interface areas while minimizing environmental impacts of fire suppression and control.
A portion of the Agua Amarga Reserve is owned by PVPLC and falls under their responsibilities
to maintain brush clearance requirements. All of these requirements were met in May and June
2010. No other fuel modification areas within the Preserve fall under the responsibility of
PVPLC.
SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH AND WILDLIFE MONITORING
The Preserve is an ideal setting for an outdoor laboratory, because it provides scientists and
students with access to a variety of habitat. A report of 2010 research is located in Appendix
III.
TRAIL MANAGEMENT, IMPROVEMENTS AND MONITORING
Trail Management
One of the directives of the draft NCCP was to minimize the number of trails within the
Preserve, to ensure the conservation of habitat, while continuing to provide public access. In
2006, the Public Use Master Plan Committee was formed to provide recommendations for
naming of the Preserve, forming a Preserve Trails Plan and reviewing other guidelines for public
use of the Preserve. The Preserve Trails Plan was brought before the RPV City Council over
the course of several meetings during early 2008.
Prior to this, only the Forrestal Reserve had a designated trails plan. Most other Reserves
within the Preserve had a series of informal trails that had not been formally designated. In
November 2007, RPV City Council decided to restrict public access solely to fire roads in the
Portuguese Bend Reserve. The drought in 2007 had a severe impact on vegetation in all of
areas of the Preserves, and the Portuguese Bend Reserve is the most heavily used of the
Reserves. The drought, combined with an unofficial trail network and limited signage, was
sufficient cause for concern to restrict access until the Preserve Trails Plan was approved. The
Preserve Trails Plan for the Portuguese Bend Reserve was approved in February 2008 and City
Council directed the PVPLC to initiate several management tools. Among these were the
development of educational materials to alert the public to the new approved trail system and
the sensitivity of the habitat and to install signage throughout the Reserve indicating trail names
and uses.
6-45
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
17
In 2010, PVPLC finalized trail maps for the whole PVNP, placed them at major trailheads, and
posted them on PVPLC’s website.
As of the writing of this report, PVPLC staff continues to maintain trail markers, close
unauthorized trails, and provide trail brochures.
Trail monitoring
PVPLC stewardship staff or volunteers from the Keeping an Extra Eye on the Preserve for
Environmental Review and Stewardship (Keepers) Program conducted all trail monitoring
during the reporting period. The Keepers program is described in detail in the Volunteer
Involvement section of the report (Appendix II). Monitoring was typically limited to overall trail
conditions such as erosion, hazards, and vegetation overgrowth.
Trail Markers and Decals
In March, the wildfire affected area at Portuguese Bend Reserve was re-opened by the City of
RPV. Staff spent four days replacing a total of 37 trail markers and 222 decals throughout the
Reserve. In addition, staff replaced trail signage (48 decals, 12 signs) and removed graffiti on
signs throughout the Preserve.
Trail Repair
The majority of trail work done in the Preserve corresponds to the outdoor volunteer
workdays. PVPLC staff or RPV Public Works department were also involved in trail
enhancement. A complete summary of the PVPLC Volunteer Trail Crew Program can be found
in the Community Involvement section of the report (Appendix II).
Abalone Cove
Staff worked with over 30 volunteers assisted Eagle Scout Ryland Miller on May 22 and
23 install a foot path and maintain storm-damaged trails on Abalone Cove Trail.
Forrestal
The Volunteer Trail Crew assessed and worked on many trails that were severely
damaged by rains.
Portuguese Bend
The volunteer trail crew rehabilitated the Sandbox Trail, as it was damaged by recent
rains.
The Toyon Trail was realigned by Bellfree Construction as a part of the fire recovery
plan. The newly aligned trail was moved to the west, avoiding the landslide. Trail
volunteers also helped improve the Toyon Trail. Several spur trails and bike jumps were
closed and 250 plants were installed.
PVPLC partnered with REI and CORBA on National Trails Day, to conduct trail
maintenance on the Ishibashi Trail with 75 volunteers.
6-46
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
18
PVPLC contracted with Bellfree Contractors to reroute the upper portion of the Rim
Trail. In August, Rolling Hills Community Association notified both the PVPLC and City
of RPV of their approval to the Nakamura family to build a fence on the property line of
Portuguese Bend. The fence planned fence bisects the Rim Trail, closing the section that
navigated users through the previously “permit only” section of the Reserve. In
October, staff placed temporary Rim trail closure/reroute signs at Portuguese Bend. In
December, PVPLC and City staff conducted a site visit to determine the location of the
trail reroute, planned for early 2011.
Upper Filiorum
Staff collaborated with NPS and RPV to host two trails planning workshops to develop
the public use trail plan for the Reserve; the workshops were held September 8 and 29.
Staff is compiling and responding to comments from the workshops, and prepare trail
maps for City Council review. An additional workshop is scheduled for April 2011 to
review any trail changes for the PVNP. This public meeting is required to be hosted on
an annual basis. The final task to be completed under this grant is a PVNP trail signage
assessment and recommendation on signage.
Vicente Bluffs
Fishing Access entrance signs were designed, and installed in March. Bellfree
Contractors completed trail closure fencing along the bluff trail.
Ocean Front Estates
In April, Bellfree Contractors repaired decomposed granite trails in Ocean Front
Estates.
Future Trail Projects
Table 5 lists future trail projects.
Table 5. Future Trails Project List (current as of April 2011)
Reserve Name Trail Name Project Type Completed
Forrestal
Flying Mane Fence Removal Project Y
Mariposa Bridge and trail repair
Vista Spur trail closure
Cristo Spur trail closure
Portuguese Bend
Burma at Panorama Grade trail to decrease water flow
onto Panorama
North Sandbox Trail Repair
Ishibashi Spur trail closure and trail delineation
6-47
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
19
Rim trail north of Burma Road End‐point delineation
Peppertree Trail Trail erosion repair Y
Barn owl trail Trail erosion repair
Rim trail near Paintbrush redirect away from private property
Toyon Trail Trail repair Y
Three Sisters
Sunshine Trail Repair Y
Barkentine Spur Trails Spur trail closure
Connector between Three sisters
and Upper Filiorum
Erosion Repair
Three Sisters trail at McCarrell’s
Canyon
Trail Repair Y
Fishing Access
Pescadero trail Trail Repair Y
Abalone Cove
Cave and Sacred Cove connection Erosion repair
Sacred Cove (to beach)Erosion repair
Bow and Arrow Erosion repair on eastern portion
Alta Vicente
North Spur trail Trail delineation
Prickly Pear trail Erosion repair and delineation
Agua Amarga
Lunada Canyon trail Delineation
Vista del Norte
Indian peak loop trail Delineation
Ranger Program
The City Council approved funding for a Ranger Program in June 2009. The City contracted
with the Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (MRCA) to provide rangers at the
Preserve.
VOLUNTEER INVOLVEMENT
PVPLC is a non-profit organization that relies heavily on the support of community involvement
to perform many of the tasks necessary to manage the Preserve. The Volunteer Annual Report
for January 1, 2010 through December 31, 2010 is located in Appendix II.
6-48
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
20
GRANTS AND FUNDING
Funding to support PVPLC activities on the Preserve, such as restoration, education, and
monitoring is obtained through many sources including government agencies, foundations,
donors, and grantors. The PVPLC maintains a program-based budget and accounting system,
allowing it to allocate revenues and costs to specific projects. A list of ongoing funding awarded
to PVPLC specific to the Preserve is found below.
The City of RPV provided $157,138 toward management of the Preserve, as specified in the
NCCP.
Private donors and PVPLC members, including The Legacy Circle members, who committed
to a $5000 per year donation for three years, and Mariposa Circle members, who commit to
$1000 per year are a large component of funding sources.
The Alcoa Foundation funded the RECIPE program, which includes science-related intern
projects and science programming in the Preserve.
A $22,944 grant from Los Angeles County Weed Management Area (WMA) ARRA, to map
and control populations of non-native carnation spurge (Euphorbia terracina) on the Peninsula.
This funding is available through December 2011.
A California Department of Fish and Game NCCP Local Assistance Grant awarded in 2009,
provided funding ($30,000) to restore coastal sage scrub and cactus scrub habitat in the burned
area of Portuguese Bend Reserve, through June 2011.
A California Department of Fish and Game agreement reached in 2009 provided funding
($40,000) to restore 9.5 acres of coastal sage scrub and grassland habitat at Portuguese Bend
Reserve.
PVPLC received a $25,000 weed management area federal stimulus grant, through
September 2011.
REI awarded PVPLC $20,000 from a $15,000 grant request submitted in May for volunteer
outreach.
In September, 2010, PVPLC and RPV received a $495,000 grant from the CA Coastal
Conservancy to develop the Palos Verdes section of the CA Coastal Trail.
PVPLC and the City received a $190,500 Habitat Conservation Fund grant for trail work
and associated restoration at Portuguese Bend Reserve.
Staff is collaborating with RPV and USFWS on two Section 6 land acquisition grants.
6-49
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 PVNP Report for the Rancho Palos Verdes NCCP
21
2010 Officers
Ken Swenson, President
Bruce Biesman-Simons, Exec. Vice President
Susan McKenna, Secretary
Marc Crawford, Treasurer
Bill Ailor, Founder
2010 Board of Directors
Allen Franz
Henry Jurgens
Elizabeth Kennedy
Mike Kilroy
Jess Morton
Joseph Platnick
Anke Raue
Jack Smith
Bill Swank
Grace Wallace
2010 Staff
Executive Director Land Stewardship
Andrea Vona Lily Verdone/Danielle LeFer, Conservation
Director
Cristian Sarabia, Stewardship Manager
Office Administration Adrienne Bosler, Stewardship Associate
Hazel Martinez, Office Administrator
Jill Wittman, Administrative Assistant
Daniel Feldman, Stewardship Technician
Damian Morando, Stewardship Technician
Hugo Moralez, Stewardship Technician
Humberto Calderon, Stewardship Technician
Nely Gonzalez, Nursery Technician
Science Program
Ann Dalkey, Research Director
Education Program
Kristina Ellis, Education Director
John Nieto, Education Manager
Siegrun Storer, Education Associate
Development
Nancy Young, Development Director
Louise Olfarnes, Communications Manager
Mary Lopes, Donor Relations
George F. Canyon Nature Center
Loretta Rose, Manager/Naturalist
Laurie Morgan, Assistant Naturalist
White Point Nature Education Center
Roxanne Roberts, Naturalist
Jessy Melowicz, Naturalist
6-50
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
TERPP 2010 Annual Report
0
2010 ANNUAL REPORT
FOR THE
TARGETED EXOTIC REMOVAL
PROGRAM FOR PLANTS (TERPP)
Prepared by:
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
Contact: Danielle LeFer
May 2011
6-51
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
TERPP 2010 Annual Report
1
INTRODUCTION
The Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy (PVPLC), as manager of the Palos Verdes
Nature Preserve (PVNP), conducts strategic weed control activities throughout the year as
part of the Targeted Exotic Plant Removal Plan for Plants (TERPP). As directed in the draft
Rancho Palos Verdes Natural Communities Conservation Plan (NCCP), PVPLC selects five
acres or 20 small sites of exotic plants for removal each year. The overall goal of this
program is to systematically target invasive species throughout the PVNP to increase the
success of native plant growth and create greater habitat opportunities for wildlife.
The TERPP is an element of the NCCP that includes a specific protocol for ranking exotic
species populations and strategically removing those species over time (Appendix B-G). The
2010 TERPP Report documents PVPLC’s effort over the past year to remove exotic plant
species that threaten native vegetation in the PVNP. It details the methods of assessing the
threat of individual exotic species to native vegetation, field methods for removal and
provides site-specific documentation related to every completed removal site.
As of the writing of this report, the NCCP is still in draft format and the regulatory agencies
have not yet signed the final plan. However, the City of Rancho Palos Verdes and PVPLC
currently perform the responsibilities outlined in the draft NCCP, including fulfillment of the
TERPP requirements.
SITE ASSESSMENT
Invasive species control is included in PVPLC’s annual conservation planning strategy where
Stewardship staff prioritize potential TERPP sites and assess best practice methods for
removal. Guided by the NCCP, which ranks known PVNP exotic species based on State and
Federal guidelines, PVPLC staff locate TERPP sites to target for the calendar year, assess the
best method for eradication, photo document and map the population/s, and conduct weed
removal accordingly.
The PVPLC weighs potential areas for exotic species control based on several criteria:
1. Threat to native vegetation, particularly populations of NCCP-covered species;
2. Feasibility of eradication, which includes limiting disturbance to native habitat and
ease of access, and;
6-52
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
2
3. Invasiveness of exotic species, using a synthesized rating system drawn from plant
invasiveness rankings from both the California Invasive Plant Council (Cal-IPC) and
the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA).
Through regular property reviews and viewing fine scale imagery through the Geographic
Information System (GIS), ArcGIS, PVPLC plans for exotic species control across the entire
NCCP area.
Staff primarily documents completed TERPP sites on the TERPP field form. Appendix A
contains a sample TERPP form. The forms provide basic information about the species
targeted, including site identification number and property, approximate location, removal
methods used, and general comments related to the removal activities. PVPLC also includes
photo documentation: staff photographs the sites before work takes place and after the
removal of the individual or population of exotic species. Photo documentation not only
confirms completion of the work, but also provides a snapshot of the surrounding
environment at the time of the TERPP-related activities. This record helps to create a
historical record of the presence of non-native plant species on the sites, which may inform
future restoration efforts.
Each TERPP site is tracked via a GIS, a tool that aids planning and monitoring efforts. Since
2006, PVPLC has treated 68 TERPP sites, and the program is ongoing. Every year, tracking,
documenting and planning for the following year becomes more complicated as more sites
are added. Use of GIS allows staff not only to look at the land within the NCCP boundaries,
but to view the Palos Verdes Peninsula at a landscape level. While the most common
approach to managing invasions of exotic species may be to target individual species, a more
comprehensive approach is to identify major pathways for invasion that will influence more
efficient and economic management of the exotic species.
FIELD METHODS
PVPLC staff uses best practice, the most effective and least intrusive, methods at all times
when conducting TERPP-related activities. High priority areas may occur near rare or
endangered biological populations. Care is taken to minimize soil erosion, fire risk,
disturbance to surrounding native vegetation and further dispersal of the exotic species.
PVPLC utilizes a combination of methods to conduct exotic species removal, generally
limited to the following:
Mechanical removal - staff may use tools with motorized blades to fell larger species;
Hand removal - staff conduct most removals by hand pulling and/or with small hand
tools for pruning and cutting;
Chemical control - trained staff applies herbicides at the appropriate phase of
vegetative
Growth and seed maturation, and;
6-53
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
3
Disposal - City of Rancho Palos Verdes staff coordinate with waste companies to
supply green waste and trash containers.
Qualified Licensed Applicator(s) develop all recommendations for chemical pest control and
senior staff supervises field staff and contractors in sensitive areas. Additionally, field staff has
an integral role in the TERPP and often have crucial, site-specific knowledge related to the
sites.
2010 TERPP
In 2010, we treated 7 populations of Euphorbia terracina (Geraldton spurge, Euphorbia) in
addition to treating the Euphorbia at the 95-acre San Ramon Reserve (Figure 1). Information
on each treated site is in Appendix H. Euphorbia grows rapidly in disturbed areas, is a
prolific seeder and is rapidly expanding its distribution in southern California. Invaded areas
show reduced ecological quality and inferior habitat quality compared to un-invaded areas.
Continued spread of this species throughout California seems possible and even likely if
action is not taken immediately. Euphorbia shows a broad habitat tolerance in southern
California, invading both cool coastal areas and hot, dry, interior areas.
This particular population of Euphorbia was included in the 2008 TERPP Report (PVPLC
2008) and has been part of the twice funded (2008, 2010) Los Angeles County Weed
Management Area (WMA) Euphorbia Grant. The project will control populations of
Euphorbia occurring throughout the Peninsula, with a combination of herbicide treatment
and mechanical removal. Populations will be targeted based on the proximity to open space
and sensitive habitat, including areas under the management of the PVPLC as well as private
property.
6-54
Pa
l
o
s
V
e
r
d
e
s
P
e
n
i
n
s
u
l
a
L
a
n
d
C
o
n
s
e
r
v
a
n
c
y
T
E
R
P
P
2
0
1
0
A
n
n
u
a
l
R
e
p
o
r
t
4
Fi
g
u
r
e
1:
Eu
p
h
o
r
b
i
a
te
r
r
a
c
i
n
a
tr
e
a
t
m
e
n
t
si
t
e
s
20
0
8
to
20
1
0
.
~
".
.
-
-
-
-
E
u
p
h
o
r
b
l
o
U
r
r
o
c
l
n
o
T
r
e
o
t
e
d
S
i
t
e
s
..
.
'..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
,
.
_
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
~e
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
,
o
Eu
p
h
O
i
b
i
l
l
tm
l
l
t
e
d
WI
20
1
0
EU
p
h
O
i
b
i
l
l
tr
e
l
l
i
e
d
WI
20
0
9
Eu
p
h
O
i
b
i
l
l
tr
e
l
l
t
e
d
WI
20
0
8
Pr
e
s
e
r
v
e
Bo
u
n
d
a
r
y
•
•
~
0
\
l
°
<£
0
,
~
"
,
S
a
n
11
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
-..-.
-'
-
M
i
l
H
•
o
>~
-
-
-
'
-
-
(
P
;r
-
-
-
>
"
'.
:
,
"
1
o
f
t
I
l
eo
..
.
"
(
-
-
'
-
-
.
"'
\
,
o
TI
o
.
.
.
Sl
.
.
.
.
.
.
J
Vk
l
l
n
t
l
l
.
I
u
f
h
~.L
..
,1"
1
~
'
-
,
-
,
'
o ••
6-55
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
TERPP 2010 Annual Report
5
REFERENCES
California Invasive Plant Council 2006. California Invasive Plant Inventory. February.
California Invasive Plant Council: Berkley, CA.
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy 2007a. 2007 Targeted Exotic Removal Plan for
Plants for the Portuguese Bend Nature Preserve For the Rancho Palos Verdes Draft
Natural Community Conservation Plan and Habitat Conservation Plan. April.
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy 2008. 2008 Annual Report for the Targeted
Exotic Removal Program for Plants for the Portuguese Bend Nature Preserve For the
Rancho Palos Verdes Draft Natural Community Conservation Plan and Habitat
Conservation Plan. September.
State of California 2007. Department of Food and Agriculture Division of Plant Health
& Prevention Services Noxious Weed Ratings. Retrieved September 2007, from:
<http://www.cdfa.ca.gov/phpps/ipc/encycloweedia/pdfs/noxiousweed_ratings.pdf>.
URS 2006. City of Rancho Palos Verdes Draft Natural Community Conservation Plan
and Habitat Conservation Plan. June 9.
6-56
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
6
Appendix A: SAMPLE TERPP FORM
Property: Year selected:
Exotic vegetation type:
Access:
Reason for removal:
Method of removal:
Method of disposal:
Surrounding native vegetation type:
Results:
Before Photo Date: After Photo Date:
6-57
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
7
Appendix B: Flowchart for High Priority Threat to Native Vegetation
Priority Ranking For Control of Exotic Species
1-3= Low priority 4-7= Medium priority 8-10= High priority
High priority where exotic species poses
immediate threat
Eradication of exotic
species very possible
Suppression of exotic
species possible
Suppression of exotic
species unlikely
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
6-58
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
8
Appendix C: Flowchart for Medium Priority Degree of Threat to Native Vegetation
Priority Ranking For Control of Exotic Species
1-3= Low priority 4-7= Medium priority 8-10= High priority
Medium priority where exotic species poses
threat within 1-2 years
Eradication of exotic
species very possible
Suppression of exotic
species possible
Suppression of exotic
species unlikely
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
6-59
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
9
Appendix D: Flowchart for Low Priority Degree of Threat to Native Vegetation
Priority Ranking For Control of Exotic Species
1-3= Low priority 4-7= Medium priority 8-10= High priority
Low priority where exotic species does not
pose threat for at least 2 years
Eradication of exotic
species very possible
Suppression of exotic
species possible
Suppression of exotic
species unlikely
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
Exotic
Highly
Invasive
Exotic
Moderately
Invasive
6-60
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
10
Appendix E: Highly Invasive Species
Genus species Common name
Arundo donax Giant reed
Asparagus asparaagoides Bridal creeper
Avena barbata Slender oat
Avena fatua Wild oat
Brachypodium distachyon False brome
Brassica nigra Black mustard
Bromus diandrus Ripgut grass
Bromus madritensis ssp. rubens Red brome
Carpobrotus edulis Hottentot fig
Caesalpinia spinosa Spiny holdback
Centaurea melitensis Tocalote
Chrysanthemum coronarium Garland chrysanthemum
Cortaderia selloana Pampas grass
Cynodon dactylon Bermuda grass
Euphorbia terracina Spurge
Foeniculum vulgare Fennel
Malva nicaeensis Bull mallow
Malva parviflora Cheeseweed
Malva sylvestris Mallow
Mesembryanthemum crystallinum Annual iceplant
Nicotiana glauca Tree tobacco
Pennisetum clandestinum Kikuyu grass
Pennisetum setaceum Fountain grass
Picris echioides Bristly ox-tongue
Pistacia atlantica Pistachio
Pittosporum undulatum Pittosporum
Raphanus sativus Wild radish
Ricinus communis Castor bean
Salsola tragus Russian thistle
Silybum marianum Milk thistle
Sonchus asper Prickly sow thistle
Sonchus oleraceus Sow thistle
Spartium junceum Spanish broom
Tamarix species Tamarisk
Tropaeolum majus Garden nasturtium
6-61
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
11
Appendix F: Moderately Invasive Species
Genus species Common Name Genus species Common Name
Acacia cyclops Acacia
Acacia species Acacia
Aegilops cylindrica Jointed goat grass
Ageratina adenophorum Eupatory
Atriplex semibaccata Australian saltbush
Bassia hyssopifolia Five-Hook bassia
Bromus hordeaceus (mollis) Soft brome
Bromus catharticus Rescue grass
Cakiel maritime Sea rocket
Carduus pycnocephalus Italian thistle
Carpobrotus aequilaterus Sea Fig
Carpobrotus chilensis Fig-Marigold iceplant
Conium maculatum Poison hemlock
Convolvulus arvensis Bindweed
Erodium cicutarium Red stem filaree
Eucalyptus camaldulensis Red gum tree
Eucalyptus globulus Blue gum tree
Eucalyptus species Gum tree
Hirschfeldia incana Annual mustard
Hordeum murinum leporinum Foxtail barley
Hordeum vulgare Common barley
Lactuca serriola Compass plant
Lathyrus tangianus Tangier pea
Limonium perezii Sea lavender
Limonium sinuatum Sea lavender
Lobularia maritima Sweet alyssum
Lolium multiflorum Italian rye
Lolium perenne Perennial ryegrass
Marrubium vulgare Horehound
Medicago polymorpha Bur clover
Medicago sativa Alfalfa
Melilotus albus White sweet clover
Melilotus indicus Yellow sweet clover
Myoporum laetum Myoporum
Olea europea Olive
Oxalis pes-caprae Bermuda buttercup
Pelargonium zonale Zonal geranium
Phalaris minor Phalaris
Phoenix canariensis Phoenix palm
Piptatherum miliacea Smilo grass
Pittosporum undulatum Pittosporum
Plantago lanceolata English plantain
Polygonum aviculare Knotweed
Polypogon monspessulensis Rabbitsfoot
Pyracantha sp. Firethorn
Rumex crispus Curly dock
Schinus molle Mexican pepper
Schinus terebinthifolius Brasilian pepper
Sisymbrium irio London rocket
Trifolium hirtum Rose clover
Washington robusta Mexican fan palm
Vicia sativa Spring vetch
Vulpia myuros varhirsuta Annual fescue
Vulpia myuros var myuros Rattail fescue
6-62
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
2010 TERPP Annual Report
12
Appendix G: Exotic, Non-invasive Species
Scientific Name Common Name Genus species Common Name
Amaranthus albus Tumbleweed
Anagallis arvensis Pimpernel
Apium graveolens Celery
Aptenia cordifolia Baby sun-rose
Atriplex glauca Saltbush
Bidnes pilosa Common beggar-ticks
Capsella bursa-pastoris Shepherd's purse
Centranthus rubber Red valerian
Ceratonia siliqua Locust bean tree
Chamaesyce maculata Spotted spurge
Chenopodium album Lamb’s quarters
Chenopodium ambrosioides Mexican tea
Chenopodium murale Nettleleaf goosefoot
Conyza canariensis Horseweed
Coronilla valentina Coronilla
Cyperus involucratus Umbrella plant
Digitaria sanguinalis Hairy crabgrass
Echium fastuosum Pride of madeira
Erodium botrys Long-beaked filaree
Euphorbia lathyris Gopher plant
Euphorbia peplus Petty spurge
Filago gallica Narrow-leaf filago
Fraxinus uhdei Shamel ash
Gazania species Gazania
Geranium carolinianum Geranium
Gnaphalium luteo-album White cudweed
Koehlreuteria species Koehlreuteria
Lamarckia aurea Goldentop
Lantana montevidensis Lantana
Lathyrus odoratus Sweet pea
Lycium species Lycium
Lycopersicon esculentum Garden tomato
Malephora crocea Mesemb
Melaleuca species Melaleuca
Mesembryanthemum nodiflorum Iceplant
Osteoapermu fruticosum African daisy
Oxalis corniculata Woodsorrel
Paspalum dilatatum Dallis grass
Pinus halepensis Alepppo pine
Plantago major Plantain
Poa annua Bluegrass
Polygonum arenastrum Knotweed
Senecio vulgaris Groundsel
Silenle gallica Common catchfly
Triticum aestivum Cultivated wheat
Urtica urens Dwarf nettle
Veronica anagallis-aquatica Water speedwell
Yucca species Spanish bayonet
6-63
13
Appendix H. 2010 TERPP DATA and PHOTOS
Abalone Cove Pre Abalone Cove Post
Location: Abalone Cove, canyon
Date: 7/6/10
Amount of Plants: 65 Estimated area treated: 500 sq ft
Phenology: flowering
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
Agua Amarga/Lunada Canyon Pre Agua Amarga/Lunada Canyon Post
Location: Agua Amarga/Lunada Canyon, near Posey Way
Date: 7/6/10
Amount of Plants: 175 Estimated area treated: 200 sq ft
Phenology: flowering
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
6-64
14
Portuguese Bend Pre Portuguese Bend Post
Location: Portuguese Bend, bottom of Klondike Trail
Date: 5/8/10
Amount of Plants: 40 Estimated area treated: 3000 sq ft
Phenology:
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
San Ramon1 Pre San Ramon1 Post
6-65
15
San Ramon4 Pre San Ramon4Post
San Ramon5 Pre San Ramon5 Post
Treatment areas at San Ramon
Location: San Ramon Reserve
Date: July –October 2010
Amount of Plants: 5000 Estimated area treated: 5 acres
Phenology: flowering
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
6-66
16
Three Sisters 4a Pre Three Sisters 4bPost
Location: Three Sisters, at end of Ocean Terrace
Date: 7/6/2010
Amount of Plants: 1000 Estimated area treated: 1.5 acres
Phenology: Flowering
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
Three Sisters 1aPre Three Sisters 1bPost
Location: Three Sisters, Barkentine Trail
Date: 7/6/2010
Amount of Plants: 150 Estimated area treated: 1 acre
Phenology: Flowering
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
6-67
17
Vicente Bluffs 1aPre Vicente Bluffs 1bPost
Location: Vicente Bluffs, near drainage outfall at bottom of bluff
Date: 7/6/2010
Amount of Plants: 100 Estimated area treated: 50 sq. ft.
Phenology: Flowering
Control method: Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
Vicente Bluffs Pre Vicente Bluffs post
Location: Vicente Bluffs near Pacifica del Mar
Date: May 2010 and 7/6/2010
Amount of Plants: 40 Estimated area treated: 1000sq ft
Phenology: flowering/fruiting
Control method: Pulled by hand in May/Sprayed with Roundup Promax 2%
6-68
VOLUNTEER PROGRAM ANNUAL REPORT
6-69
Page | 1
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Introduction and Summary
1 INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY
1.1 Volunteer Programs
This Annual Report describes each of the individual programs included within the larger Volunteer Program as
well as plans for the future. Specific activities are detailed for the reporting period January 1, 2010 to
December 31, 2010. The PVPLC continues to work to implement grants geared toward improving this
program.
Since 1988, volunteers have played an essential role in fulfilling the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy’s
(PVPLC) mission to preserve land and restore habitat for the education and enjoyment of all. PVPLC is a non-
profit organization that relies heavily on the support of community involvement to perform many of the tasks
necessary to manage the Nature Preserves (Figure 1). Volunteers donate thousands of hours each year to help
with office assistance, event planning, community education, habitat restoration, trail maintenance, and much
more. This report divides the various volunteer programs into two categories: Community Involvement
Volunteers and Stewardship Volunteers.
The first category, Community Involvement Volunteers, supports volunteer activities that focus on friend
making, fundraising, and recommendations to staff on a variety of topics. This category is further divided into
3 programs which are detailed within the report:
Special Events and Office Assistance
Education
Committees and Advisory Boards
The second category, Stewardship Volunteers, supports activities that are performed on the land to assist with
management of the Preserves. In all, there are six programs within this category that are described in more
detail in the Stewardship Volunteer section of this report. The backbone of the program is our regularly
scheduled Saturday outdoor workdays that are open to participation by all and require no long-term
commitment. Periodically, there are also individuals or groups that contact the PVPLC and arrange to
complete stewardship projects outside of the normally scheduled outdoor workdays. Boy Scouts and Girls
Scouts interested in obtaining their final awards are two such groups. There are also several Stewardship
Volunteer opportunities that require long term commitments. The 6 programs are listed below:
Outdoor Volunteer Workdays
Team Leaders
Habitat and Ecological Restoration Organization (HERO) Club
Scout Awards
Trail Crew
Keeping an Extra Eye on the Preserve for Environmental Review and Stewardship (KEEPERS)
In 2010, volunteers provided a grand total of 12,133 hours of service (Table 1). According to the Independent
Sector, volunteer time in California is valued at $23.29 per hour (based on Dollar Value of a Volunteer Hour,
by State: 2008, Independent Sector), thus generating a total of $282,578 of in-kind services. The amount of
volunteer hours donated at each Nature Preserve or for a specific volunteer category depends on the size of
property or specific projects that transpired during the reporting period.
6-70
Page | 2
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Community Involvement
1. Preserves under PVPLC management open to volunteer programs
2 COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT
2.1 Special Events and Office Assistance Volunteer Program
The PVPLC relies on individual volunteers and organized groups, such as the National Charity League (NCL),
Los Hermanos, and Assisteens, to assist employees of the PVPLC with all major fundraising and friend-raising
events. We have built very strong and fulfilling relationships with these groups and strive to provide an
environment that lets volunteers know they are indispensable and an integral part of our organization.
The annual “Spring For White Point” event took place in June, and is organized by members of the White
Point Steering Committee and community members. The funds raised make it possible to complete the
transformation of the White Point property into a functioning nature preserve. It includes local home tour, an
evening reception with great food provided by San Pedro restaurants, live music and silent auction. Volunteer
tasks include event planning, soliciting donations for the auctions and food, setup and cleanup, and staffing the
event.
In the office, volunteers handle routine tasks such as labeling newsletters, stuffing envelopes, assembling event
materials, planning and preparation for special events, and much more. During the 2010 reporting year, office
volunteers, many from the Palos Verdes Chapter of NCL, donated 812 hours of assistance.
Palos Verdes Peninsula
Land Conservancy
Natural Open Space Preserves On
the Palos Verdes Peninsula
p..t!lnVaron Nlty~""I~In
Rancho I";lIoJv....on
FUIIifI P'.i!&sVr!fOn NX\lr.F'uwrw.
tt'I.ltullld trr Tna~NJCICIIW Galf COUtM
'-...-..-_-_..~---------c...-........--.-..._....
-~..,..._......-
Vlto6r'_..Geor,I"
c..nYOIi
N.:Ilut'l;
Pr.n,....
""''''...f.Of-_IN"'-.
t.:~c..,....~.......
6-71
Page | 3
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Community Involvement
Table 1. Distribution of volunteer hours.
Preserve hours include outdoor volunteers, KEEPERS, and Trail Crew time.
2.2 Educational Programs
Volunteers assist with three education-based programs to inform community members of all ages about
natural spaces on the peninsula. Education is provided to the public through Third Grade Docents Program,
the George F. Canyon Nature Center and Nature Walks.
2.2.1 Third Grade Docents
Now in the program’s fifteenth year, the Third Grade Docents volunteered a total of 159 hours. Since the
start of the program, the docents have served over 18,000 students. The docent group is comprised of a
diverse group of retired professionals and active volunteers from all over the Peninsula. Their backgrounds
range from law and engineering to nursing, chemistry and education. This team of dedicated people is trained
by Third Grade Program Manager, John Nieto, who began running the program in 2000. He is directly
responsible for the management and coordination of the entire program. While John Nieto and the docents
are paid for their time in the classroom, they donate many additional hours to make the program a success.
In addition to learning the academic information required to give lessons in the classroom, docent’s also
volunteer extra time to developing techniques for the trail by attending various training hikes and observing
other docents teaching the program.
Prior to the field trip, each docent visits his or her school’s third grade classrooms and conducts four weekly
lessons covering such topics as birds, invertebrates, geology, Tongva indigenous culture, reptiles, mammals
and plants. Table 1 shows a list of schools that participated in the program. One of the main goals embedded
in this standards-based curriculum is to help students understand the difference between native and non-native
Distribution of 20 I0 Volunteer Hours
Grand Total =12133 Hours
2500 -.--------------------------------------------
2000 +---------
1661
1500
1000
sao
57
a
White Point Chandler P.V,Nature Nursery
Preserve
George F
Canyon
Office Education
Docents
Special
Events
Boord of Committees Nature
Directors Walk
Leaders
6-72
Page | 4
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Community Involvement
species present in the coastal sage scrub community of the Palos Verdes Peninsula. The docents meet yearly
at the end of the semester to discuss accomplishments of the year and possible new activities for the
upcoming school year.
2.2.2 George F Canyon Nature Center
The Center is managed by a dedicated staff of two employees and several volunteers. Loretta K. Rose, the
Nature Center’s Manager and Head Naturalist, and her assistant worked closely with volunteers to provide a
number of programs for visitors of all ages at the Center and in the adjacent Nature Preserve. The Center
offers three types of hikes, the Canyon Night Hikes, Bird Walks and First Saturday Hikes. Canyon Night
Hikes are held on or near full moon evenings and show participants the nocturnal wonders of the canyon.
First Saturday Hikes occur in the early afternoon on the first Saturday of every month with a trained guide
who will answer questions on the habitat, geology, wildlife, and history of the canyon. There is also a monthly
bird walk during the morning of the first Saturday of every month with the Head Naturalist. The Nature
Center also arranges private hikes for school groups, scouts, and the public when requested. Birthday Parties
have been an integral part of the Nature Center’s link to the community. The staff at the Nature Center
books Birthday Parties year round which include a craft made by the children, a guided Hike, private use of the
Center and goody bags to take home. In addition, the Center’s staff and several volunteers are in charge of
maintaining and running the small gift shop located inside the Center which provides a unique assortment of
nature-themed gifts. Live animals are kept on display with informative signage and the opportunity for a hands-
on experience. The animals and their enclosures are maintained by the staff. The Nature Center is open
Friday, Saturday, and Sunday to the general public and at other times and dates throughout the year for
private groups.
2.2.3 Nature Walks
Nature Walk Leaders donated a total of 349 hours in 2010. PVPLC Board of Directors member Anke Raue
coordinates this group of dedicated volunteers and each prospective walk leader must have a high level of
knowledge the local ecosystem, particularly the native and non-native plants found on the Peninsula. Leaders
must go through extensive training and be willing to research and learn about local history, geology, flora and
fauna. Continued research and exploration serves to add to a walk leader’s knowledge base, preparing them
to give accurate and in-depth presentations to the public.
Walks are held all over the Peninsula, from the edge of the coast to deep within the canyons. Each leader
designs his or her presentation to include special attributes and stories particular to a site. Nature walks
occur once a month every month throughout the year, featuring a different location every time (Appendix 1).
2.3 Committees and Advisory Boards
The PVPLC maintains numerous committees and advisory boards for the following purposes:
To provide review and recommendations regarding organizational plans and policies
To provide assistance with the operations of the organization
To provide community input for PVPLC activities
To provide a training and evaluation ground for potential members of the Board of Directors
6-73
Page | 5
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Stewardship Volunteers
Committees volunteers donated a total of 1301 hours, with many committees meeting on a quarterly basis.
Hours for committee-involved board members are compiled with their board volunteer time. The committees
that were active during the reporting period are listed below:
Audit Committee
Finance Committee
Forrestal Advisory Board
Fundraising Committee
Investment Committee
Science Advisory Panel
Personnel/Human Resources Committee
Special Events Committee(s)
3 STEWARDSHIP VOLUNTEERS
Summary of accomplishments in 2010:
6611.22 hours of outdoor stewardship volunteer time
$20,000 REI grant to support volunteer programs and trails development
Facilitated the volunteering effort of several organizations and corporate give-back events
Continued support from local and regional schools
3.1 Outdoor Volunteer Workdays
The PVPLC holds outdoor volunteer days nearly every Saturday of the year, held from 9am-12pm, excluding
holiday weekends and during the month of August. The focus of these events is to restore native habitat,
maintain the trail system, and do general clean ups. The intended demographic is focused on individuals of all
ages, organized groups such as Boy Scouts and the National Charity League, and employee volunteer days for
corporations. All age groups are encouraged to participate. There is a particular focus on getting young people
involved as a mechanism to ensure education and stewardship on the Preserves in perpetuity. We work with
local schools and colleges to have teachers bring groups of students or give incentives such as extra credit and
service-learning hours for students who participate on the Saturday workdays.
A detailed account of workdays found below. Events are listed chronologically by Preserve with the Palos
Verdes Nature Preserve (PVNP) further separated by Reserve.
3.1.1 Palos Verdes Nature Preserve (PVNP)
Alta Vicente Reserve
January 30, 2010 – 57 volunteers removed Brassica species from the Phase 1 restoration site.
June 26, 2010 – Nine volunteers installed 27 Astragalus trichopodus and removed weeds from the Phase
1 area.
July 24, 2010 – Three volunteers planted 50 Astragalus trichopodus in the Phase 1 area.
September 25, 2010 – In honor of National Public Lands Day, 167 volunteers removed many invasive
plants including iceplant (Carpobrotus edulis), mustard (Brassica spp.), tocalote (Centaurea melitensis),
Acacia, and bristly ox-tounge (Picris echioides).
October 23, 2010 – 33 volunteers planted 90 native plants in the Phase 1 area.
December 4, 2010 – 30 volunteers planted 100 natives and removed weeds around installed plant in
the Phase 1 area.
6-74
Page | 6
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Stewardship Volunteers
Volunteers from the Los Hermanos
service group help remove weeds from
Three Sisters on June 22, 2010.
Forrestal Reserve
September 11, 2010 – Seven volunteers worked to close spur trails and with overgrown vegetation
cleared from other trails and collected Salvia leucophylla seeds.
Portuguese Bend Reserve
June 5, 2010 – In celebration of National Trails Day, 71 volunteers repaired a .5 mile section of
Ishibashi Trail.
October 10, 2010 – 28 volunteers hand-pulled Acacia seedlings sprouting near Ishibashi Trail.
Three Sisters Reserve
March 6, 2010 – 22 volunteers removed Brassica spp. from the
restoration area.
May 8, 2010 – 12 volunteers removed invasive plants from
around the installed natives.
June 19, 2010 – Nine volunteers removed weeds from around the
installed native plants.
November 13, 2010 – 23 volunteers helped plant 100 natives and
removed weeds around the established natives.
December 11, 2010 – 350 native plants were installed with help
from volunteers of the HERO Club.
3.1.2 George F Canyon Nature Preserve
February 20, 2010 – 72 volunteers removed Avena spp. and Bromus diandrus from the demonstration
garden and repaired cracks in the decomposed granite trail.
May 15, 2010 – 38 volunteers removed invasive plants from the demonstration garden.
3.1.3 Linden H. Chandler Preserve
January 9, 2010 – Seven volunteers weeded around the restoration site and repaired a wooden stick
fence.
November 6, 2010 – Five volunteers planted 15 Astragalus trichopodus and 15 Lotus scoparius individuals
and removed weeds in the area.
3.1.4 White Point Nature Preserve
March 27, 2010 – 67 volunteers removed invasive plant species from the demonstration garden.
April 24, 2010 – In celebration of Earth Day, 52 volunteers removed invasive plants from the
demonstration garden.
May 1, 2010 – In celebration of Big Sunday, 26 volunteers removed invasive species from the
demonstration garden and surrounding grassland habitat.
July 17, 2010 – With the help of LACC and Toyota, 230 volunteers removed invasive Carpobrotus
edulis, Malva parviflora, and Brassica spp., fixed cracks in the demonstration garden’s DG trail, and
removed milk snails from the garden plants.
6-75
Page | 7
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Stewardship Volunteers
Team Leader workshops
Date Number of new Team Leaders Number of Youths (Under the age
of 18)
March 13, 2010 7 7
October 2, 2010 12 9
Date and participation of Team Leader workshops.
Volunteer effort is essential in effectively
transplanting large amounts of native seedlings.
Luxury Link employees helping at the nursery
on December 7, 2010.
October 16, 2010 – Aloca’s Month of Service brought out 95 volunteers to plant 200 natives in the
demonstration garden, remove bristly ox-tounge (Picris echioides), rake mowed thatch in the
grasslands, cleaned trail signage, collected milk snails, and enjoyed a bird walk and the nature center
kid’s activities.
3.1.5 Native Plant Nursery
January 23, 2010 – 37 volunteers (many of them Girl Scouts) transplanted 1,675 Artemesia californica
seedlings.
February 6, 2010 – 55 volunteers transplanted 700
Rhus integrifolia and 700 Eriogonom parvifolium
seedlings, salvaged soil from plant containers and
removed invasive plants from the PV blue butterfly
habitat.
May 22, 2010 – 19 volunteers transplanted Eriogonum
fasciculatum and removed weeds from other plant
containers.
July 31, 2010 – 40 volunteers with of the Japanese
Business Association helped transplant Artemesia
californica seedlings, remove weeds from plant
containers, and installed 30 Lotus scoparius in the PV
blue butterfly garden.
September 18, 2010 – Nine volunteers transplanted
500 Astragalus trichopodus seedlings and removed
weeds from other plant containers.
October 30, 2010 – 12 volunteers transplanted 79 Encelia californica and 375 Artemesia californica
seedlings as well as removed weeds from other plant containers.
December 7, 2010 – 27 volunteers from Luxury Link helped hang new shade cloth and apply weed
barrier to the north side of the shade structure, transplanted 500 Artemesia californica seedlings,
removed weeds from the plant containers and processed Astragalus trichopodus seeds.
3.2 Team Leader Program
The Team Leader program was started in 2007 in response to the growing number of volunteers that were
attending the outdoor workdays (see Outdoor Volunteer Workdays). Team Leaders are volunteers, sixteen
years or older, who assist in supervising the Saturday outdoor volunteer activities. They ensure that
volunteers have adequate instruction and the tools necessary to complete the task. They also assist in
educating the public about the PVPLC.
6-76
Page | 8
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Stewardship Volunteers
The program requires that interested volunteers go through an application and interview process. Candidates
then attend a one day weekend workshop where they learn the skills necessary to perform the job. Training
involves both class room time and field work. Team Leaders commit to working at least four volunteer days
within one year. The goal of the PVPLC is to hold two Team Leader workshops each year during the spring
and train a minimum of six new Team Leaders at each one.
The Team Leader Program has helped develop leadership skills in participants and has greatly contributed to
the success of our Outdoor Volunteer Workdays. The quality of work from regular volunteers has increased
with the guidance of Team Leaders. In addition to local adult participants, many of the Team Leaders attend
local high schools and universities. During the reporting period, the program has allowed these students to
build leadership skills that they will find useful in their future.
Two Team Leader workshops were held during this reporting year – March 13th and October 2nd. Roughly 5
hours of combined classroom and outdoor time took place at the Native Plant Nursery in the Defense Fuel
Supply Depot during each workshop.
3.3 Habitat and Ecological Restoration Organization (HERO) Club
The HERO Club has increased their participation from 4 events to 8 events a year since the last reporting
period, striving to host an event every month during the year. The HERO Club coordinators also participate
in the Team Leader program in an effort to learn more about habitat restoration and leadership to help
facilitate the Outdoor Volunteer Days.
The HERO Club started at to local high schools – Peninsula High School and the Palos Verdes High School –
in September 2007 when a group of students partnered with the PVPLC to help the environment through
volunteering and help the PVPLC in their mission to preserve land and restore habitat. The club coordinates
with PVPLC and their Outdoor Volunteer Workday schedule to recruit student volunteers during several
Saturday HERO Club workday events a year. Their efforts have received much community support and
praise.
3.4 Scout Projects
The PVPLC encourages Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts who are looking for projects to complete their final
awards, Eagle Awards for Boy Scouts and Gold Awards for Girl Scouts, by providing them with opportunities
to complete their projects on preserves the PVPLC manages. This collaboration is beneficial to the scout
groups, the PVPLC, and the public that uses the preserves. Scouts work under the mentorship of one of the
PVPLC staff to complete their projects and are steered toward objectives that meet the PVPLC stewardship
goals. A brief description of each project completed during the reporting period is listed below.
Alan Williams
On November 27th, 2010, Alan installed post and rope fencing along the pathway through the garden from the
parking lot to the White Point Nature Preserve kiosk. He and fellow scouts also installed native plants and
repositioned irrigation along the path to further discourage off-trail hiking.
Bree Swenson
Bree developed explorer backpacks to be utilized by children and families on self-guided hikes at the White
Point Nature Center. She designed three educational hikes – Pirate Hike, Young Explorer Hike, and Critter
Hike – and led tours utilizing these tools in June 2010 in fulfillment of her Gold Award requirements.
Jonathan Kim
6-77
Page | 9
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Stewardship Volunteers
Trail Crew training classes
Date # Volunteer Hours Location Project/Skill Learned
January 2010 49 Forrestal Erosion control and trail repairs
February 2010 24.5 Portuguese Bend Erosion control and trail repairs
August 2010 48 White Point Introductory class
September 2010 26 Forrestal Trail survey
October 2010 40 Portuguese Bend Trail alignment
November 2010 33 Forrestal Tread skills
December 2010 24 Abalone Cove Rock retaining wall
Participation, location and skills learned at each Trail Skills class.
The Trail Crew Program has helped
improve the state of preserve trails and
maintains accessibility for the public to
enjoy these open spaces.
Successful Trail Crew event on the
Dauntless Trail in Forrestal Reserve.
Jonathan organized an effort to install post and rope fence at the southern end of Three Sisters Reserve on
July 24, 2010. They also worked to improve the trail by removing overgrown vegetation and large rocks.
Ryland Miller
On May 22 and 23, 2010, Ryland worked with his fellow scouts to install a footbridge over a stream at
Abalone Cove as well as reconstruct and stabilize a rock wall that leads the trail down to the bottom of the
canyon.
3.5 Trail Crew Volunteer Program
This year, the volunteer Trail Crew donated a contributed a
total of 245 hours to maintaining the Preserve’s trail system.
The Volunteer Trail Crew class offered is based on the Basic
Trail Maintenance class developed by Frank Padilla, Jr. (retired
California State Parks Supervisor), and Kurt Loheit. Originally
started in 1992, the class focused on both volunteer and agency
skill building. Adopted by the Angeles District of California State
Parks and later the Southern California Trails Coalition, it
became the first step in advanced classes for crew leader
training and design and construction classes, allowing a
structured path for participants to build skills associated with
trails from basic maintenance to highly advanced techniques. The
class is a combination of classroom and hands-on training to
familiarize the participants in all aspects of trail maintenance.
The course emphasizes safety, assessments, basic maintenance
skills, water control, erosion sources, terminology, proper tool
use, basic survey skills, resource considerations, and user
experience and maintenance value. Volunteers who
demonstrate proficiency in each learned skill and fulfill a yearly
indoctrination will maintain status as a qualified Trail Crew
member. The Trail Crew assists PVPLC in maintaining trails in all of our Preserves.
Participants must be at least 18 years old and must first take the introductory course. The 50-hour course
can be taken at the participant’s own pace and it is estimated to take about a year to complete. There are
scheduled Trail Crew Skills Classes that coordinate with the trail instructor’s availability and the PVPLC
Outdoor Volunteer Workday schedule.
On December 4th, 2010, three participants completed at least 50 hours of training and passed their yearly
6-78
Page | 10
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Grants
KEEPERS for each Reserve
Reserve # of Keepers
Abalone Cove Reserve 4
Agua Amarga Reserve 4
Alta Vicente Reserve 1
Linden H. Chandler 1
Forrestal Reserve 2
Portuguese Bend Reserve 4
Three Sisters Reserve 1
White Point Nature Preserve 2
Vicente Bluffs Reserve 1
Number of Keepers assigned to each property for
monthly monitoring.
indoctrination. This is the second round of participants to obtain their official Trail Crew member status. To
date, six volunteers have completed the training program and up to eleven other participants are close to
completing their 50 hours of required training and could be expected to take the yearly indoctrination in
2011.
3.6 Keeping an Extra Eye on the Preserves Stewardship (KEEPERS) Program
The KEEPERS program was developed in April of 2007 to help staff monitor the nearly 1600 acres of land that
is managed by the PVPLC. Keepers are volunteers who monitor an area within a preserve and fill out monthly
property review forms. These forms are reviewed by staff and consolidated into a monthly report that is sent
to all of the current Keepers.
The property review form is a one page form that requires some knowledge of basic trail maintenance and
plant identification. The skills needed to fill out these forms are provided in a training session with a PVPLC
staff person and are continually developed with an
ongoing relationship between the volunteer, the PVPLC
staff, and regular visits to the preserve being monitored.
This volunteer opportunity is a one year commitment (a
total of 12 visits) to the chosen preserve area. The
person or group that accepts this responsibility also
helps, if necessary, to train the following year’s
replacement volunteer Keeper. Currently, there is no
term limit.
Some of the properties managed by the PVPLC are
large enough to require more than one Keeper to
monitor them. We will be looking for two to four
Keepers to monitor the newly-acquired Upper Filiorum
Reserve beginning in spring or fall of 2011.
4 GRANTS
In August 2010, REI awarded the PVPLC with a $20,000 grant to support the Trail Crew and Outdoor
Volunteer Day programming. ALOCA continued their support of our outdoor volunteer program through a
$3000 work grant in conjunction with their employee give-back event.
5 FUTURE PLANS
The past year has focused on improving the existing volunteer programs so they operate smoothly and
sustainably. Further improvements can be made in retaining, focusing and motivating Team Leaders of all ages
and so future recruitment may be focused toward environmentally-minded college students and active
community residents. Additionally, the same goals can be applied towards the Trail Crew program’s capacity
to recruit new members and motivate graduated volunteers to develop and execute trail projects
independently. We will continue to pursue grant opportunities to help develop and sustain all volunteer
programs.
We intend to launch a stewardship program at White Point aimed at engaging community members to help
maintain the demonstration garden, signage and nature center.
6-79
Page | 11
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
6 APPENDIX, FIGURES AND TABLES
6-80
Page | 12
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
PALOS VERDES PENINSULA LAND CONSERVANCY
20 I0 Nature Walks
Where indicated,walks are co-sponsored by the Cities of Los Angeles (LA),Palos Verdes
Estates (PVE),Rancho Palos Verdes (RPy),Rolling Hills Estates and (RHE).
The Land Conservancy is a nonprofit 50 I (c)3 organization dedicated to open space
reservation and habitat restoration throughout the Peninsula.
See unusual geological
formations on the coastal
bluffs.The area is rich in
history dating from the
Abalone fishing industry
of the late 1800s followed
by a resort with pools fed
by natural hot springs.
Moderate.LA.
JAN.8,2011
9-IIAM
MALAGA COVE
NEW!
Take a trail from the bluff
below Malaga Cove leading to
the wide,sandy beach (Right
After Torrance),viewing the
spectacular landscape along
the way.Moderate.PVE.
OCT.9
3-SPM
ROYAL PALMS
STATE BEACH
NOV.13
9 -II AM
UPPER MALAGA COVE
Walk along a secluded fire
road above MalagaCove Plaza
enjoying maturetoyon bushes
full of brilliant red berries and
savor the unobstructed view
of the beach cities coastline.
Easy.PVE.
DEC.II
9-11 AM
BUTCHER HILL
NEW!
Follow the trail to the
top of this prominent hill
marking the entrance to
the Peninsula while taking in
breathtaking views of the LA
Basin.Return through the
majestic Val monte Canyon
Trail.Moderate.RHE.
SEP.II
9-IIAM
GEORGE F CANYON
PRESERVE
journey along a willow-
filled canyon with excellent
restored riparian and coastal
sage scrub habitat.Look
down on the Peninsula's
rare Catalina Schist from
one of the few places on the
mainland where you can see
the exposed rock.Easy to
Moderate.RHE.
AUG.14
4-6PM
OCEAN TRAILS
RESERVE
Traverse the bluffs east ofthe
Trump National Golf Course
which have mature coastal
sage scrub and cactus,prime
habitat of the rare songbird,
the California gnatcatcher.
Discover local history as
you pass WWII military
bunkers before descending
the coastal switch backs to
the beach below.Moderate
to strenuous.RPV:
jUL.10
9-11 AM
KEN MALLOY
REGIONAL PARK
Visit one of LA's largest
remaining natural freshwater
lakes containing tule marsh
and willow riparian forest and
boasting over 350 species of
migrating birds.Easy.LA.
jUN .•12
..9 -I AM
WHITE eOINT
Njl.TURE PRESERVE
Admire ocean views,
grasslands,and impressive
coastal sage scrub.The
Conservancy planted over
80,000 native plants on this
former military missile site,
now the location of a new
Nature Education Center
and demonstration gardens.
Moderate.LA.
APR.10
9-11 AM
FORRESTAL RESERVE
Encounter some of the best
remaining coastal sage scrub
on the Peninsula.Enjoy local
wildflowers such as the scarlet
paintbrush and mariposa
lily and see extraordinary
geology in the dramatic cliffs
where crystal and fossils are
visible.Moderate.RPV.
MAY 8
9-IIAM
LINDEN H.CHANDLER
PRESERVE
Experience three distinct
habitat types -restored
riparian vegetation,slopes
with coastal sage scrub
and grasslands.View the
successful habitat restoration
by the Conservancy.0 help
reintroduce the endangered
PV blue butterfly.Moderate.
RHE.
FEB.13
9-11 AM
MCBRIDE TRAIL
Join us for a dedication
ceremony to celebrate the
December 2009 acquisition
of the 191-acre Upper
Filiorum property which
now connects existing
reserves to form the
contiguous 950 acre Palos
Verdes Nature Preserve.
This will be followed by a
special walk along the same
rim trail that was the site of
the Conservancy's veryfirst
nature walk 19 years ago and
features panoramic views
over the newly pres-erved
land out to Catalina and
beyond.Easy.RPV:
jAN.9
9 -II AM
EAGLE'S NEST
Walk down Burma Rd.,to
view interesting geology
and a variety of plants,
all-the-while enjoying
the spectacular views.
Moderate.RPV:
MAR.13
9.-IIAM
PORTUGUESE
BE/'lD RESERVE
Follow the Ishibashi Trail
after the rainy season
to witness the changes
in habitat following the
August fire with a chance
to view rare wildflowers,
many not seen in decades.
Moderate.RPV:
6-81
Page | 13
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
Winter &10
JOIN US FOR
PVPLC OUTDOOR VOLUNTEER DAYS
Reservations appreciated but required for Nursery days.
Call Jill Wittman (310)541·7613 x20 I.
Would you like to help lead activities on volunteer days?
Become a Volunteer Team Leader!
For more information,email Leslie Buena at Lbuena@pvplc.org.
*AII events are from 9am-12pm unless otherwise specified.Workdays cancelled in event of rain.*
Closed toes shoes are required.Long pants are also required for trail work events.
Bottled water is provided but in an effort to reduce plastic waste,we encourage you to bring your own water.
January
January 9'h -Restore PV Blue Butterfly habitat at the Chandler Preserve
January 18'"-(Monday)Celebrate Martin Luther King,Jr.Day of Service with us at White Point'
January 23'"-Transplant native seedlings at our Nursery
January 30'h -Help with habitat restoration and weeding at the Alta Vicente Reserve
February
February 6'"-Transplant native seedlings at our Nursery
February 20'"-Help with weeding the George F Canyon demonstration garden
February 27'"-Team Leader Training Workshop (9am-3pm)
March
March 6'"
March 13lh
March 20'h
March 27'h
-Help with habitat restoration by weeding and planting at the Three Sisters Reserve
-Team Leader Training Workshop (9am-3pm)
-Transplant native seedlings at our Nursery
-Help with weeding and planting the White Point demonstration garden
Schedule is subject to change.Please visit our website at www.pvplcorg for updates.
Thank you to REI for your support with our Stewardship Volunteer Programs
Last updated 01106120 I0
6-82
Page | 14
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
PALOS VERDES PENINSULA
Spring 2010
OUTDOOR VOLUNTEER DAYS
Reservations appreciated but required for Nursery days.
Call Jill Wittman (3 10)541-7613 x20 1 ~:'--__-_.-~~I~
Volun'eers
WANTED!
Are you interested in other volunteer opportunities?
Visit our website at www.pvplc.org for more information.
*AII events are from 9am-12pm unless otherwise specified.Workdays cancelled in event of rain.*
Closed toes shoes are requi red.Long pants are also requi red for trail work events.
Bottled water is provided but in an effort to reduce plastic waste,we encourage you to bring your own water.
March
March 6Th
March 13th
March 20th
March 27"h
April
April 3rd
April 10 Th
April 24 Th
May
May 1st
May 15 th
May nnd
-Help with habitat restoration by weeding and planting at the Three Sisters Reserve
-Team Leader Training Workshop (9am-3pm)
-Transplant native seedlings at our Nursery
-Hel p with weeding and planting the White Point demonstration garden
-Help with weeding in the George F Canyon demonstration garden
-Transplant native seedlings at our Nursery
-Celebrate Earth Day with weeding and habitat restoration at White Point
-Celebrate Big Sunday (on a Saturday)by being a weed warrior at White Point
-Help with weeding and trail maintenance at the Three Sisters Reserve
-Help with weeding in the George F Canyon demonstration garden
-Transplant native seedlings and help with restoration at our Nursery
Schedule subject to change.Please visit our website at www.pypJc.org for updates.
Thank you to REI for your support with our Stewardship Volunteer ProgramsIErlILastupdated04/06120 I0
6-83
Page | 15
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
PALOI VfRDES PHI INSUlA
Summer 2010
OUTDOOR VOLUNTEER DAYS
Reservations appreciated but required for Nursery days.
CaJl Jill Wittman (310)541·7613 x201 to RSVP
An opportunity to earn service-learning hours
Are you interested in other volunteer opportunities?
Visit our website at www.pvplc.org for more information.
*AII events are from 9am-12pm unless otherwise specified.Workdays cancelled in event of rain.*
Closed toes shoes are required.Long pants are also required for trail work events.
Bottled water is provided but in an effort to reduce plastic waste,we encourage you to bring your own water.
June
June S~
July
July 3"
July 31"
August
-Celebrate National Trails Day with REI and PVPLC at Portuguese Bend Reserve
-Help with habitat restoration by weeding the Three Sisters Reserve
-Help with weeding at Alta Vicente Reserve
-HOLIDAY WEEKEND (no scheduled event)
-Be a weed warrior at the Three Sisters Reserve
-Help with weeding at the White Point demonstration garden
-The weeds are everywhere'Let's go after them at Alta Vicente Reserve
-Transplant native seedlings at our Nursery
Due to heat concerns,we are not offering outdoor workdays this month.
Outdoor Volunteer Workdays will resume in September.
Schedule subject to change.Please visit our website at www.pvplc.org (or updates.
Thank you to REI for your support with our Stewardship Volunteer Programs[1tI1 Last updated 05/06120 I0
6-84
Page | 16
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
Fall 2010
OUTDOOR VOLUNTEER DAYS
Are you interested in other volunteer opportunities?
Visit our website at WW'!'i,pYplc.,01l:for more information.
Reservations appreciated but required for Nursery days,
Call Jill Wittman (310)541-7613 x20 I
"'All event.are from 9am 12pm urle"otherwi,e 'pecified.Workday'cancelled in event of rain.*
Clo,ed toe ••hoe.are required.long pant,are also required for trail work event..
Bottled water i,provided but in ~effort to reduce plastic wa,te,we encourage you to bring your own water.
September ~"
September II"
September 18"
September 25"
Octooer 2'"
Octooer 9'"
Octooer 16"
Octooer 23~
Octooer 30"
November 6"
November 13"
November 20"
November 27'"
December ~"
December II"
December 18"
-Holiday Weekend
-Trail work and weeding at Forre,tal Reserve
-Transplant seedlings in the Native Plant Nursery.
-Celebrate National Pcblic land,Day with REI by pl~ting at Alta Vicente
-Team leader Tmining Workshop (9am-3pm at the Nursery -see website to get invoi'fed)
-Help improve trail.at Portuguese Bend Preserve
-Plant the demoostration garden at 'Nhite Point
-Weeding and pl~ting at the Alta Vicente restoration site
-Transpl~t seedlings and revegetate the Native Plant Nursery
-Install native plants for PV blue butterlly habitat at linden H.O1andler PreseIYe
-Help revegetate Three Sisters by planting native,.
-ContribJte to habitat restoration by planting at Portuguese Berd
-Thonksgi,;ng weekend
-Planting at the Alta Vicente restoration ,ite
-Help cootinue restoring Three Siste,..by planting natives
-Improve blue butterlly habitat by pl~ting at linden H.O1andler
5cheduil subjea to ch()']f".Flease visit oor website Jt WWII<PWt pre (or updJte<.
Thank you to REI for your support with our Stewardship Volunteer Programs1:1.u.ltupd>tod07115lWIO
6-85
Page | 17
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
LA
Volunteer Program
TRAINING WORKSHOP on October r d from 9am-3pm
Help the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
lead groups of volunteers on outdoor workdays.
Learn skills associated with habitat restoration,native plant propagation,
and trail maintenance.
o No experience necessary
o You must be at least 16 years old to participate
o You must be committed to help at 4 volunteer days during the year ahead
o Opportunity to earn service-learning hours
o Lunch and tee-shirts will be provided during the workshop
For more information or to register for our Team Leader Training Workshop,
contact Adrienne Bosler at abosler@pvplc.org or (310)541-7613 x213.
Directions and other event details will be provided to those who RSVP.
Thank you to REI for your support with our Stewardship Volunteer Program.ma rAlOSVlROHP[NINSULA
~.
.."
6-86
Page | 18
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – March 3, 2011 | Appendix, Figures and Tables
Volunteer Trail Crew
Train to become a volunteer Trail Crew member
and help the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy
maintain trails on the Nature Preserves.
Learn skills associated with trail maintenance and design
during a 50-hour course taught by a
nationally recognized trail expert.
NEXT INTRODUCTORY COURSE -August 14,2010
1-5:00 pm at the White Point Education Center
To RSVP and receive more information contact
Adrienne Bosler at abosler@pvplc.org or (310)541-7613 x213.
THANK YOU REI FOR YOUR SUPPORT!III
6-87
ANNUAL REPORT 2010
SECTION: Research and Education Program
NAME: Ann Dalkey
6-88
P a g e | 1
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – February 28, 2011 | introduction
1. University student research
Students from California State
University, Dominguez Hills, in a
classroom research project to
investigate the age of the burned
lemonade berry stand following the
August 2009 wildfire.
1 INTRODUCTION
The Research and Education Program at the Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy (PVPLC)
began in 2006 with a generous grant from Alcoa Foundation and Alcoa Fastening Systems. The grant
funded the Research, Education, and Community Involvement Program for the Environment
(RECIPE), which was renewed for two years in 2008 and concluded in May 2010. Alcoa’s support
enabled PVPLC to develop a robust research program centered on improving our conservation
efforts while extending learning opportunities within our community.
Research is designed to engage students from elementary through university level to foster sound
scientific education for youth, as well as provide research opportunities for academia (Box 1). A
tiered approach, accommodating various skill levels, provides the framework for the research
program, and includes middle and high school students, university undergraduate students, graduate
students, and professors, PVPLC staff, and community volunteers. University professors are crucial
to the success of research, because they provide expertise and technical guidance, including managing
several research projects. Conservancy staff provides access to the preserves as well as technical
support to participants. Over 30 scientists participate in PVPLC’s Science Advisory Panel which
supports the research by providing their expertise as
needed for research projects on the preserves.
With the conclusion of the Alcoa Grant, PVPLC’s goal for
2010 was to insure continuity of the program following the
grant’s conclusion. Identified needs included strengthening
collaborative relationships with universities and
organizations, and seeking new funding sources. It was
equally important to continue integrating young students
and researchers to maintain the spirit of RECIPE. As a
result, two grants were obtained in 2010, one from the
Long Family Foundation for the research program 2010 and
one from the State of California’s Department of Food and
Agriculture that will be funded in 2011.
This report covers the Research and Education Program’s
activities via the major categories:
• Research on the Preserves
• Research Education
• Community Researchers, and
• Applied Research.
6-89
P a g e | 2
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – February 28, 2011 | Research on the Preserves
2 RESEARCH ON THE PRESERVES
Most research projects are multi-year endeavors, managed by either PVPLC or university
researchers (Box 2). By engaging in longer projects, year-to-year variability in the environmental
conditions at the research site can be captured. The longer timeframe allows high school students to
work on projects over successive years or a succession of high school students can work on the
projects.
3 RESEARCH EDUCATION
The RECIPE program fosters scientific curiosity in young students through programs designed for
elementary students. When experiencing natural surroundings supplemented with a scientific
foundation, PVPLC aims to engage students in understanding nature. Through these experiences,
student appreciation of nature grows while expanding their awareness of outdoor recreational
opportunities.
2. List of research projects currently ongoing in the preserves.
Research Managed by PVPLC
• Three Sisters Bird Survey – A bi-monthly survey to study the bird community’s response to a 21-acre
restoration effort within the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve.
• Microclimate on the Preserves – High school students participate in monitoring habitat temperature and
humidity trends for different plant species.
• Wild Animal Surveys – High school and college students track coyote and fox use of the preserves and
their diets.
Managed by University Researchers
• Archeology at Abalone Cove – CSU Fullerton students, under their professor’s guidance, conduct a
professional dig at the preserve for Native American artifacts.
• Biomass of the buckwheats Eriogonum cinereum and E. fasciculatum – The second year for a project to
develop a measure of plant material (biomass) contained within an acre of coastal sage scrub utilizing high
school and university students.
• Cursorial arthropods at Alta Vicente – A collaborative project with a CSU Long Beach undergraduate,
graduate, and high school students to assess response of cursorial arthropods to restoration at the Alta
Vicente Reserve.
• Geosciences Diversity Enhancement Program (GDEP) – Led by CSU Long Beach geography and geology
professors, this project seeks to increase the diversity of students in the disciplines of geography,
anthropology, geology, and biology.
• Study on the effects of the addition of AM fungi (mycorrhizae) on native and non-native species
germination in CSS-- UCLA Environmental Science Senior Practicum.
• Grassland and coastal sage scrub soil and seeding – University of Riverside (UCR) doctoral student’s
dissertation project, completed and PhD conferred in November 2010.
• Multi-Agency Rocky Intertidal Network (MARINe) – A new long-term monitoring site was added to the
nationally-run MARINe program, managed by a CSU Long Beach marine biology professor and his
students.
6-90
P a g e | 3
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – February 28, 2011 | Community Researchers
After four years of RECIPE research, tangible benefits students gained from the research are
apparent. Students learn about science research while working hard and gaining an appreciation for
natural sciences, often winning top honors in science fairs
(Box 3). They leverage their experience to gain entrance
to top universities, satisfy course credits, or obtain
internships.
Also, the Alcoa Grant has enabled PVPLC to develop a
program for middle school students. By leveraging the
Alcoa Grant, PVPLC received another grant to develop a
weather station array. A total of 9 weather stations have
been distributed to 6 schools, 2 preserves, and 2
community volunteer locations. The website has been
designed and allows students and their teachers to view
their data along with other sites. While teachers
incorporate the real-time display of weather into
California State Content Standards for sixth-graders,
students are more engaged in the lessons
4 COMMUNITY RESEARCHERS
Volunteers are an important for PVPLC, not only helping
with growing plants, habitat restoration, guiding walks,
and special events, but also with science research and
education. Our volunteers are terrific and travel from
throughout the Peninsula and surrounding areas to help
out.
Volunteer-based science research
surged during the year, ranging from
high school students to retirees
(Box 4). The types of projects varied
and were highlighted by reaching the
mid-point of a 5-year bird survey at
the Three Sisters Reserve
5 APPLIED RESEARCH
In addition to research, educational, and volunteerism in our scientific research, PVPLC includes
applied research in its program. Activities conducted under the applied research umbrella support
our on-going efforts to grow native plants, conduct habitat restoration, and stay on the forefront of
restoration science.
3. High school research
High school researcher Nicole Lim: ”After
hours of hiking, researching, and working
with you, I’ve learned so much about not
only wildlife but also about teamwork,
improvisation, and optimism. Whenever I
continue my research in college, I’ll always
remember that it all started with you.”
4. List of volunteer research projects currently
ongoing in the preserves.
Volunteer Research Projects
• Peninsula Wildflower Book – Community Volunteer
• Small Mammal Survey – Community Volunteer
• Three Sisters Bird Survey – PV/SB Audubon Chapter – 26
volunteers
• White Point Nature Preserve Bird Survey – Alcoa Volunteer
Day
6-91
P a g e | 4
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – February 28, 2011 | Applied Research
College students actively participate in PVPLC’s applied research through internships. In addition to
providing us support while gaining hand’s on experience, PVPLC aims to provide opportunities for
satisfying college credit. Students are able to embark on projects to meet classroom field
requirements or obtain course credit for specific projects.
Work was completed on PVPLC’s vegetation mapping project that was initiated in early 2009. With
the help of staff and college interns, all mapped data were digitized and summarized in a report. This
report provides detailed baseline data of habitat within the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve. Upon the
completion of the report, PVPLC staff presented the results to the local California Native Plant
Society, California Society for Ecological Restoration (SERCAL), and Southern California Academy of
Sciences (SCAS).
Additionally, PVPLC’s stewardship staff conducted a
variety of surveys at the restoration sites throughout the
preserves. Vegetation transect surveys are conducted
using standardized methods that provide data on the
cover of native and non-native plants in the habitat (Box
5). In 2010, the triennial survey was conducted for special
status plants in the Palos Verdes Nature Preserve. These
5. List of monitoring programs in 2010.
Vegetation Surveys
• Alta Vicente Reserve – Initial surveys on the first 10 acres of a 15-acre habitat restoration
• Defense Fuel Supply Point – Surveying habitat for the Palos Verdes blue butterfly
• Linden H. Chandler Preserve – Vegetation survey in habitat restored for the Palos Verdes blue butterfly
• Palos Verdes Nature Preserve – Monitoring for special status plant species
• Three Sisters Reserve – Surveys on a 21-acre habitat restoration
Endangered Butterfly Surveys
• Linden H. Chandler Preserve – Surveys were conducted for the Palos Verdes blue butterfly where
progeny from the 2009 release were observed.
• Vicente Bluffs and Abalone Cove Reserves – Surveys were conducted for the El Segundo blue butterfly,
including areas where PVPLC is actively improving the habitat for the butterfly.
Stewardship Manager Cris Sarabia
conducts a vegetation transect survey at
the Linden H. Chandler Preserve to obtain
quantitative data on the results of the
restoration sites. These data are important
for managing the preserve that has seen
the release of Palos Verdes blue butterflies
following the restoration.
6-92
P a g e | 5
Palos Verdes Peninsula Land Conservancy – February 28, 2011 | Applied Research
plants include species like the Catalina crossosoma, bright green Dudleya, and south coast salt bush.
Also, PVPLC staff conducted surveys of both endangered butterflies present on the Peninsula in
2010, the Palos Verdes blue butterfly and El Segundo blue butterfly.
6-93