Loading...
CC MINS 19780418 . M I N U T E S RANCHO PALOS VERDES CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING APRIL 18, 1978 The meeting was called to order at 7:35 P.M. by Mayor Ken Dyda at the Palos Verdes Unified School District Building, 30942 Hawthorne Boulevard. Following the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag, roll call was answered as follows: PRESENT: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA ABSENT: NONE Also present were City Attorney Patrick Coughlan, City Manager Leonard G. Wood, Administrative Assistant Trish Hanelin, Director of Planning Sharon W. Hightower, Director of Public Works Dennis J. Pikus, Director of Parks & Recreation Maynard Law, Community Services Officer Tom Bandy, Administrative Services Officer George Wunderlin and Deputy City Clerk Mary Jo Lofthus. CEREMONIAL MATTER Mayor Dyda presented to Mrs. Suzie SUZIE SHOWALTER Showalter a resolution in honor of (304) her being selected as the community's "honoree" at the thirteenth annual County-wide Older Americans Recognition Day being held on April 29, 1978. The resolution cited her diligent efforts in service to the senior citizens of the City and extended the sincere appreciation of the members of the City Council on behalf of the entire community. LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS Mayor Dyda introduced Mrs. Karen Downs (305) who will be serving as the Rancho Palos Verdes City Council Observer for the League of Women Voters of the Palos Verdes Peninsula. APPROVAL OF AGENDA After addition of Request from Sandpipers to place signs in the public right-of-way (City Manager) , the agenda was approved on motion of Councilman Ryan, seconded by Councilwoman Shaw. There being no objection, MAYOR DYDA SO ORDERED. WAIVER OF FULL READING OF Councilman Ryan moved, seconded by Council- ORDINANCES & RESOLUTIONS woman Shaw, to waive reading in full of all ordinances and resolutions adopted at this meeting with consent to the waiver of read- ing to be deemed to be given by all members of Council after the reading of the title, unless specific request was made at that time for the reading of such ordinance or resolution. There being no objection, MAYOR DYDA SO ORDERED. COMMISSION & COMMITTEE Mayor Dyda explained the procedure to be APPOINTMENTS used in voting for members to the various (106) City commission and committees. He stated that each member of Council would be given a separate ballot for each committee and commission. These ballots listed the candidates who had applied for appointment. Administrative Services Officer explained that the resolution presented to Council combined the procedure as set out by the Council's subcommittee and adopted on April 4, 1978; Section 54972, 3 and 4 of the California State Code (Maddy Act) ; and, the requirement that any vote of members of Council for appointment of commission or committee members be reflected in the public record. 817 Councilman Buerk voiced his objection to the April 18, 1978 draft of additions to the proposed resolution stating that these were significant changes to the procedure and requested that the procedure be resubmitted to the Council's sub- committee. Council then discussed whether each member should have one or five votes, and it was the opinion of the majority that each member of Council should have one vote. Councilman Buerk moved that the fourth line of Section 4 of the proposed res- olution be changed to read: "No member of Council shall cast more than 2 votes for any candidate." The motion was seconded by Councilwoman Hein but failed on the following roll call vote: AYES: BUERK AND HEIN NOES: RYAN, SHAW AND MAYOR DYDA Councilwoman Shaw moved, seconded by Councilwoman Hein to add to Section 2 of the proposed resolution, the provision dealing with the deadline for submission of applications as outlined in the April 18, 1978 draft submitted to Council. The motion carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE Councilwoman Shaw moved, seconded by Councilman Ryan, that Section 6 of the pro- posedresolution be substituted as it appears on the draft of April 18, 1978. Mayor Dyda then read that section as follows: SECTION 6. Breaking Tie Votes or Insufficient Votes In case of tie vote or insufficient votes, each member of the Council shall vote again. Voting under this condition shall be conducted as follows: O Where the number of tied candidates is less than the number required to fill vacancy: Voting in this case shall be restricted to the tied candi- dates, plus those candidates who received one less vote than the tied candidates. O Where the number of tied candidates is equal to the number required to fill vacancies, but each received less than three votes: Voting in this case shall be restricted to the tied candidates plus those candidates with one less vote. O Where the number of tied candidates exceeds the number of vacancies: Voting in this case shall be restricted to the tied candidates. 0 When there are two vacancies remaining and two candidates with insufficient votes and a tie does not exist: Voting shall be opened up to all candidates. The number of votes for each member of Council shall be reduced to the number of seats which remain to be filled, or in the case of a tie for a longer term, to the number of remaining appoint- ments with the longer term. City Council 818 April 18, 1978 The motion to substitute Section 6 failed on the following roll call vote: AYES: SHAW NOES: RYAN, BUERK, HEIN & MAYOR DYDA RESOLUTION NO. 78-21 OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES ADOPTING RULES AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING THE APPOINTMENT OF CITIZEN COMMISSIONS OR COMMITTEES was introduced by title. Councilwoman Shaw moved, seconded by Councilman Ryan to ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 78-21. The motion carried on the follow- ing roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, SHAW AND MAYOR DYDA 11/ NOES: BUERK AND HEIN Mayor Dyda then told the Council that they should now proceed with the voting for each appointee to the committees and commission. Councilman Buerk stated that he was not prepared to vote under this new procedure. RECESS: At 8:30 P.M. Mayor Dyda called a brief recess. At 8:35 P.M. Council reconvened with the same members present. PLANNING COMMISSION Mayor Dyda explained the voting process, APPOINTMENTS noting that it would be the same for all (106 x 1203) committees and commission. Each member of Council was then supplied with a ballot listing all those candidates who had applied for appointment to the Planning Commission. Each member of Council voted and gave their ballot to Mayor Dyda who announced the results of the voting. Appointments to the Planning Commission were as follows: Douglas Hinchliffe Harvey A. Brown Jacki Bacharach Melvin W. Hughes John C. McTaggart Because Douglas Hinchliffe received the highest number of votes, he was appointed to serve for a four year term. On a second round of voting, Harvey A. Brown, M.D. was appointed to serve for four years. Members of Council then voted for the Commission Chairman and as a result of that vote, Melvin W. Hughes was elected Chairman. It was the consensus of Council that the Chairmanship of the committees and commission would be reviewed annually by the Council. PARKS & RECREATION Mayor Dyda passed out ballots for the Parks COMMITTEE and Recreation Committee. As a result of (106 x 1201) the first round of voting, the following members were elected. Alvin Rosenthal Susan Soldoff Robert Gibson Larry Zamos Since Rosenthal and Soldoff each received five votes, they were appointed to serve four year terms. City Council 819 April 18, 1978 The second round of voting resulted in insufficient votes being cast for the eligible candidates. As a result of the third round of voting, Jerome T. Marani was appointed to this committee. The round of voting for the committee chairman resulted in a tie between two candi- dates. Council voted again for chairman and this resulted in Alvin Rosenthal being appointed Chairman. TRAFFIC COMMITTEE Mayor Dyda distributed the ballots for the (106 x 1502) Traffic Committee. The members elected as a result of that vote were: Arline Grotz Ray Mathys Russell H. Maguire David Diestel Arline Grotz and Ray Mathys each received five votes and were appointed for four year terms. Since three candidates tied for the one remaining vacancy, Council voted again. This second round of voting resulted in a tie between two candidates. As a result of the third round of voting, Michael Gould was elected as the fifth member of the Traffic Committee. Raymond Mathys was elected by Council to serve as Chairman of this committee. ENVIRONMENTAL COMMITTEE Voting for members of this committee re- (106 x 1205) sulted in the appointment of Dr. Donald Baer, Klaus Schuegraf and Alexander Muraszew. Since Klaus Schuegraf received the highest number of votes, he was appointed to a four year term. Klaus Schuegraf was elected by the Council to serve as Chairman of this committee for the next year. City Council's records for voting on these appointments are attached hereto and made a part of these minutes. RECESS: At 9:30 P.M. Mayor Dyda declared a brief recess. At 9:40 P.M. the Council re- convened with the same members present. SEA COVE Director Pikus presented the April 12, 1978 DRAINAGE CHANNEL letter from the County of Los Angeles, (604) Department of County Engineer which de- scribed three alternates, for the storm drain improvement to minimize erosion and backblow at the outlet of the existing channel near Barkentine Road and Sea Cove Drive. He stated that the funds for this project would come out of General Fund reserves since no funds had been appropriated for this project. Mr. Rudy Maus, 420 Mesa, Santa Monica representing Lyn Dakin, 36 Sea Cove, requested to know if a date could be set for commencing this project and if the channel would be covered. Director Pikus then described how the proposal received from Ralph Stone and Company, dated April 13, 19.78, would correct this condition. City Council 820 April 18, 1978 Council discussed the best method of covering the open channel and it was the consensus of Council that bids for this work should include such covering. Councilwoman Shaw moved to direct Staff to contract with a firm to get a bid package encompassing a scheme similar to the proposal in the April 13, 1978 letter from the Ralph Stone & Company with the addition of covering the open channel and, further, authorized engineering costs not to exceed $5800. The motion was seconded by Council- woman Hein and carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE VACATION OF CLOVERCLIFF Director Pikus presented the Staff memorandum 11/ (1408) of April 12, 1978 which described the location of this pocket park. It was Staff recommen- dation that the City Council adopt the proposed resolution declaring its intention to vacate a public right-of-way on Clovercliff Drive between Golden Meadow Drive and the City limits of Palos Verdes Estates and set the matter for public hearing. John McTaggart, Chairman of the Planning Commission, told the Council that he was happy to seethe Clovercliff pocket park come to fruition. RESOLUTION NO. 78-22 OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO VACATE CLOVERCLIFF DRIVE BETWEEN GOLDEN MEADOW DRIVE AND THE CITY LIMITS AND SETTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR A PUBLIC HEARING THEREON was introduced by title. Councilwoman Shaw moved, seconded by Councilman Ryan to ADOPT RESOLUTION NO. 78-22. The motion carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE PARK TREE DONATION Director Law presented the Staff report of (1407) April 6, 1978 which answered the questions raised by Council at the April 4, 1978 Council Meeting. Council briefly discussed the maintenance necessary for these trees and their placement. Councilman Ryan moved, seconded by Councilwoman Hein to accept the trees. The motion carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE COMMUNICATION FROM THE The Director of Planning presented the PLANNING COMMISSION RE April 18, 1978 memorandum from the Planning EXTENSION OF CRENSHAW Commission which outlined the Commission's (1203 x 1502) request that the Traffic Committee review the potential impacts on all the associated arterials if Crenshaw Boulevard was extended down the hill to facilitate access to properties that are currently zoned for development. Council discussed the possible liability that might be incurred in extending this road, taking into consideration its past history. Councilman Buerk moved, seconded by Councilman Ryan to accept the Planning Commission's recommendation and send this request to the Traffic Committee. (Later in the dis- cussion, the motion failed due to Councilman Ryan withdrawing his second.) City Council 821 April 18, 1978 Council then discussed the fact that any future development in this area would have to pay for geologic testing required to prove the stability of this area. Grave concern was expressed for the City exposure to liability if building was permitted in this area. Planning Commissioner, Mel Hughes, 28017 San Nicolas Drive, told the Council that it was the intent of the Planning Commission to develop background on this area should requests for building developments be presented to the Commission. Councilwoman Shaw moved, seconded by Councilman Ryan to send this matter to the Traffic Committee to review the potential impacts on the associated arterials should Crenshaw be extended down the hill to facilitate access to properties that are potentially zoned for development. The motion carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE HEALTH SERVICES AGENCY Mayor Dyda reported on this agency, citing (310) the fact that its area of authority had been extended to cover more than health. Council- man Buerk moved to send letters to the appropriate Federal legislatures requesting that they curb the scope of this agency. The motion was seconded by Councilman Ryan and carried unanimously. SANITATION DISTRICT Mayor Dyda reported on the Sanitation Districts MEETING Board Meeting where concern was expressed for (310) the diminishing number of landfill sites avail- able to cities. He noted that the landfill located in the City of Rolling Hills Estates would be full by the year 1980. Also the leases on some other fill sites were running out and there is some question as to whether or not they will be extended. If the City is forced to use sites located in the Santa Monica Mountains this could significantly impact the residents of the City. SANITATION DISTRICT - With Councilman Ryan noting how long it took for CONTINUED - Council representatives to familiarize themselves REPRESENTATION with the procedures on the Sanitation Districts (310) Board, the suggestion was made that since the City encompasses two districts, South Bay Cities District and District No. 5, that perhaps the Mayor should represent one district and the Mayor Pro Tem the other district. Mayor Dyda noted that he would work with the Mayor Pro Tem on this suggestion and report back with an appropriate approach. RANCHO PALOS VERDES Councilman Buerk explained his request to have BEAUTIFICATION COMMITTEE a Rancho Palos Verdes beautification committee (310) composed of interested citizens to improve the aesthetics in the City. He requested that the Council authorize him to work with Staff in developing a charter for such a citizens' committee and bring back to Council. Councilwoman Shaw so moved, with seconding by Councilwoman Hein. The motion carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE IDENTIFICATION OF ISSUES Councilman Buerk requested that members of BROUGHT BEFORE COUNCIL Council indicate what action they were re- BY COUNCIL MEMBERS questing when presenting items for the agenda. (310) City Council 822 April 18, 1978 LEGISLATION Councilwoman Shaw presented several bills (310) that were pending before the legislature and which impacted the City. AB2442 (Speed Limits) which would give Cities additional flexibility in establishing speed limits where radar enforcement is authorized. Councilman Ryan moved, seconded by Council- woman Hein to support this bill. The motion carried unanimously. Council voted to oppose SB1664 because of its adverse impact on the building permit procedure. Council- man Ryan moved, seconded by Councilwoman Hein to oppose this bill. The motion carried unanimously. Councilwoman Shaw noted that AB1109 could be a possible source of funding when the Lower Nike Site is developed and requested that the Council support this bill and so moved. The motion was seconded by Councilman Ryan and carried unanimously. Since SB1359 would impose a tax on registered vehicles, Councilman Ryan moved, second- ed by Councilwoman Shaw to oppose this bill. The motion carried unanimously. Councilwoman Shaw moved, seconded by Councilwoman Hein to oppose AB2885 (Inverse condemnation). The motion carried unanimously. Council also voted to oppose AB2757 (Requiring compensation for local land use actions) on motion of Councilwoman Shaw, seconded by Councilwoman Hein. The motion carried unanimously. Councilman Ryan moved, seconded by Councilwoman Shaw to oppose AB3653 -- a bill which would curtail the provisions of the Quimby Act. The motion carried unanimously. AUDIENCE QUESTIONS Jack Satalich, 4125 Lorraine Road, distributed (1201) a letter to the Council outlining the type of wrestling program that he was requesting be initiated at one of the local schools. Since Council had not had the opportunity to review this letter, it was agreed that Councilwoman Shaw and the Director of Parks & Recreation would meet with Mr. Satalich to discuss this program. Staff was directed to bring back a report on this meeting to Council at the 1st meeting in May. RECESS At 11:40 P.M. Mayor Dyda declared a brief recess. At 11:45 P.M. Council reconvened with the same members present. APPEAL OF HEIGHT Director Hightower presented the Staff VARIATION NO. 84 memorandum of April 18, 1978 which gave DR. & MRS. STEVEN MERRILL the background on this height variance (1804) which had been denied by the Planning Commission. Staff recommendation was that the City Council uphold the Commission's decision of denial based upon the incompatability of the proposed structure with the adjacent neighborhood. Mayor Dyda noted that he had received many requests to speak before the Council and requested if both sides had chosen a spokesman to voice their opinions. Dr. Steven Merrill, 30851 Rue Valois, the applicant, told the Council the reasons which necessitated his building this addition. He read a letter received from the Department of Adoptions, County of Los Angeles which referred to the inadequate sleeping accommodations which existed at the Merrill home since the adoption of four children. Additionally, he presented a petition which had been signed by 30 people in the neighborhood. Mrs. Merrill also spoke to Council about the need for this addition. Mr. Milan Smith, 1624 Granvia Altamira, Palos Verdes Estates, representing the Merrills, told the Council that this addition would not interfere with anybody's view and, therefore, the addition should be approved. City Council 823 April 18, 1978 Mr. Don Martin, 30839 Rue Valois, and Mr. Glen Turner, 30931 Rue Valois, spoke in favor of this variance. Mr. Richard Kodani, 30940 Via Rivera, spoke in opposition because it was his opinion that the addition would impact his view. Mr. Joseph Clifford, President of the West Palos Verdes Homeowners Association, also spoke in opposition to this variance, citing the fact that this proposed addition would be highly visible from Rue Valois and Via Rivera and recommended that the Council reject this appeal. Mrs. Letitia Hicks, 30924 Via Rivera, also spoke in opposition to this addition. Mayor Dyda noted that a Council subcommittee worked on the clarification of this ordinance, however there had been no legal changes made. Mr. Milan Smith and LaWanna Adams, 30845 Rue Valois, spoke again in support of the variance. Discussion then followed regarding the original intent of this ordinance with regard to view; the fact that there already were several two story homes in the area and that no CC & Rs existed which limited homes to one story. Council noted that no evidence was presented which indicated that there would be any sig- nificant view obstruction if this addition was built. Councilman Ryan moved to grant the appeal of Variance No. 84. Councilman Buerk seconded the motion which carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: HEIN At 12:00 P.M. Councilman Buerk moved to adjourn the meeting. The motion died for lack of a second. REQUEST FROM DEL CERRO'S On motion of Councilman Ryan, seconded by HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION Councilwoman Hein, this matter was tabled RE LANDSCAPING OF until the next meeting. The motion carried CRENSHAW BOULEVARD unanimously. (808) ABALONE COVE HOMEOWNERS The Director of Public Works presented the ASSOCIATION Staff memorandum of April 12, 1978 which (808) noted the receipt of a request from the Abalone Cove Homeowners Association re- questing assistance in landscaping the embank- ment and median strip on Palos Verdes Drive South in the vicinity of Barkentine Road. Staff recommendation was that the City continue with its present policy of making the needed landscaping improvements at the time Palos Verdes Drive South is im- proved in that area. However, if the embankment erosion needed prompt attention, it was recommended that the landscaping be installed by the homeowners according to plans approved by the City and that the City be responsible for the maintenance. Mr. Jeff Grant, 3212 Barkentine, referred to his letter of February 24, 1978 which described the deteriorating condition of the center strip adjacent to the road and bank areas of Palos Verdes Drive South in the vicinity of Barkentine Road. He told the Council that this area was hazardous and distributed pictures of the area which indicated where the erosion had taken place. In addition to correcting the erosion, Mr. Grant requested a sign be placed at this intersection, and that the myroporium be topped. Council noted that since other similar requests have been brought to Council, it would be best not to consider this on an individual basis but have Staff work on an overall program of cleaning debris and grading embankments that have been eroded. City Council 824 April 18, 1978 . Councilman Ryan stated that he would like to see some reflectors installed at this intersection to make left turn lane safer. It was the consensus of Council that safety improvements should be made to this intersection. Councilman Ryan moved to request the Director of Public Works to do whatever repairs were required to restore that area to a safe standard. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman Hein and carried unanimously. Councilman Ryan moved to table the issue of landscaping until the next meeting. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman Hein and carried unanimously. REQUEST FROM SANDPIPERS The City Manager presented the April 12, 1978 TO PLACE SIGNS IN THE PUBLIC request from the Sandpipers to place signs in RIGHT-OF-WAY the public right-of-way. (305) On motion of Councilman Ryan seconded by Councilwoman Hein the request to place these signs in the public right-of-way and waive the fee was granted. The motion carried unanimously. CONSENT CALENDAR: After removal of the minutes of April 4, 1978 the Consent Calendar was approved as follows: RESOLUTION NO. 78-23 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 78-23 OF THE CITY REGISTER OF DEMANDS COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES (1504) ALLOWING CERTAIN CLAIMS AND DEMANDS IN THE SUM OF $242,702.73. CLAIM FOR DAMAGE TO Denied the claim for damage to personal PERSONAL PROPERTY - property from Sanford P. Kaufman. SANFORD P. KAUFMAN (303) TENTATIVE TRACT NO. 29795 Granted the extension of Tentative Tract No. REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TRACT 29795 located on Via Campesina. (1411) COMMUNITY RECREATION PROGRAM Approved the agreement with the Palos Verdes WITH PALOS VERDES PENINSULA Unified School District for the Community SCHOOL DISTRICT Recreation Program for 1978-79. (1201 x 1401) REQUEST FOR FEE WAIVER Approved the request from the Peninsula PORTUGUESE BEND NATIONAL Committee of the Childrens Hospital to HORSE SHOW waive the fee for the Portuguese Bend (305) National Horse Show. RESOLUTION NO. 78-24 ADOPTED RESOLUTION NO. 78-24 OF THE CITY AUTHORIZING REPRESENTATIVE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES FOR FEDERAL ASSISTANCE AUTHORIZING A REPRESENTATIVE TO EXECUTE FOR (401 x 601) AND IN BEHALF OF THE CITY OF RANCHO PALOS VERDES AN APPLICATION FOR THE PURPOSE OF OBTAINING CERTAIN FEDERAL ASSISTANCE UNDER THE DISASTER RELIEF ACT. The motion to approve the Consent Calendar carried on the following roll call vote: AYES: RYAN, BUERK, SHAW, HEIN AND MAYOR DYDA NOES: NONE # 11 11 # 11 11 11 11 # City Council 825 April 18, 1978 MINUTES OF APRIL 4, 1978 Under the Audience Section of the minutes on Page 3, it was noted that Mr. Satalich's address is 4125 Lorraine Drive. The section dealing with Council Appointments to Commission/Committees on page three of the minutes was corrected to show Councilwoman Shaw's motion as follows: "Councilwoman Shaw moved that the Council set the Friday before the meeting that the resumes will be distributed to members of Council as the deadline for submitting applications for committee and commission appointments." On motion of Councilman Ryan, seconded by Councilwoman Shaw, the minutes of April 4, 1978 were approved as amended. The motion carried unanimously. ADJOURNMENT At 1:24 A.M. Councilman Buerk moved, seconded by Councilwoman Shaw, to adjourn the meeting to April 20, 1978 @ 7:30 P.M. for a work session on the Coastal Plan. The motion carried unanimously. MAYOR ATTEST: LEONARD G. WOOD, CITY CLERK AND EX OFFICIO CLERK OF THE COUNCIL Al060 / I PUT CI/ CLE' i City Council 826 April 18, 1978 BALLOT / . PARE RECREATION C-E1 `41.s— eN/comet —=E RECORD COUNCIL i APPLICANT BUERK DYDA . HEIN RYAN SHAW TOTAL ELECTED t • BERGER MIDORI X 1 -. 6-- 4 CARTIER, LUCILLE S. x DUBOIS, DONALD GEORGE GASSNER, LEE C. GIBSON, ROBERT A. V .., - t, HENDRICKS, EARLE L. . . ( — II MASON, JACQUELINE -4 RILEY, CHARLES N. . ROSENTHAL, ALVIN L. X ,4'... .\14 . .4,, >( 1-- - 4' a SOLDOFF, DR. SUSAN )( )c . ( -5' . LV 1 D--- V . WHITNEY, CARROLL M \4_ 2..- ZAMOS, LARRY K._ X. - . 3 • _i , . .. _ ......_____ *BARRETT, CAROL T. . , — • el , , - _l_____I *BENNETT, VICTOR x 1 • _ , *CARTY, MICHAEL J. . . = *IAJ GUIRE, RUSSELL HENRY *MASTROLUCA, JOSEPH P. *RAWSON, WILLIAM C. _ - *SIMPSON, WILLIAM D. o , -i RA.A) ` . - A )4■ , - - * i 4 - , _ a *THIS COMMISSION/COMMITTEE INDICATED . AS SECOND CHOICE, 0 49-' 1171/ P'11 -- - City Council 827 April 18, 1978 BALLOT c.r PARS RECREATION C••OMMIS3-I•QN/CO.I. .E RECORD COUNCIL APPLICANT BUF.RK DYDA HEIN RYAN SHAW TOTAL ELECTED • BERGER, MIDORI . ' I . CARTIER, LUCILLE S. . DUBOIS, DONALD GEORGE . GASSNER, LEE C. GIBSON, ROBERT A. C_ HENDRICKS, EARLE L. . o--.. MASON; JACQUELINE RILEY, CHARLES N. . "I( . ROSENTHAL, ALVIN L. C40_ .. MO.1 SOLDOFF, DR. SUSAN WHITNEY, CARROLL M. '4- ':74L - ::' ZAMOS, LARRY ( ( • 1 . ' _ *BARRETT, CAROL T. I/ *BENNETT, VICTOR . *CARTY, MICHAEL J. *MAGUIRE, RUSSELL HENRY - . ' *MASTROLUCA, JOSEPH P. • • *RAWSON, WILLIAM C. • *SIMPSON, WILLIAM D. L I. LI 1 - A • ' X • •)C y....._ 11111111111121111 . • - . . 11111111 ......_ III - ' . A . _ ., __ . , . . *THIS COMMISSION/COMMITTEE INDICATAD - AS SECOND CHOICE. City Council 828 April* 18, 1978 BALLOT , TRAmL_C ODA41-6-&10N/60MM=E RECORD COUNCIL . 1 -' APPLICANT BUERK DYDA HEIN RYAN SHAW TOTAL ELECTED . t"---- CAMERON, JEFFREY R. ______ -___ . 4 DIESTEL, DAVID P. )( )( _. ) , -5- _._ u 0 4-.1 L GOULD, MICHAEL GROTZ, ARLINE A. L ' )As. )C, I c 4 __O LE V E, JAMES K. . .... MAGUIRE, RUSSELL HENRY 6 1 11111111 . X Y• - , MARANI, JEROME T II MATHYS, RAY W. . . .)C• Is 41 SIMPSON, WILLIAM D. ) - • _1 1 - • . . *BELL, EVERETT C. . ....., *CARTIER, FRANCIS R. )c [... . . . 1 . . *CLIFFORD, JOSEPH M. L/// 0 )c, . 7/- *DOTTORE, JOSEPH P. • . *HUGHES, MELVIN W. * . - - *MCTAGGART, JOHN C. _ , _ 111111111111 - _I *SCHULTZ, DAVID I. • . *SWARTZ, DONALD E. -. ____ *WHITNEY, CARROLL M. ,.._ , --1 . • . . . ......_.,_ alll , = • _ . • . , i ____, - , b • L . . . ----- . , ....„...., , _ _ .... . _ . . _ 0 ..._. .......... . L ,. . , _ ..... __ _ __..... _____................ ...___ • x 0 re i THIS COMMISSION/COMMITTEE INDICATED . AS SECOND CHOICE. City Council 829 April 18, - _ • -„:-...-...,:.!;;;;.,..:i,...-Z:i. BALLOT TRH-C COM-173, -ESN/COMMT E RECORD COUNCIL . APPLICANT BUERK DYDA RYAN SHAW TOTAL . ELECTED K CAMERON, JEFFREY R. 3 DIESTEL, DAVID P. . 0 GOULD, MICHAEL Y.- PI"- ' ,4'._ :3 GROTZ, ARLINE A.. C.. J o . LEE, JAMES K. MAGUIRE, RUSSELL HENRY - MARANI, JEROME T. 11// . . MATHYS, RAY W. V . . . . , , .. . . _ . ' SIMPSON, WILLIAM D. • *BELL,-.EVERETT C. *CARTIER, FRANCIS R. . *CLIFFORD, JOSEPH M. *DOTTORE; JOSEPH P. ` *HUGHES, MELVIN W. ' • *MCTAGGART, JOHN C. *SCHULTZ, DAVID I. . V *SWARTZ, DONALD E. *WHITNEY, CARROLL M. . ._._. --- ,� • . . • ._ _ ._ . ; . . . ,•__ lig . ._..�_ - . v •*THIS COMMISSION/COMMITTEE INDICATED _ AS SECOND CHOICE. City Council 830 April 18, •1,97:$-�_: _ - BALLOT EN' JNMENTAL CO I- & -ON/COMN=E RECORD COUNCIL " APPLICANT BUERK DYDA HEIN RYAN SHAW TOTAL ELECTED . C.." . .e.,"1 /4- x 3 i/ BAER, DR. DONALD • CARTIER, FRANCIS R. ( . CARTY MICHAEL J. COMINSKY LANDREW A. j _ J FRI EDBERG, KURT . MURASZEW ALEXANDER V 3 4/ ' IISUPPELSA, EUGENE A. \C *BROWN, DR. HARVEY A. *CAMERON, JEFFREY R. *CARTIER, LUCILLE S. . *DUBOIS, DONALD GEORGE *HENDRICKS, EARLE L. a *KELSO, •WILLIAM R. . V ... *SCHUEGRAF, KLAUS K. C 11 _ ,/ ?( *SOLDOFF, DR. SUSAN *STELLINO, ANTHONY F. . w L I\4 Ll\ JJ:;FolLp 9 c • I . . __ , _ _ . ._ ..,_________ . • II _ . • . _ • . ._ ____ , • - . . L - _ t 4- -,--: ---. *THIS COMMISSION/COMMITTEE INDICATED AS SECOND CHOICE. City Council 831 - April 18, 1978 BALLOT l , ANNING COMMISSION/C-ONt =E RECORD �. COUNCI L APPLICANT --r.,. BUERK DYDA HEIN RYAN SHAW TOTAL ELECTED ARBOGAST, GLENN L. JR. BACHARACh, J ACKI I\4 —>e BARRETT, CAROL T. + -----. I BELL, EVERETT C. . BENNETT, VICTOR 1 Q \ J e BROWN, DR. HARVEY A. :5, CLIFFORD, JOSEPH M. j —DOTTORE, JOSEPH P. . '4 e2....-- - HINCHLIFFE DOUGLAS M. C ` ' ‘" ICE HUGHES, MELVIN W. )4■„.? k: , . X r' 3 KELSO, WILLIAM R. MCTAGGART, JOHN C. ' 4-- )4', N‹ 'd]t) ->IS _ MASTROLUCA, JOSEPH P. 4 RAWSON, WILLIAM C. JR. RENNIE, CHARLES J. JR. ROSENBERG, LUDWIG M. > ..)4,.. 72....- • SALTUS, SAMUEL G. X . p SCHUEGRAF, KLAUS K. A: . .)< 1 - SCHULTZ, DAVID I. STELLINO, ANTHONY F. . SWARTZ, DONALD E. . III *BAER, DR. DONALD . *COMINSKY, ANDREW . . *GIBSON, ROBERT A. *MARAN I, JEROME T. . *MUR.ASZEW, ALEXANDER • . . . , ...._________. — *THIS COMMISSION/COMMITTEE INDICATED > -/ ;144/4./.2-44:4"4--- AS SECOND CHOICE. f7 ,,kt--e,40-7-1.,// 7.19( City Council 832 April_ 18 .1,9 7.8_ _ C . -`-